You know the drill

File: Fu5MrpD (1).png (11KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 828x887px

>>68899738

>>68899738
>Not liking Today

File: verbal couture parkour with the metaphors the flow house of horror dead bolted with metal doors.png (162KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

162KB, 828x887px

howplebRu

>>68899835
it's the worst song on the album

>>68899850
how old are you

>>68899738
Patrish

>>68899850
Plebeian

>>68899854
Not on an album that includes Lost and Get Hi

>>68899738
Plebeian

>>68899850
Plebeian

>listen to """""rap"""""
HOLY FUCKING KEK LMAO DUDE

Doing all of them is exhausting so I just did the one for now.

I'll do other Bowie albums if asked.

File: HiItsMeAgain.png (208KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

208KB, 828x887px

Forgot the pic.

File: maxresdefault.jpg (87KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

87KB, 1280x720px

>>68899738
>not liking lost
>implying aint it funny is anything less than a 10
>implying golddust is anything less than an 8
>pneumonia isn't a 10
>implying today is bad
>implying Get Hi isn't the most objectively great song on the album

File: drizzy confused.png (78KB, 200x300px) Image search: [Google]

78KB, 200x300px

>>68899738
>Giving Ain't it funny a 6

>>68899979
I pity you.
>>68900028
This
>>68899850
Definitely one of the best albums this year.

>>68899850
>>68899979
>>68900028
>>68900091
>>68900096
>>68900187
I miss the times music was taken seriously here

>>68900243
>>68899979
I did nothing wrong you motherfucker.

>>68899738
Couldn't agree more. Inconsistent album

>>68900003
I wonder what's your opinion on Blackstar.
Also, why the fuck is It Ain't Easy so low??

>>68900328
Because I hate it.

Posting Blackstar chart soon.

File: 1465789680427.jpg (30KB, 379x440px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 379x440px

>>68900243
>muh serious critical analysis of noises

>>68900464
funny guy

File: BlackStar.png (33KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 828x887px

>>68900328
Sorry I took so long.

>>68900523
I'd swap 2 with 4, but overall I agree
>>68900542
Breadcrumb Trail is a 9

File: LTIA.png (166KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

166KB, 828x887px

>>68899738
Yes

>>68899850
No

>>68900003
No

>>68900187
No

>>68900464
Yes

>>68900523
Lower the score for one point and it's perfect

>>68900542
Same as above.

Think Imma do Jay Z's albums.
Cuz why not.

Posting chart for R.D. soon

>>68900978
too high

>>68901177
lol what

>>68901234
What? Is something wrong, sir?

>>68901141
ahahahahh yeah I second this

File: Lifetime.png (127KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

127KB, 828x887px

>>68901444
Nice layout.
And nice trips.

>>68901444
top tier aesthetics

>>68899911
>Lost
nigga what
>Get Hi
yeah

>>68899911
>Lost is a bad song

That song is great. The flow is good, the verses are good, the production is super trippy. Pls learn to appreciate good music

File: WHAT.jpg (19KB, 628x342px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 628x342px

>>68899911
>Lost
>A bad song

File: janedoerating.png (153KB, 828x880px) Image search: [Google]

153KB, 828x880px

>>68901104
I realise the album isn't for everyone, but to me it's perfect. It came along at the right time also.

>>68901299
imagine actually enjoying Danse

>>68900523
Girl loves me is a 10 yo

>>68904139
Nah tho.

If you have requests for any other Bowie albums I'd love to do a chart for ya <3

File: 734.jpg (33KB, 312x275px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 312x275px

>>68899738
>Rolling Stone is good

File: Jeffery Rating.png (2MB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 828x887px

these are fun

>>68903437
i dont have to imagine

>>68904198
yeah it is, go back to your cave
>>68901679
>>68901612
>>68901566
Lost is the Frankie Sinatra of Atrocity Exhibition

>>68904247
This is good.

I'm gonna rate a Kanye album now.

File: EVOL Rating.png (2MB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 828x887px

>>68904208

>>68904247
The story behind Through The Wire is nice, but i wouldn't give it a 10

>>68904286
>>68904208
do Lil Boat

>>68904247
Also, Workout Plan is 3rd best song, topped only by Jesus Walks and All Falls Down

File: Purple Reign Rating.png (2MB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 828x887px

>>68904286

>>68901299
I T S T I L L M O V E S

File: 1478384881740.png (198KB, 997x936px) Image search: [Google]

198KB, 997x936px

>>68904247
what are you fucking gay? You know school spirit is the best on the album

>>68904347
nvm, through the wire, but ss is number 2
also
>>68904298
it is a ten, that was the first of kanye as an artist. it was a brilliant story, that inspired him, and it showed him as more than a producer

>>68901405
>the herald
>only an 8

>>68904347
>Rating skits
Why tho..?

>>68904378
What did you think of the beat for that song? Personally I thought it was pretty medicore. Especially by Kanye standards.

>>68904378
y'know, music is not only lyrics
The instrumental is the weakest of the entire album, and execution in general is a let down
>>68904439
He skipped the skits

File: Lil Boat Rating.png (128KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

128KB, 828x887px

>>68904319
you are wish is my command

>>68904467
I don't know which song,
1. through the wire, is the song that spawned the kanye mythos, it was a great set peice for the album, sure the instrumental was weak, but prior, kanye was a producer, he didn't have to prove he could make good instrumentals
2. ss was one of those songs that resianted with me, I thought that the point of the song went with the album, as it was named college dropout,"nigga graduated at the top of our class, went to cheesecake he was a motherfuckin waiter there" the song's chorus is great IMO

File: LRTemp.png (140KB, 870x887px) Image search: [Google]

140KB, 870x887px

>>68904467
A: You nailed my feelings on the beat for T.T.W, man. Well done.

B: I misunderstood his chart. My fuck up. I apologize.

really, wanna hear a story about my two cousins, lil yachty and lil boat is a 10? Also, why is Minnesota only a 10?

>>68904589
Jesus Walks spawned the mythos and Runway followed them up.

>>68904628
what the fuck are you talking about? did you even look at the chart? >>68904478

File: yeezy for pres.png (125KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

125KB, 828x887px

I like Kanye a lot, but this is the truth for everything post B.D.T.F

>>68904674
intro got a 10? why

>>68904680
Move 7 to 8 and give a score to Bound 2 and I somewhat agree.

File: dbratings.png (169KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

169KB, 1000x1000px

>>68899738

>>68904659
but the near death experience he describes in TTW was his inspiration to start writing in the first place

>>68904680
You unironically dislike On Sight, Hold My Liquor, Guilt Trip and Bound 2?
Try listening to the album more than once

>>68904707
you don't like Blood on the leaves?

>>68904719
I see your point. I agree it's one of his best tracks lyrically

>>68904745
Not really, no.

>>68904697
i think the intro encapsulates everything that I enjoy about yachty. you get boat and yachty, you get the nemo skit, you get the burberry perry production. minnesota remix is good but i don't know about 10

>>68904720
why though, I listened to the whole thing twice, and thought it was overproduced, and not that great, I will listen to it again, but i did not like it, and life of pablo was worse, I am loosing hope for kanye

>>68904763
i respect that, but could you explain why, I might be disabled or something, cause I thought it was one of the few good tracks on the album

>>68904778
that makes sense, I just find the intro to be a waste, I feel like he could have done something better than the intro in the time

>>68904858
fair enough, i feel that way about the intro to summer songs 2. it tries to capture the same vibe but it feels forced. lil boat's intro felt natural

>>68904807
I pay attention to Kanye mostly for his beats and I personally thought it was one of the weaker beats on the album. Just a mediocre trap..ish beat. (I'll give it a re listen some time, maybe I'm misjudging it)

Also if we're talking about the album there were so many samples he could have used that he didn't use to his full potential (The section in the middle of 'On Sight', the ending of 'New Slaves', etc) which would have been better beats than...The rest of the beats used on the song.

(And no, you're not disabled, we just have different views :) )

>>68904788
Twice really is not enough.
I got it pretty quickly, but the track that stood out first were the most accessible ones: BOTL, Black Skinhead and New Slaves.
I suggest you give the album it's time and try again later, as forcing it won't help much
Kanye limited himself to overprocessed samples, kinda like what he did on 808s and Graduation, except this time he completely removed all instruments and actually had the balls to go full industrial.
So whenever you feel like trying it again, do it while you run or something
It's probably in Kanye's top 3, and so far has aged really well, i eventually see myself choosing Yeezus over TLOP for it's organization and cohesive construction.

File: campfiresongs.png (152KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

152KB, 828x887px

>>68904961

File: herecomestheindian.png (251KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

251KB, 828x887px

>>68904983

>>68904927
You don't get the concept. The short snippets of samples throughout the album are there to serve as a quick form of antithesis to the industrial beats, essentially to drift the listener away from them for a short time.
The album is really all about what you dislike, i guess
and that's okay

>>68904927
I don't really listen to kanye for the beats, I like the ideas he presents, and songs that fit well into the albums theme, I like, and I thought that it went well with some of the other songs. That album was not so good, blood on the leaves is kind of the best of a bad situation, kind of like ultralight bean on life of pablo, it wouldn't go on kanye's greatest hits, but it is the best on an album that is not good. (Also, this is the first board I have browsed since quitting 4chan in feb, I was a Btard, so sorry if I am hostile, and not socially appropriate )

>>68905014
>The album is really all about what you dislike
Well I wouldn't go THAT far, I'm not saying I DIDN'T enjoy parts of the main beats used, I'm just saying it could have been improved, maybe a few more songs with the samples, or just make the songs 2 parters.

But yeah, it's cool you interpret the album that way. I respect that.

File: sungtongs.png (188KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

188KB, 828x887px

>>68905013

File: feels.png (231KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

231KB, 828x887px

>>68905067

>>68905022
You're not hostile at all. You're actually pretty nice.

Although (and I don't mean this in a disrespectful way)

>I don't really listen to kanye for the beats
That honestly surprises the hell out of me. Mostly just because of people (including me) thinking his beats far....FAR...Surpass his lyrics. Cause he is a great beatmaker.

File: prospecthummer.png (231KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

231KB, 828x887px

>>68905084

File: people.png (189KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

189KB, 828x887px

>>68905100

Such a polite thread

File: rankotracks.png (2MB, 3632x1332px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 3632x1332px

>>68905132
Fuck off

>>68905132
I hope you're having a great day my friend

I did a chart for LR. Which Kanye album should I do a chart of next?

>>68905148
Holy fucking shit...mad respect dude....
That must have been a lot of work.

>>68905091
My thought process is that if you are going to go somewhere for beats, why not listen to rdj2, or others in that niche. Kanye is notorious for making great beats, but IMO that doesn't bring him anywhere close to the sample remix gods, and I like his image, of being a selfmade person, who knows what is best for him, and will do whatever that is, regardless of whether or not society will agree with him (Dropping out of college) I am one of those nerds that would like to have intimate conversations with people, and his lyrics are my way of learning about him, in a way that is as close as i could possibly get. He seems like a really interesting guy, and I support what he believes in

>>68905180
Thanks, it's a bit old though (I'd rank the Surfer Girl album a lot higher for instance)

>>68905148
could you not waste your time with a decent band instead

>>68905180
life of pablo

>>68905232
That's a really interesting way of looking at his work. I respect that.

Any request for which Ye album I should chart?

I can give you perspectives on the best beats of his.

(Here's my earlier one: >>68904594 )

>>68904173
Girl Loves Me is one of the most interesting songs on blackstar compositionally

What's your opinion on Low?

>>68905288
Making a Low chart now.
Will tag you when it's done.

>>68905284
freshmen adjustments mix tape, or life of Pablo,

>>68905284
thanks. First time I have been on 4chan and had my opinions respected

File: Low.png (205KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

205KB, 828x887px

>>68905288
Here's the Low chart.


>>68905349
...Fuck. Haven't listened to either. Sorry.

>>68905395
Glad to help. :)

IK this isn't really for this thread, but whats the best Childish Gambino album?

>>68905482
Culdesac is my guilty pleasure because i feel like it's his most genuine album. His EP and Because the Internet are nice, too; but Camp is shit

File: 1478384881740.png (109KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

109KB, 828x887px

I think people do this album a lot

>>68905447
Plz stop sperging about bowie on /mu/, im starting to recognise your posts everywhere

>>68901694
Distance and Meaning is 10!

>>68905482
kek

>>68905527
really? I thought camp was his best album, and I though because the internet had 3 or 4 good songs on it, how come you didn't like camp?

File: 1478384881740 (1).png (157KB, 992x993px) Image search: [Google]

157KB, 992x993px

I have really high standards, and love every song on this album, which is why some amazing songs only got 6/10, please don't hate me.

>>68905558
>im starting to recognise your posts everywhere
....That's a bad thing?

>>68905615
Yes because every post is "i suck lol" coupled with some boring shit about david bowie

>>68905649
Well that's just not very nice.

>>68905572
He was pretty much not mature enough for his ideas, and ended up shooting a little too high.
In some tracks, the instrumentals either overpower or are overpowered by the vocals, and that really annoyed me
It's the worst from his first works combined with the ambition of Because the Internet. There are some nice songs, like firefly and Heartbeat, though.
I really like BTI, it clicks with me for many reasons; I listened to it on release day and kinda fell for the hype with all the screenplay shit, maybe that made a difference.
But when i listen to it now, i'm able to see it as it's own thing, and basically it's Donald at his most ambicious and risky, mixing unique slow-tempo beats with effortless rhymes that are often hilarious. It goes big, then naive, then big again.
Pretty fun, in my opinion. I think he's an artist worth taking seriously, contrary to this board's opinion

>>68900978
>halftime
>good

>memory lane
>not best track on album

>one love
>good

>>68905067

How is winter's love not a 10?

>>68905721
I highkey fuck with him, and think donald is legitimate as well. Even if you think camp is shit, you have to admit that there are some really good songs on the album, and they are always in the perfect spots when the album get boring, gambino hits us with bonfire, or worldstar, or firefly. I see what you are saying, but those songs are in the perfect spots for how good they are compared to the songs around them. It was not a giant album that I had to stop listening to mid way through. Anytime I had any doubts, donald hit me with a banger. That might be me specifically, but its why i like camp

File: lil dicky.png (46KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

46KB, 828x887px

If he could somehow put some sort of meaning in his songs, I would probably take lil dicky seriously, but for now his career is a joke. I like his flow, and he is clever, but his songs have no impact at all.

>>68905844
True. maybe the boring spots are what got in my way of enjoying it. And on that matter, i felt entretained all the way through BTI. (Except for worldstar and the party)

File: Biophilia.png (164KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

164KB, 828x887px

Shoutout to the anon who called me boring an annoying and said I had Asperger.

Never been so inspired to make charts before.

>>68905920
that font is gay af my man

>>68905990
Thanks! I chose the gayest one just for this occasion.

I'm all about positivity and nothing is stopping that.

>>68905883
but we can both agree that he is going to do more great stuff in the rap industry, and people should take him as a serious artist. I respect your opinion

>>68905594
Lol I don't hate you, I don't think your being hard enough, this is an extremely overrated album

>>68906070
I hope so. I also hope he doesn't forget music, as he'll be spending all his time on the Han Solo movie.

>>68906113
I agree, but all the songs I gave tens I would not budge on. everything else could probably go down

>>68906198
I respect that taste my mane

>>68906231
thanks mang (:

>>68905148
you missed the goddamn best album that also would have made it so you wouldnt have to fill it with mike you inbred

>>68906344
>tfw not a native english speaker and have it twice as difficult to understand

File: clppng.png (69KB, 838x897px) Image search: [Google]

69KB, 838x897px

>>68906344
I like your style, anon.

File: Screenshot_1.jpg (6KB, 494x24px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 494x24px

>>68906532

Hmmmm... this is full of good music or people is easy to satisfy

File: ImtheHunter.png (184KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

184KB, 828x887px

Herbie Hancock is fantastic.

>>68905649
I suck lol

>>68906565
I deleted the post because I'm stupid.
I'm just fuckin' up tonight!
(Sorry)

>>68906593
cmon, it's not difficult not to overrate it

>>68906574
Both, probably.

>>68906574
People are more interested in rating albums they like

>>68906574
people lose their sense of comparison when rating albums they like; and end up overrating everything

>>68906644
...And now I'm somewhat interested in rating an album I hate.

Brb.

File: the milk-eyed mender.png (276KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

276KB, 828x887px

>>68906621
8.5 is probably underrated. It's still growing on me.

>>68906689
Aand you overrate MEM.

>>68905558
I mostly agree with this ranking of LTIY, except I'd take a point off of 'Who Cares' and give it to 'One Lick Less'

File: pure guava.png (207KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

207KB, 828x887px

>>68906712
>how dare you deeply enjoy albums I don't enjoy as much

>>68905751
halftime is fucking good what's wrong with you

File: Fuckthisalbum.png (91KB, 828x887px) Image search: [Google]

91KB, 828x887px

Ok so I fucked up my rating and I didn't delete my posts fast enough so here's my re do.

>>68907245
>The Bird and Parking Lot worst on the album
n i g g a
w
h
a
t

>>68907830
Oh, that's because they are