When will you accept this is the best album ever made, /mu/?

>>68612348
when you shut the fuck up about the beatles

>people unironically believe this
but there's so much more to music

>>68612387
>>68612389
>t. Underage

>>68612408
fuck you man i was born in 1957

>>68612348
>he thinks this is even the best beatles album

Listen to some more music bud, Im not even meming you.

beatles= boring and tame af

THE

FACT

THAT

>>68612481
This. If anything, a good contender for best album of all time if you're gonna put a Beatles album is obviously their self titled.

SO

>>68612660
Yup along with obviously Revolver and IMO Rubber Soul

MANY

>>68612387
>>68612389
>>68612464
>>68612481
>>68612498
It's objectively a perfect album. It has no flaws. At all. Even Paul's granny songs worked in this. I can't believe /mu/ has deluded you guys so much that you unironically think some random "muh avant-garde le experimental" album is somehow better than this. It's contemporary music at its peak, if Mozart was alive today it would probably be his favorite album as well.

>>68612749
this

>>68612749
>no flaws
>Good morning
>Shes leaving home

Its a great album but if you arent baiting and actually believe what you wrote you really fell for a meme, it is arguably the most influential album ever but Revolver and S/T are leauges above it even in general consensus

>>68612749
>I can't believe /mu/ has deluded you guys so much that you unironically think some random "muh avant-garde le experimental" album is somehow better than this.
holy shit this
i dont think Sgt Pepper's is the best album of all time either but it's sure as hell a better option than most of the shit you guys shill here
this contrarian hive mind has really fucked up most people's taste here

>>68612660
Or abbey road

File: 1449203047210.gif (796KB, 320x286px)

796KB, 320x286px

>>68612789
>Shes leaving home
>flaw
jesus christ

>>68612789
I'm sick of this Good Morning Good Morning is bad meme, it's a really great song. It just happens to be the least good of the album.
Also She's Leaving Home???? What the fuck? That's literally behind A Day In the Life for best of the album you twat

>>68612749
>if Mozart was alive today it would probably be his favorite album as well.

You completely lost me here at the end. The Beatles are great and so is this album, but you have no concept of Mozart's genius if you seriously believe this. He'd scoff at it at best.

>>68612833
I know right? Even good morning good morning is a decent song in it's own right even if it's just filler.

File: 2f22334412b75a93de69a4c5c86eb6d3dd26b1db814e8681205b72c1936bbcdb_1.jpg (49KB, 720x740px)

49KB, 720x740px

>>68612966
How do you know? Are you Mozart?

>>68612789
>She's leaving home
>flaw
Bad b8 m8.

>>68612798
Literally nothing that is frequently mentioned here as the GOAT album is that obscure or bizarre. What, babbys first krautrock? Slint? Fucking NMH?

Beatles fans really need to hear more music.

>>68613010
>>68612833
>>68612873

Shes leaving home confirmed to be pleb detector thanks guys

>>68612966
>le Mozart meme
Mozart would be fucking listening to Lil Wayne if he was alive today.

File: main source breaking atoms.jpg (225KB, 1020x1024px) Image search: [Google]

225KB, 1020x1024px

>>68612348
I already do but It's not my favorite album.

Yeah I dunno. The only song I don't like listening to on this album is Lucy In The Sky, probably because of the annoying pitched up vocals.

File: wtf death grips.jpg (79KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

79KB, 500x500px

>>68612789
>Shes leaving home
>flaws
Jesus Christ /mu/

Music today sucks. We used to have Sgt Peppers, The Doors, Dark Side of the Moon and Led Zepelin - IV and what now? Justin Bieber. LOL.

>>68613121
Actually music does suck today. Not as much as le wrong generation fags want you to believe but it's still marginally worse. Show me an album made after 2000 that's better than any album made in the 60's or 90's.

>>68613121
>re-using low tier youtube comments to shitpost
neck yourself
>>68613133
I could, but, with that mentally, there is no way you would agree with me.

>>68613121
Sgt Pepper is probably the most timeless out of all of those

>>68613121
there is more good music than ever but none of it is becoming popular

>>68613166
>actually believing this
Popular music isn't always good, but it has to be popular to be good.

>>68613180
>it has to be popular to be good.
imagine actually thinking this

>>68613180
wtf

File: 220px-Dan_Deacon_America.jpg (16KB, 220x220px)

16KB, 220x220px

>>68613133

>>68613162
The fact that so many books still name...

>>68612348
the day mu stops posting threads like this

>>68612749
This is so stupid. What the fuck does Mozart have to do with cute pop songs? Don't get me wrong, I've got nothing against pop, I love pop, and Sgt. Pepper is right up there as far as pop albums go, but throwing the word Mozart out there to say how Sgt. Pepper is good is fucking ridiculous. Mozart used chords to provoke a direct mental and emotional response. Sgt. Pepper never comes close to this level of music. Not saying that nothing out of the past fifty years of music achieves this, but, sorry, Sgt. Pepper just doesn't.

>>68612348
baby's first art pop album

This entire thread is fucking horrendous

File: nobullying.jpg (29KB, 720x720px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 720x720px

>>68614121
*Tips*

>>68612348
it's really not the greatest album of all time. pet sounds probably is. personally, i'd place sgt pepper at around #4, with a love supreme being #3, TVU&N being #2, and the parable of arable land being #5.

>>68613726
>Mozart used chords to provoke a direct mental and emotional response
Sgt Pepper does this as well.

>>68614418
This is the only correct opinion itt

Greatest, most important album of all time, yes.

>>68612348
Abbey Road >

>>68613726
Mozart wrote cute pop songs too. The symphony was never valued as a transcendent artistic achievement until the late 18th century and both Haydn and Mozart wrote dozens of symphonies tailored to their audience (whether it was for a single prince or for hundreds of aristocrats).

Pet Sounds did all the same things Sgt Pepper did a whole year earlier and yet somehow the latter gets more credit for it

What the fuck

>>68614639
>The symphony was never valued as a transcendent artistic achievement until the late 18th century
actually late 18th century might be too early. That happened probably sometime in the early/mid 19th century

>>68614665
Sgt Pepper took what Pet Sounds did, and did it better.

>>68614418
>all 5 albums released in the 60s
hi dad

>>68614709
>Sgt Pepper took what Pet Sounds did, and did it better.
(not true, by the way)

>>68614724
why do you say that?

>be me
>listening to the new Weezer album
>see this thread
>switch over to this album
>4 songs in
>HOLY SHIT! THE NEW WEEZER ALBUM IS BETTER THAN SGT. PEPPERS.

How can you defend this mediocre album?

>>68614745
The only songs on that album that come close to Pet Sounds' greatness are A Day In The Life and Shes Leaving Home. The rest is literally circus music and dumbed down vaudeville showtunes with trivial lyrics. They don't even compare to Brian's lyrics.

>>68614840
This is absolutely accurate.

>>68614840
I'd agree with you but Within You Without You exists

>>68614711
>judging music by when it was released and not the quality of the content or influence it has had
hi faggot
the funny thing is OKC is #8 for me and spiderland is #15

>>68614868
post topsters chart

>>68614665
>>68614709
>>68614840
>DUDE I'M SO SAD LMAO
>DUDE I GET HIGH WITH MY FRIENDS LSD LMAO
kek both albums are terrible lyrically-wise they're both carried by the arrangements
fucking underages I swear

File: top 42 oct 16.png (893KB, 1680x1580px)

893KB, 1680x1580px

these aren't what i consider the greatest of all time, these are what i derive the most enjoyment out of. i haven't really made a chart for what i consider the greatest

>>68614840
>The rest is literally circus music
Did you only listen to Mr Kite?

>>68614918
>DUDE I'M SO SAD LMAO is one of Wilson's best lines.

>>68614928
meant for
>>68614880

>>68614937
Mr. Kite sounds that way more than the rest of the album, but the whole thing does sound like that.

>>68614967
>but the whole thing does sound like that.
What kind of circus sounds like Within You Without you, Lovely Rita, Fixing a Hole and Good Morning Good Morning?

>>68615012
A mediocre one.

>>68615042
Non argument

>>68612728
This.

>>68615059
How is that not an argument?

>>68615139
You didn't answer the question. Your opinion of the quality is not what I'm asking.

>>68615164
Yes I did. A boring circus would probably have boring music.

>>68614918
There's more to songwriting than lyrics you dumb fuck, that's why the word "lyricism" exists

>>68615185
>boring
Not what I'm asking.

Try again.

>>68615193
What are you asking?

>>68615248
>>68615012

>>68615277
he's only pretending to be a nearsighted child, idiot.

>>68615277
>What kind of circus
A shitty one you fucking mongoloid.

>>68615310
>>68615059

>>68615321
How does it sound like circus music?

>>68615321
shitty is a relative term. you have nothing to compare to and you know it. stop posting.

I stand by the idea that it's stupid to rate an album as the best of all time but if I was put at gun point and had to pick one I'd probably choose sgt. pepper just because its influence is undeniable and it's an amazing album

>>68615354
>shitty is a relative term
No it's not.

>>68615377
How is it shitty, objectively speaking?

>>68615377
it most certainly can be, given your mental gymnastics. what do you have to hide? relax, bud.

>>68615388
AYYY LMAO! What if we let Paul write an album about acid?
Yeah! sounds good, let's also throw in some songs with sophomoric abstract lyrics, it'll be so fucking good.

That's at least what I imagine happening when I listen to it.

>>68615400
>it most certainly can be,
Not in the way I used it.

>>68615432
Non argument

>>68615432
You must be quite isolated if this is how you're choosing to articulate yourself.

>what I imagine

clearly lol

>>68615472
But it does clarify why I don't like it.

>>68615455
Okay, so you're saying you have no real foundation for your opinion?

>>68615474
You nailed it bro.
>>68615505
obviously not.

>>68615501
it's a pretty immature and superficial reason. maybe the problem isn't sgt. pepper's, it's your analytical skills.

>>68615501
Nice backpedaling

File: good argument.png (591KB, 722x832px) Image search: [Google]

591KB, 722x832px

>>68615530

>>68615583
lol wtf
you're entitled to an opinion just as i'm allowed to critique it. your narrative sucks, it doesn't mean anything and couldn't possibly cause momentum in a more civil discussion.

if you're not interested in exercising the notion that you don't have everything figured out then don't bitch.

>>68615665
>you're entitled to an opinion just as i'm allowed to critique it.
Autism at its finest.

It's getting better was a underrated song off that

File: topsters2 (10).jpg (154KB, 2026x1372px)

154KB, 2026x1372px

Albums-that-do-the-same-thing-that-sgt-pepper-did-but-better core, open for sugestions

>>68615757
it's hardly autism, it's actually pretty human. looks like my isolation assertion wasn't too farfetched after all lol

File: Tame_Impala_Lonerism_Cover.jpg (34KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 300x300px

>>68615804
Does this count?

>>68614833
But the first four tracks are pretty strong on SP
I haven't heard the new weezer though, but rivers does have a degree in music

>>68615804
odessey and oracle

>>68615836
No

>>68615902
this

>>68615665
oh wow you're a critiquer are you lolll such a pretentious faggot does mummy need to powder your bumhole? eat my shit you gay faggot

>>68615881
no they arent are you fucking stupid?

File: topsters2 (12).jpg (234KB, 2291x1372px)

234KB, 2291x1372px

>>68615902
my nigga

>>68616012
You sure Lonerism doesn't qualify.

>>68615986
https://archive.rebeccablacktech.com/mu/?task=search2&ghost=&search_text=&search_subject=&search_username=ziggy+shitdust&search_tripcode=&search_email=&search_filename=&search_datefrom=&search_dateto=&search_media_hash=&search_op=all&search_del=dontcare&search_int=dontcare&search_ord=new&search_capcode=all&search_res=post

good god get a load of you

>>68612348
the beatles were trash anyway, all their songs get boring after hearing them twice tbqhhhh lmaooo

>>68616036
yeah, it's just psych

>>68616050
MY MAN ZIGGY STRIKES AGAIN

>>68616051
Everything on that chart is just psych though

>>68615986
Did I fucking stutter mate the first four tracks are pretty good

File: 1477072165959.gif (2MB, 255x247px)

2MB, 255x247px

>>68616067

>>68616045
lol you expect me to click that? im not going to click that shit just like nobody will listen to your shitty music you fucking lowlife lmaooo get a job hippie

>>68616075
You're a fucking idiot.

>>68616050
you're a pretty good shitposter dude, maybe you could teach me your ways?

>>68616067
lonerism wasn't even made in that time era, doesn't fit at all

>>68616062
i'm not youre man im just a mortal with the potentional of a superman im shitposting on

but seriously everyone on this board needs to hear the truth its so sad seeing all these hopeless losers pursuing worthless degrees

>>68616075
wow your opinionVVVVV
GARBAGE |___________|

AHAHAHAH

eat shit you ignorant faggot nobody cares and you're wrong your opinion is wrong and you should kill yourself

>>68616050
>>68615986
>>68616079
>>68616105
ZIGGY Z ZIGGY I ZIGGY G ZIGGY G ZIGGY Y ZIGGY !!!!!!!

WOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!

>>68616095
wow telling the truth is shitposting? get your head checked faggot

>>68616103
The title of the chart doesn't mention that criteria

>>68616105
are you drunk or something because i used to go on similar shitposting crusades under the influence

>>68616116
Prove it's the truth.

>>68616116
YGGIZIGGY
YGGIGGY
YGGGY
YGY
Y
YGY
YGGGY
YGGIGGY
YGGIZIGGY

>>68616114
stop sucking up to me it's a turn off and youll get a brown nose you poofy
>>68616147
no im not drunk, you probably are though thinking you have talent you talent(lesss) faggot
>>68616151
i dont need to because you already know it in your heart

also to the janitor who submitted an ip ban request on me go fuckyourself you power hungry homosexualll so sad!

could you imagine being a janitor? no real power, just cleaning up piss, cum, blood, vomit and ziggys poo, they must have such low self esteem

>>68616116
>>68616105
>>68616079
>>68616050
>>68615986
>>68616389

Z̧̐̿͗ͬͩ̐̓̄́͛̐̓͆ͦ̓́͠҉͏͈̺͖̰̹͟ ̸̛ͫ͊̔̽̓͆͜͏̸̪̤̺͖Į̵̴͙̜͎̗̲ͨͨ̌̽͌ͧ͆ͮ̀ ̵̸̢̳̟͓̭̤̜͚̯̝̩̹͓̟͈̒̈̉̇̊̈́̈̀͢ͅͅGͩ̿̑ͯ̿҉̬̣͎̬͔̼̞̟̙̬̟͇̝̞̬̩̤̖͟ ̡̱͔͓̠̗̞͇͚͎̒̿͌ͨ̊̇͢͡͞ G̴̨̰̥̦̜̻͍͈̟̣͖̣͉̲͖͚̫̳̓ͩ̇͛̆͘͜ ̸̖̜͓͍̻͔͙̭̪̩̭̞̻̙͎͈͚͋ͮ̓̇̓͆ͮ̈́̌͐̋̾͗̚͝ Y͊ͯ̈́̏̈́̏̔͢͏̵̛̪̣͖̥͇̟͕̺̯́

>>68616389
>i dont need to because you already know it in your heart
Not really. I don't know you, I don't know if you are being genuine or not.

If you make a claim you need to prove it

>>68616425
i dont need to do what you tell me to lol faggot like back off ahahaha lmao
you know you're a talentless faggot and you wont even get to be a hasbeen or one hit wonder just get a JOB you hippie

>>68616116
Ziggy might just be the best Tripfag.

>>68616479
nah I'm just kidding i don't know wtf i'm talking about

i'm just a little faggot

>>68616497
do you SEE a trip? i might have to get a trip though with all these ingrates impersonating me, truly disgusting

God i fucking hate myself. i only do this because i wish i was dead

>>68616522
not me fucks sake ill get a trip there, eat my poo you loser. such a lightweight, so sad!

>>68616566
oh fuck you me!

>>68616551
all musicians hate themselves and only go to uni to study music to spite their parents, stop trying to impersonate some random on the internet youre actually so sad lmaoooo

File: well,:mu:?.png (63KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

63KB, 1000x1000px

.

>>68616583
wtf fukk of faggot you are not me

>>68616583
Look who's talking.

>>68616479
>>68616525
>>68616566
z i g g y y g g i z
z ı ƃ ƃ ʎ ʎ ƃ ƃ ı z

>>68616592
Stereo

>>68616582
you lose faggot pack up and go home you ignorant mole lolol so sad!

>>68616601
Z K R A G A R A S S >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> DTKE5

>>68616619
>>68616617
Oh sweet now I can filter you

Thanks for playing newtrip

>>68616619
>>68616617
>>68616601
>>68616599
>>68616583
>>68616582
>>68616566
>>68616551
>>68616525
>>68616522
>>68616479
>>68616389
>>68616116
>>68616105
>>68616079
>>68616050
>>68615986
>>68616649
ZIGGY!
Z I G G Y !!!!!

>>68616649
wow big boy you found out how to use a filter! eat my shit you fucking nigger i wont use my trip forever, it's just temporary

>>68616707
Thats fine, I'll just pop your name in my name field and make you look bad. Eventually others will do the same and you'll be nothing, either forced to not post or take up an actual trip, which can be filtered.

>>68616707
>>68616732
ZIGGY!!!!

this thread has been Z I G G E D

>>68616732
nobody likes you lol

>>68616732
or maybe ill just come up with a new identity and keep shitposting as i have been doing since the beginning of time you fucking faggot get a job
>>68616808
thats right nobody likes an imposter, so sad

>>68616848
>or maybe ill just come up with a new identity and keep shitposting as i have been doing since the beginning of time
Time didn't begin a month ago faggot

File: Angry Video Game Nerd shrugs.jpg (46KB, 377x500px)

46KB, 377x500px

>Tfw everyone sucks off A Day in the Life
>Tfw you think it's good but overrated
>Tfw She's Leaving Home and Within You Without You are your favorite songs from Sgt. Pepper

>>68616893
like you'd have any perception of time you fucking no good hippie junkie piece of shit

eat my poo poo

ziggy pls notice me

>>68617056
wow you need attention from a fictional internet character, so sad

>>68617125
>>68617056
Samefag

>>68612660
>>68612728
Magical Mystery Tour too, that album was well ahead of its time.

File: FUK U.png (15KB, 477x183px)

15KB, 477x183px

>>68617147
ahahha so sad nice try faggot

>>68617125
>fictional

you're not the real ziggy

i want the real ziggy to notice me

OP here, what the fuck just happened to my fucking thread?

>>68613288
nice

>>68617231
the real ziggy is dead faggot, dont you watch the news????
>>68617271
corrected the record you faggot go die

Tons of 66' and 67' albums were way more influential and groundbreaking, and Abbey Road is the Beatles' closest thing to a perfect album. The only thing it did that was new was the concept of 'band within a band', them being "Sgt. Pepper's band" or whatever, which was a shory lived fad anyway. And YES, THE SONGS HAVE BREAKS BETWEEN THEM FOR FUCK'S SAKE. It's a great album, full of great pop songs with some pretry creative arrangements, the impact it had at the time doesn't mean it's the best album ever made, that'd be like saying 2001 is the best film ever made. Also friendly reminder that Pet Sounds is worse than Pepper, so Wilsoncucks GTFO.

>>68617271
this site is garbage.

>>68617573

>And YES, THE SONGS HAVE BREAKS BETWEEN THEM FOR FUCK'S SAKE


what is that supposed to imply

it was the best at the time. its still the best for its time. lets leave it at that. there are other albums, at other times, that are "best" in their own way.

>>68616012
Does Piper at The Gates of Dawn qualify?

>>68616936
That ain't the angry video game nerd hombre

>>68613288
>Deaco
i agree, some talent there, complexity.

>>68612348
When you remove Good Morning, Good Morning and and Getting Better

>>68617573
>Tons of 66' and 67' albums were way more influential and groundbreaking
Name them

>>68618339
>>68617923

>>68618364
How so?

Also that's just one.

>>68618431
idk, i think it's better

and i have no idea

>>68617573
>comparing 2001 to Sgt Peppers

fuck off

Only if it's the mono version.

>>68618639
>I kike it better
>so it's more influential
Not how it works

>>68613162
DSOTM is pretty timeless tho

>>68619145
This.

>>68614840
>Brian's lyrics

>>68617573
>Pet Sounds is worse than Pepper
it's better in literally every way and it isn't negotiable

I hate the Beatles strongly. But Helter Skelter is ok...