Left or right?

>>30851973
Left.

Those stairs in the outside are just stupid

File: golden oaks library, 4th of july ball, 1921.jpg (125KB, 700x432px) Image search: [Google]

125KB, 700x432px

>>30851973
Neither will ever bee The Treebrary.

But that's alright.
We'll always be the caretakers.
We've always been the caretakers.

>>30851973
Left is cleaner and more remarkable.

>>30851973
What's with the really angry tiny little horse in the right one?

>>30851973
Left
I'd be fucking scared for our children with those retarded stairs

>>30852005
Wat?

>>30851973
Right. Don't hurt me

>>30851973
Do I see to alicorns there?

File: A Message to the Fandom.png (276KB, 629x629px) Image search: [Google]

276KB, 629x629px

>>30851973
Neither.

>>30852032
two

>>30851973
Right looks like some kind of bullshit modern """fantasy""" tower that exists only as a token object with no connection to the world.
The left one has a chance of not tipping over in a strong breeze.

>>30851973
I didn't think it was possible for the castle to get any uglier than it already is. The right one looks like a hunk of melted iron left over from a casting. What the fuck?

>>30851973
I prefer the Golden Oaks Library than either of these. Who lives in a castle in a middle of a back water mud pony village?

>>30851973
Left actually has some semblance to Twilights character, keeping to the theme of the tree library and having the star on top. The other one just looks like a generic castle.

>>30852062
Feudalism is magic

Right. Looks more organic and a bit less like a toy. Would've preferred that they kept the crystal cutie mark on top, though.

File: nice.jpg (41KB, 480x268px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 480x268px

>>30852070
now that is beautiful

>>30852070
F

>>30851973
Left one.

>>30852070
Not bad. would seem like a more logical evolution of the treebrary.

File: 1503070761642.png (382KB, 600x376px) Image search: [Google]

382KB, 600x376px

>>30852070
We could've had that instead?

File: FuckThisGayEarth.gif (986KB, 500x270px) Image search: [Google]

986KB, 500x270px

>>30852070
>This will never ever be realised in the show.
Fuck hasbro marketing.

>>30852070
You know what would have been an awesome idea to implement with that tree?

If the magic of friendship carved new windows and murals depicting the mane six's heroic deeds with each new adventure.

>>30851973
Left, because the railless stairs are a safety hazard

>>30852136
>Code Enforcement & Building Safety Officers make a visit to Princess Twilight's

>>30852070
ffffffuck

>>30852146
>"What's the lesson we learned today, gang?"
>"That even princesses aren't exempt from standard safety precautions or the IRS?"
>"Nope! That's it's time to start gassing our subjects!"

File: Daddy Issuses.png (87KB, 540x405px) Image search: [Google]

87KB, 540x405px

>>30852070

>>30851973
Always left.

File: why.png (206KB, 348x586px) Image search: [Google]

206KB, 348x586px

>>30852070
Just why

File: upper.png (1MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1280x720px

>>30851973

>>30852070
It's an improvement, but it's still ugly. Maybe less ridges in the middle would help, or just make the "bark" stone rather than crystal.

>>30852070
Mutating the library into the abomination is honestly worse than killing it.

>>30851973
I'd have to say right because out of the two it seems more tree-like I guess
though being an improvement over the original friendship castle isn't hard, even then the branching off bits of crystal and the separate towers sort of make it look like the bastard child of a drunken hate fuck session between the Canterlot Castle and the Treebary

File: This crispy cat twi castle.jpg (2MB, 1616x1003px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1616x1003px

>>30852091
Wait until you see the inside

File: good shit.jpg (33KB, 840x350px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 840x350px

>>30853724
how is it that fan made stuff looks better than official show stuff? when will Hasjew learn that more quality = more shekels?
oh well

>>30853775
3 reasons
1. Fans don't have to deal with the marketing department. They just make what they like without have to deal with people telling them what sells
2. Fans have no deadlines, they can endlessly iterate on a concept until it works
3. Fans have the benefit of hindsight because they are working with a finished property.

>>30853775
When you faggots will understand that this shit is supposed to please little girls, not you
Ask a little girl if she'd prefer having a tree castle or a crystal castle and see what happens
How fucking out of touch with reality are you faggots to even say these things

>>30853858
I'm pretty sure every little girl would prefer fantasy brought to life rather than cheap marketing, because the castle even if crystal can be done so much more tastefully.

Jesus, how do you go from the Crystal Kingdom to this fucking train wreck of a boy playing with daddy's blowtorch on his sister's barbie playhouse?

>>30853934
Oh yeah, the crystal castle looks like shit, but maybe they have something planned about why it looks like that

I mean, it's obviously made to remind you of the tree of harmony, but maybe it'll keep growing?
Maybe it's not its final form

>>30853956
>Kingdom of Harmony
Welp, there's the title for the next movie.

Goodbye Ponyville, we knew ye well.

>>30851973
>they somehow made it even worse

File: this.gif (446KB, 300x186px) Image search: [Google]

446KB, 300x186px

>>30852767

File: good morning.gif (4MB, 467x263px) Image search: [Google]

4MB, 467x263px

>>30852767

>>30852969
>tree is kill
>finale goes normally with Tirek getting defeated
>box falls in the ground where the library used to be located
>suddenly a big ass tree starts to grown really fast
>tree library 2.0 - castle edition
>first floor for books
>second floor for kitchen, rooms etc
>basement is crystal like and there are visible roots from the tree
>its also where the magic table is located
There you go

>>30853858
Fuck off Jim

>>30854008
XD ebin

>>30852062
The local lord of such a village.

File: 1500336277977.jpg (2MB, 1184x1387px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1184x1387px

>>30853858
Jim go fuck a horse

>>30851973
Left

>>30851973
Right, even though it still sucks.
Also the hanging house on the right is just weird, like who even lives here?

But left is just so cold and lifeless.

>>30854053
>who even lives here?
>looks like a cottage
Oh no, Zephyr is bunking at Twi's.

File: heheheh.jpg (27KB, 400x122px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 400x122px

>>30854053
You know who
owlicious

File: shooter.jpg (9KB, 244x200px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 244x200px

>>30854101

>>30852070
JUST

>>30852767
This. Nothing will beat how fucking comfy that library seemed

File: 1503228524598.jpg (163KB, 720x960px) Image search: [Google]

163KB, 720x960px

>>30853858
>/

Right. Right hands down.

File: 1446680708876.png (848KB, 930x602px) Image search: [Google]

848KB, 930x602px

>>30854008
>>30854027
>>30854424
>When you got no argument but you got memes

>>30851973
>The Virgin Castle
vs.
>The Chad Palace

File: imageffs.jpg (2KB, 113x150px) Image search: [Google]

2KB, 113x150px

>>30851973
This is the only correct answer, Anonion.

>>30854480
> when you got no valid answer so you use a meme pic

File: HAHAHAHA....and_now_Im_sad.jpg (42KB, 720x537px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 720x537px

>>30852070
NEVER EVER

>>30851973
The one optimize my rape power.

>>30851973
Left, if forced to choose; the right is too bulky and non-arboreal. I have the feeling that Twilight spends most of her down time in the little house part near the bottom. By-the-by, when will she get a personal guard? At least they could fill up some of the space. The new one looks like they tried to incorporate the logo shape in the center.