Deal or No Deal

>>30654130
can i remember when i get there?

>>30654130

So basically the world would be new when I got there?

Would I be a pony, human, something else?

>>30654130
Deal

File: image.png (447KB, 800x800px) Image search: [Google]

447KB, 800x800px

>>30654130
Deal. I get to fall in love with her all over again.

It's still better than earth.

File: Twilight_Sparkle27.png (1MB, 993x1280px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 993x1280px

If Twiggy can still be my Mommy

>>30654147
No
>>30654160
You can be any species prior to going to Equestria.

>>30654130
Deal.

>>30654130
I believe most here were already degenerates when they got into MLP.
Wouldnt make much of a difference

>>30654175
I'm with this Anon. Sounds like a plan to me.

>>30654188
would become a zebricorn, a cross between alolicorn and zigger to become ultimate horse god

>>30654207 Me 3

File: 124512674.jpg (36KB, 640x480px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 640x480px

>>30654130
Please don't do this to be OP, I've already had to make a serious choice recently.

File: 1501795222138.png (138KB, 350x350px) Image search: [Google]

138KB, 350x350px

>>30654212 So, you would do blackmagic?

>>30654130

So long as I can be one of the Mane 6's children and be an utter bitch to them in a tantrum moment.

Well, everyone but Rarity, since she basically had that moment with her daughter.

>>30654222
Why aren't you smiling? Don't you want to go home?

File: 24357.gif (4MB, 328x191px) Image search: [Google]

4MB, 328x191px

>>30654201
>sick freak into xenophilia in this world
>go to equestria and lose memory
>become a sick freak into xenophilia again
>become lyra obsessed with humans
what a cruel irony that would be.

What's worse? Going there knowing you will forget everything about them, everything you loved about them. Everything you knew about them.

Or growing up as a child? Being forced to remember the disgusting person you once were?

>>30654268
itd be far better to grow up a second time with all of your previous knowledge.

File: Pancakes.png (769KB, 1280x960px) Image search: [Google]

769KB, 1280x960px

>Dont have to deal with "Our world is fictional?" bullshit.
>Dont have to deal with your uncontrollable reactions to meeting the ponies yoo've essentially stalked for close to seven years now.

Literally no downside, take this deal before OP wises up.

>>30654188
>Prior.
What species will we be when we get there, or did you just word that wrong.
Unicorn foal please.

>>30654222
My fucking nigga.
I havent opened the game since i finished the solstice update, the whole thing absolutely destroyed me.

>>30654268

I have to live with who I once was even in this world. Every thing I do to make me better now makes how bad I was in the past worth it.

>>30654285
Solstice? You mean there's more?

>>30654285
I guess you might be right. I'd like to be an pegasus foal, with Luna to mother me.

File: niko_surprised.png (737B, 96x96px) Image search: [Google]

737B, 96x96px

>>30654290
>He doesnt know.
Nigga, open the game again and hold onto your butt.

>>30654290
>>30654306
Do it for her

>>30654130
deal, where do I sign faggot?

File: _88_by_vertiliago-d7xwp6w.png (827KB, 1400x1920px) Image search: [Google]

827KB, 1400x1920px

I kinda made this thread thinking of a "What if" scenario. Sure most of us here would be more than happy to go to Equestria. I put the forgetful aspect in the scenario because I'm not sure whether it is best for us to be degenerates driven only to sex the pone and possibly taking advantage of these characters since all of us know who they are.
Morally I don't think it is right to manipulate these ponies because of the knowledge we already obtained watching the show.
Sometimes I feel we might be better if not knowing.

>>30654264
>Become an human obsessed pony with no memories of an human life
>End up browsing /mlh/
>Similar thread happen
>Become a pony obssesed human with no memories of a pony life
>You have gone through this loop 3 times already.

File: wait, just hold the fuck up for a second.png (92KB, 326x248px) Image search: [Google]

92KB, 326x248px

What if you chose to live in Equestria, had no memories of the show, but after 3-4 years of living there happily, all your memories about the show came back?
Would you keep it a secret? Have a mental breakdown?

>>30654130
Wait, so I'd remember nothing about myself before going to Equestria? Deal. Take away my PTSD from two tours of Iraq please, it's a small price to pay that I'd remember nothing else, Deal.

>>30654188
>You can be any species prior to going to Equestria.
Cool, can I be a werewolf? That would be badass.
Plus I would get automatic points with Fluttershy.

>>30654520
well it depends not on "where" we end up in Equestria, but "when" if we got dropped on our necks into that world at the same time as the newest episode give or take a week then it wouldn't really matter, if we ended up at the premiere of S1 or even before with all our knowledge however then it becomes a different conundrum

File: Remember me.png (27KB, 500x345px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 500x345px

>>30654579
>Go to Twilight.
>Show them random amulet.
>"This thing appears to have cursed me with foreign memories of being a different species, can you get rid of them please, i think they're starting to overwrite my real memories"
>Zap
>"Thanks."
I've already thought about and accepted the idea of suffering psyche-death if another 'me' that wasnt as damaged were to suddenly appear, or if i appear in their shoes.

>>30654623
you do know that werewolves have no control of the wolf form right? every aspect of them becomes wolf like, including the brain, all the savagery of a bloodthirsty wolf with the tactics of a human mind, you'd end up being quarantined to the Everfree for the better part of the entirety of your time there but hey at least you could get tons of timberwolf pussy

File: doctor_who__the_end_of_time___regeneration_quote.jpg (171KB, 1024x743px) Image search: [Google]

171KB, 1024x743px

>>30654752
>I've already thought about and accepted the idea of suffering psyche-death if another 'me' that wasnt as damaged were to suddenly appear, or if i appear in their shoes.
made me think of pic related

>"You've changed Anon"
"Same faggot, different dick"
>"That's not what I meant"

File: 1485229448620.jpg (16KB, 480x477px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 480x477px

>>30654579
>Would probably start low-key freaking out
>Try my best to keep it a secret
>Don't want anyone else to start questioning their existence
>One night I'm dreaming about it and Luna sees everything
>Mfw she confronts me about how I have memories about Equestria from before I arrived there

>>30654850
I don't really know why she'd care too badly it's not like you'd be a threat to Equestria because you remember Twilight reading that book back in S1

>>30654130
DEAL!

>>30654850
>>Don't want anyone else to start questioning their existence
Surely the fact that you have been living there for 4 years would prove that it is real, regardless of whatever memories you may or may not have had about it being a TV show. I doubt anyone would start freaking out if they found out MLP was a TV show in our world, they'd probably just call you crazy.

File: 133851723651.png (275KB, 716x423px) Image search: [Google]

275KB, 716x423px

>>30654805
Was never really a fan.
Tennant was absolutely fantastic though, especially in his final episode.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dSK1APQu6K4

>>30654264
what if Lyra is just one of us who got sent back in time after taking the same deal?

>>30654130
Of course yes

File: 1432748706755.jpg (91KB, 493x639px) Image search: [Google]

91KB, 493x639px

>>30654130
But where is the downside?

File: what the fuck.png (112KB, 373x311px) Image search: [Google]

112KB, 373x311px

>>30654550
stahp.

>>30654130
Yes. That's how I'd like it to be, actually. I'd imagine re-meeting all the ponies would be very weird, especially if you were to accidentally let something slip that would imply you already had prior knowledge.

>>30654761
Werewolves, like vamps vary drastically with the setting.

>>30654130
Does that mean I'll no longer find poners attractive?

File: 665115__safe_artist-colon-kenket_artist-colon-spainfischer_princess_celestia_twilight_sparkle_both_cutie_marks_cute_eye_contact_filly_momlestia_river_s.jpg (634KB, 900x649px) Image search: [Google]

634KB, 900x649px

>>30654130
There's almost no downside once this decision is made. You don't have the awkwardness of meta knowledge, and everything MLP is fresh and new to you once more.

>You will NEVER again feel the euphoria that the show gave you 7 years ago as it drew you into its colorful world and characters.

File: 104074__safe_artist-colon-egophiliac_artist-colon-spyrothefox_princess_celestia_twilight_sparkle_alicorn_colored_eyes_closed_female_mare_nuzzling_pony_.jpg (173KB, 848x750px) Image search: [Google]

173KB, 848x750px

>>30658006
You'd discover your attraction all over again. Possibly even faster if you consider how much more exposure you'd get.

File: 1454661940453.jpg (290KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

290KB, 1920x1080px

>>30658022
>You will NEVER again feel the euphoria that the show gave you 7 years ago as it drew you into its colorful world and characters.
Speak for yourself, I never stopped feeling it.

>>30654130
>I get to forget all the terrible pony porn I've seen while browsing derpibooru with no filters
>No more memories of gay shipping
>No more memories of incest porn
>No more memories of foalcon
>No more memories of trap ponies with ugly horsecocks
>No more memories of necrophilia
>No more memories of diapers full of shit
>No more memories of Flurry Heart toddler porn

FUCKING YES PLEASE

File: 1500063970112.png (3MB, 1182x2000px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1182x2000px

But guys, what if you end up liking Glimmer this time?

>>30654130
Deal.

>>30654520
>driven only to sex the pone and possibly taking advantage of these characters
Then just don't. Is it hard to keep your dick in your pants? Are you only driven by sex and nothing else? Surely you could find some happiness in havin good pony friends. And if there's genuine romance, then what's wrong with that? You're not taking advantage of them if you just want to be with them and they want to be with you, no matter what the reason is. I don't think it's cheating to know about their life, that just means you understand them better and can make them happier.

File: what's the most you’ve ever lost in a coin toss.jpg (12KB, 340x350px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 340x350px

>>30658022
You're absolutely right anon. Lets fix that with an easy game.

Reply to this post with Evens or Odds. Call correctly and you go to equestria just as OP said with all the infomation you know about mlp gone from your memory with no ill side effects. If you call wrong however and your post ends at (1,2) You will have short term memory loss. And no, there is no magical cure. (3,4) You can't remember pony names. (5,6) You wake up in a rerun episode of season 1 and are forced to go through it again and again and again... for true fairness https://www.random.org/ minimum 1/max 26(7,8) It backfires completly and you forget everything except everything you know related to mlp. (9,0) You forget everything, period. Your name, your family, your entire life up to this point. And if you choose not to choose you get to go to equestria with a bullet in your head.

I'll even go first.
Odds.

>>30654130
Deal
I always loved shy girls so I'll still love Fluttershy even when I forget everything.

>>30658187
Evens.

>>30658213
haha jokes on u equestrias not real faggot
you cant make me follow your game

File: click.png (11KB, 216x198px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 216x198px

>>30658216
>choosing death over a few misremembered names
pity.

>>30654175
What if you never meet her? You won't know to seek her out.

File: 1344628076754.jpg (33KB, 314x314px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 314x314px

>>30658187
Odds, show me the numbers patrick bateman.

>>30658244
batemans dubs have forsaken you this day.

File: 1416195696216.jpg (28KB, 640x480px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 640x480px

>>30658266
Check'd

>>30658244
>Go to Equestria, knowing there's something about all of it that you can't remember
>It doesn't take you long to realise you're incapable of remembering any of their names
>Even after what you can only assume are multiple attempts at remembering
>Feel bad about it by giving the ponies names according to what you can remember about them
>Book Smart, Panka, Rarara and more
>It annoys them all to no end that you call them these stupid nicknames
>They continue to tolerate you and you don't tell them that you can't remember what their names are, even if you tried
>They'd just try to fix it, but you know on some level that they can't
>There's a power in saying someone's name, not only that, but a connection to an individual that you now permanently lack
>All around you are familiar faces, unfamiliar names.

>>30654130
I'm autistic enough to keep a pocket journal, and I writefag sub-frequently and have a generalized list of things regarding Equestria /in/ said journal: therefore, fuck you.

>>30654222
>>30654285
>>30654306
Stop making me cry, fuckers.

File: Believe.jpg (142KB, 763x1017px) Image search: [Google]

142KB, 763x1017px

>>30658067
Well said.
I would want nothing more than to make these ponies happy, and be a part of their lives.

Even with memories in tact I'm sure there would come a time where you would explain to them how you know of them in the first place. It would be a bit awkward at first.
They can be understanding but more so concerned of the fact that as a person you chose to go to Equestria as appose to living your own world. Unless some divine bullshit took you there or you died or something.
Seems kinda selfish in a way. And yet I'll probably feel a little guilty to leave everyone I know behind. It's easier for some to just leave because they probably got nothing going on in this life.
For me, I just want a little bit more without having to influence these ponies in a negative way. We're all degenerates here, and whether we like it or not, we probably all don't deserve to be there because of all the shit we fantasize about about them.

>There is no wrong way to fantasize.
Not sure if you guise realize but I was the OP that made those, "When you guys die I hope you go to Equestria by your own creation." Threads. Pic related.
It's easier to go to a world by our design, but what if you don't get that choice?
And you're just thrown in without any knowledge of these equines in the first place.
Question is, do you think we're better off not knowing and keeping the world in tact?
Or going in with memories and possibly being selfish and possibly corrupting it.

>Then do be an ass and corrupt them.
I get it, we're all not asses. Influencing ponies for the better would be the ticket. But lets be honest, most ponies are idiots. This is the kinda shit I think about from time to time.

>Dat Autism
Yea I know. But it's really a discussion more than anything. And if you fuckers do get there, I hope it's everything you possibly could imagine.

File: evil baby.jpg (77KB, 576x532px) Image search: [Google]

77KB, 576x532px

>>30658244
>fail
>dubbs
>ironic fail cause of dubbs
kek

>>30658279
Precisely explained. Not the worse thing that can happen to you in my game but certainly the most insidious for how often it will effect your day to day life in equestria.

File: Hmmm.png (566KB, 1280x1499px) Image search: [Google]

566KB, 1280x1499px

>>30658290
seems kinda cheatzy but hey.
It would be an interesting premise for a story.
>Anon gets to Equestria
>No memories of world.
>Has journal depicting characters in a way.
>Uses journal as reference to live in said world.

File: anon screams.gif (2MB, 650x1000px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 650x1000px

>>30658329
And our first anon in-
I saw that.

>>30658338
he chose the bullet.

>>30658310
I kinda thought you were the same anon but didn't expect it to be true
I actually think that both are good. Be it by our design or be it without our memories. Of course we would influence them in some manner but I don't think that it's necessarily corruting them. Be their friend, be happy with them, make them happy. That's all that's needed, at least for me.

I would trust myself to not bring any filth of this world to theirs. I only ever want to love and be loved. I want to feel what it's like to make someone happy. It's not happening here so maybe it would happen there. The only negative way I want to influence a pony is to spoil her with too much affection.

>>30654188
I want to be a Baali vampire then.

File: ponko.png (354KB, 624x678px) Image search: [Google]

354KB, 624x678px

>>30654176
this

>>30658187
Gimmie jock shock jock shock me evens

>>30658279
I mean, the game just says you forget the pony names. I believe you'd just have to relearn them once you first met the poners and you wouldn't forget.

>>30658187
odds

>>30658187
Odds

File: iu[2].png (230KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

230KB, 500x500px

>>30658187
this is far , far better.
Komm, süsser Tod

evens

File: don't cry for me im already dead.png (264KB, 1152x648px) Image search: [Google]

264KB, 1152x648px

>>30659887

File: image.jpg (115KB, 640x1092px) Image search: [Google]

115KB, 640x1092px

>>30658235
>never meet Pinkie Pie
Literally impossible. She'd make sure we met. She wants to be friends with EVERYONE.

>>30659244
You misread the game, those things happen in addition to forgetting everything.
>Cannot
>Not Do not
You cannot remember pony names, ever.

>>30658187
My lucks not great so lets see our punishment, evens

File: 1497599822536.png (161KB, 560x600px) Image search: [Google]

161KB, 560x600px

>>30661338
Fortune smiles upon you, friendo

>>30658060
being in their universe and not protected by fandom cynicism, falling for Glimmer's main character charm would be unavoidable

>>30654130
Sure, it'd be awkward otherwise.

>>30658235
She would seek you out.

>>30654264
Lyra isn't obsessed with humans.

>>30654520
>driven to sex the pone
Speak for yourself.

>>30654587
uh that's not what he said? try re-reading the OP.

>>30661770
get out of here with your headcanons

>>30661798
not a headcanon.

>>30658355
Waifu?

File: fugg.gif (641KB, 320x388px) Image search: [Google]

641KB, 320x388px

Pang 9

File: 1475976902135.gif (383KB, 470x471px) Image search: [Google]

383KB, 470x471px

>>30661959

>>30654130
Agh...evil bastard. I'd say yes, so long as i could have unlimited pony snuggles

>>30654130
You got yourself a hecking deal. This is literally the ideal scenario, I watch mlp because it's so wholesome and it makes me feel better about the world. I'd much rather forget all the shiz I've seen on the internet relating to mlp so I can be clean and trusting person, and live in an environment where that's actually possible.

>>30654917
>would prove that it is real
Haha no it wouldn't

>>30658187
YOLO ODDS

>>30654130
>forget everything related to MLP
It's a deal. That way I'd still keep all the memories of my past life, save for a mysterious huge hole in the past few years, so that could still be mildly interesting for other horses.
Besides, there exists a memory spell. The longer you've been on the ride, the larger the hole in your memory would be, and the better the chance you could get someone like Twilight to attempt to cast it on you. There's no telling how magic works in Equestria, but I suspect the spell could actually work at least partially, if only because "your" memories would also be hers.

>>30658187
Evens.

File: 1118543__safe_smiling_comic_human_looking+at+you_lyra+heartstrings_grin_wide+eyes_hand_creepy.jpg (222KB, 900x771px) Image search: [Google]

222KB, 900x771px

>>30664056
Food for thought, if you are the same Anon. Hope you get to see her one day.

Last question for all.

We all know that show has impacted us in some way shape or form.
So my question now is that would you still go if it meant becoming the person you once we're before ponies?

Let that one settle a bit anons.

>>30665245
I'm that anon, yes.

I'd go, the only thing that really changed me for the better was finding my waifu. If it means going there and seeing her, I think I'd manage.