ITT: /mlp/ argues over what the best fan fiction is.

>>30403265
Nice slide thread, faggot

Past Sins with Benefits

>>30403265
>best
How about "least terrible"

File: colt.png (121KB, 452x408px) Image search: [Google]

121KB, 452x408px

>>30403265
Why does Rumble have a mare's snout?
Is he a gelding or something?

>>30403265
Nominating The Celestia Code.

File: 936549__safe_artist-colon-arkiiwarki_rumble_alternate_hairstyle_ask_ask_trap-dash-rumble_bracelet_choker_clothes_crossdressing_cute_dialogue_eyelashes_.png (686KB, 1280x1161px) Image search: [Google]

686KB, 1280x1161px

>>30403315
Hes is just a trippity trappity [/spoiler]TRAP

Field Notes On Alicorn Reproductive Behavior

but actually it's "Reward"

File: same snout.jpg (30KB, 561x319px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 561x319px

>>30403486
>>30403493
But how did he change his snout to look like a filly's?
He's young,cutimarkless even, so it's doubtful that he would be allowed to have a surgery or use magic to change his skull, which implies that his body grows that way, possibly due to the lack of male hormones

Probably because he's a gelding

>>30403265
Darkest hour. No doubt. Shame the qm went insane.

File: 929321__safe_artist-colon-arkiiwarki_rumble_alternate_hairstyle_blushing_choker_cute_ear_blush_eyelashes_floppy_ears_foal_looking_at_you_male_pegasus_p.png (442KB, 1200x1092px) Image search: [Google]

442KB, 1200x1092px

>>30403684
He is just naturally girly, that makes him an excellent trap.
It's his special talent, he will get his cutie mark when he takes his first cock.

Hopefully soon~

File: thunder and rumble comparison.png (51KB, 196x216px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 196x216px

>>30403771
>He is just naturally girly

Then how come his looks like every other stallion?

>>30403771
>>30404020
his brother*

Fallout Equestria is my favorite but then again I'm a massive faggot with a boner for Fallout so take that with a grain of salt

Your idiotic assumptions of Rumble being a filly made me lose my interest of shipping him with fillies!

At first, I was seeing him as a small badass jock with dirty jokes, but now I see him just as a colt with filly body.

You guys made me notice this and think just like you! I fucking hate you people! My headcanons means nothing to me now!

Most fanfiction is shit and the fics that aren't are so good that you have to wonder why the authors wasted effort writing them instead of proper original novels.

>>30404049
Fallout Equestria is shit

File: dae7e2731f2689f86b24943fd62f1a3d.png (338KB, 1024x640px) Image search: [Google]

338KB, 1024x640px

>>30403265
My favorite is "pastoral fanfic about Chrysalis"

>>30403265
The only good fanfic is the deleted one.

>>30404169
That's where you're wrong kiddo

Butterscotch Sticks His Dick In An Anthill.

>>30403265
One of darf's.
I'd say 'Walk softly' or 'The scootaloo project'/The one about Applebloom that ends in a threesom with DT/SS.
Or maybe Lapsbin's shit. Either 'Touch the sun' or his two umbra stories.

Anything else if objectively wrong.

File: 1477697574244.png (318KB, 1126x2121px) Image search: [Google]

318KB, 1126x2121px

Pic related, it's not even close.

>>30404376
link?

File: headcanon.png (82KB, 1269x262px) Image search: [Google]

82KB, 1269x262px

>>30404149
More for you

Also,

>Rumble being a '''''filly'''''

FTFY

File: 1497873180692.jpg (51KB, 750x750px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 750x750px

>>30404478
fuck, this was great, I can't believe I missed this pearl
You got any more of the S5-6 Era like that?
I was off the ride then

>>30404020
It's genetical magic, just like the pie sisters.
Just instead of personality disorders, his family has different body types.
His brother has the body of a /fit/izen and rumble has a cute trappy body

>>30404149
He isn't a filly, unless you want him to be~

File: 1405358854909.gif (2MB, 200x120px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 200x120px

>>30404575

>>30404486
https://pastebin.com/cJbmZckE

>>30403265
Not even a contest
>https://pastebin.com/7zD8EYvZ

Murky Number Seven

>1,000,000+ words
It was a hell of a ride

>>30406835
Murky is probably the most well-written I've read so far when it comes to the technicalities.

I'm not big on fanfiction though, I did most of my reading during the Season 1 ~ 2 hiatus.

>>30403265
The Transient's Detail