YOU HAD ONE GODDAMNED JOB HASBRO WITH GOH. ONE GODDAMNED JOB

>>29482649
which one is better, price or fleecs?

>>29482649
Fosgitt did nothing wrong

File: large.jpg (190KB, 768x1024px) Image search: [Google]

190KB, 768x1024px

>>29482653
Price.

File: 1301947__safe_twilight+sparkle_princess+celestia_princess+twilight_spike_queen+chrysalis_changeling_idw_spoiler-colon-comic_drama.jpg (181KB, 790x1199px) Image search: [Google]

181KB, 790x1199px

>>29482649
>Fosgitt picked the two characters that will let him just draw gradient backgrounds/the sky instead of actually giving a fuck

Still, this might look okay I guess?

>>29482649
Get rekt, pencilfags

>>29482649
I thought your intent was to SELL the toys hasbro, not drive the little boys away with these comics.

>>29482663
Not intentionally.

>>29482716
Neither did the pilot of the hindinburgh.

>>29482649
>"Art" by Fosgitt

How many dicks is fosgitt sucking to get work at IDW anyways?

>>29483148
One to currently keep it and probably one plus eating out Cook to get it.

File: 725059__safe_idw_spoiler-colon-comic_power+ponies_preview_idw+advertisement_masked+matter-dash-horn_zapp_fili-dash-second_spoiler-colon-comicannual2014.jpg (322KB, 630x969px) Image search: [Google]

322KB, 630x969px

Could they get ben bates back please? he did great work on that power ponies comic

File: 951190__safe_artist-colon-kaijusamurai_applejack_coco+pommel_discord_nightmare+moon_princess+celestia_rarity_scootaloo_spike_tank_twilight+sparkle_hydr.jpg (238KB, 945x1365px) Image search: [Google]

238KB, 945x1365px

Why does IDW not draw from their Godzilla artist that has drawn a cover for the comic and has drawn MLP for years for MLP?

File: 1281902__safe_artist-colon-kaijusamurai_princess+luna_tiberius_spoiler-colon-comic_spoiler-colon-comic48_accord+(arc)_bat_centipede_chaos+theory+.jpg (2MB, 2063x3131px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 2063x3131px

>>29483517
The cover he drew, for reference. I can already hear bitching about the style, but seriously, this series has Jay Fosgitt on it. I'd take this over Foshitt.

>>29483517
Because IDW is allergic to success.

>>29483538
What's wrong with that cover? I thought it was incredible.

>>29482649
What has Fosgitt done that's so bad?

>>29482649
There must be some shennigans with Fosgitt still having a job. Maybe nepotism or some union bullshit.
They have to realize that his art is shit.

>>29483556
His career

>>29483557
Dicks. Millions of dicks. All sucked dry.

>>29483557
>>29483567
They likely know his art is shitty, but they get it fast, cheap, and with a smile. Plus a lot of bronies shill it.

File: 1486764577426.jpg (871KB, 1097x1598px) Image search: [Google]

871KB, 1097x1598px

>>29483556
Something like this.

>>29483557
It's called knowing your audience. We all know that everyone in this thread is going to pirate the comic if they like it and ignore it if they don't, and either scenario is worth $0.00 to IDW so why should they give a shit what you think?

The comic is aimed at kids, and kids like cute simple artwork like Fosgitt's. Also, kids (or their parents) actually pay money to read the books.

>>29483605
I actually buy the comics but avoid ones completely drawn by Fosgitt. Only getting this one because I have to own everything Guardians of Harmony.

>>29483517
Why would we want real talent wasted on such garbage stories anyway?

>>29483611
Because they might be getting show writers soon.

>>29483538
That's a great cover. I'd love to see ponies drawn like that.

>>29483605
B-b-but My Little Pony isn't for children, it's a sophisticated anime for mature adults like me!

That's why I demand IDW replace Fosgitt with my favorite edgy Deviantartist. All he's ever drawn is Apple Bloom incest porn but I'm sure Hasbro won't mind.

>>29483631
All Andy Price basically drew before MLP was Marvel/DC superhero fetish porn. So yeah.

You know, seeing Fosgitt's stuff makes me wonder if I could have a shot working for IDW.

>>29483640
Once they realize you are from the fandom they will make up excuses no matter how good you are why not to put you on interiors. You will get a variant cover no one will ever see and that's it.

>>29482649
So... are these attempts trying to force MLP more muscular thing working for sales?

>>29483654
Yes. This comic won't affect sales in any way. It's not even going to be included in the boxes like people originally thought.

>>29483279
Unfortunately Bates quit comics right after that Annual to go into animation.

File: strange.jpg (197KB, 768x1024px) Image search: [Google]

197KB, 768x1024px

>>29483635
He should more crossover pony art

File: Pic+related+is+how+op+is+gonna+kill+himself+_fec9a9e50fd0567654f9972c6418c90f.jpg (10KB, 278x300px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 278x300px

>>29482649
>Spike
>by FOstgitt

Rememebr the times where the show was shitting on Spike until S6? They didn't get the memo at IDW

File: 1486824785039.jpg (70KB, 602x611px) Image search: [Google]

70KB, 602x611px

>>29483556
Is there SOMETHING he did good?

>>29483649
So did Pencils even got a variant cover for MLP? That's always some sort of a start...

File: 1486133042840.jpg (61KB, 329x329px) Image search: [Google]

61KB, 329x329px

>>29482649
>Jay fosgitt
Nooooooooo!

>>29483556

angle-bracket legs.

File: sadPonk.jpg (26KB, 211x201px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 211x201px

>>29483903

>>29483930
No
The way he draws ponies is just fucking disgusting

>>29482649
Meghan McCarthy need to be fired!

File: 1449474772475.jpg (24KB, 399x388px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 399x388px

>>29483930

Download, when!?

>>29485043
Two weeks, if the schedule holds.

>>29485049
Argh that's so loooong.
Thank you, anon. I'll be waitng.

File: damage control.png (113KB, 481x132px) Image search: [Google]

113KB, 481x132px

>>29482649
Aaaaand Wonderbolts/Big Spike are already shit.

File: fosgitt.jpg (124KB, 494x654px) Image search: [Google]

124KB, 494x654px

>>29483556

>>29485069
Given this thread, my hopes aren't very high. I just hope there's something /mlp/ can like in it.

>>29483605
Hello, TexasUber!

File: 1455919634445.gif (826KB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]

826KB, 500x281px

>>29485221
The other four being drawn by Price and Fleecs could be good. Just depends how well the stories by Whitley and Rice are.

File: dafuqisthis.jpg (88KB, 447x350px) Image search: [Google]

88KB, 447x350px

> This edit got me banned from Derpibooru

>>29485285
they all look like they're missing chromosomes

Sometimes his art is tolerable. I just wish someone would tell him to practice.

File: cute_mental retardation.png (502KB, 776x1030px) Image search: [Google]

502KB, 776x1030px

>>29485354
No, they look like show art put through the wringer or content aware satan.

>>29485285

angle-bracket legs

>>29482649

>EQD still don't show the preview with this page

INB4 Q will never post the preview.

Someone submit this to EQD, there are some peoples that are actually hyped for the gigant spike comic and need to know that will be drawed by foshit

He might actually draw Spike better big than he does with him small.

Still, Andy should have gotten the Spike chapter.

>>29482649
F

>>29486116
Hello, Archonix! Go fuck yourself!

>>29482649
I normaly don't mind fosgit but his style really wont work here.
I am far more worried about 2/3 being written by fucking whitley.

>>29482715
Hasbro wants that but sometimes I feel idw wants the comics to fail (in which case they must have panicked when this series was ordered and scrambled to find a way to fuck it up)

>>29483654
Guardians of harmony is selling well but the tie ins are going to hurt sales they will be that bad.

>>29485339
Seriously fuck derpi I used to think there moderation is good but when I started to learn what they were deleting that quickly changed.

The smiling pony needs to get rid of most of his moderation team and replace them with better mods.

>>29486272
It got delayed for months so maybe.

>>29486260
This.

>>29486246
Archonix actually drew something showing how wrong Fosgitts anatomy is. He put his money where his mouth is.

>>29486285
Not like they pack them in with toys.

File: 1486768807450.png (885KB, 1200x1200px) Image search: [Google]

885KB, 1200x1200px

>>29482649
Welp, time to ignore IDW comics again.

Hopefully S7 will start soon and we can all forget both IDW comics and the Movie because both look like shit.

Ever since the Ted Anderson thing I refused to do so much as glance at the comics. The entire crew is a bunch of hacks and I'm sad to hear they're still trucking along.

>>29486889
They lied about firing Ted Anderson too.

>>29486246

same to you relcariox! same to you.

>>29486327

horse legs aren't difficult. I can't work out why he has so much trouble drawing them. It's like he's some sort of lazy, untalented hack who never does research and just throws everything together at the last minute.

File: twiggles.gif (332KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

332KB, 500x500px

>>29483575
Fuck's sake, Rob Liefeld can draw better than this douche

>>29486915
I don't understand how he can look at literally every other artist that works on the comics and think that his work is at all acceptable.

Does he just have Dunning-Kruger really badly?

>>29486929

I don't think he cares. Too busy gobbling nobs.

>>29486929
He only got the job because Katie Cook vouched for him. And that's all what the comic is for him: just a job.

>>29487015
But see even approaching it from that perspective how can he not see that he does his job incredibly poorly compared to the other people on it?

You don't have to have passion for a series to draw well for it. You can approach it like a job. But he does his job poorly.

File: 16123217_139687446544350_7395488798114578432_n.jpg (95KB, 1080x1080px) Image search: [Google]

95KB, 1080x1080px

Goddamn, even when he actually does try he's still just mediocre at best.

>>29487074
Mediocre?
There's no sense of perspective in that background at all, and his shading is abysmal.
That's not even getting started on his actual fucking characters

>>29487236
Oh god, look at the scale of the knife.

>>29487074
So the light comes from above and the right of the picture while only throwing one shadow...at a place where neither of those light sources would... you know what? Just forget it.

>>29486919
Has Liefeld ever done ponies?
Like for a con or some shit?

>>29487425
I don't think so.

Guys, who drew like the first comics?

They're basically the only ones I read and I loved the style. And here I hear all this drama about shitty artists in the newer comics.

>>29487611
Andy Price, who drew two chapters of this.

>>29486889
Well anderson was not a hack just a gigantic fucking faggot friends forever 3 was pretty good.

>>29487620
Oh nice

>>29482649
Comics was a mistake.

File: tmp_8067-1486071885611-1989805241.png (17KB, 522x381px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 522x381px

>>29487720
So were you desu

File: smugzuki.png (109KB, 422x427px) Image search: [Google]

109KB, 422x427px

>>29487724
At least I'm aware. IDW isn't.

>>29487751
>IDW is probably going to make a Hanazuki comic and have Fosgitt as the main artist

File: 1484521909893.jpg (128KB, 407x474px) Image search: [Google]

128KB, 407x474px

>>29487762
No, don't give them any ideas.

What the fuck happened to all the other artists?
Do they only have these three now?

>>29487932
They have Price, Hickey, Fleecs, Garbowska, and Fosgitt. Hickey couldn't do it and I guess Garbowska "didn't fit."

>>29487932

Four actually
>Andy Price
>Tony fleecs
>garwosca
>Jay Fosgitt

Gonna to be five when hickey return in April and make six issues on a row about legend of magic

File: 1461691152896.jpg (64KB, 680x607px) Image search: [Google]

64KB, 680x607px

>>29487944
>>29487951
What happened to the dike? She die from cancer?

>>29488152
She got fired for putting her OC in.

File: 6d92bef9d53cee1a43201d381abbe8ca[1].jpg (15KB, 236x297px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 236x297px

>>29488154
Bullshit. Cook and Price put their OCs in practically every issue they're involved with, they even made a cameo in the show.

>>29488175
She also didn't have any friends on staff to fight for her. And yeah, even other OCs not in the show got to put theirs in. It was because she only did one issue and was too good.

File: 1446882038636.png (250KB, 680x353px) Image search: [Google]

250KB, 680x353px

>>29488154
>implying IDW has those standards

>>29488175
That was Jim Miller's doing, who's a close friend of them.

Fortunately, that episode was also the shittiest one ever, at the point that not even Miller could avoid the critics and accepted he had fucked up.

>>29488190
They do. Unless you suck enough dick/have people to fight for your continued employment they'll drop you if you do shit they don't like.

>>29487869
You know they would do it.

File: GoH 1 PG 8.jpg (200KB, 636x978px) Image search: [Google]

200KB, 636x978px

>>29486272
Well if they're trying to make it fail, they didn't do a good job with the dash one. It was one of the better comics they've done in a while.

Fuck, I kind of wish they could have continued on with following dash after that comic, it was a nice building block for continuing onward and she was actually characterized well and was enjoyable.
Plus the art was good.

>>29488905
I hope they continue Guardians of Harmony in some form, honestly.

>>29488924
Me too, but unless they were to cut GOH into its own continuity in some way, I have a hard time seeing it being a long term success.

So long as its tied to normal, ongoing show canon, there's very little they can do for real character progression or heavy risks (In the stakes with the villains) being done.

>>29487074
Are you kidding? That's a decent art. Not technically correct with the perspectives and whatever, but it isn't noticeably terrible.

>>29489147
Its better than Fosgitt's normal Pony art at least. It looks like he actually is at least TRYING with it.

>>29482649
Dropped

>>29489110
Maybe an alternate continuity, or just a spin-off of after the show.

>>29483605
>We all know that everyone in this thread is going to pirate the comic if they like it and ignore it if they don't
You have no idea how book piracy works.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Qkyt1wXNlI

>>29490480

oh haven't you heard? unless you buy every single comic, you can't criticise them.

>>29483605
Hasn't the comic started dipping below 10k units sold recently?

>>29491695
Yep.

File: 7spook.gif (602KB, 500x370px) Image search: [Google]

602KB, 500x370px

>>29482649
>Whitley
>whitley
>whiteley
>fleecs
>fosgitt
>Fosgit
I told you it was going to be shit if done by IDW.

>>29482663
>>29482716
Neither did he do anything right, and that he didn't do intentionally.

>>29483557
Fosgitt can actually draw pretty well, just look him up on google. But I've heard that he dislikes mlp and rather than saying something he just doesn't put any effort.
>>29483605
it's called nepotism, same reason why untalented idiots like Liefield still do Marvel comics and people who didn't finish high school can work in the senate making laws about things they know shit about.

>>29486297
The smiling pony is part of the problem, though, he'd need to fire himself.

File: come agatsu.png (2MB, 1366x768px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1366x768px

>>29486358
>movie is shit
>guardians of harmony is shit
>S7 is going to be not shit

>>29493303
With a gun.

>>29493313
Best matsu?

>>29493349
Nah, he's good at keeping the site up and working, he's just terrible at moderating, picking mods, making rules or keeping his feelings in check

>>29493464
He's also terrible at keeping mentally challenged people on a tight leash and they take advantage of that to cause trouble and evade banning all the time.
Saying "Muh autism, muh aspergers and muh depression" is an excuse that never fails to work at Derpibooru.

>>29493733
No it is not.

>>29493743
lhhh hasn't been permabanned because he said he was autistic
holofan confessed he asked a workmate to give him a blowjob and then he acted the victim, saying he was feeling sad and depressed and everyone took the bait and pitied him despite him being a disgusting sexual predator.

But just commenting that a DB user is autistic is an excuse to get YOU banned under DB's bullshit rule zero.

>>29493804
Don't forget bullshit rule "#n" or "if a mod doesn't like you for whatever reason he can ban you without even needing an excuse"

File: sick degerate.jpg (53KB, 983x168px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 983x168px

>>29493804
>holofan confessed he asked a workmate to give him a blowjob and then he acted the victim, saying he was feeling sad and depressed and everyone took the bait and pitied him despite him being a disgusting sexual predator.

The guy is 19 years old, morbidly obese, virgin (duh) works flipping burgers and can't stop himself from whinning all the time or stalk people and desperately ask them to be his friends.

Also, he openly talks about his manboobs and how he was blessed with a small dick, so I can't wait until the kick him out for good.

>>29494269
https://derpibooru.org/generals/the-cringe-thread/post/2868135#post_2868135

>>29482649

File: deanshade.jpg (8KB, 200x200px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 200x200px

>>29494291
>going to the forums