How much long will it be before you autists realize how much

Spike is a useless dog. Compared to all the cool shit he is in FiM. No thanks.

File: 1450617646821.jpg (41KB, 512x512px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 512x512px

>>28823197
>EG

File: where it belongs.jpg (142KB, 878x900px) Image search: [Google]

142KB, 878x900px

>>28823197
Shut up, faggot.

Also, do you think you're clever putting Starlight Glimmer of all ponies on there?

>>28823197
It's not better. Each of them is good in their own way

File: 1430443756128.jpg (42KB, 636x415px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 636x415px

>>28823197
Already realized it.

>>28823197
They won't, that's why they're autists anon.
Patricians like us however know what's up OP.

>EG
it's EQG newfag

File: 1477182321_kill me.jpg (146KB, 516x600px) Image search: [Google]

146KB, 516x600px

>>28823197
You can go ahead and keep your complete shit, only existing to cash off of Monster High, and where the characters are only the blandest and worst shadows of their FiM counterparts. The only character that is the least bit enjoyable is Sunset, and even then, she's a Twilight clone with no much else. The only thing more or as bad as EqG is season 6.

>>28823280
Someone cap this.

>>28823197
Not much long

>>28823287
Why?

>>28823197
The last EG movie was weak. FiM did ok, at least they did not jump out of the genre. I do like EG (2 out of 4 movies aint bad)

>>28823197
The only good thing about EQG is that there's no Glimmer in it.

>>28823315
>One of the three specials will be all about Glimmer
>The other one will be about crushes
>The other one will be about the Dazzlings and nothing else

>>28823287
Do it yourself
>>28823280
>Sunset, and even then, she's a Twilight clone with no much else.
They have nothing in common with each other except for being celestia's students.

>>28823331
Give me a character trait from Sunset that is actually unique.

File: 1478315082686.jpg (28KB, 324x291px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 324x291px

>>28823211
>Caring about Spike
>Caring about male characters
Look at this literal faggot.
No really
>Caring about characters with a penis
Fuck off to /lgbt/

>>28823345
well she is more active. She does not act like a middle aged woman while still having a good attitude. her emotions have reasons and she does not have random freaks outs like Twilight. she is not obsessed with anything.

>>28823315
Glimmer and trixie where one of the few good things this year. she is better than apple jack and fluttershy

>>28823375
and better than pinkie pie
>>28823211
>Compared to all the cool shit he is in FiM
being an email service and a house elf?

Is /mlp/'s opinion of EQG representative of the rest of the viewership's opinion of it or is /mlp/ just going to claim everyone but they are wrong?

>>28823315
I started watching EQG because of this reason.
And because there's no Manehattan.

>>28823345
Shes more out going, more dominant. Likes to learn by doing than reading. Bigger ego and more courageous.

>>28823392
How the fuck should we know?

>>28823422
>getting pissed

File: 1426449566525.png (312KB, 495x344px) Image search: [Google]

312KB, 495x344px

>>28823280
EQG is better than Season 6 because at least EQG doesn't have Glimmer.

>>28823441
I blame the jews

>>28823457
So what else is new?

>>28823454
Why don't you like Glimmer?

>>28823392
The rest of the fandom really loves EG
/mlp/ is just filled with neckbeards afraid of change

>>28823280
>the least bit enjoyable is Sunset
Is this a fucking joke?
She is the villain with worst motives of every villain MLP has created

>>28823454

>it has sunset
Choose your poison
Anyway anything with hooves is more enjoyable than an orange monkey

>>28823361
Not my fault he was the best character this season. I watch this show for more than just waifus, thanks. I want a good story.

>>28823382
You mean putting pretty much every new monarch on their thrones? Oh yeah. Being a dog is better.

>>28823492
Better than Glimmer. Her only motive was losing her boyfriend as a kid.

>>28823511
>I want a good story.
>20 minute toy commercials

>>28823518
>I want to take over equestria with a bunch of highschoolers
sasuga eqgfag

>>28823524
They're not even good at that considering the content of the show doesn't look like the toys (it looks better).

>>28823492
>She is the villain with worst motives of every villain MLP has created
What did King Sombra want?
>She is the villain with worst motives of every
she is not really a villain, she is an ex mean girl and its better to forget the first movie. even with that what was so bad about it? she wanted obedience and adoration like half the villains

>>28823524
As opposed to 80 minute toy commercials that make the toyetic nature of FiM look like a creative freedom paradise.

The writers of EqG barely actually write shit, most of it is Hasbro demands.

>>28823511
>You mean putting pretty much every new monarch on their thrones? Oh yeah. Being a dog is better.
ok you have to be a legit mentally ill to think that his accidental accomplishments count for anything. hell dog spike used emotional manipulation to distract midnight long enough for sunset to make her move so he saved 2 dimensions if you want to be autistic about it

>>28823539
at this point selling games is the only legit market. microtransaction

>>28823552
>used emotional manipulation
All he did was yell her name

File: 1366x768.jpg (228KB, 1366x768px) Image search: [Google]

228KB, 1366x768px

>>28823565
he is her dog. also he used the eyes

>>28823197
> M-Muh Lauren's Legacy

I guess never.

But let's be honest. Equestria Girls isn't great. Sunset Shimmer is. Multi-layer character in a show about one-dimensional characters. It just stands out. That's all there is.

>>28823463
Do you enjoy cancer? I don't.

If you'd like a non shitposting answer, it's because she's by far the worst thing to ever be introduced in the series, as she is nearly every definition of a Sue. Whenever she is involved, everyone has to be rendered useless and she's the only one who could ever do anything. There has yet to be an instance where she has even so much as interacted with any main character aside from Twilight and hasn't done something horrible to them. And then she doesn't even know what she did wrong. She's a horribly unlikable character who unlike Sunset has done jack fucking shit to the Mane 5 to prove she's a better person, and the less she's in the series the better.

>>28823197
Dumb glimmerposter

>>28823552
>>28823577
Cadence, Ember, Thorax, and Twilight would not be rulers without Spike. He is more influential than almost every character.

File: Questin mark.jpg (544KB, 1202x1024px) Image search: [Google]

544KB, 1202x1024px

EqG is part of FiM

>>28823603
>Cadence, Ember, Thorax, and Twilight
I see a pattern here, all of them are cancer. Maybe if Spike killed them instead he would be more appreciated

File: 1469616280711.gif (123KB, 600x419px) Image search: [Google]

123KB, 600x419px

>>28823603
>Twilight

>>28823616
OP here.
You're dripping bait tastier than mine.
I like it

>>28823586
well it would be hard to get a moment to shin when you are sounded by gods. it was same with twilight and celestia. yes unlike sunset Glimmer has issues and shortcomings.Glimmer can't go into a room were people give her the evil eye, she can't go "none taken" after someone recounts her misdeeds. she is a neurotic who is obsessed with past events, not to the same level as luna so its more tolerable when seen often. She can't prove that she is a better person because she herself doubts it. she does have too much magic power but that has never been part of a plot to a point where you would bust out "sue" would her having wings and a magic amulet make you feel better?

>>28823640
Did you forget how she got her cutie mark? Did you forget how much she did and still does rely on him?

>>28823603
>confirmed for retard
The dog gets more respect

>>28823640
He did so much crap for her.
She would have failed so much without him

>>28823648
>Did you forget how much she did and still does rely on him?
as a servant. When was the last time she asked him for input for anything important? also the faggot fucked up the whole city when he was in charge, his whole thing is having accidental accomplishments. like dorothy who landed on the evil witch and was memed into a hero

>>28823648
Yeah I remember. I remember Rainbow Dash's sonic rainboom doing that.

I also remember her letting him sell his soul to Applejack without a second thought.

>>28823674
Princess Spike was contrived shit and he did nothing wrong.

>>28823652
He helped all of them get power, defended them all, and showed his unending loyalty.

>>28823674
It doesn't matter if she asks, he has to get her out of the dumb shit she does.

File: 1469399757419 (1).png (310KB, 640x720px) Image search: [Google]

310KB, 640x720px

>>28823680

>>28823707
She knew he was exaggerating and that it wouldn't last. Its like when a kid threatens to run away.

>>28823695
>he has to get her out of the dumb shit she does.
That is presumptions of him. also I asked when was he last asked for input?
>Princess Spike was contrived shit
yeah Im sure you say the same about the comic book ep and every other ep were spike fucked things up.
>He helped all of them get power, defended them all, and showed his unending loyalty.
well your view is in minority so please shut up.(or at least don't post it as fact)

>>28823723
The comic book episode was fine and a big part of his character growth.

>>28823732
He has his own room now, and some sort of gilded basket bed thing. Things are looking up.

>>28823743
They almost bought him a bed in s5 e3

Why don't they use mirrors for communication?
>>28823743
>He has his own room now, and some sort of gilded basket bed thing. Things are looking up.
>allegedly save the world more than once. get a gilded basket bed
>be a sapient being. get treated like a pet despite your species having their own kingdom.
logically he should have moved out ages ago, maybe his crystal fans could build him a house.
Then he would just be written out of the story.

>>28823835
He doesn't leave because he loves his friends.

>>28823880
he can still love them without lagging luggage and doing all the chores. Friends that love each other sometimes withhold help so their friends can grow

>>28823896
No one is making him do it, but I would like to see the reaction to him just not doing it.

File: 4534534534534534534534.png (369KB, 810x594px) Image search: [Google]

369KB, 810x594px

>>28823361
>shitposting this hard

>>28823947
dumb spikefag

I like how a EG vs FiM thread turned into a Twilight being a cunt towards Spike thread.
Also, don't forget that pic Tara tweeted of Twilight and Spike for National Pet Day

>>28823197
But it is inferior, all of its weight relies on one character being superior to any character in FIM currently.

>>28823963
Good thing she's just a VA.

>>28823964
well in that way its more classical, something we are used to. old cartoons did not have tons of character pulling thing into their own direction. it had 1 lead, a deuteragonist, a token and the supporting cast. the old way is comfy, the new way just leads to tons of filler

>>28823643
>Glimmer can't go into a room were people give her the evil eye,
I can't think of a single time this happened, unlike Sunset, the Mane 5 suddenly love her without a second thought, or even mention of her past actions. Unlike Sunset, Starlight has done nothing to make amends except bitch and moan.

>She can't prove that she is a better person because she herself doubts it.
Because again, all she does is bitch and moan while still doing obviously evil things, followed by acting like she didn't know any better.

>she does have too much magic power but that has never been part of a plot to a point where you would bust out "sue"
It's more or less the fact that again, when she's around, everyone gets handed the idiot ball and is subject to her every whim.

>>28823963
post it

>>28823947
>stating the truth is shitposting

>>28823998
But it isn't executing that method all to well because it wants us to believe its supporting cast is interesting.

>>28824021
Its shitposting because Spikefags are the third or fourth most aggressive posters on here.

>>28824015
I don't have the pic

>>28824013
>the Mane 5 suddenly love her without a second thought
They don't love her. They are giving her a chance because twilight is giving her a chance. most of them don't want to hang with her.
>even mention of her past actions
yeah because unlike the movie recaps it does not usually come up organically. They are not going sit down and have a conversation about it.
>Starlight has done nothing to make amends except bitch and moan.
she has made mild effort in things that are mostly beneficially to only her. Mane group is not the one she has to make amends to, its mostly the towns people and there has not been much of a chance for that.
>still doing obviously evil things
its not evil in her eyes. She is used to fixing everything with magic so adjustment takes time. I wonder if she even had an upbringing
>followed by acting like she didn't know any better.
she is not just going to stop using magic and finding the line is hard. especially with something that often can have unforeseen effects
>everyone gets handed the idiot ball and is subject to her every whim.
like when? 1 time she had them under mind control while the other time it was an opening episode and the moral of the story needed everyone to be dumb so sunburst could be useful

>>28824023
well MiF is guilty of that too. some of the main group really works better in the background. its true for most shows

>>28824181
The supporting cast in FIM is better than the supporting cast in EQG.

>>28824194
well obviously 1 had more time to develop the cast. cut out of the definite eps for their characters and tell me how superior they are in everyday eps

>>28824246
Even in season 1 they were more interesting, even though I consider season 1 pretty dull due to the characters not having much development at all. They were given interesting slice of life conflicts to grow and develop, and the character interactions were interesting as well as we saw the characters grow and develop.

Since the mane 5 are already friends, it makes the character interactions feel dull and pointless.

>>28823197
>EG being cannon
wew

>>28824272
season is not constricted by the same structure as a film. season 1 was 520 minutes

>>28824272
>it makes the character interactions feel dull and pointless.
How?

>>28824318
Of course it's not a cannon that doesn't even make sense
It's canon to FiM, though

>>28824318
>cannon
canon

>>28824348
The interactions themselves seem like they go through the motions. It seems like they have nearly the minimum that defines each character as what they are and they just...do what teenagers do. There isn't anything inherently interesting about building a dock, but with interesting characters or an interesting plot centered around it there could be, but EQG lacks either of those things.

>>28824350
afraid you've got that wrong friend

EQG is not canon to FiM, but FiM is canon to EQG

>>28824394
No, lad
You've been wrong about that for over three years and your butthurt won't change it

File: banner_913.jpg (42KB, 600x240px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 600x240px

>>28824391
What did you think of w.i.t.c.h ?

>>28824391
>interesting character
>interesting plot
It's subjective
Clearly it wasn't interesting to (You) but it was to other people
Maybe you should just stop watching EqG if you hate it

>>28824411
I didn't see much of it at all, but what I did see seemed to be somewhat interesting. They may have been dull characters, but they were generally doing way more interesting things.

>>28823197
The fact that you could take away FiM and EG would loose any coherency and be completely unable to stand on its own merits indicates it(EG) is the inferior product.

>>28824447
it was a 10/10 show.

>>28824318
First,
>cannon
At least try when you shitpost
Second, why would that even matter in this discussion?

>>28824449
>unable to stand on its own merits
The characters would come off as more underdeveloped but half the movies would still be able to stand on their own

>>28824449
>The fact that you could take away Star Wars and Knights of the Old Republic would lose any coherency and be completely unable to stand on its own merits indicates that it (Knights of the Old Republic) is the inferior product.

>>28824453
And I just praised it, even skipping around some episodes on Youtube still shows more entertaining conflicts than what I saw in Legend of Everfree.

>>28824468
...yes?

>>28824449
They should build on its own world rather than relying on Equestria.

>>28824468
But Knights of the Old Republic takes place in the same world as the mainline Star Wars franchise.

>>28824468
Knights of the Old Republic is meant to be expanded universe material.
Equestria Girls is closer to being Mega Man Star Force, which can survive on its own.

>>28823197
Never. You can pry FiM from my cold dead hands, keep EQG to yourself faggot

>>28824482
EqG also uses settings in the same world as FiM
What is your point

>>28824500
But EQG explicitly takes place in a different world than FIM, that's kind of the whole point.

>>28824468
What? Knights can stand on its own
>>28824482
>as the mainline Star Wars franchise.
not anymore
>>28824482
>They should build on its own world rather than relying on Equestria.
like what? would you tune in for a random show about high school girls that do magic? every show of this type had to tap existing lore. This is not even a tv show, its just few movies, would you randomly pick up 4 movies?

>>28824498
No, it's inherently linked to FiM
That's why it starts in Equestria and uses characters who are ponies.
>>28824516
>explicitly
Except when it doesn't

>>28824526
I mean if they do decide to have their own TV show they should start making their own world more interesting rather than relying on magic for every extraordinary conflict.

>>28824526
So can Equestria Girls
It sets up everything that you need to know about the pony world and then introduces its characters all over again like in FiM's pilot
You don't need to watch the show to know anything

>>28824466
I meant that if the initial elements from FiM were removed, EG would be reduced to nothing whatsoever. EG by its nature cannot even exist on its own.

It would be a collection of disjointed highschool drama with no driving force or direction. Like a bad 90's animated sitcom.

>>28824470
it has 52 eps and Everfree is almost the worst EqG movie. conflict is more about an amish girl who somehow got into debit and can't move on from the camp, its ok but its also in no way contacted to the main group

>>28824533
Friendship Games and especially Legend of Everfree take place entirely in the Mirror World.

>>28824559
>disjointed highschool drama
You don't know what highschool drama is
The plot has always revolved around magical forces, not highschool

>>28824551
friendship games was about school revelry and difference between co workers and friends. magic was more of a metaphor used to speed things up, nothing was done that could not have been done with mortal hands

>>28824567
That's irrelevant

>>28824559
It could if the writers would get creative with it. There are like 80 different shows about high school students dealing with supernatural threats in their town, EQG could just be like any of them.

>>28824585
Except that Twilight turned into a fucking demon and was going to destroy the universe

>>28824559
>remove everything from monster high that makes it monster high
>you will have mediocrity
no shit sherlock. also they could use none horse related magic thus it would be mostly the same, a wolf could be a school mascot

>>28824585
But the conflict of the Friendship Games had no stakes held to it.

File: Sunset_writing_a_friendship_report_to_Princess_Twilight_EG2.png (491KB, 1280x714px) Image search: [Google]

491KB, 1280x714px

>>28824567
It still has this sexy link to Equestria

>>28824602
Not really, Monster High takes place in an explicitly fantastical world. It is not the same as just not having a portal exist.

File: Shamwow disdain.png (51KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 500x500px

>>28824605
>Twilight was going to literally destroy the world
>no stakes

>>28824573
there would be no magic force, because nothing from FiM would be present. To put said magic force in universe would require completely rewriting the the entire setting, to the point you would have a completely different product.

EG relies on piggybacking on FiM's setting. It has no reason to even exist on its own.

That's not to say there's anything wrong with that, just that it makes EG, as originally stated, inferior to the original.

>>28824619
I was explicitly referring to the Friendship Games themselves, the characters have nothing at stake for losing it.

>>28824596
not really, its all razzle dazzle to make things more visually pleasing. you could have had her being pushed into cheating, freaking out and being talked down by a new friend, no magic required. same plot can be had without magic or songs, it just won't be fun to watch

>>28824633
Yeah, they said how the point of the games was to strengthen the companionship between the schools. It wasnt meant to have stakes.
The actual games was just an event to spark the plot into motion of Scitwi trying to understand magic and Sunset trying to control it.

>>28824633
Okay
Did the characters have anything at stake for losing the battle of the bands if the Dazzlings weren't actually hypnotic fish people or for Sunset becoming princess of the Fall Formal if she wasn't actually an evil pony?
It's never ever been about the event, but the antagonist using the event

>>28824627
Equestria Girls could easily just introduce everything else that's supernatural, but magic. You don't even really need to cheat to make the same kind of plots without magic.

>>28824618
so world of technicolored people that has dirt biking as an event for underaged kids is not
fantastical?
>Monster High takes place in an explicitly fantastical world
if you turn every monster into a human with no magic what fantastical aspect would be left? if MH or ever after did not have the fairy tail lore to back it, what would it be about? of course you would have drop in quality and interest

>>28824636
Except everything that Twilight did in that movie was about studying magic
You'd have to remove everything that she and Sunset did to make that work.

>>28824645
Then the entire first act of the film is pointless outside of SciTwi, there is even a musical number meant to make us care about an event that has no stakes tied to it.

>>28824647
But the characters already knew from the start that there was an evil force running it and they had to stop it.

>>28824605
>not everything has to be about world destroying magic
>boo school pride, peer pressure, struggle with reformation are boring. bring me stakes
make up your mind

>>28824672
And Sunset knew from the start that Twilight was fucking with magic and tried to stop her

>>28824666
Not really, especially not compared to shows like Weird Science or Danny Phantom. And Monster High has genies, aliens, and ghosts native to their world.

>>28824633
except last shred of their self worth. They always lose so they once again got hyped up, in hopes it would be different. sometimes losing sucks even if they don't shut down the rec center (or whatever you think counts as stakes)

>>28824680
But that was mostly unrelated to the conflict of winning the Friendship Games.

>>28824672
>Then the entire first act of the film is pointless outside of SciTwi, there is even a musical number meant to make us care about an event that has no stakes tied to it.
In the first draft, the beginning of the movie was originally about Sunset having a meeting with pony twi at a diner and Sunset was talking about her internal conflict of where her true home is. Hasbro made them scrap it and now you're right. RDs song was completely arbitrary but it was pretty catchy.

>>28824670
or you could switch it to technology, maybe even sports. like maybe everyone had a unique training program they busted out for this event and she wanted to know its secrets (maybe it was drugs)

>>28824696
Or they could just not care about winning or losing and just have fun. Like what Buckball Season had as its moral.

>>28824656
This, FIM did not invent magic

>>28824700
Are you sure that whole conflict of "b-b-but they'll make fun of us if we lose" was not in the first draft?

File: shiggy dahling.png (91KB, 400x511px) Image search: [Google]

91KB, 400x511px

>>28824697
>a movie can't have two conflicts that intertwine

>>28824672
>there is even a musical number meant to make us care about an event that has no stakes tied to it
can you not care unless someones grandma is dying and their last wish is to win the big game? can't you get pumped and dare I say even recall stuff from your own youth?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dVK168-qxTM

>>28824725
But there was no decent motivation for the mane 7 to win the Friendship Games.

Only Sci-Twi had a decent motivation to win.

>>28824735
The other school treated all of them like shit and vandalized their school for years
Is that not enough motivation to want to push their shit in?

>>28824723
Not that I remember

>>28824732
But now you are changing the stakes, anyway I never got that worked up over something with so little stakes at that age. I was basically a Crystal Prep student and I was more concerned with getting good grades and debate class than any of these stupid events.

>>28824748
When did the other school vandalize their stuff, the Crystal Prep students and Canterlot High students were pretty friendly with each other during the pre-games party.

>>28824711
That is garbage moral that breeds the "we are all winners" mentality. you can play for fun in your everyday life but for competitions you got to get your shit together

>>28824773
If it is a competition you care about or if there are actual stakes then sure. What were the stakes in losing the Friendship Games?

>>28824769
Did you not watch the beginning with the m6 in the library?

>>28824756
so? characters are not literally you so they suck? its a kids movie, you can't have everyone be a cynical snob. I mean have you seen anyone ever get hyped for a camp the same way they got hyped for everfree?I think not but there is still something sweet about such enthusiasm

>>28824782
I may not remember, please remind me now they vandalized the school.

>>28824769
>When did the other school vandalize their stuff
>Pretty friendly
DYEWTM?

>>28824796
RD showed pics of how they vandalized the statue in various ways in past years.

>>28824735
Have you never competed in anything, autist? If someone beat you at everything you did wouldn't you try extra hard at trying to beat them?

>>28824780
>If it is a competition you care about or if there are actual stakes then sure.
are you are robot? have you never gotten fired up playing backgammon or basically any video game? What are the stakes of you losing there? people are sick of stakes in such plots, it just guarantees a win or some out of the left filed change that often would not be legal in the real world

File: YP-1BR-EQGFG.mkv_snapshot_00.07.15_[2016.11.06_18.28.04].jpg (156KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

156KB, 1920x1080px

>>28824796
Dash went on and on about how Crystal Prep treated them all like trash

>>28824794
But they don't want to win because they enjoy the event, they want to win because they don't want someone else calling them names.

>>28824803
They had a dance party together before the games.

>>28824820
I think when you play something you should try to win, but you shouldn't play something just to win.

>>28824735
no Sci-Twi had a cartoonish motivation of being blackmailed

>>28824843
>They had a dance party together before the games
That was mandatory and where the M6 and Shadowbolts trash talked each other

>>28824843
>But they don't want to win because they enjoy the event, they want to win because they don't want someone else calling them names.
or, or it was both and that is why they picked events they liked
>They had a dance party together before the games.
a mandated party that was awkward as fuck and no one was mingling. The only attempt to foster friendship was crushed
>I think when you play something you should try to win, but you shouldn't play something just to win.
psychology does not work like that. If it did we would not have sunk cost fallacy

>>28824843
>They had a dance party together before the games
And tensions were hella high at it. That's why Ponks brought out the cannons.

Why do we fight?

>>28824958
for luna also one guy is just pushing his mediocre bait

>>28824958
Because people think that you can't like both at the same time and want to have a shitpost war

>>28823197
EQG is pretty boring desu, aside from Equestria Girls.

>>28823280
>Season 6 is bad meme
lol

File: tmp_11770-1478201591401-73416025.png (90KB, 238x276px) Image search: [Google]

90KB, 238x276px

>>28823197

>shilling EQG
Things have been pretty dead on the shimmernigger circlejerks eh?
Even a disgrace as Starlight is always rated above EQG crap on polls

>>28825028
0/10

>>28825039
>Hasbro shill
Opinion discarded

>>28823197
Diet Winx Club?

No thanks.

>>28824822
I care more about the competition than how much my opponent sucks.

>>28824780
The problem wasn't that there weren't any stakes, it is that they tried to set up stakes that were laughable. Had the movie focused more on the Friendship Games than making Crystal Prep into some engineered evil society, then it would have turned out better.

>>28823197
Too much focus on magic which makes it feel like a diluted FIM.

File: Capture.jpg (38KB, 995x406px) Image search: [Google]

38KB, 995x406px

>>28825078
Well now that's just not true.

File: 1463846887160.jpg (72KB, 628x414px) Image search: [Google]

72KB, 628x414px

>>28825166
>Too much focus on magic
>Implying you can have too much focus on magic

File: 1477125070273.png (26KB, 327x850px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 327x850px

>>28825168
Here's the freshest one

File: firefox_2016-09-24_20-34-02.jpg (199KB, 919x1290px) Image search: [Google]

199KB, 919x1290px

>>28825166
Yeah, magic currently looks and acts the same way it does in Equestria, but robots are something the EQG world could have that Equestria doesn't.

>>28825197
Damn, I knew they wanted her but not this much. Does Hasbro understand how high the ratings will be if they give her a cameo?

>>28825218
They don't want to render the show canon to EQG, or deal with the idiots asking why she won't return to Equestria.

>>28825218
after the Flash debacle there'll never be another EQG reference again

>>28825225
>They don't want to render the show canon to EQG
Why not? What harm will giving her a cameo do?

>>28825230
Except when there was one in the S6 finale, you dummyhead

File: 1470019018120.png (83KB, 493x300px) Image search: [Google]

83KB, 493x300px

>>28825230
Flash is much different. People hated Flash with a passion. People love Sunset.

>>28825235
A massive shitstorm of people who can no longer state EQG as non-canon

>>28825245
Cool
Why is that a bad thing again?

>>28823287
Good day redditfag

>>28825245
Fuck em

>>28825253
>>28825264
People might boycott Hasbro products, or be confused since they never watched EQG.

>>28825273
>People might boycott Hasbro products
No they won't.
They're not gonna stop buying their shitnover one episode they don't like. If that was true, everyone would have stopped buying their crap after MMC

>>28825245
>>28825253
>>28825258
>>28825264
>>28825273
>>28825243
EqG is still garbage. We should have had Guardians of Harmony as our first and only spinoff, with Berrow as the story editor.

But no, pretend that your dicks get hard from these weird alien "humans."

File: 1469831699415.png (413KB, 800x450px) Image search: [Google]

413KB, 800x450px

>>28825285
pretend that your dicks get hard from these weird alien "ponies."

File: Shimmer Shimmy.gif (2MB, 428x535px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 428x535px

>>28825273
>People might boycott Hasbro products
My fucking sides
A tiny fraction of manchildren from an anonymous imageboard wouldn't even show up as a blip on Hasbro's radar
>>28825285
>Pretend

File: 1478442664382.jpg (35KB, 668x960px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 668x960px

>>28825285
>Pretend

>>28825311
>>28825321
Proportion does not work that way. Humans look like shit and are unsexy when they have incorrect proportions.

>>28825302
It's different with animals.

>>28825285
Anon we've all been pretending for six years
The whole board never liked ponies; it's just an ironic meme
Don't tell me you actually fell for it

File: 1469179472949.gif (1MB, 480x358px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 480x358px

>>28825328
>Humans look like shit and are unsexy when they have incorrect proportions.
>It's different with animals

File: Marie_and_DD_by_14_bis.jpg (82KB, 850x567px) Image search: [Google]

82KB, 850x567px

>>28825328
>Humans look like shit and are unsexy when they have incorrect proportions
My years of looking at cartoon girls says the exact opposite
Keep your shitty 3d garbage

>>28825367
I guess Kora Kosicka didn't know how to draw human proportions/was forced by Hasbro to make these ugly Barbie doll things. That's fine. Only incorrect proportions are bad.

>>28825206
That would be pretty fun.

File: 1456016201969.jpg (45KB, 375x375px) Image search: [Google]

45KB, 375x375px

>>28823197

How about you get your own board, then?

>>28825379
I want you to understand that you have the single most shit opinion on this board.

>>28825328
>when they have incorrect proportions.
kek. most hentai has wrong proportions. They have to photoshop proportions because natural proportions maybe hot but unnatural can be extra hot

File: 1451889207948.gif (338KB, 538x572px) Image search: [Google]

338KB, 538x572px

>>28823197
>eqgfags don't even get movies anymore

>>28825379
She drew several designs, Hasbro picked the design you see now.

>>28825384
Yeah, ask Hiro if he can make another board for autists. He will TOTALLY comply.

>>28825379
Have you never watched a single cartoon in your life you dumb nigger?
Nearly all of them have incorrect proportions because it's a fucking cartoon

File: ishygddt.jpg (134KB, 460x345px) Image search: [Google]

134KB, 460x345px

>>28825335
If someone where to legitimately browse this fucking board for the past 6 years just to go along with an iconic meme, that'd be the most autistic thing, period.

I would like the films to become more comedy and action packed.

>>28825390
We will in 2018
Hasbro didn't want to have two pony movies in the same year

>>28825389
No. Unnatural is fucking creepy. Have even a intro-level college art course tier level knowledge of the way human anatomy is drawn on a page and you can't see anything but horror.

Even doing cartooning has strict rules that EqG breaks.

>>28825399
Yeah, but they follow strict rules of cartooning and don't have this weird "cartoonish, but not" middle ground that just looks ugly.

>>28825419
One movie makes no money. They make more money with these 22 minute specials so they can just make a fuckload of DVDs and Blu-Rays. They can have seven total EqG DVDs next year versus four. EqG was always about quantity over quality. Even with things like Minis. They just keep pumping out waves with minimal improvement.

>>28825431
Kora Kosicka get anatomy, Hasbro decided on the design you see here.

IIRC the first design she recommended was closer to the EQG minis.

>>28825431
>cartoonish, but not
EqG is clearly cartoonish what the fuck are you talking about you dumbshit
>One movie makes no money. They make more money with these 22 minute specials so they can just make a fuckload of DVDs and Blu-Rays. They can have seven total EqG DVDs next year versus four. EqG was always about quantity over quality. Even with things like Minis. They just keep pumping out waves with minimal improvement.
Literally pulled straight from your ass with no possible citation

>>28825328
>Humans look like shit and are unsexy when they have incorrect proportions.
I guess that's why nobody likes anime.
Jesus christ you are retarded.

>>28825440
You mean the ones designed by Amy Mebberson? I've seen the behind the scenes for EqG. Kosicka was always drawing those Barbie horrors.

>>28825446
Why in the fuck else would they make three separate specials? It's just to sell DVDs, man.

>>28825447
Plebeians who like broken backs and chests that couldn't hold any organs sure do get a lot of content made for them, eh?

>>28825456
>Why in the fuck else would they make three separate specials? It's just to sell DVDs, man.
So that they do something related to EqG this year, dumbass
And where was it ever said that they were coming out on DVD?

>>28825397

That's not my/our issue. Anthro fags can go to >>>/trash/. They are very welcomed there.

>>28825472
Yes, and instead they could have made one movie and released one DVD. Now they have three specials and can make three of them.

That's how they make their money, selling DVDs and Blu-Rays. This lets them sell more.

>>28825483
>human is anthro
ebbin meme

>>28825483
You should take your ponies there then, since they are anthro, while the humans are not, your opinion belongs in the trash too so you fit right in.

>>28825501
Ponied up humans are anthro.

I'm curious how purely slice of life EQG story will be like, since most of the films require a magic battle at the end.

>>28825486
Hasbro wants to market the pony movie you dumbass
Another pony movie coming out the same year would require more resources
And releasing one DVD per short would be contrary to everything that we've seen them do in terms of pony marketing
They're going to TV first and if there even is a DVD it would be with them all together on it

>>28825502
How so?

>>28825502
Catgirls are not anthro so girls with horse ears aren't either

>>28825508
The three specials are basically the length of one standard EqG movie. They're splitting these up so they can spread out the money they get over the course of the year and so it can't compete with the FiM movie.

>>28825514
>Implying Catgirls aren't anthro

How are they not? They have a non-human characteristic on a human body. This was always retarded.

>>28825522
>The three specials are basically the length of one standard EqG movie. They're splitting these up so they can spread out the money they get over the course of the year and so it can't compete with the FiM movie.
You have literally no evidence to support this
All other pony dvds consist of multiple episodes

>>28825535
Other than how Monster High does their stuff, no. But all EqG does is copy what Monster High does, so it's a fair bet to make. Yes, even the Minis were ripped off from Monster High.

>>28825243
When in the S6 finale

>>28825554
When Trixie was dreaming about Celestia paying her in peanut butter crackers

>>28825486
They wouldn't release DVDs that only have one 22 short on it dipshit

>>28825168
>>28825197
>using a poll run by autist to bigger autist as any kind of proof
Yeah, transformers 4 was great too because it made people go to the cinema

File: at least they're show accurate, but they are not posable.jpg (443KB, 3000x1688px) Image search: [Google]

443KB, 3000x1688px

>>28825550
meh, I prefer EqG over MH, but MH is interesting in of itself

>>28825285

Seconded

>>28825625
>Anon says Starlight does better than EqG on polls
>posts polls where the majority votes are for something EqG related over Starlight
>hurr polls don't mean anything

>>28825649

/mlp/ polls, not shit eaters poll
I can run a poll on /b/ and 75% will vote fuck mlp
Does that mean mlp is shit?

>>28825672
>polls confined to my sekret circlejerk club are the only ones that matter; the actual majority doesn't count
wew laddie

File: 1220293__safe_twilight+sparkle_equestria+girls_screencap_animated_edit_human+twilight_spoiler-colon-legend+of+everfree_eyebrow+wiggle_timber+spruce.gif (88KB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]

88KB, 640x360px

>>28825285
>pretend that your dicks get hard from these weird alien "humans."

EqG humanoids evolved from a common ancestor of the equine, the Hyracotherium
over time, they no longer needed hair all over their bodies and the pigmentation that went into the hair/fur coats is now the melanin in their skin
they also have slight ponuts and able to wink their "horsepussy"
https://derpibooru.org/1074056
and
https://derpibooru.org/1278948
males still have the ability to flare a bit just before orgasm

the reason why they have stripes of color in their hair is from a genetic mutation of Poliosis, which normally is a lack of melanin or pigmentation
in FiM and EqG universes, it actually carries recessive colors based on the dominant color(s) in the genes, this is why you never come across OC tier coloring in either universes

>>28825700
Why are you even here?
Go suck seth's dick already

File: 1447631611040.png (497KB, 1000x800px) Image search: [Google]

497KB, 1000x800px

I swear it's the same 5 autists arguing over nothing every time a fim > eqg >fim bait thread pops up, and it stopped being entertaining a looooong time ago.

>>28825727
It'd be better if you fucking EqGniggers were banned like you should have been in 2013

>>28825732
it's amusing that the hate you spew at EqG is the same hate YOU got before mlp got banned from 4chan

>>28825755
are we supposed to sympathize? I don't care if everyone else hates us, I hate you. And need I remind you that pony is banned everywhere else

File: You are (You)'d get in there.jpg (53KB, 500x456px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 500x456px

>>28825732

>>28825705
ew ew ew ew ew ew ew

>>28823197
well, i could decide if I'd watch it

which I won't since the stylized human forms look ugly imo, I don't like em

File: What does the movie title say.jpg (99KB, 720x1080px) Image search: [Google]

99KB, 720x1080px

>>28825774
>And need I remind you that pony is banned everywhere else

>>28825635
its ok but the slang kills me. especially whenever draculaura talks about music

>>28825815
Don't feed this raging autist more (You)s cmon.

>>28825635
>meh, I prefer EqG over MH, but MH is interesting in of itself
Is it? Never seen it. Also the design of the rightmost one looks horrendous.

>>28825774
Fuck, thats a clever comment

>>28825776
you spelled "hot as fuck" wrong

>>28825825
I liked her early-on voice, before they went to 3D
at least FiM only has a few pony related words (barring city names) such as everypony

>>28825841
idk the name, but I think she's the daughter of the thing from the black lagoon or some mer-creature
she looks like their worlds Derpy

I think an EQG series would be great if it became a slice of life/monster hunter series.

>>28823454
Yet.

>>28825916
That would be pretty great.

>>28825841
lagoona has a cute australian accent and criminally little screen time. The movies are mostly garbage. episodes are shot 5 minute things
opening is catchy as fuck
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nGawAhRjtoA
here is an extended version (ignore the live action people)

File: 1473028808885.jpg (69KB, 626x930px) Image search: [Google]

69KB, 626x930px

>>28826146
Damn that IS catchy.

has anyone asked ishi if the Dazzlings are the only "bad guys" that were banished to the EqG universe?
will we ever find out what happened to HUMAN Sunset?

>>28826339
They won't talk about stuff that might happen in the future. Ishi answers those questions with a zipped mouth emoticon.

>>28826339
I hope not, I want more original villains.

File: what_s_eating_sunset_shimmer__by_daniel_sg-d9470na.png (2MB, 1100x2595px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1100x2595px

>>28826339
>HUMAN Sunset

EQG is boring unlike FIM.

>>28826852
Every film except Rainbow Rocks really.

>>28826870
Except Rainbow Rocks and Friendship Games and Legend of Everfree you mean

>>28826880
Oh no Legend of Everfree was definitely boring.

>>28826882
Maybe for (You)

>>28826880
They are all boring except for Rainbow Rocks.

File: 1463236824206.png (327KB, 495x498px) Image search: [Google]

327KB, 495x498px

>>28826880
>Friendship Games and Legend of Everfree

>>28826880
Rainbow Rocks is the only decent one.

>>28826898
Yes because spending half the film building a dock and blushing around Timber Spruce is so exhilarating.

>>28826880
Friendship Games and Legend of Everfree are the epitome of boring.

LoE was just to set up for the EG show

>>28826969
doesn't excuse it from being boring shit

>>28826969
All we are getting is three specials.

>>28826979
>I don't like slice of life

>implying anything was good after s2

>>28826987
For EQG most of the slice of life isn't very good.

>>28826987
slice of life done wrong gets you shit like Applejack's Day Off

>>28827002
Yup

>>28825501
U wot mate. The "hoomans" are the most anthro. They're fully anthropomorphic!

>>28825514
But EqG pony up isn't cat girl. Did you know people have gotten warnings over ponied up fanart here for posting anthro?
Plus consider that a lot of places do, in fact, consider it anthro.
The MLP wiki labels it as anthro
TVTropes refers to ponied up form as anthroponies
KYM labels it as anthro
You can get warnings here for that fan art

The thing that separates it from cat girls is the fact that cat girls do not have a cat's coloration. Imagine if cat girls were the same color as a cat, I bet it would move it to the anthro territory. Ponied up by contrast has pony coloration and the style of the characters is pretty similar to the show's art style. The only people here that bitch about is the muzzle = anthro crowd. They'll say these things as Shepard's art which has the characters with actual hooves but to them a human face deters from this. But not for most people.

>>28823197

You have angered very powerful people. Everybody knows Starlight is better. Everybody except the people who make the show

>>28827052
No
Starlight is trash

>>28825168

Oh, if only you knew that graphs mean nothing. Just like everything taught in school, it never applies to real life

File: 1246053__safe_pinkie+pie_humanized_equestria+girls_magic_sunset+shimmer_eared+humanization_ponied+up_spoiler-colon-legend+of+everfree_legend+of+everfree.jpg (218KB, 1024x1280px) Image search: [Google]

218KB, 1024x1280px

>>28827040
pic related is canon, therefore it should be allowed on /mlp/ and should be exempt from the "anthro" rule

anthropomorphic by definition, is anything not an actual human (as in, not a living breathing human like you or me that is actually alive and in our reality, aka exists), but is given human traits and or characteristics
this means that everything from humanized to pony and even screen caps from the show, is "anthro"
this also means that all fictional characters everywhere are anthropomorphic

anthro (4chan's definition) is anything furry (usually bipedal animals with some mixture of other parts of human anatomy thrown in) an example of this in the ponyverse is Catrina and Iron Will (which should also be exempt from the "anthro" rule due to being canon) even Ember and spike is anthro

tl;dr
anything canon (to the show or movies) that would normally considered "anthro", should be exempt from the no anthro part of /mlp/ rule #5

Rule #5 should state something like: Canonized anthro is allowed (Cat Women, Minotaurs, Gryphons, Dragons, ponied up EqG, etc) - anything not canonized anthro, is not allowed

if mods allow Satyrs, Plane Ponies, Strange Waifu and Bat Ponies, ponied up pics of EqG is really the least of the boards problems

they need to either enforce the rules, or make it abundantly clear to what is and isn't "anthro" on /mlp/

File: tmp_4552-embarrassed-bunny-1274180368.jpg (42KB, 456x342px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 456x342px

>>28826880

To read your comment literally made me feel shivers
I like RR and LoE a bit but his is embarassing

>>28827897
it's how you know when someone has autism, son.

But FIM is better.

The EQG series is generally pretty boring.

File: 1478159474755.gif (354KB, 442x347px) Image search: [Google]

354KB, 442x347px

>>28823197
Infinity years because that'll never happen because it's not true

File: 1445302046384.jpg (80KB, 960x539px) Image search: [Google]

80KB, 960x539px

>>28823524
>I enjoy a good story
>High School Musical + Monster High + 70 minute long toy commercials + a story so cringy, predictable, and bland that I wanted to kill myself through all three movies
senpai pls

File: no greater pleasure.png (81KB, 355x426px) Image search: [Google]

81KB, 355x426px

>>28826921
What was Rainbow Rocks about again?
>pic unrelated

>>28830172
Saving a school from being fed upon by evil creatures from another world by winning a rock competition?

>>28830181
>by winning a rock competition?
no, they needed to make a counter-spell

>>28830202
No they didn't they just used a random song that Fluttershit wrote

>>28830202
Oh yeah.

>>28830210
that was because they realized it didn't matter what the song was about, as long as it came from the heart, it would be powered by their magic

Rainbow Rocks is the only good one of the series.

>>28830930
Friendship Games is better

>>28830930
>>28830938
Legend of Everfree is still the worst.

i've seen the first two (hey, fucking blame me, each hiatus is harder than the last) and saw a little of the third one during the end of mlp anniversary stream (i passed out shortly after it started). it seemed pretty solid.

>>28830947
No the first is objectively the worst movie and pony-related thing ever

>>28823197
Can't force people to get good taste OP.

Anyway EQG > FiM easily.

>>28830953
It had ponies in it and tried to have a sense of adventure, plus better songs.

>>28830967
It had no adventure at all because it was about literally nothing but high school and the songs were 100x more generic and poppy than all of the others
Every song in LoE is unique and sounds different from the others

>>28830953
at least it had ponies

>>28830976
It had ponies though and energetic songs.

>>28830982
>>28830994
Who cares when the pony scenes were fucking shit like the rest of the movie

>>28830999
There was a nice scene with Twilight and Spike at the beginning.

>>28830930
Friendship Games is too.

Equestria Girls and Legend of Everfree are just awful though.

Legend of Everfree was so massively boring. Why can't Hasbro let this series do anything interesting?

>>28831020
They want to play it as safe as possible, people will continue watching the films no matter how terrible they are.

Nearly anyone could write a better plot for an EQG film than what we currently got.

>>28831020
Hasbro is way more worried about this series doing well than FIM which already proved it is a massive success, ESPECIALLY since Friendship Games flopped.

Legend of Everfree is objectively the worst because it's the only one that didn't have any pony scenes.

>>28831455
>watching EqG for the ponies

>>28824171
>Mane group is not the one she has to make amends to
You do remember that she held them against their will and stole their innate magic abilities and personalities, right? Also,
>its not evil in her eyes
Please go back to /pol/

File: 1474740061783.png (110KB, 439x270px) Image search: [Google]

110KB, 439x270px

>>28825705
Really don't know what to say here.

starlight was Hasbro's answer for autists whining about Sunset possibly showing up in FiM, making EqG canon

>>28834759
that it's hot?

what do you think the EqG specials will be about?

boop

>>28839378
Hardcore lesbian sex between Ponks and Sunny.

EqG is bad.

>>28841812
>EqG is good.
FTFY

>>28841824
Wrong.

>>28841847
>Right
wow your auto correct sucks, Anon. it keeps having you post the wrong text

EQG is boring.

>>28842108
>EQG is amazing
FTFY
Your autocorrect must be on the fritz today.

>>28823197
LOE ruined that chance for me.

What a load of boring drivel, now with Trump as president we can get these things thrown out.

>>28842165
Only newfags hate SoL

>>28842165
>I don't like Slice of life
it was cute and comfy

>>28842173
Not when I don't care about half the cast due to a lack of characterization.

>>28842191
Don't forget most of the character interactions lacking conflict or just not being as dynamic as the show's.

>>28842191
>I don't care about the cast of the show
Then why are you here?

File: wall.png (1MB, 1024x576px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1024x576px

I can finally use this.

>>28842211
>supporting Trump, the dump

>>28842222
I am more optimistic now. As long as he gets rid of ISIS it will be okay.

>>28842210
EQG cast =/= FiM cast

>>28842210
They aren't the same as the cast of the show despite looking and sounding similar.

>>28842253
there will always be "terrorists" as long as there are at least 2 people on this planet

>>28842210
EQG cast is not the same cast as the show.

File: 1474889984728.jpg (43KB, 481x600px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 481x600px

>>28839378
pic related

>>28842382
that was LoE, we need something new

File: 1233208__safe_solo_sonata+dusk_siren_mermaid_artist-colon-themexicanpunisher.png (140KB, 522x380px) Image search: [Google]

140KB, 522x380px

>>28842391
How about fish pussy then?

>>28842282
>>28842305
>>28842360
They essentially are because they act exactly the same

>>28842409
They are overflandarized.

>>28842409
are you retarded

Never.

>>28843538
nice bump
We heard you the last 20 times