Find a flaw. Hint: Fucking everything about them.

>>28622443
How are we supposed to play if you already gave us the only right answer?

>>28622443
they're not canon lol

>>28622443
I don't get it

sunset shimmer and glim glam had more character development than Applejack, Rainbow dash or Pinkie pie.

>>28622499
You can't have a good building without a solid foundation.

File: dalema1.jpg (23KB, 432x288px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 432x288px

>>28622443
Another quality thread.

they exist

>>28622443
Each of them are both still more interesting and better written then each of the Mane 6 individually. That's the truth.

>>28622443
Sunset's colors are wrong

Sunset is awesome
Glimglam is okay I suppose I just wish they wouldn't try to make her Twilight 2.0 and appeal to some autistic faggots who miss the old Twilight (since they're not gonna like Glimglam anywat)

>>28622629
>Twilight 2.0
You mean Twilight 3.0

>>28622643
Trixie was Twilight 2.0
Sunset was Twilight 3.0
Moondancer was Twilight 4.0
Starlight is Twilight 5.0
Scilight was twilight 6.0

>>28622693
>Moondancer was Twilight 4.0
nah she is just twilight with some paint on it

>>28622693
Funny because Trixie, Sunset, Moondancer, and Starlight are only called twilight clones because they have something to do with magic and are female unicorns. None of them are close to being clones of each other and they each have a distinct personality.

This meme has to stop, along with the "season 2 is good" meme.

>>28622443
every character trope has been done
it's about combining elements together to make the character unique in their own way
which the show and movies, have done
if you understood this, you wouldn't have made this thread

>>28622715
Trixie isn't anywhere near a twilight clone you retard. Moondancer is just a recolor. Starlight on the other hand is sociopath Twilight on steroids, character and all.

File: 32482fa8af19b087b210cdc8afff5e39.png (435KB, 828x793px) Image search: [Google]

435KB, 828x793px

>>28622443
>that image
I seem to have misplaced all my fucks to give OP.

>>28622715
>This meme has to stop, along with the "season 2 is good" meme.
did it ruin your headcanons about luna being fluttershy 2.0 or something

>>28622715
>Sunset
Celestia's protege, studied magic, and is good with magic

>Moondancer
Social shut in, studied magic, went to Celestia School of Magic, Spike even said that Twilight could've ended up like Moondancer, is a recolor of Twilight with glasses and a different butt mark.

>Starlight
Social shut in to the point that she doesn't even have the word friendship in her vocabulary, really good at magic, after losing/joining Twilight she does nothing but studies magic.

A clone isn't 100% anon, that's why when a cartoon has a 1001 clones episode, all the clones are a little different from each other, but still have enough in common with the original to be called a clone. And the only one who doesn't fit that bill is Trixie

File: tfw your post.png (7KB, 723x192px) Image search: [Google]

7KB, 723x192px

>>28622777
>those digits
Those should be pony-related digits.

File: large.png (1MB, 1260x1024px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1260x1024px

>>28622837
To bad

File: Chara_Render_By_Skodwarde.png (212KB, 476x656px) Image search: [Google]

212KB, 476x656px

>>28622837
but the season finale teaches us the same lesson as undertale does
it's important to spread love

>>28622872
>implying
The message of Undertale is that humans are the master race and if we let bleeding heart liberals take over our country they'll let dangerous war criminals with a thirst for vengeance live amongst us. It's showing us the dystopian future that will occur if we don't vote Trump.

>>28622798
>Sunset
Hellbent on getting what she wants when she wants it. Negative view towards friendship and any positive emotions experience by others. No fucking care for anyone who wasn't her.
>Reformed:
Tries her best to make friends with everyone. Relaxed personality. Not uptight or nerdy.

>Moondancer
Lonely "I want no friends" loser mentality. Doesn't like being around anyone. Keeps to herself and herself only.

>Starlight
Sociopath who wants to live in the perfect utopian society where no one is special. In order to fulfill her agenda she steals other cutie marks and has them suffer from some sort of depression, caring not for what they want, but only for how she wants them to behave.
>Reformed:
Socially awkward ptsd infested nutcase who doesn't understand the difference between friendhsip and effectiveness.


None of them are like Twilight at all. Maybe there's a case for Moondancer, but Sunset and Starlight? The two evil bitches who cared for nothing aside from pleasuring themselves because something was "stolen" from them?

Anyone who says they are Twilight clones has never seen the show before or are just memeing. They aren't clones in the slightest, they are vastly different.

>>28622914
So is evil Jimmy from Jimmy Neutron not Jimmy because he's evil? Is Goku Black not Goku because he's evil? I could keep going, but I hope I don't have to. And Like I said A clone isn't a complete one to one. All a clone needs is a similar bases to the original, how they act, or what they want is, or how they go about life is irrelevant.

>>28622914
Take twilight, make her an evil bitch for stupid reasons, and you have Sunset/Starlight.

>>28622914
Sunset, Starlight, and Moondancer are all basically different takes on what Twilight could've become without friendship.

I agree that Starlight Glimmer is hardly unique. Yes she's good with magic and has a backstory but she lacks the special interests and ambitions the rest of the Main 6 have (Twilight - books, Fluttershy - animals, etc.).

I think a good idea for an episode would be them set up a house for her in Ponyville (does she still live in the castle?) so she can develop proper hobbies and ambitions beyond "magic" and "learning friendship".

>>28623075
Starlight is what you would call a control enthusiast. Her hobbies include controlling magic and controlling things with magic.

>>28622966
Then why imply that all clones are bad just for being clones?

no one had a problem with "Too Many Pinkies"

>>28623300
It was a clone ep, not a character
.

Sunset was just a Trixie clone. She's no better.

>>28622715
>along with the "season 2 is good" meme.
Wew freaking lad

>>28622778
It's really not all that good anon. Strip off the nostalgia goggles, it gave us a fuckload of episodes that can't even be defended when you strip out that it was a Faust season and the one most fags came in on.

Also, lets face it, there's a reason why nobody wants a goddamn /mlp/ written show, we have no fucking clue how to fucking write.

File: Dr._Ivo_Kintobor.jpg (585KB, 635x756px) Image search: [Google]

585KB, 635x756px

>>28623250
??? I never said all clones are bad, I just used evil ones to prove a point.

>>28623300
Because only one escaped the Pinkiecide, and she didn't even talk when we saw her.

>>28623355
No you may have never implied it, but the OP sure as fuck did.

>>28623355
>one escaped the Pinkiecide
I think that the rave pony with the binky was a pinkie clone in disguise

>>28622966
No, actually. Goku Black isn't a Goku clone. Nigga, Zamasu swapped bodies with Goku. They don't have the same mindset at all, their only relation is that they look the same, breath air, eat, and simple bullshit like that.

Evil Jimmy was literally a clone. The ponies listed are different beings entirely who share a few common interests.

>>28622972
And Applejack is a different take on what Twilight was if she was raised on a farm and never had magic.
That reasoning is fucking retarded.

>>28622968
>Take character A
>Make them look like character B
>Give them the personality and mindset of Character C
>Keep 1 or 2 traits from character A
>Somehow still a copy of character A.
Might as well say you are a clone copy of your dad or even your mom.

>>28623354
this season might've had some dull eps, but it had more great-tier episodes than any other one.
RoH, Lesson Zero, Sisterhooves Social, Hearth's Warming Eve, A Friend In Deed, Putting Your Hoof Down, Hurricane Fluttershy

File: 1465318086454.png (2KB, 380x380px) Image search: [Google]

2KB, 380x380px

>>28622872
>love
*Still just you, frisk

>>28623542
And that's pretty much every season. it's not good, it's not bad, it's just average.

And hell I can find faults (some heavy) for each of those episodes (Okay not Sisterhooves Social, that was a gem), some within said episode, some with the longer lasting impact they had.

>>28622872
>>28623568
Chara, no. You should spread love, not LoVE

File: Blog_Scourge.jpg (94KB, 300x415px) Image search: [Google]

94KB, 300x415px

>>28623381
>They don't have the same mindset at all
>They both like to fight strong opponents
>They'll both hold back to prolong the fight
>They both like fighting in general
>These traits were apart of Zamasu before he even took over Goku's body
>People call him Goku Black because he acts like a evil version of Goku
But since you won't accept Goku Black, Turtles

>Evil Jimmy was literally a clone
And your original defense was they are not clones because they're evil, so I gave you some evil clones, and by that logic, this isn't a clone of Sonic.

>>28623633
>>28623381
Don't conflate definitions. Evil Jimmy is a literal clone (The same DNA or some such), but was he a figurative clone (sharing too many traits and an archetype) in the way people are going on about in this thread? Is Green Sonic a figurative clone as well as a literal clone?

>>28623680
Literal. Scourge was basically Evil Spock Sonic who then got juiced up by the master emerald.

>>28623680
Yes he is. The only difference between, them is they are from different dimensions, just like how Owlman and Batman are clones from different dimensions, and Superman and Superboy are clones, but act differently from each other.

>>28622499
>Pinkie Pie and Rainbow Dash are worse characters than GlimGlam and ShimSham
Shit b8 desu

>>28622567
And yet neither of them are anywhere near as entertaining.

>>28623300
I did.
I sure as fucking hell did.
Ironically, the best thing about the episode was Pinkie.
The resolution was basically the dumbest thing I've ever seen in the show. It seriously topped MMC, because it permanantly cemented Twilight as a drooling retard, which is a theme still prevailant to this day.

>>28623790
It cemented everybody as a drooling retard. Say what you will about Spike at Your Service (still the worst episode of the show) but that episode was a close second for worst of Season 3.

>>28622443
Shimmer is an overall better character than Glimmer just because Glimmer is a piece of fucking shit after she's been reformed.

Too bad Shimmer isn't canon. She even has prettier colors and hairdo.

>>28625020
But she is canon you memester

File: IMG_1796.jpg (58KB, 889x799px) Image search: [Google]

58KB, 889x799px

>>28622693
>Trixie is like twilight
Are you serious?

>>28625078
canon in the eqg universe
not canon in the MLP universe
Say what you want, you can't change the truth. Eqg as a whole isn't canon until it gets explicitly mentioned in one of the official episodes. Not even the writers and their twitters and facebooks can change that.

>>28625129
>EqG character appearing in FiM
>Characters behaving like they first did in EqG
It's canon m8, you can't deny it

>>28625150
Where? When?

>>28625020
>prettier colors
She's an eyesore.

File: 1266518__safe_solo_screencap_animated_trixie_food_starlight+glimmer_subtitles_to+where+and+back+again_spoiler-colon-s06e25.gif (2MB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 500x281px

>>28625158
>not watching the show
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hv8wjQ5GGNQ
>>28625167
you must be blind then

>>28625167
That's funny because that's the word I'd use to describe Glimmer.

Her fans are the fucking worst, though. They are even worse than Shimmerfags once been.

>>28625114
Glimmer/Shimmerfags have insane retarded logic and will spout nonsense like Trixie being a clone of Twilight.

File: fully autistic.png (177KB, 403x368px) Image search: [Google]

177KB, 403x368px

>>28625189
>Glimmerfags & Shimmerfags
>calling their waifu a Twilight clone

>>28625184
Trixie has a good color scheme. Sunset doesn't at all, she looks like condiments.

File: shrug.png (212KB, 1024x1024px) Image search: [Google]

212KB, 1024x1024px

>>28625205
What condiments?

>>28625184
>flash sentry
Is that seriously the only thing you've got? Wow, that's pathetic. For all we know, he existed way before eqg and just made an appearance after that. If Shimmer made a background show appearance, that would make her canon but not the entire movie until the eqg world or the events that took place there would be mentioned verbally or by a flashback.

File: o-BACON-BURGER-facebook.jpg (302KB, 1536x1041px) Image search: [Google]

302KB, 1536x1041px

>>28625241
stupid burger thinks bacon is a condiment

File: trixpone.png (92KB, 371x321px) Image search: [Google]

92KB, 371x321px

>>28625241
Take a look at the fuckin pone, this is how you do colors right.

>>28625247
> For all we know, he existed way before eqg and just made an appearance after that
Except that's not true because he was objectively made for EqG to be Twilight's shitty love interest
We never saw anything at all about him prior; if he was going to be in the show for another reason he would have at least had a toy

File: Sunburst does the thing.webm (156KB, 1120x666px) Image search: [Google]

156KB, 1120x666px

>>28625274
Do you also think Sunburst looks bad?
He has literally the same scheme just with two different shades of orange for his mane rather than red and light yellow.

>>28625277
You do realize weve only seen him twice outsude the movies, and he's literally less of a character than EqG, basically being a special guard character that has less lines than some one off joke characters,

File: NETS.jpg (431KB, 1600x1064px) Image search: [Google]

431KB, 1600x1064px

>>28625247

>>28622499
Well seeing as Sunset is only isolated to annual movies, she better be.

>>28625289
He looks better than ketchup and mustard shimmer.

>>28625297
You are moving the goal post just like >>28625298 points out

You said a mention of EqG content would make it canon yet now you've changed it to "oh but it has to be a specific KIND of mention defined by my arbitrary standards"

>>28625305
>ketchup and mustard
Lol where have you seen mustard that light in color lad?

>>28622798
>A clone isn't 100%
Uh...isn't that the definition of a clone? An exact copy?

>>28625325
We wish it was, but it isn't. For example, the first sheep ever cloned wasn't 100% copy of the original. It had it's genetic make up messed with to make it exist in the first place, the scientist even admit that it isn't a perfect clone, but it shares enough to be considered a clone so no one cares.

File: 71e45EN8PgL._SL1500_.jpg (44KB, 1500x1500px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 1500x1500px

>>28625318

File: 1464823104283.jpg (1MB, 3375x1650px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 3375x1650px

>>28625351
I don't see how that's an insult. Shes still cute too me. They all are.

File: Your snuggling only makes me stronger!.jpg (194KB, 1539x866px) Image search: [Google]

194KB, 1539x866px

>>28625351
I think you need your eyes adjusted
Her mane is clearly not mustard colored and if you see it depicted as such in fan art then it's wrong

File: Orange_Chicken_Skillet.jpg (168KB, 650x435px) Image search: [Google]

168KB, 650x435px

>>28625305
his hair looks like orange chicken and it's sauce

>>28625364
I've seen that Filename before.

File: Twiggy frown.png (225KB, 427x654px) Image search: [Google]

225KB, 427x654px

>>28625372
probably because I post in a lot of different threads

>>28625384
You were fucking with the light to see her real mane color

File: 213805-loc_cluckinbell.jpg (8KB, 250x170px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 250x170px

>>28625362
>>28625364
cluckity fuck, can I take your order?

>>28625299
well we get sunset 3 times next year

File: IMG_5674.png (36KB, 496x333px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 496x333px

>>28625310

File: medium.jpg (161KB, 800x457px) Image search: [Google]

161KB, 800x457px

>>28625426
Still cute
>>28625430
Fuck yes
>>28625439
Hilarious

>>28625310
Pointing out something that even Scilight vs Twilight should have pointed out to your retarded ass.

An EqG character showing up (or vice versa) isn't evidence, especially not in the case of Flash "Twily's Love Interest as a human, a nobody as a horse" Sentry, hell is that even actually Flash or a color scheme similar pony, because, y'know your evidence is never referred to by name.

File: grasping-at-straws.jpg (607KB, 648x881px) Image search: [Google]

607KB, 648x881px

>>28625526
You're an idiot of you think that wasn't the same Flash

File: 1475105489344.png (584KB, 506x718px) Image search: [Google]

584KB, 506x718px

>>28625526
>An EqG character showing up isn't evidence
So by your logic, if Sunset went on the show, it means she's not canon still?

>>28625551
Nothing past S2 is canon, so no.

>>28625568
ebbin

>>28625568
oh god not another one

>>28625581
>not knowing it's the same faggot every time

Sunset is never talked about or even mentioned on the show.

>>28625581
It's just someone joking around. Saying nothing past season 2 is canon is basic bait. A joke for most but g8 b8 for newfags

>>28625594
K, and?

>>28625608
She doesn't exist as far as the show is concerned. Nothing points to or even acknowledges her existence. We don't need another Twilight anyway.

>>28625540
Yes Flash comes and goes through the portal that's closed during both his tenures.

>>28625551
see
>>28625594
But for the hypothetical (not going to happen because Sunny came from Equestria-World to CHSWorld so no double) if she did it would be Sunset Shimmer, a pony who happens to have the same color scheme, and likely name, and has less spoken lines than DJ Pon-3.

I've always been of the mind that EqG Personality does not equal MLP personality.

Over on the human side Flash Sentry is a guitar playing stereotypical good bad boy. On the completely different Pony Double side, he's Guard #10233.

Basically Scilight fucked all the it's canon because Flash made two appearances, and one of them speaking a generic guard line arguments.

>>28625594
The events of Star Wars: The Clone Wars aren't mentioned in the movies.

>>28625621
>Over on the human side Flash Sentry is a guitar playing stereotypical good bad boy. On the completely different Pony Double side, he's Guard #10233.
Cause most stallions are drafted when they hit a certain age.

>>28625621
What does personality have to do with literally ANYTHING?
The pony appears first in EqG, making him an EqG character
Then he appears on the show, making him an EqG character on the show

File: 1468441052795.png (568KB, 1022x920px) Image search: [Google]

568KB, 1022x920px

>>28625658

>>28625658
He appears on the Equestria Side for one, as basically generic guard #10233. Twilight doesn't even acknowledge him, unlike in the movie, and everything basically points towards, making you faggots mad at somebody who has the same color scheme, but absolutely 0 connection.
Hell the first appearance post-EqG is supposedly something done by the Animators, which aren't even in house but outsourced.

>>28625679
He was first in EG, and later appeared in the show.
Canon.
Stop moving the fucking goal post

File: YP-1R-EQG.mkv_snapshot_00.01.38_[2016.10.10_17.56.26].jpg (171KB, 1904x1064px) Image search: [Google]

171KB, 1904x1064px

>>28625679
>the same color scheme
You mean exactly the same design?

File: download (6).jpg (6KB, 246x205px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 246x205px

>>28625568

I just love how much FiMfags move those goal posts
this whole thread is entertaining af

Flash is just another guard, nothing about the events of eqg had any effect on the show. Notice how flash didn't say a fucking word about it?

>>28625756
Notice how he was in the middle of doing his job?

>>28625762
Notice how he's never seen again?

>>28622443
while the role in the group is very similar, essentially they are two completely different characters with different personalities and backstory

but of course you wouldn't realize those very obvious things, because you just want something to bitch about

>>28625762
Notice how Twilight and Flash act like eqg never existed, or even hinted at it? There isn't a single word that was ever spoken on the show that even hints at eqg's existence.

>>28625767
Iron Will never appeared outside of Putting Your Hoof Down.
I guess that episode isn't canon.

>>28625777
See the gif I posted at >>28625184

>>28625769
They are Twilight if she was evil for dumb reasons. Don't pretend like they are anything more.

File: EQG.png (767KB, 1162x782px) Image search: [Google]

767KB, 1162x782px

>people still arguing about EQG canonicity

Jesus christ, you niggers, EQG is just a generic high school spin-off. The fact that no one reacts to Flash's presence only reinforces that the show and the movies are completely separate

>>28625797
tell that to shimmerfags

>>28625782
Nice hoop jumping anon, you should sign up for the circus. Oh and thanks for point out how insignificant Flash is by comparing him to a one off character.

File: Sandwich.gif (134KB, 480x480px) Image search: [Google]

134KB, 480x480px

>>28625792
Wow I must have missed the episode where everyone fucking hated Twilight and she had to defeat the Pillar Men to earn everyone's respect back.
And the time where Twilight experimented with a whole new breed of magic.
And the time where Twilight taught the whole m5 how to use magic.
And when she suddenly had a disinterest in reading as opposed to field research, could read minds, could play guitar, could do motorcross, used magic wings to fly, ect

>>28625698
Neat, a lighter that shows your reflection.

>>28625769
U wut m8?
Starlight role is much different.

>>28625668
got the gif of larson counting money?

>>28627313
I do not. I've actually been searching for that gif.

>>28625426
Don't choke on the bone fragments.

File: 1466308291423.gif (782KB, 635x343px) Image search: [Google]

782KB, 635x343px

>>28622443

>>28627515
Found the shimmer/glimmerfag

File: Slowpoke.png (125KB, 596x582px) Image search: [Google]

125KB, 596x582px

>>28627571
Forgot pic

File: well your mom.png (86KB, 500x276px) Image search: [Google]

86KB, 500x276px

>>28625837

File: 1443165927491.jpg (71KB, 501x576px) Image search: [Google]

71KB, 501x576px

>>28622887
Now now, those poor refugees just need some help. Them being the cause of skyrocketing crime rates and Sweden's downfall is just fact-founded lies and deciet. Open your heart, and open your doors go- friend.

>>28628940
>Implying Israel wouldn't be screwed the moment liberal Europe falls, meaning that a good chunck of them are shooting themselves in the foot.
>Implying skyrocketing crime wouldn't happen with, say, English or French refugees going somewhere else in Europe.

>>28622443
I can't find a flaw in Starlight

prove it wrong
>protip: you really can't