BANNER THREAD

File: ea9408f88f68fe7fbd6c50011ad918943a3734dd.jpg (36KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 468x60px

In all honesty, this would probably win, if barneyfag doesn't buy 100 passes to make his submissions win.

>>28342855
>nyx
God why?, is the cringist thing in this board

>>28342855
>someone submitted a dupe of my banner

File: d68987ed06ef8b795faa0759e877500b2985569b[1].gif (89KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

89KB, 468x60px

>>28342855
voted for this

>>28342876
O heard pass owners can see who is winning.

>>28342881
nope

>>28342855
Reminder of you don't vote for something with ponies in it, you're a faggot.

File: 4d1aa58ea026f564624440a366bac512d9fcf19c.gif (78KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

78KB, 468x60px

>inb4 this wins

>>28342876
All pass users should vote for this one so we don't split the vote

>>28342861
>>28342932
God dammit one of these is gonna win, won't they?

>>28342942
don't say that

>>28342855
>75% of them are fugly shit

>>28342948
Why

>>28342953
i'm the guy who voted for it, but there are a couple of other good choices too.
and this is 4chan, people are less likely to do something if you tell them to

File: excited ponk.gif (458KB, 500x439px) Image search: [Google]

458KB, 500x439px

>>28342855
>my banner is in the screenshot

File: 11315ca2dbd4a82e84b9539f2a21f23e871cdadb.jpg (37KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

37KB, 468x60px

voted

>>28342979
This was my banner I was just talking about here >>28342970

Voted for Nyx just to piss you off

File: 1462777911041.png (144KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

144KB, 500x500px

>>28342855
>you have to look farther down to see the good ones
>people like this >>28342979 voted for non-pony banners
>a lot of shit banners
This had been rigged from the start.

>>28342979
>not pony
What is your problem?

>>28343016
You're partly right that there's bias for options that are higher up. Randomizing the order each time the page is loaded would have been more fair.

Christ there's like 60 to choose from

File: moe.jpg (12KB, 222x200px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 222x200px

>there are just two/three hate banners vs 50+ "real" banners
>the hate vote won't be divided
>a hate banner will win

>>28343029
I like naked men.

File: 0ca9c089934b14ba1751b7d59638bfb96950a162.png (74KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

74KB, 468x60px

I can't make horns or ponytails of this one

>>28343037
It's randomized periodically.

>>28343043
There's only like 23 I would be okay with, excluding variants of them.

File: 1471889979640.jpg (10KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 468x60px

>>28343069
Still, no one will vote for the mediocre banners, but there are too few plainly horrible banners vs 23 (or whatever) good ones. Haters will vote for the terrible banners, while honest vote will be divided between too many good banners. Statistically, the chances that a terrible banner wins are too high.

In hindsight, we should have submitted some more terrible banners to divide the hate vote. Now it's too late. We're doomed. ;_;

File: image.jpg (32KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 468x60px

Vote for this pls.

>>28343110
>it isn't on the voting list
>you didn't submit it
I don't know if call you an idiot or thank you. Since you're a footfag you're probably an idiot, but I'm too grateful so, thank you anyway.

File: image.jpg (360KB, 1250x744px) Image search: [Google]

360KB, 1250x744px

>>28343131
That enough for you?

>>28343105
I wish there was a simple 10 question requirement about the show in order to vote.

>>28343105
Okay.

>I counted 60* banners
29* of them were considered "good."
>29 good banners

>48.33%* of the banners are good.

My requirements:
>Be original*
>Look aesthetically pleasing
>Related to board*
>Have ponies

This excludes EqD due to /mlp/ being primarily a pony centered board.

To restate:
>48.33%* of the banners are good

>>28343149
Anyone can google them, and they (the mods) are not autistic about doing one for us as they would for Pokemon, Technology or [s4s]

>>28343146
Huh. It isn't on the list tho, so I guess some mod just hates you. That's nice.

File: 2ch.hk_ololo_mlp_7.gif (92KB, 300x100px) Image search: [Google]

92KB, 300x100px

>>28342949
ikr

>>28343169
That's cause I just submitted it dummy. If I'm too late then oh well.

File: submit.png (6KB, 511x265px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 511x265px

>>28343188
>I just submitted it
How? Are you a wizard?

>>28343201
I'm betting a ketsup bottle wins for /r/

File: 1453395202250.png (263KB, 427x655px) Image search: [Google]

263KB, 427x655px

How plausible would it be to argue to the people in charge that /mlp/ doesn't want one of the "hate" banners?
We do have a whole months worth of the banner threads that was up most of the time to show the kind of stuff that was wanted.

>>28343213
I don't know. We can't even get our janitors to do something most of the time.

>>28343055
Obscure like shit.
Took me 5 minutes to realize it's that crow from last friends forever comic.

I can't decide between these two
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/7fd6f88df4f9e0c4c601667f1f3fc331011d1bd2.gif
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/1b351ffc502a4d19021c67047b8101d6d28ce956.gif

They're both pure pottery

>>28343549
I like the first one.

>>28343549
Second seem better

>>28343549
I prefer >>28342876.

>>28343552
Yea I do too. It does sum up the board quite well, but I kinda feel like people might not get it. The second one is a lot more visceral, and the milk thing is something that everyone on 4chan gets even if they haven't seen the stuff done with Twilight. It also shows the other side of the board that the other one really doesn't.

I'm conflicted.

File: 16c47d4ebd35edb20d95795d327c86f979417c20.png (23KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 468x60px

SUNNY

>>28343571
Terrible banner

>>28343574
I'm kind of a mind to say that the banner shouldn't be EQG

Nothing against EQG fans, but Pony should always be front and center here.

>>28343549
Ok, that second one got me good. Nearly made me spit my drink.

Are we going to mass vote on one? All the butthurt autists who still hate ponies will probably try to target the least triggering banner.

>>28343607
>implying
They would pick the banner that makes us look as autistic as possible which would probably be one of these
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/a4521bf4f4f97095e63f33d9f8253882401f784b.gif
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/cd66339f8503d8bc5642eceea095250820bd2f2a.png
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/e08ea88752759c3e07b26260bff189acc7bae997.gif

We're fucked. Everyone on the site who likes ponies (us) will vote for the legit banners, and everyone who doesn't like ponies (every other board) will flood the troll banners and outnumber us.

File: 1447850399543.jpg (258KB, 760x760px) Image search: [Google]

258KB, 760x760px

I want this to win so bad
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/e303de6ffc9f4c601b946d15ed99002053e49a18.gif

>>28343637
That only makes it more exciting.

>>28343637
So lets choose one to bandwagon.

>>28343549
*poetry

File: 1464479386821.png (170KB, 450x450px) Image search: [Google]

170KB, 450x450px

>>28343708
>newfag

>>28343638
it's yours, isn't it.

File: 1354841244813.jpg (7KB, 225x225px) Image search: [Google]

7KB, 225x225px

>>28343725
oh no, I missed a meme? How could I?

>>28343043
FUCK

>>28343726
No but it's antrho, which means it's guaranteed to piss off the most amount of people.

>>28343732
Not sure how you missed it, it's a 10 year old meme originating from deviantart iirc, because they kept misspelling poetry. It's used quite a lot on here.

>>28343751
There's your problem, I hardly visit dA.

https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/e303de6ffc9f4c601b946d15ed99002053e49a18.gif

https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/4d1aa58ea026f564624440a366bac512d9fcf19c.gif

https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/d68987ed06ef8b795faa0759e877500b2985569b.gif

https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/68874d533730f006762657aca48b963b6218b5db.png

I can't decide. Fuck. It wasn't supposed to be this hard to choose.

>>28343765
Voting between butts and Kevin, I'd say flip a coin.

either way they'll both lose against the hateful ones.

>>28343765
>https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/e303de6ffc9f4c601b946d15ed99002053e49a18.gif
>You couldn't normally post this banner on /mlp/ without getting banned for antrho

Whoever made it is a genius.

>>28342855
I hope the "Hi Anon" banner wins

I need microbenis to win

>>28343784
Meh, I don't think it's great. I don't know why "Hi Anon!" is in greentext, and I don't usually associate Cadance with the chocolate milk joke. I think the milk one from here >>28343549 is better.

>>28343549
Second one is what I was planning on voting on, but the comments in here about the hate banners being concentrated votes has me worried.

>>28343607
Ok, I did a thing for anyone who wants to vote as a group. You're welcome, this took me a long time to make.

https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSc8f2JTs0lLFaLpp4VWD2oXLqStUdRJaAD8Fb0vRlFrXsp_WQ/viewform

Also I would appreciate it if you could please tell me if it's working properly. It should allow you to look at the results after the fact and it should also allow you to go back and change your selection after you've submitted it if that really turns you on.

>>28343643
>>28343667
Direct all vote to BUTTS
>>28342876

/mlp/ has the biggest 4cc fanbase, I'm sure our pass users can channel their autism into this too

>>28343176
Fucking russians always get the nice things. Their board even allows porn.

>>28342876
Might have to focus all on this one lads.

File: 1472612204808.png (298KB, 448x392px) Image search: [Google]

298KB, 448x392px

> Barneyfag selling his car to prevent a website from getting a banner of something he doesn't like is a very real possibility
Damn. but seriously the numbers game is a bit worrying.

File: 8a03f8f37d873aff0fbce71199c669e0ba387ab5.png (46KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

46KB, 468x60px

>>28343833
I personally prefer pic related. I don't have a pass tho, so it doesn't really matter much.

File: Dat Ear Twitch Do.gif (272KB, 1150x700px) Image search: [Google]

272KB, 1150x700px

>>28343816
I'll be quite saddened if I wake up and find that the responses to this are in the single digits. If we end up moving this over to another thread I would appreciate it if you could repost the link there as well.

Goodnight/Bedtime /mlp/

File: Banner_Contest_-_4chan_-_2016-09-05_15.05.46.png (2MB, 1349x5398px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1349x5398px

>>28343855
Yes. Here's the whole list.

>>28343773
Whats with the clampdown on anthro lately anyway

>>28343870
Fear from the mods and board that furries would think they could find a home here and post thier stuff unchallenged.

>>28343878
/trash/ does exist though

Anyone NOT voting one of these are scum and do not deserve to vote:
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/8f971b5af93233f24a7b1fa4e3388e28d3da4445.png
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/a9affeac9d4f88a5ddfb8d8669ebef7a2ed1b3ff.png
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/e28f339f5c4ea1390327bf559c70cfbfa8bb6e40.png
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/e303de6ffc9f4c601b946d15ed99002053e49a18.gif
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/7fd6f88df4f9e0c4c601667f1f3fc331011d1bd2.gif
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/66e3cbd3b3487de0ab2f67c629162cc024da4735.png
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/ebb7c42dbdc4506e818cca3c84e6367b6257fbd8.gif
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/1a8130f6d34fd1f2d25e810bda26f630c280245a.gif
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/562158d87d713db03383bfa5c5ab540f504ddeb9.png
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/2d3ce4fe883e5c0cf3101c8371726aaacae4759f.gif
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/d68987ed06ef8b795faa0759e877500b2985569b.gif
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/833e2509185a4890b7f93372663519c55f07028a.png
https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/f0bfff38a37d18065e148a586942372ccc249ace.gif

>>28343882
/trash/ is the exception to the rule, as well as /b/ sometimes. For them specifically we need to self-enforce the no anthro rule as well as encourage the mods to enforce it as well since we don't want them to come leaking in.

In that case it's sort of a "Fuck off, we're full" sort of deal.

File: 1462075655102.jpg (165KB, 700x700px) Image search: [Google]

165KB, 700x700px

>>28343016
If you haven't braced yourself for disappointment the moment this was announced, you have only yourself to blame.

Seriously what did you people expect to happen with a board like ours? I'm not saying I like it but it is what it is

Not even half the people in this thread probably have a pass

>>28343893
>milk one not on there
Why is that one scumish? I'm waiting to see if there's any kind of consensus in this thread or a big majority in >>28343816 before voting, but still.

File: 1380026681532.jpg (80KB, 350x335px) Image search: [Google]

80KB, 350x335px

>>28343841
I don't know why they even accepted it.

File: 1441060179460.jpg (99KB, 1136x640px) Image search: [Google]

99KB, 1136x640px

>>28343911
>>28343841
This is Hiro's plan all along. He knows we're autistic, maybe autistic enough to try and put the numbers on our favor, and therefore, spend money to vote on the more favorable banners.

Anyone know why the Twilight one from the comics is repeated twice? Seems like if people want to vote for it it'd split up the votes

I didn't notice a difference

>>28343841
>Barneyfag single handedly funds the website for a few years with this vote and pass buying autism
>actually helps to keep /mlp/ alive as a result

>>28343921
top kek.
> mods make a new banner contest every 10 years to sustain the site
> not a s single pony banner actually ever accepted

this was meant to be a /mulp/ banner but it's unlikely.

>>28343913
>milk one not on there
>Why is that one scumish?
It's flattened, had an unnecessary 4chan logo when /mlp/ - Pony was enough, and it's not the original meme.
Plus it would spoil a newfag's first time seeing the thread, knowing what the punchline is.

>>28343934
>spoiler
Okay, that's sensible enough for me. I'm gonna likely butts now.

>>28342855
Fucking vanilla banners. Nothing special honestly, except for the quote from nyx. That's so exploitable.

File: 1421932223040.gif (1MB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 640x360px

>>28343950
PUSH THE BUTTS UP TO THE TOP

>>28343950
Butts is a little cluttered for my taste.

File: e94aa6761b3f62b80e937f69efff75302a059df1.gif (8KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 468x60px

>>28343983
This basically.
I just want one that is simple and aesthetically pleasing, but it doesn't matter since one of barneyfag's submissions will probably win.

File: 6d6503451c87f17b31b2558951ff680ee065dcb6.png (16KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 468x60px

>>28344056
That one's way too simple for its own good.

I do prefer the running derpy or pic

>>28343149
Thing is if barneyfag buys 50 passes (which at this point would not suprise me) he knows more about ponys then most of us.

Looking at the /qa/ thread, it seems like all boards have been having problems with random nobodies voting when they've never even been to the board.

File: Screen Shot 2016-09-05 at 7.20.43 AM.png (1MB, 1998x1008px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1998x1008px

Take solace in the fact that we aren't /g/.

>>28344133
/vp/ has a lot of good ones.

>>28344133
Wait why is there an /an/ banner for /g/
May as well make a guro banner at that point.

>>28343878
i though all that started when pencils brought katrina into his comic. and since she is pony related, is an exception to the rule, like diamond dogs or minotaurs

>>28342876
Voted for this one.

It's really too bad you can only vote for one - if you could vote for multiple, there would be a lot less to worry about regarding vote splitting. And I thought everyone knew by now that first-past-the-post is a garbage system?

>͏>28343878
>͏>28343896
there is no way you can be this dumb
terrible bait

>>28344149
thatsthejoke.jpg

File: 624220__safe_meme_screencap_exploitable+meme_edit_hub+logo_twilight's+kingdom_golden+oaks+library_spoiler-colon-s04e26_spoiler-colon-s04e25.jpg (335KB, 1450x811px) Image search: [Google]

335KB, 1450x811px

Well, good job, /mlp/, ya blew it. Now you're gonna blame the fact that we get a shit banner on everyone but yourselves, but the truth is that

YOU COULD HAVE PREVENTED THIS

but you chose not to. Might as well start the mass shitstorm to An Hiro now about how all of /mlp/ went out and bought 4chan Gold like good goyim but the shitty voting system resulted in our getting an absolute garbage banner no one who actually frequents the board wants.

>>28344250
K

>>28342855
>see the horse cum jar
Man I knew I should have made a banner out of that other meme

>>28342855
There are too many, I can't decide.

I do like the Daki one, the "now your day is ruined" and the animated Daapi though

File: 1421711690875.jpg (26KB, 371x354px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 371x354px

>>28342855
>only 4chan Pass users will be able to vote
Then why am I seeing a "Vote" button next to each one?

>rogue submissions
>mfw I made the tl;dr one
The road to Hell is paved with good intentions, Anon.
I certainly didn't make it out of malice.

>>28344548
>Then why am I seeing a "Vote" button next to each one?
Laziness. You still see those even after you've voted, they just don't do anything then.

File: 01bca2bda1eb3082d06aecbbd27ac905318e314f.png (33KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 468x60px

If this doesn't win I will kill myself and stream it

>>28344743
>If this doesn't win I will kill myself and stream it

That should have been a banner

>People are actually voting for banners that don't have ponies in them

It's like you don't give a shit about the board you fucks!

>>28342855
>now your day is ruined

I can already see people use proxies to vote more than once

>>28344056
I love this one, I really don't want to focus on BUTTS. I think we're gonna get a shitty one.

Wait, only 4chan pass users can vote?

What the fuck is this shit.

>>28342979
>no neck beard
>not fat enough

What is your problem?

>>28344799
>People are actually voting for banners that don't have ponies in them
They are? And how exactly would you know?

>>28343163
Should we call upon bronies from other places to help us? It is for a good cause after all. I am sure some of them will buy a pass

>>28344841
You might want to think a bit longer about whether you really want EqD posters voting on our banner.

File: 1470364727119.jpg (33KB, 375x363px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 375x363px

>>28344846
I don't see how this can possibly go wrong.

File: large[1].jpg (434KB, 818x1024px) Image search: [Google]

434KB, 818x1024px

>>28344839
Because you're talking to Hiro, featherbrain. Like most, he's a planted horsefucker and really wants us to have something good for our/his board.

File: 1366985834942.jpg (57KB, 894x894px) Image search: [Google]

57KB, 894x894px

>>28344846
>>28344857
Yeah, it'll be totally fun! Just like when Seth posted about our 4CC Team playing on EqD! Wasn't that a great, safe idea?

File: dashinside.png (145KB, 535x640px) Image search: [Google]

145KB, 535x640px

In the end we will end up with shit banner, because you, retards, can't consolidate.

>>28344870
When? link?

>>28344871
Oh piss off senpai. We've already been over this.

>>28344871
Prisoner's dilemma. It's in each individual's best interest to not consolidate.

If the voting system wasn't such shit, this wouldn't be a problem.

>>28344841
I'd rather this and see an actual banner win

>>28344878
It was years ago now lad. I think two or three people might have told him to do it, he did and then it caused a mini shitstorm so he took the post down shortly after. Poor lad.

The viewership for that Cup spiked a bit when we did play as a result

>>28344814
>I can already see people use proxies to vote more than once
Proxies wouldn't help, only the passcodes help and those cost something like $20 each. I doubt anyone would go that far just to rig the poll

>>28344871
>people vote for a banner they don't really like thinking it's the only way to have a good banner, even if it's not the best one
>a shitty banner wins anyway because haters outnumber us
>all the effort is ultimately pointless

I don't have a pass, but I'd rather lose with dignity voting a banner I like.

File: 1433396309549.png (44KB, 300x100px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 300x100px

Old one

>>28344947
Submission phase is over, lads.

File: untitled.png (28KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 468x60px

>>28344947
It's too late to submit anything now mate.
I regret not finishing this one up.

>>28344956
Some can get away with it.

>>28344939
This, I'd also rather vote for my favorite than something I think has "a chance to win".

>>28344968
In a case like this, why would people only vote for ones they think will win, and not the ones they like?

File: Angry-Frog-Meme-05.jpg (20KB, 306x306px) Image search: [Google]

20KB, 306x306px

>only 4chan pass users can vote
Fucking dropped

File: Checkem.jpg (22KB, 472x472px) Image search: [Google]

22KB, 472x472px

>>28344999
Frog is waste of trips. But I agree with you.

>>28344941
Damn. I should have got on earlier.

File: large-3.gif (974KB, 1024x1024px) Image search: [Google]

974KB, 1024x1024px

> pony pics only belonging on /mlp/

I'll post pony anywhere I damn want to.

>>28345011
Sadly, that will get you banned, for reasons that I can't say without getting banned.

File: IMG_20160905_122329.jpg (42KB, 800x272px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 800x272px

Did fucking Barneyfag make these?!

>>28344939
>>28344968
I think the complaint about "consolidation" is more about the submissions than the voting. In theory if we had pre-decided and only submitted one "good" banner, then all /mlp/ users would vote for the good banner, all the barneys would split their votes among their shitty/troll banners, and the good banner would win.

>>28344979
Same reason people vote strategically in US elections. If I vote for Gary Johnson, then my vote has no effect on the results - either Trump or Hillary is going to win no matter what, and a vote for Gary Johnson has no effect on WHICH of them will win.

>>28345029
Nah, one of us probably did desu

It even uses the MLP Equestria font, I wouldn't be surprised if it's a little in joke.

>>28345017
You can talk about the reasons freely. It's because we were a nuisance in 2010 and 2011

File: PRESS F.png (17KB, 500x200px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 500x200px

>>28345033
>I think the complaint about "consolidation" is more about the submissions than the voting
Oh, that makes sense.

In my defense, I'm one of the few anons who deleted one of their banners after being asked to. Y'all will regret not having a salt shaker as a banner when >>28342861 wins.

>>28345172
>a 4cc banner
It won't be missed

>>28343841
>implying barneyfag even has a car
At least I hope he doesn't, I don't want him to leak into /o/

>>28343911
I expected a better submission process that barred barneyfag tier ones, but I guess that's also wishful thinking.

>>28345381
Maybe we are lucky and our mod takes a look at it. Something like still giving the first place the pass but use a highly voted banner that actually represents the board well.

After all, the purpose of this was to encourage cross-pollination between the different boards, so it would make sense to use the ones that might actually motivate people to check out the board being advertised.

File: 1359466858098.jpg (53KB, 431x370px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 431x370px

>>28344743
You and I both know that's not going to win.
All it's got going for it is rounded corners.
And changing perceived intentions with the use of a crop.
And potential commentary on Ashleigh Ball being a lesbian.
And Applejack's ass.

But, apart from that, it's got nothing going for it.

So when do we find out was the winrar?

>>28345525
On the 15th anniversary of 9/11.
It seriously is.

File: bestbanner.gif (104KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

104KB, 468x60px

If this doesn't win I'll be thoroughly disappointed.

>>28345553
it literally has no chance of winning

>>28345553
none of the inside jokes really have a chance of winning since /mlp/ doesn't have the majority of voters

>>28345553
>Ugly font
You'll be thoroughly disappointed.

>>28343043
You may be forgetting that anyone could have submitted a banner. That means that since there are much fewer hate banners than legit banners, then there must be less antimlp people who give a shit than people here who give a shit. However, there are fewer hate banners to spread those fewer votes over, so that means both the hate banners and legit banners are pretty much on equal footing. We just have to co-ordinate our votes using >>28343816 to pull through.

>>28345553
That's a PTS-tier banner

So are we getting something good or are we getting fucked in the ass? Is there a way to know which one is winning?

File: 1449329857588.png (124KB, 694x671px) Image search: [Google]

124KB, 694x671px

submitted the animated version of my banner and someone else apparently submitted the still one.

why? i specifically only did the animated one as to not spread the votes.

i will find you

>>28345791
>Is there a way to know which one is winning?
No.
We do have a mod who actually cares about the board at least enough to make regular stickies though, so I wouldn't worry too much. If we end up with a total shit banner he will probably suggest to put at least a second, decent one into the rotation.
To which Hiro replies
>"Nani? :3c"
because he didn't understand a word and they just go ahead with it anyway.

Does the order descending represent most to least votes?

>>28345838
Just shows how shitty the whole process is. I hope to see yours win but it the chances are even slimmer now.

>>28345849
no

>>28345849
No. The order is also random so no one profits from being at the top.

>>28343549
kek the second one

File: 1b351ffc502a4d19021c67047b8101d6d28ce956.gif (146KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

146KB, 468x60px

>>28342855
this one is perfect, Holy shit!, i'm voting for this one for sure

>>28346189
>this one is now at the top
I think maybe the ordering has to do with whenever the banner was last voted for.

Milk banners are retarded as its a site-wide meme not just mlp related, kevon has too much going on and looks cluttered as fuck, and most of the banners are just messes/eqg/hate banners. The only couple worth while are the one with the human and the main 6 appearing behind him (which can also be seen as bad because of the domination of Anon self insert fiction around here), Twilight looking at Butts, and twilight alone talking about how she'll be stuck her forever. If one of the hate banners were to win, I really hope it's just >>28342392 as it's still laughable to us and can been seen as in-board humor as well. It would still draw attention to the board as a whole while keeping some of the humor and feelings of /mlp/ in it. Here's to hoping that Butts clenches the win.

>>28346227
I guess

>>28345657
>Ugly font
It's supposed to look like cum.

>>28346330
>(which can also be seen as bad because of the domination of Anon self insert fiction around here)
That was my main gripe about that one, yeah. Good idea but it felt gross in execution.

> twilight alone talking about how she'll be stuck her forever.
Guaranteed to fail, since there are two different versions of it.

>>28346391
It doesn't. It looks like one of those shitty edgy fonts people use in the intros of YouTube music videos.

>one luna banner
>no celestia banner

Just like my pony cartoon

>>28343816
Remember to thing in the thing

File: sunfag after reading issue 18.jpg (108KB, 900x675px) Image search: [Google]

108KB, 900x675px

>>28346430
I failed my waifu. I should have submitted one.

Did any of you vote on >>28343816?

I have one in mind I want to vote for, but I think it's better saved for making sure what /mlp/ wants gets it.

>>28346566
Yes, now throw your vote for what you want. You wait too long and it will be too late. Like young British lads that wanted to stay in the EU but didn't realize they had to actually go out and vote.

>>28346629
I'm not worried. There's a whole week to wait and I'm gonna keep an eye on it.

>>>/qa/655907

>6 years
>still butthurt

At least if they win that banner will be the reminder of their saltyness

>>28346687

just ignore them , don't give them the attention they want

File: dupe.png (41KB, 500x181px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 500x181px

>>28345772
>since there are much fewer hate banners than legit banners, then there must be less antimlp people who give a shit
On top of that, this anon >>>/qa/655907 claims to have singlehandedly made no fewer than FOUR of the anti-mlp banners. That's out of about eight strongly anti-mlp banners, and 60 banners total.

>>28345838
Even worse, pic related. These two are literally adjacent to each other on the page right now.

>>28346687
You really need to switch up your posting style if you're gonna samefag. Maybe learn English too.

>>28346629
The only people who actually want to be part of the EU are Greeks and Roaches. That should really tell you something.

File: no, seriously.gif (395KB, 400x355px) Image search: [Google]

395KB, 400x355px

>>28346687
I thought that those banners were made by different people. The fact that all of them were made by the same faggot is so pathetic that it's just hilarious. Also
>some of my banners
He made EVEN MORE and some of them weren't approved. Holy shit. You can't make this shit up. Hatefags confirmed maximum autistic crybabies.

>>28346932
Why would he even make more than one? Wouldn't that split the vote even more? kek

>>28346845
/qa/'s banner should be purely reddit logos as they are equal if not worse cancer.

File: 6bfdd0a4cf6d46292ccdb6285e2f89a575399206.png (42KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 468x60px

Does /vp/ have a lot in common with us?

>>28347066
They will never get a banner because it isn't a real board.

>>28347338
i was fucking pokemons before ponies, but i have to admit that the ponytafags/rapidashfags had a lot of knowledge about horses just like us

>>28347338
The very presence of waifufaggotry is a lot more contentious over there, but they do exist.

>>28346932
> some of my
wait. did you need a pass for each banner or could you just chuck them in? dayum

>>28347436
Anybody can submit anything they want, passes are only needed for voting.

>>28345840
I want to protect Hiro's smile

>>28343816
For those of you wondering how things are playing out with this. We currently have 41 responses to the poll.

#26, which is this https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/1b351ffc502a4d19021c67047b8101d6d28ce956.gif is currently in the lead

#11 https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/d68987ed06ef8b795faa0759e877500b2985569b.gif is at a somewhat close second

And finally the very tasteful #38 https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/e94aa6761b3f62b80e937f69efff75302a059df1.gif is trailing slightly behind in third place

Remember that if you haven't voted in this poll yet that you should do so to make sure that your voice is heard so that the people here who have 4chan passes can best represent /mlp/ in this endeavor to select the best possible banner. As for those of you who intend to actually vote based on this poll please make sure to check back BEFORE the 11th and see which one is currently leading and cast the appropriate vote then.
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSc8f2JTs0lLFaLpp4VWD2oXLqStUdRJaAD8Fb0vRlFrXsp_WQ/viewform

>>28347722
Someone must be samefagging to have that chocolate milk one in the lead

>>28347752
Probably not. It's been pretty popular, and it's fairly well done.

A bit disappointed that mine is trailing so hard, but as long as a good one gets in, I'll be happy.

>>28347782
Are you #11 or a different one?

>>28347947
I'm down near the bottom, actually. I wouldn't consider any of the ones listed in that post to be trailing hard.

>>28347722
I already voted for butts, so it's good to see it's doing well in the poll. And I agree with >>28347752, there's no way that shitty chocolate milk gif should be winning this.

Please don't let some shitty milk meme that doesn't represent ponies in any way win. With the Butts picture, we at least get Twilight doing what Twilight loves, reading. The milk meme is just that, a passing fad that will be retarded as shit and has been forgotten by more than half of this website. Make it something that will last a little longer.

>>28348002
The gif itself is great. The banner could've been better instead of being just a stretched gif though.

>>28348043
>passing fad
What are you talking about? That shit's been common on /mlp/ since like 2012.

>>28348083
It's still stupid

>>28348162
no u

File: 1472419363756.gif (2MB, 586x605px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 586x605px

>>28347722
>26
Shit taste, shit taste the lot of you.

>>28347752
>>28348043
>>28348162
>>28348290
Are you samefagging? Cause I might be being paranoid but I think this is samefagging

>>28348439
You forgot me: >>28348002

>>28348439
Don't you have a Tulpa to be talking to, schizo?

File: carlosdash.png (479KB, 1280x925px) Image search: [Google]

479KB, 1280x925px

>>28348439
The last two are new IPs. While it's easily possible to post from new ones it's pretty goddamn autistic to cry over spilt milk

>>28343110
Voted

>>28347752
>>28347979
>>28348002
>>28348290
To be fair, when I said that it was in the lead it was only in the lead by one at the time. They're currently tied with 38 still behind by a bit.

>>28348439

More like a meme from the entirety of 4chan with a pony slapped onto it levitating a gun doesn't represent the board or the show as much as a cute edited picture of the main character doing something she likes while still making it broadly appealing and funny without having to cling to memes. It's just that one requires you to have a very specific interest in 4chan as a whole and the other is just a goofy picture that anyone can see the humor in even if it isn't their kind of humor. I'd rather having something broadly appealing than something targeted towards a very small subsection of 4chan for the one thing we'll be able to get out the door and onto all boards (if it isn't beat by the antipony banners or just kept in the subsection of /mlp/ in the end).

Which banners do you think will be vastly underrated?

File: 6662d2e2fd133872ea0787ad7b98c84e4a60b7e4.jpg (16KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 468x60px

>>28348893

>>28347752
>>28348043
>>28348002
I like the chocolate milk one much better than butts.
>>28348937
I made that one.

>Create a trash gmail account to submit the banner
>Get into the contest
>Try to log in today
>Google demands my phone number
>Give them a burner number
>Google locks my account forever
Vote for me anyway

File: barneyfag.png (26KB, 730x321px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 730x321px

BARNEYFAG THE ETERNAL AUTIST AT IT AGAIN

DO NOT VOTE FOR BARNEYFAG'S BANNERS

THE ABSOLUTE MAD<AN

>>28349056
You sound like a sperg m8

People will vote for whatever they like. Stop pissing off /qa/.

>>28349028
I'm not going to vote for your banner, because I think it's pathetic you wasted all that time and resources instead of buying a pass.

>>28349087
I try to relieve my spergy side on here so I don't sperg out IRL. Surely you understand Anon

>>28349161
Ok, but acting like a sperg runs counter to your desires, and people will do the opposite of what you say just because you pissed them off.

>>28349197
At least I'm an honest sperg, and I didn't even post on /qa/ ever

File: FragileFeelings.png (62KB, 498x480px) Image search: [Google]

62KB, 498x480px

I like the one that acknowledges there's no longer any reason to be here but I'm trapped in a pretty, pretty, princess penitentiary.

>>28349215
You just posted a screencap with a (You), genius.

>>28349028
>Create a trash gmail account to submit the banner
Just use mailinator, it's literally designed for this

>>28349247
The jig is up, I forgot I replied to it, but the fact remains that awareness needs to be brought to banners created to undermine an honest voting for this board

>>28349225
>Pretty princess
So the Luna banner? I don't think anyone voted for it. Even though I put in a lot of love in it for you faggots

>>28349225
>>28349302
There's going to be a lot of banners that will be overlooked, sadly

>>28349285
No, it really doesn't. People already know.

Screaming "THIS IS A TROLL DO NOT REPLY!!!!" just makes you look like an underage loon, and reinforces the idea that /mlp/ is full of autistic cretins. Meaning people are more likely to vote anti-/mlp/ because you said something about it.

Unless this is just some elaborate false-flag "pretending to be retarded" gambit, in which case, well played I guess.

>>28349285
Awareness has already been brought. Twice, in fact:
>>28346687
>>28346845
And anyway, did you even look at the banners from that post? They're all shit, nobody was going to vote for them anyway.

>>28349354
I'm sorry anon I'm kind of drunk and barneyfag really cums my quats

He won't leave us alone and that angers me we are board of peace

So goodnight and good luck, also im innocent of being guilty of pretending to be retarted because im under the influence of alcohol and i think im legitamitely retarded in recent years

>>28349409
>we are board of peace
There's no need to take it that far, anon. We may troll every once in a while, but it's not like we've ever blown people up with bombs.

>>28349317
This, and it's not because they're bad. Most of them are at least decent, but there are so many of them that a lot of them won't get much love.

File: 1363016128007.jpg (345KB, 1040x1040px) Image search: [Google]

345KB, 1040x1040px

>>28349409
kek, it all falls into place.

Sleep well, drunkanon.

>>28349430
we are board of absolute peace since we can't afford actual bombs kek so we stick to salt which i hope is iodized

>>28349443
you as well anon i hope you enjoyed your labor day and have a nice tuesday morning

File: large[1].jpg (89KB, 1168x279px) Image search: [Google]

89KB, 1168x279px

>>28342855
What the fuck. I thought for sure that one of you guys would have used this as a banner. Now I'm upset. I should have done it myself =(

>>28349465

Doesn't really fit most of the board. We all know we're retarded and rediculous for obsessing over this show.

File: banner.png (424KB, 444x604px) Image search: [Google]

424KB, 444x604px

Hi, I'm here for the banner thread. Am I in the wrong place?

>>28349409
>>28349354
>>28349526
""questionably authentic""
nobody is retarded for being passionate about ponies on the internet. if you genuinely believe this you've fallen for the memes.

>>28349573
Thanks, Doc Banner

File: Saddle Rager.png (128KB, 444x413px) Image search: [Google]

128KB, 444x413px

>>28349573
Hi, Doc. I've got someone who you might want to meet.

File: SCREW YOU DISCOVERY FAMILY.png (2MB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1920x1080px

Man you're really taking this banner seriously aren't you

>>28347722
>Like #38 better
>But of the two definite leads, #11 is by far better
>Definitely don't want #26 to win
Fug, I don't know what to do. First Past The Post is fucking retarded.

>>28349573
I honestly was going to photoshop the Hulk in the OP.

>>28348937
>No ponies

Nope.

>>28349706
This. Why isn't runoff more common? I feel like the last time I saw it used in anything was the Skullgirls IGG back in like 2013.

>>28349706
>>28349811
We could set up a runn-off after this if you guys like. I mean, we've got a few days until the actual deadline comes in and the top three are rather close.

>>28347066
Even better. They won't get a banner at all.

>>28350485
Why would they get banner in the first place?
/qa/ along with /trash/ aren't even on front page, they are hidden board. Why advertise them?

>>28345840
Yes but we also have a mod who was enough of a faggot to ban prompts

>>28348083
Milk threads are older then even /mlp/ it has its roots years before fim was even a thing back on /b/.

Its one of the most enduring memes there is.

>>28349573
Press f

File: OKie Dokie Lokie.png (371KB, 1750x1750px) Image search: [Google]

371KB, 1750x1750px

>>28343934
I was generally annoyed by you pushing the milk meme aside but your spoiler won me over.

>>28350495
And /mlp/ is a containment board

>>28351281
Your mum is a containment board for my dick

>>28351401
xd
Ok that's enough shitposting for one day, Anon.

>>28351410
Oh come on even i can see that one was funny and it was my mother he is talking about.

File: Rate our banner submission.png (270KB, 444x445px) Image search: [Google]

270KB, 444x445px

/vp/ here. I saved 3 of your banner submission.

>>28351735
From that set I quite like the 3rd one

Having variations of the same banner isn't a good idea senpai, it splits up the votes so it pretty much kills the chances of it winning.

>>28343016
>>28343037
I just want to point out that the banners are randomized. No need for the victim card.

>>28351735

>Rate our banner submission

A lot of hit and miss.

My favourites

https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/44c8e91ac59fa1bce1f27b86b44620447e56f82b.gif

https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/4cdf38ead97a1add6406e6eed2f327c87bb3e0e8.jpg

https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/a5436ed4ee3c839cb9e437af6f9bf7028787f061.jpg

>>28344743
I voted for it.

>>28352950
That fucking Brock one is just good, but the girl one fits /vp/ better.

File: 474cc3aef36b039e2c905ae0b090cc6135b62e65.png (38KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

38KB, 468x60px

I voted for this one

>>28353459
LOL nice! le witty meta maymay arrow banner xd

>>28353761
Don't be mean :(

>>28351038
F

File: banner.png (40KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

40KB, 468x60px

>>28352307
You think thats bad? There's 3 of these and two are identical.

https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/4cdf38ead97a1add6406e6eed2f327c87bb3e0e8.jpg

https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/4629a3b9f014b0ac33dbb95de745e2369357abef.jpg

https://s.4cdn.org/image/contest_banners/cd1b0e99542088680f8783cfab5b462ed3d91851.gif

>>28351027
>implying that was a bad thing
face it, we had way too many AiEs clogging the catalog.

>>28354277
There should be rule to prevent this from happening.

>>28354821
They should at least combine the votes after the fact.

>>28354517
>hur dur lets stifle creativity.

File: 1404132960059.jpg (914KB, 4800x4800px) Image search: [Google]

914KB, 4800x4800px

>>28354919
If by creativity you mean 8/10 times the greentext prompt is Anon having sex with _______ with the context of ________ then yes, stifle that shit. It's amazing how /mlp/ would make fun of outside fanfiction and OCs when the board after the scruffening consists mostly of just that. The board can even get allergic to pony only greentext, which is funny considering the backlash against humans in Equestria.

Though I suppose it's not the board's fault but rather time itself. As a subject, MLP wasn't made to last 4 years for a 4chan board as it's only one show and two comic book lines with a traffic only slightly slower than /co/, faster than /vp/.

File: Fix.gif (52KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

52KB, 468x60px

VOTE THIS!

>>28355107
Feel like this can count as a /tg/ one too.

>>28342876
ishyg are voting for this one

File: 1a8130f6d34fd1f2d25e810bda26f630c280245a.gif (80KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

80KB, 468x60px

>>28355107
That's not the current version

File: Oak.gif (111KB, 468x60px) Image search: [Google]

111KB, 468x60px

>>28351735
You guys made some fucking great banners, but I think this one speaks the most to us here at /mlp/.

yfw nyx wins

>>28359214
yay!

Bamp

Reminder for everyone to vote here >>28343816 to let pass users know which banner the board wants as a whole.

Only pass users can vote?

>>28362030
aye.

>>28361998
The fuck do I do when two banners are tied?

>>28362372
Vote for butts. The chocolate milk meme is garbage.

File: chinese spurdo.png (277KB, 600x623px) Image search: [Google]

277KB, 600x623px

>>28342855

only the spurdo banner is allowed to win.

>>28361998
>>28362372
>>28362438
Actually, since those two are pretty consistently tied I feel that we should shift the poll over to a secondary contest.

Here's another poll that only contains the three front runners.

So...

VOTE AGAIN HERE FAGS!!!
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdQxFObjI5QesamRCueGvNAhsO91ZwlrbpWdlph3UxRhHxeQQ/viewform

>>28363930
Well kinda already vote buttz

>>28363954
That's fine, Anon. You can still vote in this poll as well. The point is to figure out which one is the most popular so that those who haven't yet voted, but still want to vote for the most popular option can see which one is the most popular option.

>>28363930
>Submit another response
Discard this version of the survey, I just voted twice. For the final response, my answers wer "It's cute" and "Testing 123". Since they both appeared, that means I have successfully voted twice, so you should fix that now.

I fixed it, are you happy now? Now nobody gets to vote becuase you're being an autistic faggot about it.

There's literally nothing you can do to stop someone from voting twice on an internet poll, you just have to trust that people won't do so which I clearly can't in this case becuase you're autistic.

>>28363930
To be clear, poll is closed due becuase of >>28364066 being a dick about it

File: DELET THIS.png (31KB, 1280x709px) Image search: [Google]

31KB, 1280x709px

>>28363930
>>28364066
Submitted a third response just so I could get this screenshot.

>>28364142
>>28364148
Fuck, now you're making me feel bad. I just wanted to nip this problem in the bud.

>>28364142
To be clear, I only used one account to do it, which wasn't possible on the first survey. I wasn't trying to be a dick, I was just saying that there's probably an option you forgot to check that prevents people from voting more than once on one account, since the thing I circled in wasn't in the original survey you posted. Sorry I wasn't more clear the first time

>>28364165
No, it's fine, you can vote in the poll as many times as you want now. I don't care anymore.

The reason that option was there is becuase the only way that Google can stop people voting more than once is to have people sign into their Google+ account. Not only do I not want to have to make people do that to do a 4chan poll, there's no limit to some people's autism. You would be amazed how easy it is to make multiple Google+ accounts just to bot a poll like this.

I don't want you to feel bad, because I'm not an asshole, but maybe you should for acting impulsively and not thinking that at the very least what you were doing would result in more work for someone else. That someone else would be me, and fuck off I'm not going to make polls if people are just gonna abuse them.

>>28343870
You say this like it's a problem and not a good thing.

File: tumblr_oc5jjeo5hs1vs9gg5o1_400.jpg (44KB, 400x236px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 400x236px

>>28345017
Remember Anon, it's only really a 3 day vacation

>>28364197
I only voted a second time to test if that link meant exactly what I thought it meant, and a third to get the screenshot in case you didn't know what I meant. It wasn't my intention to abuse it and then rub it in your face that I did it. I just didn't want to say anything if my suspicions proved to be false. I now realize that my posts came off as cocky and as if to say "because I can". Sorry I didn't think this through.

>>28345163
I think he's referring to GR8

>inb4 I get banned

Whatever this poll you're doing is is likely to accomplish nothing desu

It's just a banner lads

I swear if an EQG one wins I'm fucking killing myself on stream

>>28365608
No matter who wins, there will be a shitstorm.

I might aswell swing it in my favor.

>>28365670
>>28365678
Well brace yourself for nothing good to come out of this

>>28365670
>Killing yourself for EG

There's a better reason to die anon.

>>28365711
yeah, like Nyx.

>>28345163
only content of the kind to be banned which is and was easily exploitable and ignores the fact that shitposting teams that have no interest in ponies have false flagged them for that exact intent.

mods mentioned a anti bias pony campaign in the leaked mod logs so the odds were stacked in the first place perhaps encouraged.

being told you're doing nothing means you're doing all the more.

>>28342876
This is the only one suitable for winning. I would be extremely pissed off if we wound up getting anything having to do with that piece of shit Barney Faggot.

>>28365858
>pointing out what pisses you off
>in a place where people are probably lurking to find out exactly what pisses you off, so they can vote for it
>on a site where people get their jollies from pissing others off
You are not a clever person

>>28366537
Except the barney banners were explicitly made with the intent of pissing off /mlp/ anons

File: shrugaloo.png (109KB, 894x894px) Image search: [Google]

109KB, 894x894px

>>28366550
Of course. But why would you call attention to the fact that it has the intended effect? That's just stupid. It's a big "I got trorred" sign you tape to your own back.

>>28366537
As if that made it any worse.

File: 1364276202266.png (338KB, 762x1048px) Image search: [Google]

338KB, 762x1048px

>Banner thread on /sp/ gets deleted and OP is banned

At least got to have some fun with this lads, wew