Who names their child Granny?

>>25707230
>Shortly after OP posted he was taken away by pony CIA officials.
>And he was never heard from again.

>>25707256
>CIA

>>25707276
>Canterlot Intelligence Association

Just let me have my fun and not fuck my shit into oblivion, family.

>Granny Smith is an actual kind of Apple
>All Apple relatives have apple related names
>the staff obviously referenced the name as both the actual apple and her position in the family.

It's not that hard really

>>25707500
Ya don't say?

Either way, he was talking about the canon explanation. Of all the kinds of apples, why name their child (granny smith) after a kind of Apple that makes her sound old?

>>25707614
Big mac isn't that big either.
Applejack isn't an alcoholic either.
Applebloom doesn't make the aples bloom.

File: the fire rises.png (267KB, 641x356px) Image search: [Google]

267KB, 641x356px

>>25707256
>mfw OP was a big guy
>mfw OP wanted to get caught
>mfw it's just a part of his master plan
>mfw he's crashing a plane with no survivors

>>25707630
>Big Mac is larger than the average stallion
>Applejack could simply be a reference to the cereal of similar name
>Fuck Applebloom

>>25707646
Horseshoes would like to kick your ass.

File: mlfw385_130654289534.png (117KB, 500x455px) Image search: [Google]

117KB, 500x455px

>>25707230
>Her name is Granny Smith
>She is a grandmother

>>25707668
How about the years before AJ and Big mac were born?

File: 1447031955909.jpg (14KB, 260x326px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 260x326px

>>25707293
I want a writefag on this

>>25707668
he meant in canon you fucktard, in the story, not the writers reason for naming her that

>>25707230
maybe that isn't her name, and just a nickname she goes by today? AJ and Bigmac started calling her that and then it just stuck with the rest after the parents died

Maybe her real name is just Apple smith

>>25707230

Granny smith is a type of apple. Is it odd to be young and named Granny? Yes, but it fits the apple theme and she's green apple colored. It's just wildly appropriate now that she's old and shit.

>>25707698
>he meant in canon you fucktard, in the story, not the writers reason for naming her that

Can you restate this complaint in non-retard?

Because what else is "canon" but what the writers decide should be?

File: Trouble_Shoes_ID_S5E6[1].png (456KB, 800x872px) Image search: [Google]

456KB, 800x872px

>>25707655
Unless I'm forgetting something; surely you mean Trouble Shoes?

>>25707230
Even though its a type of apple I always considered the "granny" as a honorific.

>>25707767
This is what they call her, yes, in that sense granny smith is canon, but is that her REAL name in canon?

Like the Derpy/Muffins/Ditzy fiasco, she has been called in the show Derpy and the writers refer to her now as Muffins and Ditzy, but canonically what is her real name, because it obviously is not all three.

>>25707230

>apple family
>"Big Mac Apple"
>"Applejack Apple"
>"Apple Bloom Apple"
>"Granny Smith Apple"

>pie family
>"Pinkie Pie"
>"Maud Pie"
>"Marble Pie"
>"Limestone Pie"
>"Igneous Rock Pie"
>"Cloudy Quartz Pie"

>>25707802
They haven't referred to her as anything else, dumb ass. She has never been called "Muffins"

>>25707230
Her parents knew she will be the old pony in the show. It's all part of a plan

>>25707785
Yeah just my luck.

>>25707614
>>25707698
Granny Smith apples are originally from Australia ane named after an Australian lady, "Granny" Anne Smith.

File: CHZK2z_WsAAUpc0.jpg (22KB, 600x364px) Image search: [Google]

22KB, 600x364px

>>25707836
holy crap are you retarded

>>25707886
so it's Anne.
Thank you anon