CYOA discussion

>>25487801
>the guy
>implying it's one guy

>>25487818
I was assuming it was mostly one guy with few exceptions.

>>25487827
I do it most of the time so you would be correct.

File: CYOAG nov 18-19 wordcloud.png (116KB, 812x526px) Image search: [Google]

116KB, 812x526px

>last thread

>>25487827
>>25487839
I was going to look it up to see how often I do it, but Desu is busted. It's not uncommon though.

>>25487864
>filly tamale
Sounds either extremely cute, extremely lewd, or extremely fucked up.

>>25487864

>bully fun. Treads okay

You heard the word cloud, we need to bull her more. She can take it.

Mendacity up: should have drawn a mammoth edition.
>>25487899

File: 1446606439824.jpg (11KB, 331x331px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 331x331px

>>25487864
>B-but help kind like probably bad QM abuse
>popular wrong rather hot

>>25487749
I like to focus in on a specific issue and discuss it a length. That's more interesting for me than just listing all the problems.

>>25487792
>>25487793
>>25487819
>>25487931
Cool, I'll get started in a bit.

File: Jam.jpg (37KB, 480x540px) Image search: [Google]

37KB, 480x540px

>>25488008
>hijunko gonna get slammed

>>25488062
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sOj7Jspsqhs

What 6 races would you want in a CYOA?


What 6 races would you not want in a CYOA?

>>25488259
http://www.poll-maker.com/polls.asp?p=poll-results&qp=446999xB322D1D5-18&t=y#tab-2

>>25487645
>>25487661
Yes' Fragile actually, also how do you know that!?

>>25488259
pone
pone
pone
pone
pone
batpone

>>25488259
pone
stripey pone
small pone
bug pone

>>25488259
Erf
Changeling
Pegasus
Unicorn
Batpony
Griffon

Alicorn As PC or significant party member, side character is fine
Human
EQG Human
Satyr
Centaur
Siren

>>25488313
because I think Stay is a very nice song.

>>25488259
BAT. PONY.

>>25488272
1 IP in arizona? So Nips lives in tucson then.

>>25488259
unicorn
deer
alpaca
cow
sheep
longma

File: Breaking news!.gif (28KB, 350x400px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 350x400px

>>25488413

Active threads

M&M: >>25438448
FOE: >>25477544
FOE 2: >>25441384
JAD: >>25486435
99.99999% Done: >>25436531
Vampony: >>25478766
Archipelago: >>25366038
Urban Survival: >>25401462
One Good Pint: >>25485045
Mendacity: >>25478307
Alchemy: >>25445919
11-54: >>25347924
Space: >>25472316
Trottingham: >>25457965

>>25488613
14, looking up.

>>25488613
Flutterrape and SIM both have cyoas in them now-a-days.

>>25488668
15 if that Anon hadn't personally failed Hijacker.

File: 1407532308490.png (242KB, 789x720px) Image search: [Google]

242KB, 789x720px

>>25488699

File: ScenesFromAHat3.jpg (12KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 480x360px

Posts that will always turn your beloved CYOA into a drama novel

>>25488761
Hey Jet, I'm not interested.

>>25488761
tell to the edgy pone how to be edgy

>>25488761
"Be a trap."

>>25488761

"Game Over."

>>25488761
"What kind of disguise should we get?"

>>25488761
"kekekeke"

>>25488761
"Wow, so that's how you get your kicks?"
"Beating a defenseless mare in a dark, unsanitary back alley?"

"Pff, wow. How climactic."
"I can tell you really know drama.."

"..not..."

"Look, tonight while you're in bed, you're not gonna remember a thing about this gross brutality."
"Not one damned thing."

"Why all this effort for a fuzzy memory?"
"Wait for the right time, bleed her and savour it."

"Or maybe you don't have the patience?"

File: a phantom pain.jpg (74KB, 821x717px) Image search: [Google]

74KB, 821x717px

>>25488840
How could we have let this happen?

>>25488840
This was probably the single biggest fuckup in the history of CYOA.
It's a shame, 'cause despite all the memes GC was a decent QM.

>>25488814
We up
A little later than i had hoped, but i had to get some stuff done

File: Humans.png (305KB, 1080x768px) Image search: [Google]

305KB, 1080x768px

>>25488761
>"Wait, are there humans in this CYOA?"

>>25488761

>choose a race:

>Unicorn
>Pegasus
>Earth
>BAT

>>25488761
"The humans should just nuke the ponies."

>>25488880
Shame
Wonder what she would be doing right now if she kept going
İ remember her first 'quest'
Good times

>>25488975
>Wonder what she would be doing right now if she kept going
Commission streams.
So no majour change.

Gotta say Hijacker, I'm not a fan of the crossovers you're shoving into the mission. It's getting kind of ridiculous at this point. Unless its purpose is building up to something down the line I can understand but right now it just looks like it doesn't serve any purpose other than jerking-off your questrunner buddies for shits and giggles. It's really detracting from the story. Also alienates players that don't follow those quests. My two cents.

>>25488926
İ would let little treads escort me around in her box tank

>>25489131
>still following the current mission

>>25489173
>missing out on cancerbat combat
I bet you like willow.

>>25489191
Considering she has a personality, yes.

File: carlostensifies.gif (248KB, 250x184px) Image search: [Google]

248KB, 250x184px

>>25489207
Willow seems pretty wooden to me.

>>25489131
Have you looked at the master trinket list? He's been jerking off other QMs and quests for ages.

>>25489131
References don't alienate players that don't get them. They just seem like random characters/monsters/events. To alienate players you have to actively point out that something is a reference, which I don't recall Hijacker doing.

Besides, didn't he say from the getgo that it's Crossover: The Quest?

>>25489207
>generic action girl trope that never develops at any point.
>personality.
Anon, do you even know what that word means?
Willow is so cardboard she acts the same way buying baked goods as she does fighting cosmic horrors.

>>25489207
Slutbat of Napping has more character than Violence Bird does though. All we know about Willow is that violence is fun.

>>25489229
Fuck off Carlos

>>25489236
I could say that Tara never develops either since all she ever does is try to make everything sexual.

>>25489251
You know, besides the development that she got this chapter.

>>25489251
>I could say that Tara never develops either since all she ever does is try to make everything sexual.
and if you had been reading the current mission you'd know that's wrong.

File: 1447395161464.jpg (229KB, 819x692px) Image search: [Google]

229KB, 819x692px

>>25489251
>Tara never develops either

>>25489262
No, I don't, because I don't follow shit characters who's only motivation is to find something to beat off to.

File: abs.jpg (15KB, 201x202px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 201x202px

Live Thread: >>25489241

Stream Up: https://picarto.tv/TheBirdieBin

And to everyone not enjoying the quest, sorry.

>>25489291
Try reading the chapter, and you'll see how very wrong you are.

Long as that development actually sticks, of course.

>>25489285
Even if you ignore the Steel stuff, Her getting nervous the second she lost control of keys is development.
Or how she handled Squishy.
Or her whole roughhouse backstory.

anyone saying slutbat is one dimensional just wasn't paying attention.

File: image.jpg (154KB, 988x1339px) Image search: [Google]

154KB, 988x1339px

>>25489298
_____________

File: scootaloo's thoughts on stopping diamond tiara's bullying.jpg (73KB, 254x261px) Image search: [Google]

73KB, 254x261px

>>25489311
>Or how she handled Squishy.

...Go on...

File: 1446452001571.jpg (176KB, 953x666px) Image search: [Google]

176KB, 953x666px

>>25489450
Might have been some mild mind raping initially.

File: 1446707333511.jpg (136KB, 1000x664px) Image search: [Google]

136KB, 1000x664px

>>25489462
But it worked out in the end.

>>25489296
Hijack, you should consider running earlier.

You too, Bath.

>>25489509
I'm sorry, I wanted to, but I've been sitting here drawing the same panel since ten.

Hi everyone

Welp, my incredibly drawn-out uni shit's FINALLY over and I'm pleased to announce that Galloping Steel should be back up and running within the next couple of days. I'm hoping to run it a lot starting now and proceeding over the Christmas period. I shouldn't be very busy unless I happen to find a job.

Anyway, I spent this afternoon looking through the /cyoag/s that have been while I was away and wow, Treads really took on a life of her own in that time, didn't she? Not hard to see why you guys like her, though. The char. gen. for GS happened to come up with a pony with a lot of inherent likability, I reckon.

>>25466311

Before I say anything else, this is absolutely wonderful. I never imagined I'd see such a perfect piece of Galloping Steel drawfaggotry, especially not during the hiatus. From the bottom of my heart, thankyou! Treads a cute!

>>25482454
>>25482503

Innkeeper kept me posted.

>>25482516
>>25482664

Honestly? I'm not that much of a pearl clutcher. If you guys wanna draw Treadsabuse, it isn't really my place to tell you to stop, especially since it's not really effecting Galloping Steel itself. Moreover, she's not even my character, technically. You guys came up with her design and even her personality. So she's really the anons' character to do with as the anons please. I just breathe life and (hopefully) additional depth into her through my writings, and even then I usually let the anons write her dialogue.

>>25486946

Don't forget the breathplay fetish!

>>25486990
>>25487198

Innkeeper and I aren't the same person, but I'll grant that we're similar enough in some ways that at times we may as well be. He's actually Canadian and works nights, though, not a fellow Aussie. As some of you may remember, I was the one who convinced him to give QMing a try, since from my perspective he's a (much) better writer than me and, hey, I figured if I can make a go of it here he could probably make something truly inspired, as indeed he has.

>>25489726
You got more art during your hiatus than when you were running.

http://anonpone.pineapplecomputing.com/steel/fanart

>>25489782

So I noticed! Hell, the gallery there is even missing some, like the one where Treads is in a cardboard box and asking a human soldier if he's sure he doesn't need a tank escort.

Treads just seems to have gained this cult following over the last few weeks. Not that I'm complaining at all. If anything it's cool to see you guys having fun with GS-related stuff even when I'm not here.

>>25489826
Yeah, Hero was mad that you gave her parents and thus couldn't fit her into the urban/M&M cross-canon.

Thus bully was born.

>>25489886
I'm pretty sure bully was born out of a greentext that was written based off a comment on the armor ponies pick.

>>25489726

Well you know, it's not like they've ever seen us both in the same room at the same time.

It could still be an elaborate hoax.

>>25489926
Don't think we're convinced by you two having different IPs!

>>25489942
Tinfoil stays firmly planted.

>>25489942
Obviously a VPN to try and trick us.

Oh, if anyone has any questions or comments before I start the next Galloping Steel thread, I'd appreciate the feedback. It's been a while since I last ran, so anything you reckon'll help get me back on track is appreciated...

>>25489963

Or perhaps one just tells the other one what to post, thus two people but only one person is really writing the messages.

>>25490036
Devious.

>>25490036
Nah. Panzer is actually a robot that Innkeeper transmits commands to that then relays them from his network connection in Australia. He had a software update a while back and had to be redone from scratch.

So I always heard that Panzer writes well.
>"I understand," you say understandingly.

>>25490179

Well, I must've had a brain-fart there. I'm assuming, though, that you think my writing is poor overall, not just that one single quote. In which case, care to elaborate so I can improve?

>>25490249
I was actually just going through and removing non-story posts, so I can't really comment on writing quality. That just amused me when I noticed it.

On that note, Urban Survival and Galloping Steel have had their archives cleaned.

>>25490268

OK, thanks a bunch. GS has a lot of delete-repost because I'm incompetent like that, so it definitely needed it

File: Splitter.png (680KB, 768x768px) Image search: [Google]

680KB, 768x768px

Sorry about the wait, working off some art-block.
Let's continue shall we?
>>25490283

>>25489285
>>25489262
>>25489284
>>25489298

>whaaa everyone lies so I can manipulate and mind control people
>except I feel bad about it some times pls no hate

wow so much character

>>25490694
Still more than willow

>Be birb, like punching

>>25489285

What happened there? I must have missed that game.

File: >I don't know anything about the subject matter in question.jpg (51KB, 522x441px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 522x441px

>>25490694

>>25490702
At least She doesn't jerk off ponies while everyone is getting messed up by trans dimensional monsters.

File: 1418741337502.jpg (95KB, 497x732px) Image search: [Google]

95KB, 497x732px

>Panzermane is back

>>25490007
__________J U S T__________

>>25490702
>setting ancestor Steel free when she didn't need to
>momma didn't raise no liar
>always got some kind of quip to say

Just cus she doesn't have a dark and edgy past doesn't mean she has no character

>>25490726
Neither did Tara canonically.

File: 1446702316163.png (12KB, 237x229px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 237x229px

>>25490694
>let me tell you all about that thing I haven't read

>>25490763
I actually like both characters, I was just playing devil's advocate.

>>25490767
>didn't see the fluids on the cookie monster

>>25490774
>I only started reading when the bat became leader

>>25490783
Shiny pls.

>>25490783
>I'm comparing two characters
>I refuse to read about one of them though
Okay then.

>>25490792
>complain someone doesn't read about both characters
>doesn't read about both himself

wew lad

>>25490799
>implying
You're going to have to do better than that Shiny.

>>25490806
>got no comeback

TIME TO BRING OUT THE >IMPLYING

File: pirate gis.jpg (329KB, 1250x750px) Image search: [Google]

329KB, 1250x750px

guys shush
pirate gis is here

>>25490799
The only person that ever said he hadn't read both characters was the guy arguing against Tara. This argument has gone off the edge into retarded strawmanning.

>>25490825
>openly admits to not reading the current chapter
>gets called out on it
>"n-no u"
Are you actually retarded?

>>25490828
She needs an eye patch and a parrot

>>25490830
>>25490832

Nigga I ain't that guy.
You know there are many anons here right?

fucking wow.

>>25490843
My post holds regardless.

>>25490843
>damage control
Yeah sure, he just disappeared and you stepped in to respond to every response to his post.

>>25490832
>one post saying they haven't read it

>now everyone that says anything against Tara is that one person

can't get any more
>implying
than that

>>25490843
Sure you're not.
You're not-shiny, the totally different anon known for his not being Shiny.

>>25490854
>direct response to response chain
>not the same guy
okay

File: pirate gis + parrot.jpg (336KB, 1250x750px) Image search: [Google]

336KB, 1250x750px

>>25490833
done

>>25490852
>>25490863
>>25490876

>o-only one person would insult my waifu

I was mocking you tards for saying Tara got loads of characterization this chapter when all she was basically

>but mind control is bad

>>25490896
>implying I said that
It goes both ways.

>>25490889
Nice!

>>25490889
>Gisela is captain
>Willow is first mate
>Pen is Main Gunner

We need more Griffons for our Pirate ship

>>25490889
>not Blitz as a parrot

>>25490915
Well, Gunther from Threshold is an engineer.

>>25490920
"LETS BE FRIENDS"
*SQUAWK*
"LETS BE FRIENDS"

>>25490896
Her getting nervous when she lost the ability to hear Keys heart isn't 'but mind control is bad'.
Her breakdown after losing control had less to do with how her powers worked and more to do with the pressure it caused by always being on.
Her choice to help the guard at all was motivated by her desire to fit in, it was literally 'if I do this they'll owe me and they wont run me off as quickly'
Furthermore the initial insight into her character before the Esmeralda intermission showed us that she's near constantly waiting for people to betray her.
Plus all of the roughhouse stuff where she's infatuated with someone immune to her powers who hasn't betrayed her.

By comparison, the three examples of Willow characterization are all purely characterizations imparted by the playerbase which basically amounts to 'she has a character, look how she's a blank slate'. Also, we say 'momma didn't raise no liar', but the first time we see her out of our control she's pocketing treasures in the royal vault.

There, you got your post. good bait 10/10.

>>25490915
Got a doctor and engineer both from the two Spaces. Two males for once, three with Gunther.

>>25490935
Pen is a male.

>>25490933
Stealing isn't lying anon.

File: 1439434371737.png (325KB, 640x640px) Image search: [Google]

325KB, 640x640px

>>25490889
>no treasure chests filled with booty

>>25490953
>dont take anything
>okay
>takes thing

>>25490933
>By comparison, the three examples of Willow characterization are all purely characterizations imparted by the playerbase.

Nigga this is a CYOA that is how it should be.

Not this oww the edge crap.

File: LETS BE FRIENDS -SQUAWK-.jpg (332KB, 1250x750px) Image search: [Google]

332KB, 1250x750px

>>25490920
>>25490928
ok
>>25490956
that might be too far.

>>25490968
>implying she wasn't just borrowing it.

>>25490989
>no hook hand

0/10 would not plunder booty with.

>>25490973
It's been consistently stated that a QM should contribute to a character because players inevitably create something bland.

>>25491007
I mean look at Pepper Mint who has absolutely no character to speak of and Sunny Days who is completely schizophrenic.
Hijacker could do a lot worse.

>>25491007
And betrayed outcast with superpower isnt generic as fuck?

File: fucking landlubbers.jpg (333KB, 1250x750px) Image search: [Google]

333KB, 1250x750px

>>25491005
YOU

>>25490915

There's Airy and Qasim from JAD you can add to that crew.

>>25491026
Not if handled correctly, no.

>>25491028
ARRR MATEY

>>25490915

You can use Thunder Wing from Galloping Steel if you want.

>>25491032
Practically anything handled correctly is gonna be good though.

>>25491037
Yes?

>>25491039
So you might as well say "it will be good if its done well"

That doesn't tell you anything.

>>25491021
Who is Pepper Mint?

>>25491050
It's QM input that can work if handled well, not player input. That's the point, it's preexisting character.

>>25490828
She looks like a Bloodborne character in the first pic

>>25491063
That's like saying "Every pirate looks like an Assassin's Creed: Black Flag character".

File: 1443237217291.jpg (127KB, 739x863px) Image search: [Google]

127KB, 739x863px

>>25491063
>gis gets a new weapon
>It's pic related
fund it

>>25491054
11-54 finally got a real name. Pepper Mint to distinguish her from Spearmint.

>>25491074
Yes cus there are many games based around Victorian England with people wearing tricorns and leather coats on the streets and no other media with pirates in them.

>>25491086
And every character wearing tricorns and leather coats must definitely be a reference to that one game where the main character also did.

>>25491093
Where did I say he referenced Bloodborne?

>>25491101
It's just like that bloodborne character is the only case of someone wearing such an outfit you've ever seen.

>>25491058
Player input can be handled just as well.
The QM is gonna have to write around the plays in both cases anyway.

>>25491113
And it works out more often when it's QM input, at lest at first, because they have more direct control over the character.

>>25491110
yeah I said it looked like

LOOKED
LIKE

Not "OMG ITS THAT ONE CHARACTER FROM BLOODBORNE NO ONE HAS EVER CREATED A BEING THAT LOOKED LIKE THIS EVER TRULY THIS IS UNIQUE TO BLOODBORNE"

Why are you even complaining about this?

>>25491113
>>Player input can be handled just as well.
but usually isn't because players don't often volunteer characterization.
And if they don't you're fucked and left with a zombie that follows the players direction.

We had this discussion a few days ago.

>>25491028
I'd plunder her booty.

>>25491127
From what I've observed it's more that most QMs don't take characterization that's inherent in how the players command. They expect the pure characterization to come from players, which isn't really doable.

>>25491075
She already has a sword and crossbow. Total swashbuckler.

>>25491127
both depends on the QM as they are the one writing in either case.
With player input you have to write the character around players actions while QM input is writing the players actions around the character.

Both have advantages and disadvantages.

>>25491157
>both depends on the QM as they are the one writing in either case.
and one depends on the QM and the players providing the material.

The proof is very much in the pudding when it comes to the limitations of blank slates.

>>25491178
The fuck is going on with Tara's butt there?

File: file.png (233KB, 1005x659px) Image search: [Google]

233KB, 1005x659px

>>25491184
REMOVE
BUTT

>>25491184
that question is why its so cropped.
the original drawing had full bat booty but it was a bit off.

>>25491184
Looks fine to me.

>>25491195
At the time fixing it would have taken longer than I'd like.

There will always be time for booty in the future.

File: file.png (23KB, 257x162px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 257x162px

>>25491191
>>25491195
>removing the butt
>ever at any time
You have failed me for the last time, Hinjaku.

>>25491214
He mustu commitu Hijuku

>>25491207
>>25491214
>>25491219
He must draw more Pirate Catbirbs as punishment!

>>25491028
Can you put the hook and the one with the parrot?

>>25491231
That's like a five second edit lad.

I wanna bully treads while panzermane watches and does nothing to help her

>>25491307
>Treads cries and hugs Panzer's leg, sitting on his foot and looking up at him.
>He looks away.

>>25491178
>>25491191
Tara has a stupid face

>>25491307
>>25491335

Whilst I may not be able to stop the bullying, I'll gladly pick her up and give her all the snuggles and tank-shaped ice cream she wants if she comes to me for help. I'll even let her test drive my Tiger II in World of Tanks (and my E-75... when I get around to saving enough credits to actually buy the damn thing...)

She's gonna have to find a new cardboard box somewhere else, though. We need those for our eBay... I imagine Innkeeper probably has some wooden creates lying around, though. Those might do.

I want to play World of Tanks with Treads and Panzer.

Tablet'sfucked, gonna have to get a new one. Getting a better one. See y'all next year if nothing bad happens, like a natural disaster. Or I die.

File: 1445992021028.jpg (15KB, 370x371px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 370x371px

>panzer came back right after i went to bed
Nice

>>25491438
Panzer, you can't keep feeding her delusions. She needs to know her tanks and friends aren't real.

>>25491623
>her tanks and friends aten't real
Neither is panzer

>>25491567
rip

>>25487864
>tank cute little filly

>worse continues

I'm still waiting for that tfh cyoa

>>25491805
What do you hope to find in such a cyoa, except special OC races.

>>25491832
>b-but the lore is by mommy Faust.. it.. it can't be bad :(((

>>25491805
tfh?

>>25491844
the game formerly known as "C&D is magic"

>>25491844
Them's fightin' herds

File: 1447882065893.jpg (145KB, 1111x597px) Image search: [Google]

145KB, 1111x597px

>>25491805
>TFH
lol'd

>>25491845
Oh that.
I'd probably give it a look, but the premise alone certainly wouldn't carry it.

>>25491843
there is lore?

>>25491857
Yes, who could forget the tragic backstory of Arizona Cow's parents?

>>25491851
You won't regret anon, it has such original ideas and names such as baaaaah, baaaaaah and let's not forget baaaaaaah.

>>25491843
>fighting game
>lore
Kekking

>>25491857
Yeah, something along the lines of "eating meat is bad, so all carnivores have been sent to some other dimension where they and their families are doomed to starve, just because they can't change what they have been born as".

>>25491870
Sounds like just what would happen to men if radfems took over, thanks Lauren.

>>25491870
And they're fighting because...

>>25491870
Sweet baby Jesus, that's fucked up.
I have an idea of CYOA based on this sentence. You'd play as carnivore, of course. But I won't start it.

>>25491870
Do all the herbivores starve now because of overpopulation and have to fight for food, and this being the reason for the game?

File: ponyquest.jpg (3MB, 2432x4904px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 2432x4904px

So this is appropriate for /cyoa/, right? Kinda sucks that this never got finished.

>>25491870
I thought the idea was more:
>stop eating things with hooves they're sapient
>lol no
>fine get banished then
I mean there are still predators like dogs and snakes around, so it can't have just been a meat thing.

>>25491899
Nah, this is a different thing.

iirc, this is the kind of thing /tg/ calls a CYOA.

>>25491899
Not really

>pinkie is an engineer
How about no

>>25491899
>>25491911
Exactly, what we call a CYOA is what they call a quest, but in /tg/ these two things are very separated and have their own clans and cultures.

>>25491920
Meh, they all are roleplaying anyways.

>>25491920
before Nips started SS I always thought that CYOA on /mlp/ meant something more funny and random and quest meant a more serious story.

>>25491950
Then you're differentiating by their genre, but they're the same kind of interactive story/roleplay. The difference between >>25491899 and a story of any kind is bigger.

>>25491883
No, that doesn't seem to be an issue. The herbivores are canonically "more intelligent", so I guess they don't have any problems with that.

File: 1439791798962.png (650KB, 691x897px) Image search: [Google]

650KB, 691x897px

>PQ is getting a ME3 ending
Inept pls

>>25487794
i don't see emerald in this picture

>>25492184
Who

>>25491899
I'd swear I've seen a completed version of that somewhere.

Anyway, I take Fallen Princess, Bard Duo, and The Raiders.

>>25492184
>tfw RITS gets on there but you don't
I guess I just have to work harder if I want senpai to notice me...

>>25492288
Don't worry, my friend. You at least have a paper pony, right?

File: 1414437876414.jpg (11KB, 249x250px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 249x250px

>>25492296

File: 1437957311581.png (100KB, 300x304px) Image search: [Google]

100KB, 300x304px

>>25492184
>>25492296
>there's no Emerald paper pone either

>>25488259
All the canon pony races
Mothponies
Satyrs
Changelings
Griffins
Deers

Batponies
Other alicorns
Minotaurs
Dragons
Food ponies
Diamond dogs

>>25492184
To be fair, the base sketch for that image is significantly older than Colt Quest. The most recent quests there are Delta P and OGP, both from early august.

>miscolorings
>layering issues leaving lines where they shouldn't
>pure white character we STILL can't identify on the right
Needs some touching up.

>>25492427
>Want canon pony races
>don't want bat ponies
You have to pick one anon

>>25492646
Those were just costumes :^)

File: Luna's_guards_S2E04.png (866KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

866KB, 1280x720px

>>25492653
This is NOT who I am, and this is NOT OKAY.

We're a culture not a costume.

>>25492669
I'm going to batface and there's nothing you can do about it.

File: 1.jpg (56KB, 508x603px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 508x603px

>>25492653
Afraid not

>>25492685
What did Hasbro say? :^)

>>25492690
Hasbro doesn't write the show

>>25492646
Right, right, I completely forgot that Luna's fangless guards showing up for two seconds means that everything the fandom has made up about them is 100% canon.

>>25492685
Because them mentioning things one time on Twitter totally means that it's been in the show and that everything's canon, right? You retard.

>>25492704
Of course not.
They just decide what's canon.

>>25492713
>Hasbro decides what's canon
>comics
>eqg
>canon
lol

>>25492710
>Basing an entire race off of 2 individuals
It's 2015 anon, time to stop being a bigot

>>25492727
It's not just a river in Egypt.

>>25492710
>>25492713
This is literally the show's writers answering the question of "Hey what are bat ponies" directly to a fan. How are you so stupid as to argue with that?

>>25492673
Shut up Gar

>>25492741
But what did Hasbro say? :^)

>>25492736
But there are tons of fanged bat ponies in the comics

>Shiny's actually getting people to reply
What is this, 3 months ago?

File: maximum overbait.jpg (107KB, 625x626px) Image search: [Google]

107KB, 625x626px

>>25492748

>>25492741
Just ignore Shiny. He just wants his headcanon about batponies to be true.

>>25492758
Took you long enough.

File: 1445044725670.png (110KB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

110KB, 900x900px

>>25492755
Only ear tuft warmers can stop Shiny

File: tumblr_nwgbm1bqlJ1qjefaro1_1280.png (130KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]

130KB, 1000x1000px

>>25492788
Ear tuft warmers and delicious treats to make sure he stays squishy.

>>25492733
>Basing an entire race off of 2 individuals

Nobody had a problem with that in s1 with Luna and Celestia :^)

>>25492733
>Thinking an entire race and everything about them is canon
>Even though pretty much everything about them has been made up entirely by the fandom
It's 2015 anon, time to stop being a fan of the fandom.

>>25492741
Has Luna's guards been seen eating and praising mangoes, sucking blood, hanging upside down, and living in a place called Hollow Shades in the show? No? Wow! that means that it's not canon!
>show's writers
Lauren quit a long time ago, and she's mentioned a ton of things that she would've wanted to put in the show. Does that mean that everything she's said is canon now, even though the show itself says otherwise?

>>25492749
They weren't fanged when they appeared for the first time in the show and the comics.

>>25492758
So every post that questions your retarded headcanons is bait?

>>25492788
>>25492808
I want to hold Shiny in my lap and scratch his mane while he goes through fits of autistic rambling.

File: 1425921603782.png (51KB, 876x773px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 876x773px

>>25492808
>no fat bat husbando with a squishy belly that you can lay your head on

>>25492818
Wow, you're going all out, Shiny.

>>25492818
>Putting words in my mouth
I never said anything that is explicitly part of one CYOA's character to be canon to a whole race. I just said that bat ponies are canonically a separate pony subspecies. And Lauren quit the show AFTER season two- and what season did bat ponies canonically become a thing? That's right- season two!

>>25492864
Anon, don't argue with a retard. He'll only drag you down to his level and beat you with experience.

>>25492874
Upvoted :^)

File: colored sad.png (77KB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

77KB, 900x900px

>>25492788

>>25492874
But what did Hasbro say? ^:)

>>25492864
>And Lauren quit the show AFTER season two-
And it was in season two that Luna's guards showed up -without- fangs, so they canonically don't have fangs. Guess that means that Lauren never intended for them to have fangs.

>>25492874
Because EVERYONE who doesn't blindly love the fanon batponies, every retarded batmeme, and every single thing the fandom has made up about them is a shitposter, right?

>>25492818
Hey Shiny, Vampony has canon batponies. Those batponies don't sleep upside down or have fangs.

Isn't it everything you ever wanted?

>>25492923
Yes.

>>25492923
Yes.

>>25492923
Yes.

>>25492808
>Tumblr
Craft has a tumblr?
D R O P P E D
R
O
P
P
E
D

>>25492953
You having fun there lad?

File: xDxVZ.gif (40KB, 320x224px) Image search: [Google]

40KB, 320x224px

>>25492874
>Anon, don't argue with a retard. He'll only drag you down to his level and beat you with experience.

File: do it.png (386KB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

386KB, 900x900px

>>25492953

File: 1445217993549.png (107KB, 640x600px) Image search: [Google]

107KB, 640x600px

>>25492957
Yes

>>25492788
>>25492912
>That look of true, unending suffering
What did he do to deserve this?

>>25492328
Got a reference or description?

File: 1431755105505.jpg (152KB, 915x913px) Image search: [Google]

152KB, 915x913px

>>25492967

File: file.png (299KB, 640x600px) Image search: [Google]

299KB, 640x600px

>>25492988
Emerald is the filly-looking colt in the middle. Though if you're going to do one it'd be nice if you could do all three. Pretty much the only major characters of the CYOA.

>>25492988
I don't have any references, but I have professional contacts

File: 1444461079002.png (421KB, 800x750px) Image search: [Google]

421KB, 800x750px

>>25492988
Emerald and Hope.

File: 1434212586541.gif (42KB, 500x471px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 500x471px

>>25493000

File: 1448047439431.png (122KB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

122KB, 900x900px

>>25492982
There

>>25493000
>every anon's face in the CC derail

File: 1432531322636.png (576KB, 1300x1000px) Image search: [Google]

576KB, 1300x1000px

>>25493043
>This will never happen again

File: 1439158814581.png (162KB, 800x800px) Image search: [Google]

162KB, 800x800px

There we go

>>25493007
be careful not to lose them!

>>25493076
I'm trying my best to lose them. I think they're hired thugs and they're following me everywhere I go.

File: Untitled.png (26KB, 464x486px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 464x486px

Hey Amm, when I was going around looking for pictures to googly I noticed that things were... wrong.

>>25492953
>>25492970
>>25493000
>>25493039
>>25493075
>>25493106
So you're going to shit up this thread with a ton of googly eye pictures? Because that's totally related to discussions about CYOAs, right?

>>25493175
I thought it was kind of cute. No need to be hostile.

File: pepebizarreadventure.jpg (233KB, 700x700px) Image search: [Google]

233KB, 700x700px

>>25493175
lol

File: 1446420027560.png (771KB, 1225x869px) Image search: [Google]

771KB, 1225x869px

>>25493175

>>25493175
Calm down lad. No harm was being done.

>>25493175
Hey, it was kinda funny the first six times.

Why does everybody in this thread hate bats so much?

>>25493426
It's just one guy.

>>25493433
It's for ants.

>>25493426
We actually just hate you

File: Emerald2.png (834B, 128x128px) Image search: [Google]

834B, 128x128px

>>25493006
Sorry these took so long, I'm a little occupied by other things at the moment.
Forgot to scale them.

>>25493447
ayy

File: Hope.png (1KB, 128x128px) Image search: [Google]

1KB, 128x128px

>>25493447

File: Joyride.png (1KB, 128x128px) Image search: [Google]

1KB, 128x128px

>>25493456
I hope I got the right names for these,
If I fucked anything up, tell me and I'll fix them when I can.

File: 1437605694915.jpg (73KB, 716x768px) Image search: [Google]

73KB, 716x768px

>>25493426
>not hating the disease infecting society

>>25493447
>>25493456
>>25493462
As per usual, nice work paper pone guy.

>>25493447
>>25493456
>>25493462
noice

File: 1pixel.png (2KB, 128x128px) Image search: [Google]

2KB, 128x128px

>>25493456
There's only one pixel that I could say is incorrect. Thanks a ton paperpone.

So, quick question CYOA
Is anybody out there still planning on sequeling/ picking up at the end of cuti-clash. I ask because if you are I'd like to work with you for reasons that may become apparent when my new quest starts up and goes for a while.

>>25493429
>that's what batfags actually believe

>>25493513
Only person that ever expressed a real intention was Owl Eyes and he died of shame.

>>25493550
And I was interested in what he was doing, too. There was no indication that it was tied to CC and it was perfectly fine. Damn guy dropping after getting me invested.

>>25493581
I'm gonna say the opposite. I could tell there was something interesting there, but it wasn't being communicated well.

>>25493426
I actually don't mind bats.
Its the batfags that I don't like.

>>25493590
That's just the thing! It was already there it just needed... something. It's the potential that's just sitting there is what's eating me up.

>>25493634
I don't know exactly what went wrong, but I think I can give it a shot.

It's a case of the QM knowing exactly what's going on, and the characters all do too, so they don't talk about it.
The whole CYOA I was just totally confused about everything.

>>25493657
Going back to my original critique, it was the writing style that did him in mainly. He was trying to emulate a movie, which has difference scene design and pacing than written word.

File: ponka.png (334KB, 1824x1616px) Image search: [Google]

334KB, 1824x1616px

why aren't you bullying Treads, anon?

File: Pegasus Engineering.jpg (34KB, 567x425px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 567x425px

>>25493717
I've done my fair share already. Why aren't you?

>>25493717
I started the fad, my work is done.

File: deep.gif (124KB, 197x197px) Image search: [Google]

124KB, 197x197px

>>25493717
Because I don't give a flying shit about her

File: 1445163364275.jpg (196KB, 1000x647px) Image search: [Google]

196KB, 1000x647px

>>25493513
yeah, I still wanted to take a whack at it

though as it stands, it's gonna be a long while before I can start up on it

>>25493717
I bully all the ponies.

>>25493866
>psycho mantis, a plague doctor, and mothman

>>25493752
Are we going to add boxes to the list of tank shaped things to find?

>>25493717
You can't bully something that is dead anon.

>>25493866
That's fine, I really rather keep the specifics of what I plan on doing under wraps until about three (chapters/missions/sections) in anyway.

>>25493581
>it was perfectly fine

It was literally incomprehensible

>>25494005
I think you can and I think we've seen it happen.

>>25494019
Agreed.

File: paper daring.png (1KB, 128x128px) Image search: [Google]

1KB, 128x128px

Muffin Top concludes now!
>>25436531

DEUS VULT

Trottingham runs a shorter than usual session tonight:
>>25494122

File: 37955575_p0.png (68KB, 1024x1024px) Image search: [Google]

68KB, 1024x1024px

What do QMs do during sessions while waiting for commands from prompts?

>>25494219
I catch up on other quests, watch anime or series, depending on the mood.

File: gold face.png (572KB, 600x580px) Image search: [Google]

572KB, 600x580px

>>25493513
how did I not see this?

>>25494219
Lay the tracks.

>>25494219
Pre-draw/pre-type possible outcomes

>>25494219
Listen to music/drink/write another thing.

>>25494219
Homework, usually

File: I_want_to_get_off_Mr_Bones_Wild_Ride.png (781KB, 1366x768px) Image search: [Google]

781KB, 1366x768px

>>25494219
Worrying about the future and losing hope in myself

>>25493429
>Implying
Because exactly everyone must like it when crap like >>25493467 is posted here, right? Anyone who doesn't love autistic shit like that it is just a samefagging shitposter.

>>25494486
Uh, yeah, especially when the antibatfags are the ones who start shit every time.

>>25494219
planing, doubting myself, slowly dying on the inside

Just the usual QM routine.

>>25494486
>>25494501
Both extremes are complete shit.

I wanna force Treads to breed with a batpone

>>25494486
Because that is so much worse than every other meme that gets posted in here.