Worst recent gundam show?

File: Equal hate.png (438KB, 981x418px) Image search: [Google]

438KB, 981x418px

So /m/ hates them each equally then?

>Iron Boring Orphans
>G Rushed
>Dragon Ball fighters TRY

>>14567911

Oh those 3, TRY. I'd probably put AGE below it though, because it made so many just plain baffling decisions and while the show was mostly boring it was punctuated with some outright stupid and insulting stuff but the more I think about it after viewing the more stupid even a lot of the boring stuff is. And no, that isn't predicated on disliking Kio, whose pacifism wouldn't even make my top 10 lists of things wrong with the show. Nor is it predicated on Flit not genociding the Vagan, which I wouldn't actually want. TRY is boring with no character development despite repeated chance, AGE is boring, stupid and insulting.

And yes I'm aware some people disagree and like it: good for them. I don't discourage them from doing so. It's still my least favorite and worst regardless.

>>14567911
TRY was the worst by a mile.

File: 1461467839824.png (718KB, 979x720px) Image search: [Google]

718KB, 979x720px

Anyone have a solid opinion on why they believe one of these is actually the worst out of the 3?

Seems like the hate for each is pretty equal so far.

>>14568518
Try: Shits on all the good things GBF did while repeating all the bad ones.
IBO: Boring show all around, except that all the missed worldbuilding makes it worse.
G-Reco: I didn't get it, therefore it is stupid.

>>14568538

> Bias? What's that? Are you giving me Philippino hoovers again?

>>14568518
Personally, I'm baffled that IBO isn't dominating this poll. It's practically, "Nothing Happens: The Series." It feel like they only wrote part of an episode for each episode, and then padded it out with a bunch of nothing. There aren't even gratuitous mobile suit battles, which you'd think would be the easy fallback for when you can't write an entire episode's worth of content, but no. There's nothing.

Fighters Try by a large ass margin.

The other two, whatever. But Try was a sequel to a promising new side franchise and completely dropped the fucking ball.

Can we all agree that the 3 of them are better than AGE and SEED?

>>14568546
>It feel like they only wrote part of an episode for each episode, and then padded it out with a bunch of nothing.

They basically did. A whole bunch of stuff got cut out of the original script like Eugene being a traitor and tekkadan fucking up and getting their members killed pointlessly.

G Reco had great animation,art direction and music compared to the other two.
Build fighters had nice animation but shit choreography, IBO is the vice versa of this and it's choreography is extremely hampered by its animation quality.
I'd still put it a notch over build fighters try for its concept, mecha design and music

>>14568456
>G Rush
that sounds like it could be a cool title for a mecha anime.
But what would it be about? Motorcycle power armor? Transformable jets? supa speedy robots?

>>14567911
>So these 3 Gundam TV series are mostly poorly received around here, which is because they happen to be the 3 most recent Gundam TV series.

There, I fixed it.

>>14568617
G Rush would be the underground street racing circuit in the IGPX universe.

>>14568569
SEED was actually good. It went only full retard during SEED Destiny.

>>14568546
Because its actually liked legitimately. Why do you think is getting a s2?

>>14568543
He's not wrong tho

G-Reco: Pure Tomino, not to everybody's taste.

Try: A super-generic toy tournament anime full of waifu-bait.

IBO: A show that tries to sell itself on being edgy, but it's only skin-deep. It feels very safe and subdued. Would have been better as a late-night anime so they could actually get away with some shit.

>>14568658

He is though. Plenty of people dislike the show for legitimate reasons, just because there was lots of shit posting doesn't mean you only dislike it if you don't understand it.

>>14568657
> Why do you think is getting a s2?
Gunpla sales.

IBO. It does everything wrong.

File: 1432242080812.jpg (32KB, 636x622px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 636x622px

>>14568670
>Plenty of people dislike the show for legitimate reasons,

>>14568635
Not with that ugly ass artstyle. The characters are stupidly out of proportion, most notably in the face.

>>14568705

> I have a reaction image therefore I'm right

>>14568622
I like it,
>the MC is caught up in debt and forced to pilot by the yakuza

>>14568787
You don't need a reaction image to know he's right.

>>14568855

And I don't need one to know he's wrong.

>>14568830
>After winning a big race, he has enough money to pay back his debt.
>Instead he blows it all and goes even deeper into debt to upgrade his robot, wagering that he'll be able to win even more in the next race.
>Next race he loses horribly, he's injured, and his robot gets thrashed beyond repair.
>End credits for Episode 1.

>>14568858
But he isn't.

File: 1462438844486.jpg (49KB, 393x358px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 393x358px

Home come Greco brings out the pettiest of posters?

Just shut the fuck up already. Who cares if you like it or hate it, you're not going to change the other person's mind.

File: __mai_pilaf_and_trunks_dragon_ball_and_dragon_ball_super_drawn_by_ameneko__2f42c8958b3a49b5b122de3b6df74648-1.jpg (27KB, 350x255px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 350x255px

I like Reco and found Try watchable (I agree season 1 was better but I think it is overblown) I get why people hated Try tho. Could not watch IBO. It was boring and ugly, same with Age and the SEED shows for me.

>>14568902
Because G-Reco fags have done their darndest to get on everybody else's nerves.
They're basically the precursors to the Capekino Snyderfags from /tv/, making some embarrassing shit out to be a thought provoking masterpiece and verbally assaulting anybody who didn't like it.

File: why.png (359KB, 720x540px) Image search: [Google]

359KB, 720x540px

>>14568902
>Provoking shitposters on purpose.

Why? What does this accomplish other than generating more shitposting about G-Reco and making more people vote for it as the worst? Unless that's what you actually want, in which case good job.

greco: good writing, bad director, a mess
try: boring, uninspired, fanservice virus
ibo: another gendum show, shitty writing, fuck the MC

try is the worst of the 3
nothing is worst than seed, destiny, age

>>14568518
G-reco is sorta incoherent but it's better than IBO. At least in G-reco things happen. The animation and fight scenes are really well done and choreographed. IBO sure as hell can't claim that.

File: 14680082653228.png (284KB, 628x465px) Image search: [Google]

284KB, 628x465px

>>14568705

>Gundam G no Reconguista
>33%
I didn't know there were so many retards on /m/

File: (You).jpg (359KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

359KB, 1280x720px

>>14568914

File: 1406595098347.png (2MB, 2352x2404px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 2352x2404px

I'm still assmad about Age. None of these look that bad in comparison.

Each of those shows are deemed bad for their own reason, I doubt it's because they're new. I mean I quite liked recoguista and while try didn't live up to it's potential it was entertaining at a few parts.

>>14567911
>Try
A not as good version of Build Fighters which was overrated anyway
>G-Reco
It was pretty and easy to follow until the last third or so
>IBO
One of the absolute worst anime I have ever seen that did everything wrong, may Ein Graze join Skarbrand in /m/echa Valhalla

>>14569563
>until the last third or so
Found the retard

>>14569577
I thought Greco was great though

>>14568635
SEED began sticking crayons up it's nose when Kira got the Freedom.

Try was bad, I didn't mind IBO, Haven't seen G-reco.

What's G-reco fan's top 3 favorite mecha series. If they are similar to mine I guess I'll give it a watch.

>>14569625
Zeta
V
0079

File: image.jpg (28KB, 410x558px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 410x558px

I am incredibly biased against TRY because Gundam Build Fighters is uniroically my favorite Gundam. I couldn't even finish that shit.

>>14570035
>Gundam Build Fighters is uniroically my favorite Gundam
2. You will immediately cease and not continue to access the site if you are under the age of 18.

>>14570042
>I hate fun
>The only good gundam are the ones for mature viewers such as myself.
Ok.

>>14569625
Fafner
Victory Gundam
Heroic Age

>>14570050
>I literally have 12 years old: the post
Go back to your summer camp kid

>>14570189
>have 12 years old
>have
spic detected

File: image.jpg (10KB, 165x171px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 165x171px

>>14570189
>I'll just call him underaged, that'll do it.

>>14570195
This isn't the getter thread Pablo

>>14570198
Keep crying kiddo

G-Reco was so boring. There was never any real danger or gravity to what was happening. It was a struggle to even finish it cuz there was just nothing to be interested in following.

Try and IBO I was at least interested in tuning in each week to see what was gonna happen, even if it ended up being disappointing.

File: o0582033012709003398.jpg (31KB, 582x330px) Image search: [Google]

31KB, 582x330px

>Special episode was supposed to be launched this month
>Show got penalized and postponed due to VA leaving for new record company
>wait till 2017

>>14570210
Fuck off Carlos

What does /m/ thinks about Turn A

>>14570551
/m/ thinks it's shit.

I know, because I just called it.

>>14570595
Please stop baitposting Turn A sucks everytime someone mentions it.

File: 1445180383356.jpg (8KB, 259x194px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 259x194px

To those who liked G-Reco, where would you rank it among the rest of the Gundams you've watched?

To those who liked IBO, where would you rank it among the rest of the Gundams you've watched?

To those who liked Try, why haven't you killed yourselves already? You're waifus all a cancer and shit btw.

>>14570551
It's usually highly regarded around here. Are you new?

File: 1466799619018.jpg (98KB, 600x410px) Image search: [Google]

98KB, 600x410px

Honestly even the original Build Fighters is iffy as hell to me. The fights were amazing and it really makes you want to buy gunpla, but it was the most predictable pile of shit imaginable. You knew how just about every fight was going to go from start to finish right when the brackets were shown. Made me much less invested and kinda pissed off knowing everything that was going to happen.

Frankly outside of the fights being worse, I don't see how Try is so bad in comparison.

>>14570660

I think G-Reco is basically second to Turn-A by virtue of Turn-A being longer and having more room to breathe. They're both excellent proper sci-fi and have broken out of Gundam's rigidity of storytelling.

>>14570551
What does /m/ think about X?

>good show disguised as a bad show
>kid's show
>bad show disguised as a good show

>>14570660
>To those who liked G-Reco, where would you rank it among the rest of the Gundams you've watched?
1. 0079
2. Turn A
3. Either G-Reco or CCA

>>14570511
Why are you so mad Mario? I just said that this isn't the getter thread, so you're not supposed to be here.

>>14570894
You left out the gratuitous gunota wank. They omitted it in try and the gunota hated it because "WHY AREN'T THEY SPERGING OVER GUNPLA ITSELF LIKE LAST TIME"

It knew what Gundam was, what gunpla was and why people love them, and made a point to show those things. One of the most poignant scenes is when Ral is showing off a new MS-06J model to Sei and Reiji, who is confused when Ral says it's not for fighting. Ral and Sei enjoy a moment of autism about all the ways to enjoy gundam.

>>14571521
>"Great moves, kid! How many models have you built?
>"None lol"
>"FFFFFFFF GO PLAY WITH A FUCKING ACTION FIGURE REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE"
The battle bar was so great.

>>14571528
>Reiji starts beating their ass with a ball

Do i need to watch something before watching "Turn a gundam?"

Try. When the moon blew with the bird attack, I knew it's the worst.

File: Barbatos.png (1MB, 1127x639px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1127x639px

>>14569563
G-Reco felt like a 48-ish series that got cut in half. It started off decently, and I actually rather liked the suits - sure the main gundam was a special-A kind of ugly, but it fit, and the other suits were varying levels of "this has great plamo potential if it catches on enough to get some sweetass ova detail". And the plot, being so far in the future with all that shit in the museums could easily have given us evilly tantalizing glimpses into how things went after unicorn, etc...

But, instead, it starts compacting itself more and more midway, and suddenly the war that should've been building towards for the past 35ish episodes, before what would usually be the final arc, happens and is over in the final two episodes, a good ten early, the end.

Speaking of midway through what the fuck's with the OPs switching to some faggy shit halfway through the season? G-Reco and IBO both pulled that one on us.

>>14571552
No, but you'll get more out of it if you've seen every Gundam that came before it. It ties all of them together

File: spookyghosts.gif (443KB, 500x343px) Image search: [Google]

443KB, 500x343px

>>14570098
>Heroic Age
>That sameface studio
>It looks like it'll be some more homoerotic "Kazuki! are you there? "Soushi, I'm so here... I'm here, are you there?" with fights that get hinted at in the fucking previews and then literally don't happen
>Well, there's nothing better at all to watch tonight I might as well give it two ep~
>Kaiju?
>Apocalyptic bug-swarms and their psychic overlords?
>THE TWELVE FUCKING LABORS OF SPACE GODZILLA?!?!?
>STOP! STOP!!! MY PENIS CAN ONLY GET *SO* ERECT!

Honestly, I'd say TRY. I enjoyed Build Fighters & so the disappointment was even higher when TRY failed to deliver.

>>14571570
G-Self's head had a "NYORO~N" quality to it.

>Try
Like the previous show in the franchise, it was pretty much an ad for Gumpla and I hate shows that try to advertise crap to you as strongly as build fighters. I watched the original OVA and deviced that I'd stay far away from these ads disguised as garbage shows

>G-rekt
I can understand why the autists who constantly complain about too much 3D CG in anime would defend this mess, but that doesn't mean that the actual show is any good. The writing is roughly on the same level as that of Ed Wood, i.e you can follow if you pay good attention and pretentious idiots like to act as if anyone who can't be bothered to follow closely enough is retarded.

>IBO
A dumb shonen anime for those who like shonen stuff. Sadly releasing just after G-rekt plenty of the same autists who defended G-rekt attacked this for not trying to be the same kind of supposedly intricate space opera G-rekt tried to be, but failed at it. The main character was also a nice change, not being the usual whiny autist, but more along the lines of Garrod Ran from X.

>>14568635
I wouldn't go that far. Before completely shitting the bed in Destiny it was pretty mediocre before hand.

>>14571687
Do try Breaker 3 though even if you dislike the 'ads for gunpla'. Unlike Try it's fiendishly addictive, and it's hard not to smirk a little when you're fighting atop boxes in the back of a store in certain modes.

>>14571687
>Ed Wood
wat? that was a really simple fun movie

>>14568657
Because it was planned that way you dolt.

>>14571687
>pretentious idiots like to act as if anyone who can't be bothered to follow closely enough is retarded.
But it's true, every single question they asked could be answered by just paying atention to the goddamn show.

>>14569625
Genesis of Aquarion, Dendoh, and Dougram

IBO, it's the most boring show of the three.

File: 3way.png (432KB, 953x395px) Image search: [Google]

432KB, 953x395px

I'm impressed how divided this poll is

>>14567911
I wish G-Reco had a more comprehensible script because it's one of the few decent looking Gundam shows

>>14567911
I still don't get why people don't like G-Reco. You have to really pay attention while watching it, sure, but it had a lot of interesting shit most anime in space don't address and it was generally a good time.

>>14567911
They're all shit, famalam.

File: 1460525090381.gif (2MB, 491x271px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 491x271px

Since all three shows are highly flawed, it's easier to rank them based on where they did well.

>G Reco
Beautiful animation

>Try Fighters
Gave us the Tryon 3

>IBO
???

Looks like we have a winner!

File: tryon3_zpsdpcmlnos.jpg (9KB, 100x94px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 100x94px

>>14573616
>Gave us the Tryon 3
Good man

>>14573616
IBO gave us Hyakuri, Gusion, Grimgerde, and Barbatos and Kimaris if you're into that. I think it's definitely the worst of the three, but if Tryon 3 is enough to carry Try, it's unfair to say IBO didn't have its good designs.

>>14573644
In terms of MS design, I'd rank them like so:
G-Reco > IBO > Try

>>14573578

It's like this scene from Mission Hill

https://youtu.be/Su9C1XRttLc?t=4m45s

People have their own ideas about what is good storytelling, pacing, character development, etc and they want the shows they watch to conform to those ideas. Some people believe that a good show will allow the viewer to follow along, while others believe a good show allows the viewer to figure things out for themselves. Some people call exposition lazy while others gush about all this world-building. You get the idea.

G-Reco is a sci-fi anime that doesn't ease it's viewer into the world. It takes off right out of the gate and expects them to be able to keep up. They're supposed to pick up little details about the world, which is different from our own, and the dialogue offers information in a casual sort of way that people can easily overlook. People get lost along the way as a result, and they declare it bad. Simple really.

There was that one review of G-Reco where they talked about how in today's information age, people are losing the ability to figure things out for themselves. That people feel frustrated when things don't instantly make sense to them, so we look online for simple explanations as to what we don't understand. Just a little food for thought, but considering the moral of G-Reco is "figure the world out for yourself rather than just listening to your elders/nation/religion/etc," (or as the tagline put it, "see it with your own eyes") there may be something to what that reviewer had to say.

Plus, people watch anime for enjoyment. If G-Reco doesn't work for them, it doesn't work for them.

IBO is not finished yet, so far it's still much better than G.

G Reco is garbage.

TRY is for kids, and it doed a great job at that. Anyone saying TRY is bad is just a neckbeard.

>>14568937
That same reaction image is always in any thread in which G-Reco is criticized hence it's the same dude.

>>14567911
They're all equally terrible in different ways.