Who is the most consistently good /m/ creator?

>>13519053
Imagawa.

>>13519053
okada

Kawamori

Me

>>13519058
>>13519062
>>13519065
Re-read OP's question please

>Who is the most consistently good /m/ creator?
>consistently good

>>13519053
Go Nagai

>>13519053
Fukuda.

>>13519077
Not our fault he didn't explain what he considers good.

>>13519053
Pic unrelated right?

>>13519053
70's and 80's Tomino

Zambot 3
Daitarn 3
Gundam
Ideon
Xabungle
Dunbine
L-Gaim
Zeta Gundam

Ishikawa
rip

>>13519080
>>13519142
My Dyna Pro brethren.

File: bayfinger_size3.png (215KB, 590x295px) Image search: [Google]

215KB, 590x295px

>>13519053
The Bay

I want to say Dezaki up until a certain point in his like, but the majority of his stuff wasn't /m/.

Takahashi was on the ball for a pretty long time.

>>13519077
okada

>>13519141
>Zeta Gundam
>good
You failed anon

>>13519053
Ishinomori

>>13519278

This.

>>13519288
Was wondering when you were going to pop up.

>>13519278
No.

Imagawa for sure. Total perfection

>>13519258
>Zeta Gundam
>bad

stop being a contrarian hipster

>>13519053
Dr. Light.

>>13519053
Dr. Wily

>>13519053
Dr. Cossack

Anno
He only made 2 mecha anime tho, but he does have consistency.

If you're asking who made most good Mecha, it's a tie with Tomino and Go Nagai.

>>13519319
>implying I dislike Zeta because I'm a hipster
No, I dislike it because it's a shit show, and many people are also realizing this, except Zetafags like you.

>>13519053
Dr. Robotnik

Ryosuke Takahashi

>>13519058
Imagawa gets a lot of love for a guy who's great 10% of the time and recycles the other 90%

File: 1429428032746.jpg (50KB, 540x368px) Image search: [Google]

50KB, 540x368px

>>13519337

>>13519053
Yokoyama

>>13519357
Isn't that Obari u pleb

>>13519378
Why not both? Maybe even count everyone mentioned in this thread, too.

>>13519372

And also this.

>>13519332
ok dude, you're a special snowflake, congratulations

>>13519080

this is objectively wrong

>>13519080
>>13519142
>>13519278
>>13519372
I like these four the most
>>13519288
>>13519394
>>13519413
You can fuck right the hell off though.

>>13519415

this is partially correct

They're all consistent at what they're doing. The problem is the audience's expectations.

Tomino's storytelling hasn't changed over 40 years. It's the audience who changed.

Same for Nagai. He has been doing the same masturbatory material over 40 years.

Takahashi? Military masturbation with some
nationalistic tendencies, over 30 years.

Oshii? Dull anime for dull people to enjoy. Again, 30 years.

Yokoyama? Muh chink classics.

Ishinomori? Muh super heroes.

Imagawa? Muh sins (and shota)

Ishikawa? Rape face, repeat till 06.

Anno? Muh depression, muh symbolism, muh rehash.

Obari? OBARI.

Just pick your poison man.

>>13519432
I actually like you doing this kind of shitposting. It's vaguely entertaining. Good job.
>>13519445
These are some of the most amazing generalizations I've seen in a while. Must've been hard work to do.

>intentionally make a shitposting thread
For what purpose?

>>13519464

Shitpost, what else?

>>13519445
>Obari? OBARI.
>not MUH KANADA

>>13519445
You have a point there... A better question would be, who are the most inconsistent /m/ creators?

>>13519520
HORSECOCKS

>>13519520

Go Nagai

>>13519528
Already counted under consistent whether you like it or not.

>>13519453
u forgot your trip

>>13519552
What the hell are you talking about?

>>13519520
Fukada.
Dendoh, which is great.
SEED, which is kind of crap but not as bad as half the other AU Gundams.
Destiny, which is so crap that legends say it created /m/.
Cross Ange, which is bad in an amazing way.

No two Fukada shows are alike.

>>13519058

I'm not sure how much of a creator you can really do Imagawa. Imagawa to me seems to do his best work when he's creating love letters to the authors that inspired him and there's nothing wrong with that but he's more tinkering with others characters and stories.

>>13519558
Where does Cyber Formula fall in on that list?

>>13519560
I can see your point, but personally, I think G gundam Shin Mazinger and Giant Robo are all fantastic, so I believe that he's consistently the best mecha guy.

File: 1387892955321.jpg (331KB, 717x1918px) Image search: [Google]

331KB, 717x1918px

>>13519608
>forgetting Tetsujin 28

>>13519558
Fukuda was the producer for Cross Ange, so I don't think he can be regarded as a creator for that one.

>>13519608
>>13519613

And from all those, only Tetsujin and Giant Robo were love letters to the author that inspired him. He's just good.

>>13519520
I don't think anyone can peg down Noboru Ishiguro.
http://anidb.net/perl-bin/animedb.pl?show=creator&creatorid=151

>>13519631
Shin Mazinger was more like hate mail.

>>13519445
>Anno? Muh depression
>Gunbuster

>>13519704

It's understandable, since the original Mazinger is a half assed piece of shit.

>>13519704
Except not at all?

>>13519728
Can you not just fuck off and lick Ishinomoris/Yokoyamas nutsack like we all know you want to instead of shit on Nagai ?

>>13519445
>Yokoyama? Muh chink classics until he died in a Big Fire.
Fixed it for you.

>>13519749

There's nothing objectively wrong with that statement. Actually, Nagai himself would probably agree with it. He admits he did not put much effort into it.

>>13519774
I don't care.

Shinkai

>>13519053
I was going to say Tadao Nagahama, but then I've heard the second half of Combattler V was kind of bad.

Still, 4.5 /m/ series done by him, and all but half of one of them was good. That's a pretty solid track record.

>>13519853

None of them is exceptionally good either.

File: 1383209092867.gif (875KB, 220x220px) Image search: [Google]

875KB, 220x220px

>>13519631
>>13519774
>>13519704
And here you can observe the Spic in his natural environment.

>>13519704
>le Shin Mazinger is bad meme

Fuck off. You don't belong on /m/ if you dislike Shin Mazinger.

>>13519887
but the part that mazinger was half assed is true, after all, he was doing devilman at the time as well.
keep naming spic to anyone and the real shitposter will escape you idiot

>>13519887
I hope for your sake that your third quote was supposed to be >>13519728

>>13519732
>>13519893
Le OC donut steel mary sue is the main character XD
Who is Sayaka? Is she in this anime? Oh fuck better give her some lines too.
HEY GUYS DON'T FORGET ABOUT *MY* CHARACTER THE WORLD REVOLVES AROUND HER
SHE'S BETTER THAN KOUJI
SHE'S BETTER THAN MAZINGER Z
SHE'S BETTER THAN EVERY CHARACTER AND ACTUALLY EVERYBODY LOVES HER, AND INSTEAD OF COOL MECHA ACTION WE'RE GOING TO FOCUS ON POORLY-WRITTEN MELODRAMA ABOUT HER!

>>13519853
On that note, Shuuji Iuchi somehow managed to keep Wataru good, even though his other fantasy efforts more or less stumble.

>>13519907
Nice try Carlos

>>13519445
>Muh blank
For fuck's sake, just talk! Speak words! Elucidate your thoughts! You seem to genuinely believe what your saying, so I don't think you're bait, but for everloving sake of fuck, talk like a human being!

>>13519907

Escape from what?

>>13519919
>Tsubasa
>OC
So it's you again.
>>13519925
Oddest suspicion of falseflagging or newfaggotry.

>>13519053
Gee, to read this thread you'd think every Mecha creator is a hack. The fuck happened to this board?

>>13519943
Shitposters for even the tiniest of fanbases.

>>13519949
Its incredible. This place has become so incestuous. I hate to say it, but it might be better for the community if we got a rush of new users, liven things up a bit

>>13519941
>taking a minor, possibly unnamed character from an unrelated manga and coopting her into the main character of a Mazinger Z remake with all of the Mazinger Z elements removed somehow prevents her from being an oc donut steel
I guess Sonic recolors aren't OC donut steels either.

>>13519952
At least there are alternatives. Mostly dead ones, but still.

File: 048.jpg (344KB, 1342x1790px) Image search: [Google]

344KB, 1342x1790px

Go Nagai
>some of the most genre shaping series
>probably the most mecha classics/hits
>one of the most prolific manga creators ever
>acclaimed basically everywhere but the USA
>radically different styles of works, always exploring new concepts in the genre
>sheer body of different and new works rivals even heavily commercialized franchises like Gundam and Kamen Rider
>a large influence for Japanese creators, dating back to the 1970s

sage

>>13519943
>>13519952
Why are you two taking trolls so seriously?
Are you new?

An influx of new users would be nice though. Not to much of course, nothing on the level of /v/ or /a/.

>>13519968
You shouldn't have posted that here anon.

>>13519968

The delusion is strong with this one.

File: gekiman1.png (87KB, 261x429px) Image search: [Google]

87KB, 261x429px

>>13519968

>>13519934
from getting called of course, once you slam that acusation to the ground, every time the fucker shitpost and some one called him on his bullshit, either labeling spic or not, everyone will invalidate it

>>13519974
Because some of them never go away and are in every thread related to their shitposting material all day long, as I'm sure you know.

>>13520012

Oh, that will show him! The little bastard...!

>>13520014
Ever been to /v/?

>>13519715
Gunbuster kinda was about mild depression, though.

>>13520037
A couple of times. Likely never again though.

>>13519053
Kouki

>>13519919
spic you're too obvious

I am

>>13521282
>literal opposite of spicposting
>hurr durr spic
Oh my god, fucking kill yourself newfag.

>>13521412
>literal opposite of spicposting
Holy fucking shit, and you call me a newfag?

I was here when Shin Mazinger aired.

Spics hate Shin Mazinger because not muh zinger.

You're the fucking newfag here. Kill yourself, spic.

>>13521449
>Spics hate Shin Mazinger because not muh zinger.
Spics hate Shin Mazinger because it's not TOEIZINGER, you fucking neanderthal. I hate it because it's a shitty anime and nothing like the manga to boot (which spics also hate). And don't pretend that "spic" isn't just some buzzword for "dynamic pro fan I disagree with," when in reality it's "obnoxious, hispanic toei robot fan"

>>13519053

Ryosuke Takahashi?

>>13519564
TV series (and Double One) is a decent show. It's just a simple kid show in the 90s. It did nothing spectacular or bad but it works. 11 closed the only plot thread left hanging in the tv series because it was cut short

Zero is 10/10 if you removed the crappy SAO-tier romance. It's basically Ayrton Senna: The Animation.

Saga and Sin are SEED-tier shit.

>>13519053
Nagano.

>>13519953
He pretty much did to Mazinger what he had already done to Giant Robo. Is that "hate mail" as well?

>>13522618
Giant Robo fans are by far the biggest cancer on this site.

>>13521491
But that's what I just said you fucking horsecock sucker.

Muh zinger = Toeizinger

Learn to read.

>shin mazinger
>nothing like the manga to boot
Top fucking kek, now I know you're the piece of shit who keeps ruining every mazinger thread he finds.

Kill yourself.

>>13522704
What the fuck are you smoking?

I barely see any Giant Robo threads around.

Gundam fags are by far the biggest cancer this board has to offer. Get real, faglord.

>>13522724
>I barely see any Giant Robo threads around.
That's because they derail other threads.

>>13522733
Yeah sure.

Think before you type and stop spouting bullshit.

Time to grab some popcorn

>>13522704
Can you answer the question instead of attacking me personally?

>>13521528
Sounds about right.

>>13519608
Giant Robo is my favorite OVA and probably favorite anime and the only thing that could have over throne it was if Imagawa completed Getter Robo Armageddon. But as I said both are love letters.

>>13519631
I love Imagawa. I really do. But even though G Gundam is nothing like previous Gundam I still see it as him playing with others toys. And I don't knock him for it. If anything had I the money I would just give it to Imagawa and tell him to make more homages to the things he loves.

>>13521528
So basically non of his works are the same, right.

>>13526027
Pretty much, yeah.