What's the difference between poems and poetry?
Poetry is the art, poems are the medium.
>>8757841
but... medium is the art
>>8757846
A finished painting is not the process of painting.
>>8757846
>art w/o concepts
>>8757848
but that implies that all that makes up "poetry" is unfinished poems
>>8757857
Le Checkmate
gg
>>8757840
Perhaps a sufficient analogy would be that of Sinn vs Bedeuteng. The <i>poem</i> characterizes Bedeuteng, the <i>poetry</i> is the Sinn - related: Millian <i>connotation</i>.
Consider the following:
>Here, said she, Is your card, the drowned Phoenician Sailor, (Those are pearls that were his eyes. Look!) Here is Belladonna, the Lady of the Rocks, The lady of situations...The Hanged Man. Fear death by water. I see crowds of people, walking round in a ring.
Is the Phoenician Sailor the hanged man? The Sinn of the "Phoenician Sailor" exists, but the Bedeuteng may not denote through ostension some object in-der-welt. The <i> poetry </i> exists, but the poem does not.
>eσπερος είναι το ίδιο πλανήτη kαι φωσφόρου
In Modal logic, we also have a famous example of Sinn/Bedeuteng. Kripkean semantics resolves this issue, but it serves as a useful analogy nonetheless.
>>8757857
It does not imply that, because the English language is not perfectly logical.
Someone doing poetry is poetry, poems are also poetry. Someone doing painting is painting, paintings are also paintings.