Was Sherlock Holmes a Mary Sue? He was literally never wrong.

>>8257208
...someone hasn't read Scandal in Bohemia.

You'd have to be pretty delusional if you don't find anything wrong with a coke addicted, anti-social misanthrope that... Wait, I just remembered I'm on 4chan. Forget what I said.

>>8257373
tee hee

>>8257352
Once out of 40-something stories and four novels?

>>8257373
Epic upboat my good sir! XDXD

No, he's a combination of hipster shit and a friend of Doyle's who was a doctor. Doyle kind of hated him, which is why he tried to kill him off, and then had to come up with more hipster shit that would save his life when the fans revolted.

>>8257424
Also, Doyle believed in fairies and shit.

He was wrong once in a while. He also had a shitload of personal issues.

Would you really want to read a detective story where the detective is wrong?

>>8257424
Define hipster

>>8257424
What do you think hipster means?

>>8258744
YES

>>8258828

Yeah, after I typed that out I started thinking about it and realised that it'd be pretty interesting.