AGP here. Are my hips wide enough to fool the boys? Or am I forever doomed to hon status?
passgen, individual body part edition: for those of us too afraid to post our faces, submit individual body parts for commentary on whether they might pass here
>>8749871
Oh wow your hips are even higher than mine, but you don't have the weird violin hips as bad as I do.
Really hoping hrt gets rid of my violin hips cause mine are like 100x worse than yours despite my hips not being high like yours are.
>>8749891
>Oh wow your hips are even higher than mine, but you don't have the weird violin hips as bad as I do.
Iktf
>Really hoping hrt gets rid of my violin hips
Sadly it doesn't tbqh. Source: Me 2.5 yrs on HRT.
>>8749901
I haven't been on hrt long and I've noticed it reducing though. It was actually one of the biggest changes I've noticed and I'm only 6 months in.
It's really noticeable to me though because I've had it my entire life
>>8749871
Still narrower than the skinniest cis girl, but men are clueless anyway
>>8749932
>female broader pubic arch >90
is this why they have a noticeable thigh gap?
>>8749891
Violin hips are sexy on girls
t. bulldyke
>>8749948
Thigh gap comes from both the fact that their pubic arch is larger but also because the angle of inclination in their femoral attachment to the pelvis is different from males
>>8749953
I don't really like girls ;_;
>>8749957
Also over the course of a lifetime despite women hovering close to cox vara and men hovering around cox valga due to gravity and Wolff's Law both men and women will end up at <120 degrees.
Both men and women end up with wide hips due to gravity and Wolff's Law over the course of your life.
The only thing actually stopping mens bones from feminizing is muscle that resists gravity's effects on widening hips and lowering the angle of inclination of your female. You simply cannot defeat Wolff's Law and gravity though.
>>8749989
of your hips*
weird spelling error lol
>>8749871
>Are my hips wide enough to fool the boys?
>to fool the boys?
>to fool
How can you guys fucking defend the idea that you're not trying to 'trap' people when you talk like this? Why shouldn't some asshole feel attacked when you try to 'fool' them?
>>8749993
b-but we don't want to fool in the literal sense
we just want them to put their hands on our hips and fondle our sad neglected bodies we ourselves hate tbqh
>>8750012
If you could push a button, and immediately become passable in all ways, but everyone in the world instinctively knows you're trans, would you push the button?
If you wouldn't, it means that you're a bad person and basically justify althese 'trans panic' manslaughter cases.
>>8750024
lmao that's not an accurate analogy at all. Being trans means you want to be a girl not be trans. Nobody fucking wants to be a tranny, it's just what reality is.
>>8750024
yes
who gives a shit about what you normies want to believe I don't have to interact with you enough to care.
>>8750031
Yeah, but not pushing the button means you value controlling other people's informed actions over accomplishing what you really want, which is supposedly to be and live as a girl.
So do you want to be a girl or do you want for no one to know you're trans? Do you actually care about your 'true self' or do you just hate your current self?
>>8750047
You're twisting words because in an ideal world nobody would be trans. Nobody wants to be a transsexual it's just the reality of life.
Nobody wants to be known as trans for the same reason that nobody wants to be born with an incurable disease.
>>8750051
>ITT: /pol/ agrees with retards that agree with their twisted ideals, news at 11
>>8750024
> immediately become passable in all ways, but everyone in the world instinctively knows you're trans
> but everyone in the world instinctively knows you're trans
you just described what being "unpassable" is, dummy
if everyone could tell i am trans then i am not passable, duh
>>8750052
Imagine this change to the original question, you're born male, you press the button, you get randomized and spat out as an average female, essentially not trans anymore in any real sense, but people KNOW you pushed the button, and, if you believe in spirituality, for the sake of this problem your 'soul' is still the same.
Do you press the button then?
The point I'm trying to get as, assuming you could get everything you really want, would you also afford that ability to other people, assuming their true desires include "not dating or physically contacting trans people," if your desires require that you rob someone of their own, are you a good person and are your desires really 'just' or 'good.'
>>8750084
I will keep pressing the button
>>8750084
The thing is you're presenting a situation that is not in reality. You are saying that people will always know you are not a cis girl thus your argument is a fallacy.
Your argument is neither intelligent, correct, it's full of holes, and it's easily shot down in event basic juniour high school debates. I'd expect that level of intelligence out of a 10-15 year old though.
>>8749993
>Op said something
>"How can you guys..."
>>8750100
The argument isn't a fallacy, it's fucking magic. It's a hypothetical. Hypothetical's can't be fallacious. You're just trying to avoid telling me if you'd press the button or not, because despite not giving a shit about my opinion you somehow care how I'll judge you for it.
Just fucking answer the question.
>>8750101
Fair point, I concede that.
>>8749993
OP here. When I say "fool", I mean fool the base instincts into thinking I look like a girl with a cursory assessment. I don't mean "fool into sleeping with someone who looks like a girl, and then I flop out my dick".
I'm not quite so duplicitous, nor am I a complete idiot. I have no desire to get murdered.
I just want to look pretty.
>>8750154
You cool then.
Fallacy-fag is still of sucking up that swamp though, will probably take him a while
Good luck looking pretty, remember that most people don't look good in sheer fabrics. For some reason, the handful of trans people I've met all look like they're wearing dresses made out of bed sheets.
>>8749891
>Oh wow your hips are even higher than mine
Could this perhaps be because I'm freakishly tall?
I haven't actually been on any hormones. I wonder how they'd change my hip shape, if at all.
Here's another view
>>8749957
I don't understand this. I'm a cis male and I have a thigh gap, but I don't have wide hips at all.
>>8749871
Hey OP just wanna let you know u look good and nice guys like me dont care what you look like so long as u take care of yourself (shave, etc). :) It's who u are that counts.
>>8749871
you pass
>>8749871
Uh, uh, this is where we share insecurities?
Here I am too.
>>8749932
> but men are clueless anyway
This is the things that gives me hope. I mean, is not great, I still feel like shit, but at least people won't point you and laugh...
>>8751474
>>8751474
10/10 would transbian
how fucked is this body for passing as male, theoretically?
>>8751474
How long on hormones?
>>8751768
not bad at all. you already look like a MTF
>>8751272
OP here. Seriously? No hugboxing now. Aren't they kind of high?
>>8751265
Thanks anon. I do what I can to take care of myself, and it's nice to know that someone out there might appreciate it.
>>8751474
>Uh, uh, this is where we share insecurities?
Yes, this is where you share your insecurities. And congrats, you have nothing to be insecure about with regard to your hips. With a waist so narrow and hips so wide, I wouldn't doubt that you're female for a second.
Judging by the breast tissue, I'm guessing you've been or hormones for a while. Did they grow to that size naturally?
>>8751474
>nice body,gj
>>8751768
i think shes a cit gurl wanting to go for FtM transition, looks good anyway as a gurl
>>8749871
>meh
>>8751474
i seriously struggle to beleive this isnt a cis girl memeing us
>>8751474
I NEED to shove my cock in you
>>8751988
>i seriously struggle to beleive this isnt a cis girl memeing us
>lawl
>TFW MIDDLE-AGED MAN TORSO FUCKING KILL ME OH MY GOD
front view
>>8752302
I've seen your pre-stupid pics
You could have been a 10/10 chad
What is wrong with you
>>8752302
>>8752308
>>8752308
Your eyes are so awesome lol
It's some sort of disease that causes that isn't it?
>>8752505
It's neat but I'd imagine it sucks in the real world. Life is shitty
>>8752505
discussing this is out of topic.
i want to congratulate with you for the courage of posting full body + face tho
>>8749957
old people get their hips replaced
can angle adjustment be used to give trannies wider hips and shorter height?
how bad is my jawline /tttt/
25 mtf, 9 months hrt
>>8752332
implying there aren't tonnes of cis girls with waist/hip ratios like that (and even worse)
>>8751474
Holy hells. Please live on my island and be single.
>>8752584
You could use magnets to stretch hips. It's been done for rib cages. There's a treatment for pectus excavatum that uses a magnetic brace and a surgically implanted magnet on the sternum to fix the rib cage.
We know that gravity causes both mens and womens hips to enlarge as they age, this is due to bone remodelling being a constant process as well as bone turnover. Simply yanking down on your iliac crest would change the shape due to 3 processes: Wolff's law states that due to external forces it induces bone modeling, you'd also get normal bone remodelling that fixes microfractures throughout your entire life, and normal bone turnover rate occurs over your whole lifespan.
This isn't speculation either, it's been done already.
>>8752628
How high is the arthritis risk if you fuck this?
>>8751474
I'm legit crying looking at this pic...I want nothing more than to be that. (Well, without the penis.)
>>8752636
>>8751474
>tfw I'm a cis man with that exact body type minus the tits
>>8752634
You use Wolff's law to determine forces needed. Your iliac crest will put a torque on the center and put force on the cartilage and tissue that connects your femur. Calculate how much cushioning the tissue gives and you're golden lol
Old peoples hips widening isn't due to arthritis or osteoporosis it's just because your body responds to external forces by adapting skeletal structure, it's just gravity.
>>8751840
+ 3 years
>>8751895
>Did they grow to that size naturally?
No. I had to get surgery. Which I regret, by the way.
I'm still incredibly insecure about a lot of other things.
>>8752645
Yeah, is genetics, most likely. I took pictures during my transition and my body hasn't changed that much. I had the same figure as a boy.
>>8752595
I would lick your face
t. no homo
>>8752645
reading this kinda turned me off
>>8752920
why do you regret the breast surgery?
>August 20th, 2017
>still not using biokinesis to become a genetic woman
why didn't I do this shit sooner. my vagina would have been fully formed by now, and not just some wet lips on a ball sack
Only one body part?
>>8750194
No, it's because your ribcage and hips practically touch with no waist inbetween
>>8753135
You have horrible gyno bro
>>8753135
Yup, it's a boob
small one, but still.
Tell me I look like a man senpaitachi.
I'm basically a pretty boy for life. I've accepted that lol.
>>8753657
It would be easier to assess you if you weren't sucking in your cheeks, but at a glance, I wouldn't be able to tell you were born male.
I think you look fine.
I don't suck my cheeks in. Everyone says that. Shit drives me crazy. I'm not, at least not intentionally if I am.
That's my face lol
I might look like a tweaker or something but that's real.
>>8753771
I guess you just have well-defined cheekbones.
I think you're cute. The thought of you having been male wouldn't even occur to me if I were to randomly see you in public.
>>8753657
that picture looks like a female
cute cat :3
>>8753771
How can I learn to do my eyebrows like that?
>>8752595
you cute nigga
>>8752595
you manfaced manjawed manosed, nigga
>>8752595
Looks soft enough to me. The chin dimple is evident, but it's not that severe and lots of biological women have chin dimples anyway.
I'd say you pass quite well. Especially having only been or hormones for 9mo.
>>8752595
Very cute. Freckles are a nice touch.
>>8750108
Different anon here. The problem with your button is that people treat you differently as a trans person and I want no part of that bullshit because it's nobody's damn business /except/ my partner who obviously I would tell anyway. Also, my answer would kind of depend on if they also instinctively know I'm identical to a cis girl or they just somehow think tranny with no clarification. I'd probably go with the former because I could tolerate people's bullshit for that, but I don't want people to instinctively see me as a man, because part of dysphoria is fitting in as a woman.
>>8751474
holy shit that's one of the best bodies I've ever seen. Like legit, top 5 most attractive bodies I've seen in my entire life.
>>8752595
cute but a little bit of man-jaw going on. The dimple especially, but it's not that bad. I would consider getting ffs for it if you're insecure, but you don't need it, you pass regardless.
>>8753135
would suck on
>>8753771
You're pretty cute, definitely passing. Your hairline is kinda far back though, but that doesn't really make you not pass. Eyes and jawline are really good though.
>>8749871
>>8749932
Why people are so obsessed with thigh gap? I don't get it.
>>8751474
Your calves look masculine as do your forearms and hands, the rest of what is pictured looks nice tho. Nice curve to your hips, flat stomach, slim torso, nice tits, decent thighs. I am a big fan of the twinkhon Elf body myself Tbh
>>8751768
>passing as male, theoretically?
Lets see....
>barely taller than a vacuum cleaner
>disfigured and asymmetrical knees and legs
>childbearing hips
>ribcage of a 6yr old child
LUL Aiden pls go
You have a decent female fuckbuddy bod xir
>>8753869
She is unironically a meth head faM
>>8754494
how can you judge the calves from a front facing pic?
>>8754539
>how can you judge the calves from a front facing pic?
The same way I can judge you are retarded.
By using basic cognitive function that you appear to lack.
>>8754549
don't like to be called out for bs'ing, eh?
>>8754494
>your forearms and hands
I think they look fine. Never been conscious about them.
>>8753029
>why do you regret the breast surgery?
I think they look worse now. I found them to be more... aesthetically pleasing? when they were small.
Although they look great when dressed. Or simply wearing a bra.
Back
>>8754819
Arm looks like a hot dog. Do you shave it?
>>8754819
>I think they look worse now. I found them to be more... aesthetically pleasing? when they were small.
Aww. I wish girls, cis and trans alike, weren't so insecure about having small breasts. They're honestly precious so long as they're proportionately shaped.
>>8753135
Isn't this cute? I hope she never feels compelled to get any augmentation procedures because that breast, small as it may be, is simply adorable.
No denying that large breasts look great in certain types of clothing, but you could also just wear clothes that don't emphasize the breast area at all. that can look good too.
>>8754826
A slightly male upper body and a decently female lower body.
Start building those glutes and hams (HARD SQUATS), ZERO UPPER BODY OR CORE WORK, and eat like a pig.
[spoiler]also poast moar[/spoiler]
>tfw will just get told i look like a man if i post
these kinda threads are skewed because you know the poster is a tranny
>>8749871
while they aren't wide enough to 'fool' the boys, that doesn't by any means say they look bad, cuz damn XD
>>8754819
Manhand
We should take all these bodyparts and photoshop them to be one Frankenstein person
>>8754819
No yeah, your hand looks good. Very feminine, I would never guess male looking at that.
I get where you're coming from with the breasts, I think small breasts often look nice, but based off of that picture yours looked very nice, though it wasn't the best picture admittedly.
>>8751474
that looks pretty yummy but if you showed at least shoulders then it would be a bit more realistic
>>8754949
>Relax, bro. People should do whatever they want.
>I thought getting the surgery was the best thing to do at that moment.
I didn't mean to imply that you made the wrong decision. Judging by what little I can see, the results of your surgery look perfectly fine to me.
I was only agreeing that small breasts aren't inherently bad. At the same time, there's nothing necessarily wrong with wanting bigger ones if one can afford it.
>>8756321
>small breasts aren't inherently bad
yea right im completely flat chested and becaus of this my chest is undeniably male, even after 4 yrs hrt, what a fucking load of bullshit, bigger tits boost your passability tenfold
>>8756338
I reiterate that small breasts aren't inherently bad. They can be lovely in their own right.
But I mean, if you really are COMPLETELY flat, and your chest is basically indistinguishable from that of a male, then yes, your passability is probably negatively affected.
In cases like that, surgery might help. But first you'd have to figure out if adjusting the hormone cocktail wouldn't help. It also depends on how long you've been on them.
>>8756359
no such thing as adjusting hormones, if your levels are in the female range thats it, that was my "chest growth", nothing, genetics fucked me over
>>8753657
you look like a witch living in Portland, coding apps about vegan cooking and crystals
nice kitty too
>>8756392
this is so on-point it's almost upsetting
>>8756378
So are you actually -completely- flat, then? Is surgery truly the only option in that case?
I find it curious that you would get absolutely no breast growth. Even high-testosterone men sometimes inadvertently end up with gynecomastia as a side effect of certain medications.
>>8756403
well its how it is
and to top it off not even great hips, i just look like an underdeveloped human
>>8756419
dfc is a good thing b/c you never know how you'll feel 5 years from now, and you'll be able to go back to being cis/andro/fem without need for boob surgery
>>8756433
implying i'd want to detransition???
>>8756419
"Great" hips are a rare thing even among cis women, though. You look pretty slim to me, and slim girls don't often have prominent hips. In that regard I think you look fine.
The complete lack of breast growth is a mystery. How long have you been on hormones, and are you sure your levels are right? Have you spoken to your doctor about this?
In any case, you wouldn't be the only one to see no growth on hormones. If it really bothers you, it isn't the end of the world if you're open to surgery.
Also, you have a cute face.
>>8756470
4 years, levels are fine, tried progesterone aswell for a year, nothing
it doesnt bother me, really, but it'd just make passing easier....
>>8754859
>>8754880
>>8755232
>>8756321
>>8756359
>>8756403
>>8756470
GTFO you beta supplicating prison gay wannabe chaser faggot. You are wasting precious replies to a pass thread with your inane ass kissing and reddit spacing.
>But first you'd have to figure out if adjusting the hormone cocktail wouldn't help
LMAO you have never been with a trans girl faM, just fuck off brah xD xD xD
>>8756476
If it doesn't bother you personally, it might not even be worth worrying about. Unless you're in an environment where not passing actually puts you at risk of danger or something.
>>8756556
PASSING IS PARAMOUNT THOUGH
i don't want to get pity passes or get hugboxed jfc
>>8756531
I made this thread, prick. You don't know anything about me.
>>8756573
I'm not hugboxing you, nor am I giving you a pity pass. You specifically said "it doesn't bother me", but obviously it must bother you if you find passing to be absolutely essential.
So again, I'll say just as I said before: If it really bothers you, it isn't the end of the world if you're open to surgery.
>>8753657
>>8753771
You look like a feminazi sex-starving bitch,
somewhat better in the second pic, but still attractive as female imo
>>8756419
i can't say the same thing of your body u totally look like a guy in the shower of my water polo team:
-hips/waist/shoudler ratio are totally fucked up as female
-where are the boobs ?
-dem tattoos texture and positioning arent helping you for sure
if u are 4 years on hrt and still have that body some surgery is REQUIRED
>>8756660
My WHR IS 0.72….its not fucked.
Shoulders are 15".
>>8756531
>>8756585
>I made this thread, prick. You don't know anything about me
LMAO yeah AGP failed chaser beta cuck, know plenty about your type faM. I know enough about you from your writing to write you off as a joke, as most people are with your reddit tier supplication and hugboxing. Get beat faM
xD xD xD
Is it cheating to post my body if I'm XXY
AGP failed chaser beta cucks or as we like to call them around here
T R A N S B I A N S
Ya killin me faM
xD xD xD
>>8756712
Not necessarily. Klinefelter's doesn't always yield a female phenotype, but perhaps you're one of the lucky ones.
Mommy pls halp daddy is being mean again :(
>>8756758
quite embarrassing
>>8756751
I am one of the lucky ones.
>>8754494
>autistic criticism of "calves, forearms, and hands"
>"twinkhon Elf body"
Carth I'm as negative about people's bodies, including my own, as anyone, but even I can see you're bullshitting this girl to try and hurt her self-esteem. It's straight out of the PUA playbook and you always do this. Most guys don't need to shit all over a girl to make her feel like she needs to settle for him, they just work on making themselves more desirable partners.
Don't bully FtMs either.
>>8756850
>>8756850
>PUA playbook
>lawl
5 months
>>8756905
wtf how, ive been on for 5 months and i havent had any chest growth at all
>>8756905
dat picture suck honey post a full body pic with a decent angle plz
>>8756830
Still, I wouldn't say it's cheating to submit a pic, but it's up to you.
>>8757055
i asked a simple question and he insulted me based on almost nothing
i think sissies, bdsm and really damaged people are drawn towards the abuse
>>8757101
Yes.
Damaged people seek out and feel comfortable with abusers because it feels normal to them and they don't have the self-esteem necessary to see it for what it is.
>>8754494
>Your calves look masculine as do your forearms and hands
Fuck off abusive retard.
>>8756905
T W I N K H O N B O D
Ribcage looks wide af tbhon.
>>8752267
PUFFY
VULVA
>>8754819
naisu gamu
but organize your desktop pls
So let me get this straight if carth says something negative he is abusive, if he says something positive it is considered manipulative? That doesn't seem fair.
Why do some trans women hang on his every word? I don't really see anything wrong with his original comments. Just curious why others can leave whatever feedback they want but everybody jumps on carth regardless of what he says.
Inb4 twinkhon defense force accusations
>>8757655
I don't know who this carth autist is but I really wish you'd all stop bitching about him.
>>8757388
It's actually a protruding penis
let me know the good and the bad
>>8757661
>I don't know who this carth autist is but I really wish you'd all stop bitching about him.
Insecure short, basically textbook manlet. Spends his days doing nothing but jerking off to tranny porn in his mom's (or aunt's i forget) basement. Some say the egg will eventually come out of the closet as trans but by then it will probably be too late. One wonders if he might start judging people normally (without using the highest standards possible) if he left his basement and understood that not all women look like small petite pornstars that he fixates on.
I'll take a second to go over a couple quick things with Carth. It is possible for women to have arms that are larger/ more muscular than average it does not make them masculine or look masculine, I know that's hard to understand given that all the women in your life are lifetime welfare recipients who undoubtedly have dainty forearms and hands. Same goes for calves brotard. Here's another important one, there are women that are taller than you. I know thats hard to take in but just cause a tranny is taller than you does not make them an automatic hon.
TL:DR Just because a women deviates slightly from your ideal image of a woman, it does not make her masculine just as your short stature does not make you feminine.
Everythings good except the spiked choker.
>>8756915
...why is this Avatarfag tolerable and precious??? I like him.
>>8757923
You have a lot of hair but you need to learn how to take care of it
>>8751474
cute panties.
Wish I could look this good...
>>8757979
it's rly wet and yeah... i do... need to lern
>>8757957
I just met him he isn't short ^__^
looks like this thread is still active so I'll post
Do you guys think I could pass? I feel like my shoulders are a little broad but that my hips aren't bad and could be a lot better if I did HRT.
I'm 19 and 5'6.5-7"
>>8758139
inverted triangle af
your shoulders are really broad and your hips are really narrow
>>8758147
doomed to be a triangle manlet then I guess
the last thing I want to be is a hon
>>8758147
>shoulders are really broad and your hips are really narrow
literally every male born
>>8758139
There's not much you can do about broad shoulders, but with the right exercise you could potentially build your hip and thigh muscles to make the ratio a little more favorable.
>>8758139
Too manly to ever pass for a convincing female body/5
If it's any consolation I'm in the same boat, my man.
>>8758444
It's interesting.
I never thought women's ribcages were this narrow.
How can they even fit lungs and hearts into that?
>>8758444
i have seen cases less severe than that though
>>8758493
They have smaller organs
Is it even possible for mtfs to have passable shoulders?
>>8749891
I wouldn't obsess over it, lots of cis women have violin hips. It's not what you see on /s/ but if you look around you IRL it's actually really common - a lot of the women in my family have them. Plus there's always padding.
>>8758916
Not really.
Nice conetits that are very far from each other due to a wide ribcage.
>>8753869
:/
>>8754494
Am I a pretty crackwhore tho oh wait meth head? Nah. Molly! kratom?
>>8753861
>>8753904
Thanks :)
>>8753939
Post your brows? I dye mine.
>>8754310
Thank you!
>>8756392
>>8756397
That's pretty good 2bqf.
>>8756660
>sex-starving
That's pretty good too. I got that bitch face in a bad way.
Thanks the compliment tho :)
>>8756905
Nice tits faggot
>>8757923
You look stupid and useless. I guess that means you pass as a woman. Gratz.
>>8758139
Just take the pills anyways. You'll know if it's right for you.
>>8756419
HAWWT
>>8754826
Hon hair. I bet your face is gross.
>>8754819
Lgtm
>>8754410
I'm impressed with your complete lack of m muscle tone you baby skinned panty boy. Keep up the good work.
>>8753771
Cute
>>8753657
Uhhhhh
>>8753135
That's a boobie alright
>>8752595
Ellie, we've seen enough. Please go do something else and come back. Ily.
>>8752308
Looks like a big scary girl. Would avoid.
>>8752302
Idk
>>8751768
Pretty fucked imo
>>8751474
Cute bod, I guess. Hmph.
>>8750194
Big ribcage. Weird bod. Good luck senpai.
>>8750093
Catt
>>8749871
This picture is deception
Ok ladies (and Christian-poster) here's a piece of me. You're welcome.
>>8759021
>uhhhhh
What
That's a nice eye
>>8759039
I like ur cat :3
>>8756419
I am 2.5 yrs HRT in and I got the same body/boobs as you.
What's your ethnicity?
>>8754826
F O O T B A L L
P L A Y E R
>>8759078
Idk, I'm from Italy so probably lots of stuff in the mix.
>>8759021
Emokiddeh?
>>8756905
Nice twinkhon bod Tbh. Would be nice to see a standing pic so we can see your shoulders and legs as well. Got nice tiddies for 5months.
>>8757491
>go back to Discord you fucking autist
Im sorry did you just ask for my Discord? :^)
Kik: The_Carthaginian
Discord: The Carthaginian#4454
>>8757655
>>8758102
Fuck off Twinkhon Defense Force let Carth be a man and fight his own battles for once. He is just manipulating and abusing you, you know that right?
<3 (:
>>8757923
Which individual body part were we supposed to be leaving feedback on here?
The good is that in this very poor quality photo you pass as a girl.
The bad is that hardly any features of your body are clear at all to get an honest assessment of what you actually look like.
>>8758139
>Do you guys think I could pass?
You have a very masculine torso. Somehow I have a feeling that white knight beta trannies wont jump on me for telling you that because they dont want to suck your tiny feminine penis. If you feel you are trans you should just get on HRT and start dropping your weight. Waiting wont make you look any better. Focusing on things like shoulders is just stupid, you cant do anything about it. You should focus on getting in shape.
If you are hot nobody gives a fuck about your shoulders LMAO.
>>8758916
>Is it even possible for mtfs to have passable shoulders?
No, not really and that is part of what makes them hotter in some ways than a cis girl. A very average run of the mill trans girl has the body of a top tier female athlete. Too many trannies get caught up in dumb shit when they should be embracing it and owning up to the fact that they have strong, powerful bodies. Its a plus not a minus.
>>8759018
Miranda have you told yourself that you are worthless yet today? Because you are :^)
aaayy
>>8759138
>Italy
Funny, I also am South Euro ethnically. But also Ashkenazi, lol.
>>8759196
>that angle where your hips seem wider than your shoulders even though they are not
Oh I do this angle regularly as well. :^)
>>8758493
they don't actually look like that, that's some deviantart crap
>>8754826
i have similar backside. could I talk to you offline? [email protected]
>>8751768
You have wide shoulders so once you get on T, you'll probably be fine; building muscle won't hurt though
do my hands pass?
>>8759638
what's up with your thumb?
can you show us a picture that includes your wrist? that can change things.
you seem alright though. skin looks really soft, which helps. your fingers seem a little pudgy at the base.
>>8751768
Your proportions look lanky and you have broad shoulders, you could definitely pass.
You might need to lower your body fat % before you go on T to reduce your hips, but if that's bone structure it can't be helped (and there are guys out there with womanly hips and it's an easy area to hide).
>>8759021
Too ugly to post anything but too desperate for attention to not, so posts the worst angle possible with glasses taking half of the image.
>>8757957
>Some say the egg will eventually come out of the closet as trans but by then it will probably be too late
Huh, I remember carth posting nudes and he looked pretty transable
>>8759638
>*fills lungs with air*
>HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
>>8758139
>>8758147
Don't listen to him anon, you don't look like an inverted triangle, you're a classic rectangle - still a very masculine shape but it could be salvageable
We could maybe judge you better with a better pic, mirror pics tend to be kinda distorted
Try putting your phone somewhere at eye level and standing like 1-2 meters away from it instead of taking a regular selfie
>>8758493
They're not, the picture is exaggerated
>>8758916
Yes
>>8758938
Do men normally get violin hips?
I thought it's a very feminine feature but maybe it's only girls that are self-conscious enough to complain about it
>>8759638
Looks like 8yo beauty pageant with a crazy mother but I bet your hands are actually huge
>>8759752
>We could maybe judge you better with a better pic, mirror pics tend to be kinda distorted
>Try putting your phone somewhere at eye level and standing like 1-2 meters away from it instead of taking a regular selfie
I don't get home today for another 13 hours (school and work) but if this thread is still alive then I'll do this
Do you really think I'm a rectangle and not a triangle? Maybe the lower half of my torso, but my upper chest and shoulders seem pretty triangular. A triangle on a rectangle?
>>8759803
It's about the relation between your shoulders and hips/shape of your entire torso
>A triangle on a rectangle?
That's either a regular triangle or a hourglass but you don't look like one
I guess you could be a triangle but like I said the position you're in tends to distort body shape towards the triangle and you already don't look much like one
Maybe you just have a bit of a waist like most men that aren't fat
How bad is it? be brutally honest plz.
Im pre-hrt but I probably shouldnt even try.
>>8759178
Carth, you know the easiest way to have sex with trans girls is to start transitioning, right? I'm still in boymode but I already I have lesbian trans girls throwing themselves at me.
>>8756905
>>8759196
>angles
>you are doing it wrong honey
>pretty much this:
>>8759178
>Nice twinkhon bod Tbh. Would be nice to see a standing pic so we can see your shoulders and legs as well. Got nice tiddies for 5months.
idk fellas when you start to get down on yourselves just remember you weren't born black in Detroit LIKE ME first gender/racial transitioner
>>8759196
Nice.
Should lose some weight though Tbh
>>8759638
>do my hands pass?
Pass as hambeast hands, too much adipose tissue to pass as human.
>>8759650
>what's up with your thumb?
The hambeasts hands are covered in fat from excess caloric intake causing an extra fold of skin to appear between the index finger and thumb. Keep in mind while humanoid in form, hambeasts are not actually human.
>>8759656
>Your proportions look lanky
Her proportions look strictly female, she has a very long torso relative to her legs. It is even more exaggerated in her but that is a female trait, not masculine. She also looks about 5'1" so calling anyone that height (especially someone that is supposed to be perceived as male) "lanky" seems patently retarded.
>broad shoulders
LMAO no, her shoulders might look broad for her body because her waist is tiny
>You might need to lower your body fat %
You just told a biological female with visible abs that she needs to lower her body fat%...... I am floored by how retarded you are. There is hardly any fat padding her hips as it is now, do your eyes even fucking work? Dropping her body fat further would not be noticeable at all in clothes, and would do nothing to change her female birthing hip structure unclothed.
>>8759683
>I remember carth posting nudes and he looked pretty transable
Oh yea you got me. I can DL damn near 500lbs. I am just a tiny, pretty little thing. Why dont you go ahead and repost my nudes faM. Show everybody how "transable" I am.
>>8760251
Ayyy baby girl you forgot to tell them you are 6'5" <3
xD xD xD
Aiiight gym time y'all
>>8760597
>gym time
Daddy take me with you uwu
>>8760597
thanks carth, im already on it im currently at 135lbs 5'6 the goal right now its 110 however last time i was that way i wasnt on HRT so not very curvy, ill see how i look this time around if not ill just adjust
>>8751768
Narrow rib cage, but ok shoulders, small hips and boobs and long upper body. You'll do good... and I'm pretty jelly, I have wide hips and I'm getting kind of pudgy, urk. Wore my usual binder today and it was getting pretty uncomfortable by the end of the day, I need to loose somewhere between 10-20 pounds to get rid of some of "muh curves".
>>8756419
Huh, if you'd said you were a FtM 1 year on T I actually wouldn't question it (tho your shoulders are a lil' bit on the wide side) Your lower body and face (from what I can see) is quite feminine.
Time accept no one here passes.
Sexual dimorphism, if you were born male, you'll always have a male body.
Not that it invalidates your identity.
>>8760728
>you'll always have a male body.
>>8761150
Haiii Carth x3
>>8751474
>hiding shoulders
nice try hon
>>8761171
Make me some pizza bitch <3
Aiiiight I am up y'all, you know where to find me tho
>>8761321
nice alpha frame chart
Well use that man brain of yours if it fools you then yes you sick freak
>>8761171
>>8761343
cmq anche se è truccata all'inverosimile ancora non passa
>>8760597
You know HRT makes people lose muscles right
>>8761471
He's a nigger, of course he doesn't.
>>8749871
>Are my hips wide enough to fool the boys?
>to fool the boys?
>fool
delusion.avi
>>8752302
Serial rapist in the women's bathroom
>>8761171
>this is the kind of men (men) Nigger Manlet is into
Sad!
>>8761644
it's clearly the disabled bathroom
>>8762179
im not a jerk, i like robin
it just a disabled bathroom is all
>>8759138
B O L O G N A
O
L
O
G
N
A
>>8762337
mi piacerebbe tesoro ma ancora nn passi non mi garba
>>8750101
I know no one who thinks like that pic
>>8759752
>>8759842
>>8759178
Hey it's >>8758139 again, glad to see this thread still seems to be alive after 13 (well 14 now) hours while I was doing normie shit like "working" and """getting a post-highschool education"""
I took your advice and took a non-mirror pic. I couldn't quite get it up to eye level because I didn't have enough books to stack and I think the camera was tiny bit off center but hopefully this should be good enough. What do you think now? I'm standing with my heels together, still 5'6.5-7" and 19. Could I pass?
>>8763450
Also before anyone says anything I know I'm a little doughy at the gut, I'm working on it
>>8763450
B A R R E L B O D
>>8763489
is that better or worse than triangle man
>>8763450
based on your body, nope, I'd definitely not say pass. Are you on hormones yet?
>>8763561
No, I haven't done any ever.
What makes you think I wouldn't pass?
If you're going to date someone, tell them you're trans beforehand.
3 months on hormones, how does it look now? I'm terrible at telling with shit like this
>>8763599
I was just stating passing right now- didn't realize you meant in the future
It's honestly hard to tell. Between dieting and HRT, the body can change so much.
>>8763678
Damn, definite pass, and pretty cute to boot. Great waist/hips/legs, very nice tummy. Your shoulders are a bit brought, your arms seem a bit big, but you're only 3 months on hrt, that might still improve yet. Your skintone still needs work too, but that should come naturally, at only 3 months you're doing fine.
After you're further along with HRT, especially if your arms/shoulders look better by then, I'd consider trying to put on a few more pounds, make your ribs show less, that sort of thing. It's hard to say though, might not work.
Still though, you look very cute for only 3 months, highly bangable.
My hips, this is 7 weeks on HRT.
How are they?
>>8763700
Oh, whoops, probably should have made it clearer that I haven't done anything yet and was wondering about my chances if I started. I don't blame you, pretty much everyone else in this thread is already doing HRT.
Anyone else have an opinion on my chances? And can someone explain barrel bod to me
>>8752302
It's ok robin, I'm just as bad
>all these people not on HRT and less than 1 year on HRT asking questions
Can you fuck off?
>>8763894
mangry hon spotted
>>8763894
People want to know if people think they'll be able to pass, whether it would even be worth it to commit to HRT.
are my shoulders too wide for me to pass?
>>8764024
Yes, much.
I'm sorry anon :(
>>8764024
Why are almost all pre-HRT mtfs potbellied dadbod twinks?
>>8764095
>tfw I'm pre-HRT mtf and have a body like Hank Hill
at least I'm not a twink
>>8764113
>tfw I'm on HRT and still have a body like Hank Hill
mfw
>>8764137
Fugk, is this my fate?
>>8764147
Probably (not).
>>8764155
I dunno anon, it's pretty bad.
>6'2
>210 lbs
>25.5 inch head
>44 around the ribcage
>awful violin hips
>men's 13w shoes
My legs are alright and my complexion's already pretty solid, good hair too, that's literally all I have going for me. I guess my face might have been alright if it wasn't for my massive head, throwing off the face-to-head ratio. I think I'm fucked.
>>8764024
majority of male borns have broad shoulders and dad bods, eventually
>>8764095
That's basically my life due to no exercise and not caring about my body. I just don't eat like a fatty but I'm pudgy cause no muscle so whatever fat is there is misshapen.
Exercising sucks though lol
>>8764162
Well my measurements are slightly different but I still look like a gross icky manbodied twink tbqh.
>>8759178
>Worthless
Not today but that's what I come here for! <3
But hey tell me the truth. You wouldn't hmu if I left my details cause I totally think you would lol
Do I pass or is my face still too masculine?
Are my boobs alright? Is my beak to big?
>>8764314
i want to give you my seed so hard
>>8764291
I know plenty of girls with faces more masculine than that
you get a pass from me
I think you could afford to thicken your eyebrows a bit.
>>8759178
This is really true desu. The killer for MtFs is being tall + no hips + broad shoulders + wide ribcage with heavy *side length*, and honestly that's not that many people (though it certainly is common for males). If you have say, larger shoulders, you can minimize that by working on your hips, ass and thighs. If you're like me, your shoulders are okay and your front and hips are fine, but your ribcage is really lengthy from the side. This can be fixed by working out your arms, creating the illusion you're just overall bigger in muscle mass. It's fine, honestly, most people can use it.
The problem is too much people on MtF don't diet and exercise specifically to work on the body parts they need to, instead they think "im girl so small arms, big tits and big butt right???"
>>8762106
>Sad!
Actually I am quite proud to have her as a friend. She is a very chill, intelligent, friendly, creative, openminded person, and she knows how to have fun. The world would be a better place if there were more people like her in it. So yes I can proudly say she is the type of person I am into (:
What type of person are you into? Better yet, what type of person are YOU? :^)
>>8764220
>But hey tell me the truth
You can add me if you want, but its not going to go anywhere. Too far away, in a logistically bad location. Plus I am talking to a lot of people rn, and dont have a lot of time to talk. If you lived closer I would be a lot more interested in hanging out or partying, checking your shows, etc. Its not that I dont like you, its just the logistics are terrible.
This is an interesting thread tho, it was very different seeing more bodies and less faces. Kinda liked it Tbh.
>>8764090
fugggg : (
Is there at least hope for my face ?
ignore the hot pocket desu
>>8763403
really? I can think of 10 people immediately who think that way.
WHY ARE MY SHOULDERS SO FUCKING BROAD
>>8765550
>hope for my face
I think there is.
>>8764291
Your jawline is pretty manly. I don't think I'd actually clock you, though.
>>8765637
>WHY ARE MY SHOULDERS SO FUCKING BROAD
testosterone honey
and they're not that broad
>>8764666
Wow that is really sweet carth
>>8765637
>>8765637
You have my dream body! Okay, I'm ftm, but I want to be slim and femme, heh (but I'm kinda short and skinny fat) Your shoulders aren't that bad, tho. Mine are probably just a hair smaller. You have a nice slim waist and your hips are def not the worst either, love that lil hip bone peaking through. Looks like you have very slender arms, but still a bit of meat on your thighs. You look pretty femme to me, despair not.
i love when i post in the wrong thread : )))
>>8765550
Yeah your face can definitely pass
>>8766954
what's more important in terms of passing in general, face or body?
>>8766954
rly ?
>>8766959
1)face
2)body
imo, but ofc u cant have a total manly body even if u are a cute angel face
>>8763450
A-anyone else? I know I posted this kind of late yesterday
How is this thread not dead yet
this thread is so ancient....