So is it /k/ approved?

>>34630011
Kill yourself

>>34630011
there's no gore. it's too tame for a war movie, but it's a good movie nonetheless.

also we have a board dedicated to movies, you retarded nigger.

>>34630022
There is precedent for /k/ discussing war/weapon related movies. There's even a few infographics that have been made with tiered lists of /k/ approved movies. I don't know why you're so assblasted.

>>34630011
Go fuck your self nigger

>>34630011
It's a movie that tries to put lipstick on the pig that was the utter humiliation of the British being granted mercy by the Germans. Stiff upper lip and all that.

>>34630011
Fuck off nigger

>>34630011

It doesn't really fall under the category of /k/'s judgement. It's a drama that takes place in the context of war, but it's not really a "war movie."

>>34630011
Yes. Go see it in IMAX 15/70.

>>34630011
>le is it approv
I hate god damn summer niggers like you

>>34630011
is it BBC approved ?
>the Luftwaffe failed to do its job

>>34630011
The plane scenes are pretty cool, I enjoyed it

>>34630011

plane scenes are good. rest is meh... some enfield gunporn but not really worth it. Wait for DVD... If you are into Spitfires... yeah... ok... I have seen better. Just ... not enough action. Liked WonderWoman more on the gunporn side... so draw your own conclusions from that.

>>34631140
>not enough action
>just like wonderwoman more on the gunporn side
jesus christ, did you even watch the movie?

>>34630011
no it's been "diversified" the same way BF1 was with forcing nigger and woman soldiers in your face that were nonexistent in real life.

>>34631386
there were two (2) niggers in an army they were realistically in in the ENTIRE movie, you're a dumb cunt.
and i personally hated the movie, so that's not just me fanboying.
>women soldiers
literally none. fuck off

>>34630011
There's some decent plane porn. That's it. inaccurate plane porn, too.

>>34631386
>there weren't any colonial soldiers at Dunkirk
>forging history to suit your own agenda
Idiot.

>>34630011
ja, kamerad

>>34630011
I loved this movie.

>>34630011
Yeah, it's a pretty great movie

File: 1500505836854.jpg (68KB, 530x600px) Image search: [Google]

68KB, 530x600px

>>34630481
>granted mercy by the Germans.

>>34631140
Please ignore this retard. He clearly hasn't seen the movie

>>34631386
You've clearly never seen the fucking movie.
There are like 2 or 3 Senegalese guys in the French army (which is not historically inaccurate) and they don't play any major role in the film.

>women soldiers
yep, this just proves you haven't seen it

I'm not paying to watch this garbage.

+ stuka sirens
+ the shot of tom hardy flying his out-of-fuel spitfire over dunkirk was very pretty
+ plane scenes in general

- tom hardy's spitfire got destroyed

ITT: Summerfags deluding themselves into thinking if its not about Rhodesia its not worth their time.

File: Senagalese_French_soldiers_WW1.jpg (50KB, 600x369px) Image search: [Google]

50KB, 600x369px

Lmao at the broader /pol/osphere getting into a giant tizzy about like one black guy being in like one shot of this movie and ferociously throwing fuel on that outrage to generate all those sweet sweet outrage clicks for Breitbart articles written by the same people who probably started the outrage in the first place by twitter shitposting.

The movie's pretty good tho, quality plane porn (mostly practical, not CGI if I am not mistaken, or good enough that I can't tell the difference), the rest of it is very unconventional for a war movie, it's more like a survival film disaster movie kind of affair than a typical war movie.

>>34630011
I learned that spitfires have a 100:1 glide ratio.

>>34631386

you can probably count the seconds with nigger on screen with the fingers of one hand, also the only women in the film are nurses.

>>34633256

I think they used RC plane

Can anyone ITT post this /k/ approved movies infographic?

>>34633270
That would fit, I guess there literally aren't enough early model spitfires in the world for some of those shots

>>34630011
The sound effects were incredible. Best I've ever heard.

That alone was great for me. It also kind of encompasses an atmosphere of dread. (waiting on the shores to die)

To the German high command's shock Hitler gave the order to stop attacking.

Goering was a big reason for the downfall of the Reich.

So did Nolan actually blow up a 'priceless WW2 plane' or what?

File: 658.jpg (10KB, 260x384px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 260x384px

>>34630011

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LqZ9IIl_yEI

> 2017
> using ha 1112 instead of 109

File: Hispano_Aviación_HA-1112_K._1._L_Tripala.jpg (92KB, 750x563px) Image search: [Google]

92KB, 750x563px

>>34633389
>Painting the 1112 in Bf109 colours despite how the engine looks obviously different
NOLAN, YOU HACK FRAUD

>>34633365
Yes, Tom Hardy actually burned down a priceless relic, it's like the banjo from The Hateful Eight.

>>34630011
Hollywood knows Hollywood and anyone that knows the garbage cans and alley knows Hollywood.

>>34633396
not to mention that the all yellow nose wasn't used during the battle over Dunkirk

>>34633389
Who the fuck gives a shit

File: n6fh8w.jpg (62KB, 1000x407px) Image search: [Google]

62KB, 1000x407px

>>34633408
that's what 109 used to look like in June - July 1940

you'll think that they would get it right with all that money but nope ...

>>34633416
A bunch of indignant spergy neets with too much time on their hands

>>34633416
do you know where you are ?

>>34630022
>discussing movies on /tv/

Kek

>>34633441
Ironically you'll get a better experience there than here. /k/ somehow manages to be worse at movie discussion that even /tv/.

>>34633416
I mean, no one, but it fun to point this stuff out

What the hell was the deal with the high-pitch, shrieking alarm-like noises the Destroyer made when the civilian ships arrived?

>>34630481
Go home wehraboo

>>34633862
Bongs didnu nuffin, de was a gud boy.

>>34633473
It's an alarm you mong

File: french para algeria.jpg (1MB, 1000x1422px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1000x1422px

Hated it there was noiFrench troops fuk brits.

>>34636796
yes, there was. There were lots. One of the main characters is French

>>34630011
It shit all over american WW2 films of recent years.

fucking red tails junk to appease blacks and then fury to appease teenagers who think ww2 is world of tanks with undeadable Americans.

>>34631386
I haven't seen the movie, I really dislike anything Noland every put out but Dunkirk wasn't just the evacuation of British soldiers.
France was full of colonial troops.
https://youtu.be/_4nGDo04OLU?t=18m2s

>>34630011
Is it true that Germany let the British flee out of mercy?

>>34630481
^
This is exactly why I didn't see it. Brits and Russians alike glorify the shit out of everything they did during WW2, including humiliating defeats.

Probably would be gone to see it if it was shot entirely from the perspective of a British civilian rescuing his country's finest.

Isolationism is best ism.

My thoughts, informed by literally ten hours of IL-2 play years ago
The 109s weren't doing those boom and zoom tactics I was told they do
109s had cannons right? Didn't see them seem to deliver canon hits, nothing explosive at least
All the shootdowns were white smoke - what about black smoke? I heard white smoke wasn't always a kill

File: 1482303754130.jpg (19KB, 450x338px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 450x338px

>>34637178
>with undeadable Americans.

Only one of the main characters actually survives. I'm guessing you never saw the movie yet still want to complain about it on the internet.

File: 1939-1940-battle_of_france-plan-evolution.jpg (389KB, 1256x956px) Image search: [Google]

389KB, 1256x956px

>>34639391
No.

While it was the opinion of the time of the British that the army was allowed to escape in order to show peace towards fellow Aryans, and to better secure a favorable peace, that was shown to be false.

This guy Manstein submitted a plan to quickly encircle the enemy on the advice of Guderian. He submitted it to his boss, von Rundstedt, not mentioning Guderian, who was seen as too much of a maverick. von Rundstedt modified it, and submitted it to OKH. OKH modified it, and sent it down.

Then the actual execution was more along the lines of what Guderian had actually proposed. Tearing his hair out, Hitler thought his generals too big for their britches, and ordered a general halt. He would let the infantry catch up to his tanks, because he couldn't stand the thought of losing them.

And so, one of the greatest Allied generals was Adolph Hitler, someone who never advanced past corporal, but who thought himself smarter than his generals.

Tom Hardy getting the kill at the end was bs. He was gliding prior and even turning would put his plane much lower in the air than that luftwaffe one.

>>34640558
well a kill with a gliding plane is possible only vs a retard who either agrees with a head-on or maybe needlessly loses energy in a sharp turn or some silly acrobatic maneuver, otherwise a gliding plane is a helpless sitting duck

>>34639897
>that was shown to be false
I am going to need to see Hitler's diary entry where he explains how he suddenly changed his mind and suddenly hated the Brits and no longer longed for an alliance with them as he discussed in Mein Kampf and made clear repeatedly during the lead up to the war.

>>34640622
His false hope doesn't show any of the above to be false.

>>34640622
If Hitler was so concerned about the casualties of the British and wanted to minimize them to make peace, why did he let the Luftwaffe go to town on them?
He only stopped because Rundstedt was rightly concerned about British and French attacks on his flanks with 50% of tanks needing some form of repair and refit, and the need for foot infantry to take on hundreds of thousands of soldiers.

>>34640708
Plus inflicting another 30,000 casualties, and capturing another 300,000 men would have done more to negotiate peace from a position of strength.

I fear that it is summer.

>>34633473
the boat equivalent of
>CIVY BOATS REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

File: sVhjLPqCE8nboyw37UTqCRPE_250.jpg (15KB, 150x222px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 150x222px

>>34630438
FAGGOT

Today we were walking around the Oshkosh airshow, and saw a spitfire taxi right by us. It reminded me that Dunkirk was out in theaters, so we ubered to the movies and watched it this evening.

As a aviation and ww2 buff, I enjoyed it.
I've got a little wehraboo in me and my favorite plane of all time is the ju-87, but even though the movie hardly showed the German side, it was still very good.

No romance, real spitfires (not cgi), real ships, real boats, real beaches (not cgi rendered backgrounds).

Not really a spoiler.
My favorite scene was watching the spitfire pilot put his gear down with the aux hand pump. It's cool watching Hollywood get it right.

File: 1499143365247.jpg (79KB, 924x960px) Image search: [Google]

79KB, 924x960px

Dun Cuck

>>34640901
Except that American taxes were insanely low, and after the revolution, inflation became ruinous, and the greatest depression to occur to America happened.

File: IMG_1084.jpg (294KB, 1125x1252px) Image search: [Google]

294KB, 1125x1252px

>>34640857
I think it's amazing though that when finally see Germans, it's part of the most emotional scene (for me at least) of the entire movie. Seeing Farrier go through all of that over the course of the hour then beautifully glide landing on the beach, finally removing his mask, and burning up the spitfire then getting taken prisoner by the two Wehrmacht soldiers was just a punch in the gut for me

>>34640558
It was a Stuka
They're easy money

>>34630481
>being granted mercy by the Germans
Someone wasn't paying attention in history class.

The reason Germany didn't fuck shit up at Dunkirk was because of a halt order by General von Rundstedt, along with bad weather preventing the Luftwaffles from working at full potential.

The Germans stumbled, and payed the price for it dearly, while Hitler tried to play it off as being kind in order to save face.

>>34633365
>bane crashes his plane
>his fire rises
>getting caught was part of his plan

Seriously though, did you see the movie? It was obvious that the airplane set on fire was a prop, the damn thing didn't even have a fake engine, the propeller was held up by a big pole.

I thought it was excellent, bit more of a survival thriller than a war movie but the visuals/sounds (the stuka runs were so loud the old fucks were complaining)/suspense really made it for me

>>34642774
also the high rpm, short bursts mg fire from the spitfires tickled me good

>>34642774
>the stuka runs were so loud
Pretty much all of the gunfire was loud as fuck, I dunno if it was just because of the cinema I went to, but when the scavenging brits started taking fire at the start I almost covered my ears.

It was definitely something to appreciate, though - not a lot of war movies do justice to just how fucking loud a gunshot is, and I think Nolan must've cranked it up as high as the studio would allow.

>>34640938
He'd been gliding for quite a while, easily made it past the spot where the beached Dutch boat was, so I figured he was going to end up captured. Some of the scenes were really moving though, the flotilla of little ships being spotted by the allies had me tearing up a bit.

>>34642900
oh yeah it was that loud at mine as well, also thumpy. when the pilot gets hit with the rounds unexpectedly i jumped in my seat. definitely a war is hell sort of film

Please tell me they didn't fuck up the bit where the French stay behind to hold up the rear.

>>34642955
Theater I was at the bass was shaking the screen so bad it was blurry. It was fucking awesome during the action.
>>34642974
Literally 45 seconds into the movie it shows a barricade manned by french soldiers covering the main british soldier as he's running away from germans who just fucked up his whole squad.

File: 1481849389699.png (66KB, 621x339px) Image search: [Google]

66KB, 621x339px

>>34630011
>self glorifying UK war movie
"No."

>>34637178
>Undefeatable Americans
>Literally every Sherman in the movie is destroyed
>Entire main cast save one is killed
>Lone survivor cowers under destroyed tank
>Is spared by a German who sees how pathetic and helpless he is
>Undefeatable Americans

>>34643617
>1 disabled sherman vs a german battalion

>>34633408
>>34633427
He said in an interview it was slightly anachronistic to help discern them from the spitfires, which makes sense.

If we're gonna get upset over nitpicks, the Stuka siren isn't supposed to only be audible when its diving, it's on all the time.

>>34642477
>Stuka
>small boat captain calls it a Heinkel (unless i am misremembering it)

Maybe im just confused about my wwii german planes, but were the Stukas the ones dive bombing the beaches (complete with sirens), and the Bf109s over the water escorting the Meschershmitt?

>>34643687
>1 armored gun platform waiting in ambush
>VS
>A bunch of dudes on a road

>Gun platform loses

>>34639629
>>34643617

They only die after killing a stupid amount of Germans in about as Hollywood a way as possible.

Fury was trash.
Hacksaw Ridge was trash
Red Tails was Trash
USS Indianapolis was written by children with some of the worst effects i've ever seen.

I genuinely can't think of a good US film about WW2 since Saving Private Ryan - which is excellent as no one will deny.

Meanwhile, the UK has a nice collection of WW2 films, dunkirk, Imitation Game (not combat related but very good and set in WW2), The Railway Man, The boy in Striped Pyjamas.

And lets not forget the classics like the Great Escape, Bridge over the river kwai, a bridge too far, Empire of the rising sun (British story American director) and the battle of Britain.

>>34643745
sorry, this isn't call of dooty where you have unlimited ammo and only have to survive for 3 minutes

>>34630011
Only the air combat scenes and the very start.

Rest is boring.

>>34633408
Neither were post war spanish buchons.

JG26 is probably the most widely recognizable paint scheme of the BoB era BF109-E models, not a big deal. The action more than makes up for these inconsistencies.

>>34631386
The British army had black soldiers in it. American training films for US troops going to britain explicitly make a big point of this and how race isn't a huge deal in the UK like it is in the US.

>>34630011
It was an enjoyable film that showed the various microcosms of the event.

I thought it was interesting to have the land sea and air stories taking place at different time scales.

The lack of CGI and use of real aircraft and visual effects was a breath of fresh air for a war film.

It managed to capture a lot of subtle historical points very well, the French rear guard, the British army consigned to defeat.

The soldiers realising they weren't cowards for escaping was quite moving, especially since the main reason for remembering Dunkirk is that there's no shame in living to fight another day, especially considering the UK went on to beat Germany and Italy on land sea and air before the US entered the war.

Was great.

The only jarring part of the movie was everything to do with that group getting the landed dingy out to sea.

The more you think about it, the more it makes no god damn sense.

File: fascism.png (456KB, 797x634px) Image search: [Google]

456KB, 797x634px

>>34634119
hitler was a gud boy, he let them beefeaters go on home

File: ju-87-stuka-28.jpg (93KB, 893x554px) Image search: [Google]

93KB, 893x554px

>>34633326
>>34633256
I'm guessing that the stukas they featured must have been either CGI or RC because I highly doubt anyone is letting Christopher Nolan use one of the remaining 2 for a movie

>>34630011
>almost no french or germans
>in a movie about Dunkerque
>budget so shit you only ever see 3 plane formations and white smoke
>stukas use bombs without diving and never use their fucking guns
>the beach isn't a messy hell of equipment lying disorganized like it should be
It terrible on the /k/ front.

>>34644870
in a modern movie everything should be considered cgi unless proven otherwise

>>34643580
>tfw polls taken in 1945 were all massively in favor of the soviets
Hollywood propaganda worked.

>>34630011
>Christopher Nolan
lol

>>34640916
>implying the revolution was a horrible idea
Fucking wew lad
Salty Bong spotted

>>34643992
>pyjamas
Hello Bong

>>34645053

I am a bong, but that's literally the name of the film

Definitely see it in cinema the stuka sirens alone gave me multiple orgasms

>>34643992
anthropoid was good

>>34630011
Just got back. I think my ears are ringing, at least more than usually noticeable.

totally worth it though the mild tinnitus is essential to the experience of true war kino

>>34643729
Yeah, Stukas were doing dive banger action on the beach, Heinkel was going for the floaty boaty, and Messy Mc109sies were escorting and dogfighting and losing like little babies

>>34644870
I think all the Stukas were R/C models

>>34633473
>Literally the only way for the destroyer captain to greet the civiies
Gee I don't know mate

>>34644971
Turns out using retards and women as suicide bombers is a great strategy.

>>34631386
there were three Senegalese troops in a group of french deserters portrayed like giant fucking cowards

>>34633326
Bit late but mixed cgi can make several of the same aircraft appear on screen to create formations convincingly.

>>34631386
theres only <5 niggers in the whole movie and the stronk wimmyn are just nurses

>>34639897
To be fair sending armored divisions, whom were already in need of a refit after driving and fighting non-stop across northern France, to attack fortified positions without infantry support, all while the weather was turning the ground muddy and preventing proper air cover is a good way to get said armored divisions totally mauled.

>>34633433
thats all of 4chan not just /k/

Anybody notice the cold war era destroyer in the flotilla?

>>34646082
yes, and i think i saw the movie production studios (green warehouses)

>>34646143
Well they actually filmed it AT DUNKIRK so all the buildings and architecture are mostly 2017. They could have used decent CG to hide it but didn't. Luckily it's not that noticeable unless you're looking for it

>>34633218
Please ignore this retard. He needs to lurk some /his/.

>>34639897
>that was shown to be false.
Shown by whom?
>Weasel words, classical propaganda spin tactic

>>34640916
>>34645034
More so irony about American failure afterwards, really.
>Like Haitian failure to not enslave themselves due to lack of gibs
>Like American failure to be honest about 1812

How do they portray the french rearguard?

>>34645158

No... They did the usual Hollywood bullshit and but a love story in it and it ends with him dying 'meeting her again'. Fucking bullshit almost ruins the entire film.

File: 18e.jpg (52KB, 900x810px) Image search: [Google]

52KB, 900x810px

>>34631400
>>34631745
>>34633223
>>34633264
>>34637409
>>34644062
>>34645870
>>34646035
>falling for the bait this much

File: 91zLBUcnmrL._SY679_.jpg (109KB, 480x679px) Image search: [Google]

109KB, 480x679px

Is it /K/ approved?

File: he112.jpg (17KB, 606x240px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 606x240px

>>34640857
>ju-87
Not the he-112.. it's like you don't even into aesthetics.

File: japan.png (43KB, 603x436px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 603x436px

>>34643580
Fixed

>>34644308
>The soldiers realising they weren't cowards for escaping was quite moving, especially since the main reason for remembering Dunkirk is that there's no shame in living to fight another day, especially considering the UK went on to beat Germany and Italy on land sea and air before the US entered the war.
They weren't doing all that great

>>34646472
>that's bait
No, you're bait.

>>34646482
>Is it /K/ approved?

Absolutely. However there is only one real /k film. This is where eagles dare.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CdaeBiF__u4

>>34649564
Ah Clint Eastwood dressed as a Nazi duel wielding MP40s. Perfect

>>34649591
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8XKGhG0W0LQ

It is perfection in all ways.

Saw it today, it was fantastic. A solid 8.5/10.


Wish there were a little more back story with each character so I could become a little more attached -- but then again, the soldiers in the film had very little about each other as well.


Great film, go see it.

File: PolishMahWood.gif (3MB, 412x304px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 412x304px

>>34645588
>Stukas were doing dive banger action on the beach

LISTEN

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KuVcbU5iJBc

WHERE EAGLES DARE IT MUST /K OFFICIAL FILM BE

>>34644062

The American army had black soldiers in it. The American training film which I think you are referring to is this one:

https://youtu.be/ltVtnCzg9xw?t=25m47s

He's talking about how civilians in the UK would associate or speak to coloured US soldiers in a way which probably wouldn't happen in the US - i.e. in the US a nigra wouldn't have been invited over for tea.

File: 0ceb0a25339e8ee609e452ad52239fdb.jpg (208KB, 897x1168px) Image search: [Google]

208KB, 897x1168px

>>34649636
My favorite war movie theme is from Patton.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EnBYaWnKB6Y

>>34633242
>he left no survivors
Was crashing the pane part of the plan?

>>34630536
Was lucky enough to have a 70mm film showing at the nearest theater to me so I did that instead. IMAX may have been better for sweeping shots but the shaky film quality reminded me of old war movies, honestly made the experience for me. >>34633441
Why is /tv/ so trash? Went there for the first time last week looking for movie recommendations, every other thread was game of thrones and the only movies people were talking about were absolute dogshit. I figured it would be more like /mu/ where most people just regurgitate ignorance but there are a few good discussions and a decent sticky, but I learned absolutely nothing from the hour I spent there.

RIMLOCK
I
M
L
O
C
K

>>34650830
Wouldn't have happened if that faggot had loaded the bullets right

>>34650969
>gun fetish
>degenerate
Why are you here?

>>34639554
Brit and Russian glorification is nothing compared to Americans

File: Dakimakura.jpg (23KB, 480x480px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 480x480px

>>34651001
Good question. He clearly doesn't belong.

>>34646082
>>34646143
is he talking about here what you think you saw?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6AlDqFgQnqQ&t=7m34s

>>34630011
Why did the bongs just sit on the beach and wait for death instead of turning around and fighting?

Seems they got what they deserved. Learn2swim, bongs.