[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

What do you think of revolvers being used in actual combat situations?

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 166
Thread images: 29

File: revolver-german-SEK.jpg (161KB, 750x1125px) Image search: [Google]
revolver-german-SEK.jpg
161KB, 750x1125px
What do you think of revolvers being used in actual combat situations?
>>
Obsolete.

The only way i can see a revolver being used is if you gotta take down mister mundo if you know what i mean
>>
>>32889073
Not op but what about as something to carry while hiking? Im scared of mtn lions.
>>
10mm glogg is best innawoods pistol.
>>
>>32889089
.40 s&w and .357 Sig should be good enough for any predator except bears.
>>
>>32889089

theres no way you could hit and stop a mountain lion with a 6 shooter
>>
Doesn't make much sense when you can get 15 or more rounds in a semi auto. It makes more sense if there's the possibility of an attacker grabbing the gun - that's more a civilian self defense issue than a military/police one though.
>>
>>32889114

meme calibers
>>
>>32889089
Well i take combat=/=innawoods differently so my bad

If youre in lion/ bear country a good .44 is great
>>
>>32889032
Six bullets. More than enough to kill anything that moves.
>>
>>32889114
Tbh dude.
If i unloaded a full magazine of .40 fmj into a bear it is probably going down pretty easily. That's what semi autos are for after all, I don't think a bear could take that much top the chest and keep coming.

One shot? No
10 shots in 2 seconds? Probably
>>
File: Screenshot_20170205-022915.png (1MB, 1440x2560px) Image search: [Google]
Screenshot_20170205-022915.png
1MB, 1440x2560px
>>32889137
>Six bullets. More than enough to kill anything that moves

Go to bed kid.

http://www.baka.com.au/world/man-survives-after-being-shot-21-times-in-gunfight-20100809-11ukw.html
>>
>>32889122

Umm what? Are you saying if you are attacked by a predator, you expect to expend 6 rounds before you make a hit on the animal? I think you may have some misconceptions about how firearms are supposed to be used.
>>
>>32889137
>>32889143
I'm always amazed that some moron always takes this pop culture reference seriously.
>>
>>32889167
I think he is implying that you would never hit the animal at all with that kind of weapon, like semi autos have cat tracking bullets or something, which is even more retarded.
>>
>>32889032
I don't think in combat situation. But that guy is from a police special task force and they carry their favorite firearm meme, if your whole squad runs semi auto pistols it won't hurt if you have someone with a .44 stoppapowa
>>
>>32889073
This.

They are doubly useless in Military application, because you might not always know exactly where the enemy is and reloading every six shots isn't very great. Then again, that's not really what pistols are used for, but more bullets is always a good thing.
>>
I trust my M&P340 to save my fucking bacon if anyone tries to grab my duty weapon from its holster.
>>
http://www.policemag.com/channel/weapons/articles/2008/05/smith-wesson-327-trr8-revolver.aspx

When used with tactical shields, they're pretty OP

>no slide to catch on the shield
>8 shots with the TRR8
>>
>>32889032
gign seem to like them and i guess germans do too. honestly i believe >>32889137 despite the meme. There really shouldnt be any situation you are in a revolver couldnt handle and if it doesnt than another handgun probably wouldnt have either.
>>
File: speedloader.jpg (10KB, 383x244px) Image search: [Google]
speedloader.jpg
10KB, 383x244px
How effective are speedloaders compared to an old fashioned drop-n-pop clipazine that an automatic would use?

Faster? Slower? More/less awkward? Chunkier shape means you can fit fewer of them in a tacticool pouch?

>Personally, I'd go for automatics over meme guns in such a situation, but I'm not an oper8or so my opinion on such matters is ill-informed.
>>
>>32889032
Outdated, but ultimately functional, a gun is a gun is a gun, people CC 5shot .38 snubs just fine, because it's deadly enough and it's rare to even have to pull the trigger, let alone more than once.

>>32889089
That's not so much combat as wildlife defense, the mountain lion is PROBABLY not going to shoot back, so that's a concern to set aside.

A .357 Magnum with a 4" or 6" barrel (mayhaps a Ruger Redhawk), and good loads, can be very adequate. Lehigh XPs are pure rape in this caliber, for instance, it'll hollow out a black bear (not that you'd need to, black bears run if you sneeze or use a harsh tone of voice).
Buffalo Bore hardcasts are pretty heavy hitters too, when the box says hardcast, they really mean hard.

Are there 'objectively better' weapons? Sure, a shotgun or self-loading rifle would be easier and more effective, but it weighs more and takes up more space.

A shotgun, AR15 or AK would be quite amazing wildlife defense (also pulling duty for hunting), but you also want to consider if you actually want to bring a long gun with you, some do, some don't.

There's also the whole thing about a compact package, if you're really cornered or pinned by a huge cat, a long gun could be too big to deploy and be of no use.

>>32889122
Sure you can.

>>32889143
Underageb&
>>
>>32889322
Handguns almost not relevant in a military context.

I'm not kidding when I say an army could issue Hi-Points for sidearms and it would almost never matter.
>>
>>32889386
Speedloaders are reasonably fast with a bit of practice.

Full and half moon clips can be reasonably fast with practice too.

There are also speed strips, but they're more so you can carry spare ammo as a flat package and in units. It's faster and more practical than loading loose rounds from your pockets, but the other two alternatives are faster.
>>
>>32889032
That "revolver" could actually be a hammer to smash windows or something.
>>
File: Untitled.png (157KB, 250x377px) Image search: [Google]
Untitled.png
157KB, 250x377px
>>32889423
wow, nowadays hammers have speedloaders too??
>>
>>32889396
So an sp101 with the right load would be enough to kill one or at least get it to fuck off? Or would something in .44 be better?
>>
>>32889406
Yeah, that's true.
>>
File: volvospacecraft.jpg (265KB, 746x688px) Image search: [Google]
volvospacecraft.jpg
265KB, 746x688px
In applications in orbital gravity or the "free-fall" environment of space revolvers are useful. The extreme hot and cold of the vacuum of space makes traditional gun lubricants freeze or boil, making them a liability. A simple mechanical mechanism like an old six shooter makes more sense as an astronauts side arm.
>>
File: gign-en-action-1998-micheletti.jpg (570KB, 1000x1411px) Image search: [Google]
gign-en-action-1998-micheletti.jpg
570KB, 1000x1411px
GiGN kinda favouring the revolver over semi-automatics.

(Picture of real GiGN operation during 1998 AirFrance hijacking)
>>
File: tumblr_inline_ndvqjwbV641rvnfts.jpg (14KB, 500x216px) Image search: [Google]
tumblr_inline_ndvqjwbV641rvnfts.jpg
14KB, 500x216px
>>32889322
My mule thinks you're laughing at him. I know your not, but see he doesn't seem to understand. Apologize.
>>
>>32889501
>tfw you will never know the joy of speed loading your 16oz tactical claw hammer.
>tfw you'll never get to make "pulling back the hammer" and "hammer time" jokes while doing operator stuff.
>>
File: 1441550741958.jpg (91KB, 700x443px) Image search: [Google]
1441550741958.jpg
91KB, 700x443px
GiGN MR73 customized into a very-short range sniping system.
>>
File: Gign 002.jpg (84KB, 695x489px) Image search: [Google]
Gign 002.jpg
84KB, 695x489px
>>32889680
>>
>>32889143
Yeah but that was probably 9mm.
>>
File: MEK.jpg (56KB, 820x461px) Image search: [Google]
MEK.jpg
56KB, 820x461px
The MEK in Hamburg(where this pic is from) solely carries revolvers and no pistols. The official reason is the higher reliability and the ability of high powered revolver cartridges to break door locks and stop car engines.
>>
>>32889652
Sure, but I'd insist on at least a 4" long barrel to let Magnum loads be really worthwhile.

I'd probably also carry it on my person, not in my bag.

Again, go for something with shitloads of penetration like XPs or some good hot hardcasts.

.44 Magnun would have better effect for sure, but it's a lot harder to do followup shots with, especially if you've never shot one before, it means a lot of practice, and .44 isn't all that cheap (not even Specials).

I'm not saying don't go for .44 Magnum, because it's an excellent caliber for wildlife defense (and punks), but there's a higher barrier, make sure you have the money and time to git gud if you go .44
The kind of penetration a .44 Magnum hardcast can give you is really something else.
>>
>>32889669
>gun gets warm
>no air to radiate through
>heat stays in gun
>heat radiates towards through your hand or into the chambers
>get space chainfire
>no wind resistance and little gravity so shrapnel kills everyone in the area
SHEEEEEIT HOUSTON
>>
>>32889423
Thats a flashlight mountedon the butt of the revolver.
>>
>>32889692
Guys have taken magazines of .45 and not been incapacitated
>>
>>32889032
>What do you think of revolvers being used in actual combat situations?

better than semis
>>
>>32889032
Retarded
>>
File: autist burr.jpg (95KB, 622x447px) Image search: [Google]
autist burr.jpg
95KB, 622x447px
>>32889806
depends on what oyu are doing, as always. if you are bear/moose hunting, go with 44mag. if you are just innawoods for other shit, get a 10mm G20.
>>
File: IMG_3274.png (327KB, 535x632px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_3274.png
327KB, 535x632px
>>32889421
>>
>>32889089
any magnum revolver will do if bears any magnum revolver over .44
>>
File: rug_5301.jpg (16KB, 535x422px) Image search: [Google]
rug_5301.jpg
16KB, 535x422px
>>32889089
Six shots of .454 Casull.
Enough to kill anything that walks on land.
>>
>>32889032
>What do you think of revolvers being used in actual combat situations?
Define "actual combat situations". For personal defense or the limited roles they still enjoy in euro LE and CT circles they're perfectly fine...I think the GIGN and SEK know better than the neckbeards on /k/.
>>
File: 1474571489366.jpg (70KB, 1024x576px) Image search: [Google]
1474571489366.jpg
70KB, 1024x576px
>>32890544
>I think the GIGN and SEK know better than the neckbeards on /k/.

and thats where youre wrong kiddo.
>>
>>32890574
>>32889721
people don't do stuff without reasons. Different jobs require different guns
>>
>>32890656
>people don't do stuff without reasons.

yes they do.

>Different jobs require different guns

maybe but

>and stop car engines

is a demonstrably wrong meme from a movie popular in the 70s. They aren't even using 44mag though.
>>
>>32889125
Darren Wilsons pistol was pushed out of battery. It does happen.
>>32889721
>>32890544
Fit right into that.
>>
>>32890656
>>32890698
that aside, the German tier 1 cop/SOF soldier has about 1/5th the trigger time of a moderately trained US tactical doodle guy. Let that sink in.
>>
>>32890715
>Darren Wilsons pistol was pushed out of battery. It does happen.

in a scuffle a revolver can get mechanically blocked too.
>>
>>32890717
Source?

Also, I doubt that Germany's KSK (basically their DELTA equivalent) is worse trained than any DELTA, SEAL or DEVGRU guy.
>>
>>32889032
If you need a very powerful cartridge out of a small package.
>inb4 muh 10mm
10mm has nothing on a 44 mag
>>
>>32889198

no retard, I never said cat seeking bullets. im saying no one on this board has the skill to draw and fire on a fucking wildcat that probably got the drop on you, and be able to put it down with ANY pistol caliber with only 6 shots

shooting a cougar running at you at like 25 miles per hour is different than shooting cans off a fence or hunting an animal that likely doesnt even know you're there

i would never carry anything that's not semi auto and can hold AT LEAST 10 rounds for any kind of self defence
>>
>>32890698
>is a demonstrably wrong meme
.357magnum + is used for over 40 years now. If it wouldn't work, they wouldn't you it you retard.
>>
>>32890747
If a mountain lion gets the drop on you, you're dead. Period.
>>
>>32890780
Can confirm, played Red Dead Redemption
>>
>>32890789
Hey, me too!
>>
>>32889032
No. Use a semiauto. If you're in a combat scenario, you want as many bullets as humanly possible. You want 30 round mags for your pistols, you want a magazine that has a tiny fairy that makes more bullets for you.

You don't want to be stuck with six rounds then have to fuck around for two seconds just to reload, during which time your opponent, who is not stricken with autism, will have murdered you with his semiauto, which never emptied because HE HAD ENOUGH BULLETS.
>>
File: Zastava-HG3089-N-787450220720-1.jpg (15KB, 535x296px) Image search: [Google]
Zastava-HG3089-N-787450220720-1.jpg
15KB, 535x296px
>>32890780

jesus christ is everybody dumb? you have to admit you'd stand a better chance with 15 rounds of 10mm than 6 rounds of .44 right? or even better, 30 rounds of 7.62
>>
>>32890808

thank you for not being a moron. anyone who seriously recommends a revolver for defense has never shot under stress, and is going to get some poor uneducated bastard killed because they listened to that shitty advice and got a fucking wheelgun
>>
>>32890747
I drew and shot a bobcat while i was hunting but im pretty sure it was luck
>>
>>32889167

yes thats what im saying. have you ever shot at a a moving target?
>>
File: m92.png (297KB, 1024x365px) Image search: [Google]
m92.png
297KB, 1024x365px
>>32890818
>30 rounds of 7.62

An AK pistol would be the working man's weapon innawoods, yes. you know, when you're innawoods because you ahve a job to do and aren't just cosplaying your favourite young adult fiction novel or computer game. It kills the moose and bear dead. Also good against bipedes. shotgun, rifle and magnum revolver fgts get fucked.
>>
>>32890833
>anyone who seriously recommends a revolver for defense

the yannkee marshal does that.
>>
>>32889122

Retarded

Opinion discarded
>>
File: I'm GIGN.png (840KB, 1053x1600px) Image search: [Google]
I'm GIGN.png
840KB, 1053x1600px
>>32890574
Je suis GIGN
>>
>>32890861

ok have fun dying with a half empty revolver in your hands
>>
>>32890747
newsflash: the sound of a .44 magnum going off will probably scare an attacking animal
>>
>>32890858
And the lucky gunner
>>
It's a bad choice on a battlefield but for CT/HRT groups that have to use them maybe once a year it's a great no bullshit backup weapon. The weight isn't a big deal and the .357 will stop most threats with armor on. The chances of needing to reload are pretty slim and a medium frame revolver is much easier to use with gloves on.
>>
>>32890921

WOW NEWS FLASH, so will a 7.62 or a 10mm, or any other fucking gun. and if it doesn't, at least you have more than 6 chances to incapacitate the animal. a revolver has no benefit over a semi auto
>>
>>32890881
Por Vous
>>
>>32890921
you can scare a bear away by being loud, throwing a rock at it or hitting it with a big stick. but you shouldn't rely on that. scaring a bear away by hitting it is actually quite preferable as it teaches the bear fear/respect of humans.
>>
>>32890818
This is obviously true.
But if a Mountain Lion gets the drop on you, you're pretty much dead anyway.
Not supposed to be an argument to carry a revolver over an AK though.
>>
>>32889032
i've spent quite a lot of time behind a revolver. i trust it just fine to do what it's meant to do, so i'll carry it in the woods etc. with no worry.

if there is the chance someone /might/ even /think/ about shooting back, i've got my glock brand glock with two mags. there is a reason we went away from antique designs, same reason why i wouldn't carry a single stack 1911. we've come farther in a 100 years.
>>
>>32890842
I'm with you, I've seen how those move, they're fast and nimble. Hard to kill even if YOU have the surprise
>>
>>32891052
This. And if they attack you, they're not going to run at you from the front and they have likely been stalking you for a good while.
>>
>>32889032
Revolvers have been matched or eclipsed by semi autos in the following areas:
>price
>capacity
>size
You can get more gun from a semi auto similar size to or smaller than a J frame
>reliability
Modern quality semi autos are reliable enough that this has ceased to be a serious issue.
>practical accuracy
Testing puts match grade revolvers only slightly ahead of semi auto service pistols with tilting barrels when you go out to 50 yards. The difference is irrelevant unless you need to pull off 50 yard headshots although that could be made moot with a fixed barrel design.
>energy for what could be realistically considered for a service pistol role
.460 Rowland matches lower to mid range .44 magnum when using the barrel length of a typical service pistol (.44 magnum can still win from longer barrels due to having more powder capacity), can be used in a pistol with 10 round capacity with a flush fit magazine, and you can set up a pistol to use it for under $1,000. Revolvers currently only have an advantage when it comes to supermagnum rounds like .454 Cassul or .500 S&W Magnum or when using longer barrels.

The only advantages revolvers have are the ability to be chambered for supermagnum ammunition, more velocity increase from longer than average barrels to to increased powder capacity, the ability to still function when using really light loads for practice, the ability to work with lower quality ammunition if you want to fantasize about long therm SHTF/WROL/whatever situations, and that's about it.
>>
>>32889721
There exists no handgun that will stop a car's engine in one shot.
>>
>>32890760
They are not using it to stop cars because it won't.

The kind of shit you need to stop a car dead in it's tracks would be closer to Russian 23mm 'Barrikada' steel slug, .357 Magnum can at best be comparable to a small rifle cartridge like a .30 Carbine, maybe a bit more depending on loads.

A 7.62x51mm rifle would do a MUCH better job at destroying the engine of a car, and even then that's a good couple of shots and waiting for the thing to die.
>>
>>32891370
anecdotal, i know, but i've had both my revolvers fail more than my glawk. and all three of those failed more often than they should.
>>
>>32889423
I think you mean that revolver could be a "hammer" if you needed it to be
>>
File: Ruger SP101.jpg (74KB, 960x720px) Image search: [Google]
Ruger SP101.jpg
74KB, 960x720px
>>32890833
>>32890808
In the statistically unlikely scenario that you actually pull the trigger (just pointing a gun is reliably effective in scaring off perpetrators), it's even less likely that you'll do it a second time.

I understand that higher capacity is nice, but fact of the matter is that in the average CC scenario, a snub revolver will consistently be 'good enough'.
You want high capacity, I encourage it, I want the same, can't hurt, but let's be real for a moment.
>>
>>32891520
Combat dipshit, combat. War - Where your opponent isn't trying to mug you.
>>
>>32891575
Then you're barking up the wrong tree even more.

Handguns don't matter for shit in war.
>>
>>32891575
>Combat dipshit, combat. War
>combat
>war
The two aren't necessarily synonymous. No one will argue that revolvers are appropriate military weapons, but they're fine for civilian/LE defense and even some limited counter-terror use. You'll see more Glocks and SIGs in their holsters than in decades past, but even in recent pictures you'll see GIGN troops armed with .357s...I guess you know better than them how to do their job?
>>
>>32891478
>but i've had both my revolvers
Irrelevant without knowing the make/model and how they failed.
>>
>>32891727
blackhawk that likes to let the cylinder pin slide out on recoil, and an h&r that's just a fucking mess all over.
>>
>>32889721
The reason is if you shoot the dindu with .357 he'll lay down and 'll stay down. Stopping power, dude. They are good enough shooters to hit any poor refugee (who happens to need to kill ya) with the bullets they have, and don't expect prolonged firefight anyway. If SHTF they have 5.56 rifles
>>
>>32889032
Revolvers are a good choice for concealed carry by those who aren't exceptionally skilled at handling a gun. As for legitimate combat use, I guess a well-trained person with a high-quality .357 magnum could make it work, but why would you if you have access to a semi automatic?
>>
>>32890747
ok, what would you carry for bear protection a semi auto shotgun, a battle rifle? You know that you have to carry that extra weight right to actually be considered carry, beein in your undies in your room with your DEAGLE BRAND DEAGLE
>>
>>32889032
Dude has an MP5. Why even bother with a less accurate, non-selectfire, low capacity pistol?

Why not have a 44 mag backup?
>>
File: IMG_2523.jpg (485KB, 700x670px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_2523.jpg
485KB, 700x670px
>>32891712
>>
>>32889143
>>32889172
>>32889692
That story might be BS, but here is a similar one.

>In 2007, Navy SEAL Mike Day walked into a room in Fallujah and was immediately met by four Al-Qaeda militants who opened fire on him.

>Day’s rifle was shot out of his hands. He was hit 27 times in total. Fortunately, his body armor successfully stopped 11 rounds, but 16 rounds penetrated his body in various places.

http://controversialtimes.com/military/navy-seal-shot-27-times-by-4-terrorists-he-killed-2-of-them-with-a-pistol-now-see-what-hes-doing-video/
>>
>>32890505
would this be a reliable bigfoot self defense gun
>>
>>32891862
>h&r that's just a fucking mess all over
So you're comparing a decades old gun that was on the lower end when it came out to a modern higher quality service pistol?
>>
>>32889073
Useful if you are carrying a Ballistic shield

source: GSG 9
>>
>>32891983
>Fortunately, his body armor successfully stopped 11 rounds
This is really all that matters. There's no reason for your body to stop working within a time frame that would be relevant in a CQB situation, even when considering rifle ammunition, if no round damages major organs (which are the largest target and pretty much covered by a rifle plate or a concealable kevlar when dealing with opponents armed with pistols/shotguns), the brain, the spine (which is mostly covered in the case of rifle plates or a concealable kevlar vest), or severs one of the major veins/arteries that go to your arms/legs/head.
>>
>>32892327
>glawk
>higher quality

it's okay. it goes bang most of the time.
>>
>>32891976
Is he grabbing his belt while shooting his gun?
>>
>>32889137
Except for 7 people.
>>
>>32889721
Why don't they use deagle brand deagles?
>>
>>32889032
their only use is as a boot gun and even then that's kind of a meme
>>
>>32893588
because muh higher reliability.

Fun fact, they don't use speedloaders, they change the cylinders
>>
File: MRAPS-IV.jpg (145KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
MRAPS-IV.jpg
145KB, 1280x720px
>>32889347
>>32892399
>muh shields
Pretty much a non issue now days given that there are shields cut for resting your gun on. There are even ones designed so that the shield guy can use a rifle while holding the shield (pic related, which can also stop rifle ammunition).

>>32893595
Semi autos even beat them for that. Meme tier advantages of revolvers are things like being able to blindly fire them through a bag.
>>
>>32893792
>antiquated
>low capacity
>overpriced
>underperforming

i was unaware that 1911s were revolvers.
>>
>>32889032
my only thought as to why it would be effective is the need for penetration or shock on heavier defended targets.
>>
File: 16_rocznica_powstania_GROM_16.jpg (237KB, 1024x680px) Image search: [Google]
16_rocznica_powstania_GROM_16.jpg
237KB, 1024x680px
>>32893588
JW GROM I think has Mark XIX Desert Eagles in their inventory, but they don't really use them too often.
>>
>>32889137
I can't fucking believe you fucks don't recognize that line anymore. At some point you could do it and all was good and /k/ was fun but now it's all retard autists sperging out. Y'all should be fucking ashamed of yourselves
>>
>>32894573
>cucks not realizing MG memes
>>
File: WegenersM19_zps6b0467cf.jpg (67KB, 1024x678px) Image search: [Google]
WegenersM19_zps6b0467cf.jpg
67KB, 1024x678px
The GSG-9 preferred to use revolver in aircraft hijacking situation. They even used the S&W M10, M36, M19 during 1977 Landshut hijacking.

Picture is the real duty pistol of GSG-9 commander Ulrich Wegener used and fired this gun when entering Lufthansa"Landshut in Mogadishu, October 18th, 1977..
>>
File: WegenermitM191977_zps7d6873e5.jpg (62KB, 722x550px) Image search: [Google]
WegenermitM191977_zps7d6873e5.jpg
62KB, 722x550px
>>32896036

Ulrich Wegener with Chancellor Helmut Schmidt who gave the order to rescue the hostages. Note the holster.

The point is although revolver is kinda odd, but in certain situation. Revolver will out-classed the Semi-Auto pistol.
>>
>>32890505
what would the instructor think if I showed up with one of these
>>
>>32896036
Why the US quarter in the grip? I bet there's a story behind that too.
>>
>>32892640
he tucked it in his pants. the old one hand shooting stances had their hand in the pocket or tucked in like that.
>>
>>32889143
>9mm
>>
>>32896300

Yup. But no one knows the story behind it. Some say this revolver was gifted by Major Beckwith himself. But that just a rumour.
>>
File: I fucking hate bears.jpg (37KB, 346x480px) Image search: [Google]
I fucking hate bears.jpg
37KB, 346x480px
>>32889142

Black bear, maybe.

Grizzly bear, you might as well bathe in BBQ sauce, your 10 rounds of .40 is just going to piss it off
>>
>>32891575
You seem to have combat and combatant confused.
Also revolver doesn't seem that bad in a mugging, if they try to grab if they'll probably get a nice cylinder burn even if the bullet misses.
>>
>>32891964
>44 mag backup
only thing worth it now in handguns vests are everywhere
>>
>>32889114
>357 sig
NERVE DAMAGE
N
E
R
V
E

D
A
M
A
G
E
>>
>>32890731
true but it's more likely to work once it's pulled away. What's getting me seriously thinking about revolvers is this guy's training video, and some from Sage Dynamics that I can't find now. Semis get out of battery a lot in these training events
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jSFpJqK1sP4
>>
>>32889669
revolvers are more complex than most automatics.
>>
>>32893903
YOU T-TAKE THAT BACK
>>
>>32899632

And that will only make a difference in a SHTF situation, or if you're a Green Beret deep behind enemy lines in a daily survival situation, where your gun is being bumped and eating dirt daily.

Since most of us here in the city, suburbs, or small towns carry our EDC gun doing normal mundane tasks, and shoot it at the range occasionally.

It won't see any failure from that extra engineering.

And as a matter of fact, are even more reliable if the need to pull the gun out ever came.
>>
>>32896715
Nah, i think fmj would do fine with less than shit shot placement. If they stood up like that they would get a heart and lungs full of lead and blood, I'm sure you'd be ok.

If you didn't have time to aim with a .40 and place shots then you don't have time with anything else either and bullet size won't make a shit if you shoot them in the foot as they maul your face.

As long as you can penetrate reasonably i think any caliber that starts with 4 would be fine.
>>
>>32899598

Proving that grappling is important
>>
>>32891404
Mechanic here. One shot stops of auto engines require a lucky hit on ignition or fuel systems for a prompt stop. Engines can otherwise take severe damage and continue running for quite a while.

Best way for a one shot stop is kill the driver.
>>
>>32899971

Chris Kyle said this
>>
>>32899971
>shoot the google car driver
>car keeps coming at you
>regret
>>
>>32891913

A J-frame revolver takes more skill to use than an auto.

The double action pull requires more attention
>>
>>32889032
I heard a few years ago NYPD was purchasing S&W revolvers for their SWAT to use with ballistic shields as selfloaders might jam if the slide recoils into the shield while firing.

Don't know if they actually went through with it though.
>>
>>32896715
If you are innawoods in bear country then bring a rifle to kill the bear and anything else you get a shot at. There's no point being innawoods if not hunting.
>>
>>32899986
If the car is coming at you the momentum will carry it into you even if the engine quits.

Do not stand in front of moving vehicles lest ye be squashed.
>>
>>32900012
I think you missed "google car", I had to re-read it myself
>>
File: Thierry Prungnaud.jpg (76KB, 576x661px) Image search: [Google]
Thierry Prungnaud.jpg
76KB, 576x661px
>>32896036
>>32896062
Likewise, to keep with revolver trivia, the pointman during the 1994 Air France Flight 8969 hijacking used a MR 73.

The first one to enter the cockpit, Thierry Prungnaud met the four terrorists, killing two of them and wounding a third one before being shot by the fourth, which was hiding under the navigator board.
He was hit by seven bullets, six in his right arm and one on his helmet, shattering its visor, and fell outside the cockpit.
Shortly after he was again wounded by a grenade before his teammates managed to reach and evacuate him.
>>
File: Thierry Prungnaud arm.jpg (63KB, 579x659px) Image search: [Google]
Thierry Prungnaud arm.jpg
63KB, 579x659px
>>32900079
>>
File: MR73.jpg (109KB, 676x561px) Image search: [Google]
MR73.jpg
109KB, 676x561px
>>32900084
Manurhin also send him a new revolver, to replace the one destroyed during the assault.
>>
>>32898955
Calm down Dugan
>>
>>32896062
But that's not Schmidt, that's minister Maihofer
>>
Yeah Reddit I know.

>GI Joe cannot get a firearm
>gets shipped an 1858 black powder revolver
>OP alledges that GI Joe killed two gooks with it
>yfw you are the gook getting killed by hundred year old tech

https://www.reddit.com/r/guns/comments/rezzc/my_fathers_sidearm_while_he_was_in_vietnam_album/
>>
What's the best pistol against skinwalkers? Or should I just try to make friends with them?
>>
>>32900084
Must've been an interesting procedure for the surgeon in charge.
>>
>>32889386

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lLk1v5bSFPw
>>
>>32900377
I find them quite friendly. Why make trouble, anon?
>>
>>32900496
So next time I'm called into the dark woods, I should go?
>>
https://www.instagram.com/p/BPteirLAWKh/


Also, this:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6sj6bmEAIzQ
>>
>>32889032
If you're accurate with it and you can make good use of what ammo you have it's perfectly viable in CQB.
>>
>>32901094
200% badass
>>
>>32900440
He lost his arm I think
>>
>>32899989
No shit. Which is why I said "well-trained" and "high-quality". J-frames aren't high quality. They're pretty much middle of the road. Were I to carry a wheelgat, it'd have to be a Python or maybe something like a model 27.
>>
>>32901199
He's still got it, it just has limited functionality. There's a video of him shooting his MR73 somewhere.
>>
File: IMG_2657.jpg (576KB, 1200x880px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_2657.jpg
576KB, 1200x880px
>>32901223
It surprises me to see the difference in how the people act nowadays. Here we got a guy who pretty much lost his arm and nearly died protecting his country but fast forward to today and the people would be somewhat mad at him. Like the guy who shot the terrorist at the louvre. People are mad at the guy for stopping people from dying. Where is the logic in that
>>
File: 1485424972312.jpg (105KB, 640x640px) Image search: [Google]
1485424972312.jpg
105KB, 640x640px
>>32901347
Being mean to brown people is bad anon, that's racism! They have to get their way even if it kills you.

Fuck this gay earth.
>>
>>32890505
>Ruger Alaskan
goodbye hands
>>
>>32901406
>goodbye hands
recoil or unsafe?
>>
>>32896715
IT'S SO ADORABLE
>>
>>32890848
And yet I work for the Forest Service in Montana (you know, where grizzlies and mountain lions are) and the guys that carry usually carry either 9mm (this is mostly LEOs) or .357 magnum (this is other USFS employees doing work innawilderness).

So yeah basically all you guys are dumbasses and people who work innawoods professionally and carry are gonna pack a hot-loaded revolver (unless they're worried about people rather than animals).
>>
>>32901347
>people
No, just no, most people aren't angry at him. It's just that most (I.e. a large majority of people) don't care enough to post anything on the internet.
The people you're noticing are vocal but small in number.
>>
>>32901552
>So yeah basically all you guys are dumbasses

OK, an AKS is dumb for innawoods, we feel you.
>>
>>32901564
Still shitty behavior
>>
>>32890833
PROTIP: If you can git gud shooting a revolver double-action then shooting autos is like playing with cheat codes on.

Practice practice practice.

Also, .357 is probably the smallest pistol caliber with enough kinetic energy behind it today make STOPPIN POWAH a factor in a defensive shooting.
>>
>>32891404

>tfw the deagle isn't actually chambered in .50 Beowulf.
Thread posts: 166
Thread images: 29


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoin at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Posts and uploaded images are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that website. If you need information about a Poster - contact 4chan. This project is not affiliated in any way with 4chan.