Why is Napoleon a hero while Hitler is a villain?

one is french and the other is g*rman

File: 1491110911573.jpg (11KB, 226x225px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 226x225px

Hi

>>73110321
Napoleon didnt massacred civs by millions
Napoleon followed the rules of war
Napoleon was noble and smart unlike Hitler who was mongrel and kike as well

Ideology and, well, constant propaganda that vilified his persona.
Though, I don't remember Napoleon doing mass executions of civilians.

>>73110364
>Napoleon followed the rules of war
what rules did he follow and what rules did hitler break?

>>73110321
Napoleon didn't try to exterminate whole groups of people in an industrial manner

>>73110431
Read about rules of war in 18-19 century
The Geneva Convention (1929)

>>73110364
This is true. There is also the fact that the Napoleonic wars happened before warfare was made efficient. It was still seen as noble by the masses, and had decisive results. There was no trench warfare at the time. But it's true that they are pretty similar.

Mass murder of non combatants is probably a big part of the reason.

File: 1491080467995.jpg (43KB, 500x424px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 500x424px

>>73110321
M'/pol/anon

>>73110364
>Hitler was a kike

Ah yes. He was also gay and had one testicle.

>>73110542
Hitler was a kike loving faggot, if he wasnt one of (((them))) he would have put them in camps and gassed them for real

>>73110542
He was and he did. Also he got cucked by a practicing Jew

>>73110592
Is this from Buzzfeed's Ten things you won't believe about Adolf Hitler?

>>73110321
Excuse me, Napoleon was NOT a hero

>>73110542
>SS had jews
>natsoc party had jews
>Hitler himself was partly jew

>>73110635
The heroes were the Duke of Wellington and Horatio Nelson

one was actually good at war

>>73110321
Industrialization. Napoleons wars weren't fully industrialized, and he didn't murder people using an industrial supply chain that carried people like cargo into ovens.

Napoleon tried to bring about social progress in Europe. He tried to end absolute monarchy in Europe and, although he was defeated in the end, his example inspired the social revolutions of 1830 and 1848.

Hitler was a criminal surrounded by gangsters whose main purpose was slaughtering people with industrial means. Other war leaders killed their enemies as a means to conquer lands, defend their own or press claims to a throne, the Nazis were particularly evil because killing millions was not an unfortunate consequence, it was the whole point.

File: Nordic Aryan Masterrace.png (811KB, 2233x393px) Image search: [Google]

811KB, 2233x393px

>>73110542
>>73110615
h-heil! xXDDD

>>73110321
Hitler planed and put into action a genocide on half of Europe.

Napoleon did not.

That's the key and main difference between the two

>>73110321
Hitler - hates Poland
Napoleon - loves Poland
THAT'S WHY!!!

>>73111924
>Napoleon - loves Poland
Another deluded cuck.

He loved Poland so much that he allowed newly-created pseudo-nation like Prussia to exist. Everyone who reads knows that it was Prussia that was against any form of Polish country because they were afraid and he let them live.
He also didn't listen to Polish generals when they said to station in Baltics and Crimea and wait for the supplies.
Instead of creating Kingdom, he created Dutchy. Kingdom was later created by the Russian tsar.

Lmao, this is your Napoopleon.

>>73110321
>napoleon
Some guy who lived long ago, has not effected anyone alive today
>hitler
Literally just happend and people are still feeling the effects he left

That's why

You should read about Hitler's postwar plans for Europe. They were pretty fucked up.

>>73111977
oj weź już zamknij dupe próbuje być zabawny. :)

>>73112011
>has not effected anyone alive today
French Revolution and his chimp-out affects people to this day.
>>73112038
hur dur it was a joke XDDD

>>73112046
Przepraszaj mnie natychmiast!!!

>>73112046
>implying regular people know anything at all about Napoleon

Not everyone is like you mr.autist

>>73112073
Just becuse they don't know about it, doesn't mean they live in the world he created.

You stupid fucking snownigger mongrel.

>>73110931
>He tried to end absolute monarchy in Europe
He was Emperor

>>73110364
>Napoleon didnt massacred civs by millions
>Napoleon followed the rules of war
>Napoleon was noble and smart unlike Hitler who was mongrel and kike as well
Omg, do you really belive what you are writing ? I feel sorry for you.

>>73110327
one is Italian and one is Austrian

>>73110321
>Napoleon
nobody gives a shit abou Napoleon other than the French who love to live in an illusion of grandeur

>>73112135
Whilst military deaths are invariably put at between 2.5 million and 3.5 million, civilian death tolls vary from 750,000 to 3 million. Thus estimates of total dead, both military and civilian, can reasonably range from 3,250,000 to 6,500,000. - Wikipedia
And it was probably a whole lot more.

Napoleon abolished feudalism in the countries he conquered; this made it possible for the growth of modern nation states over the following decades.

File: 1467894338347.jpg (16KB, 185x243px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 185x243px

>>73112196
good one

>>73112164
We give a shit about Napoleon as mush as you do with uncle Bismarck. Giving a shit about some of the most important part of your nation History is not the same as jerking off on french colonial empire maps.

Anyway Napoleon Brought some good part of the french revolution through Europe and he soled you Louisiana and fought against Britain. As modern mainstream History go through the american POV that makes sense.
Napoleon Good Guy and Adolf bad guy.
Anyway i still believe Hitler was evil on earth whereas Napoleon was more of a warmonger beliving in some kind of post revolutionary french "manifest desitiny".

good doc watch the rest, this is the relevant part
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TXYDnJpKX_E

>>73112281
>he soled you Louisiana
I meant to speak to OP here

File: Europe_1812_map_en.png (1MB, 2293x1512px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2293x1512px

Don't cry because it's over, smile because it happened.

>>73111977
Napoleon's ultimate plans for Poland are unclear anyway, he never said what he intended to do with the place.

File: the_french_colonial_empire_by_dinospain-d8tobxf.png (604KB, 4976x2516px) Image search: [Google]

604KB, 4976x2516px

>>73112281
>is not the same as jerking off on french colonial empire maps.

To be fair, look at these curves. How could anyone resist, really ?

>>73110364
>Napoleon followed the rules of war
So invading your allies is allowed?

Because French imperialism is better than German imperialism. I'm glad that he was defeated though, so the eternal Anglo could rule.

>>73110515
>There is also the fact that the Napoleonic wars happened before warfare was made efficient
Which is bullshit by the way. Foch was still seen as noble, Lettow-Vorbeck was still seen as noble and Rommel was still seen as noble. Individual behavior on the battlefield and treatment of prisoners of war counts more than what toys you're using.

File: Marseilles street prayer.jpg (53KB, 622x409px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 622x409px

>>73112454
Wait, aren't your former colonial subjects now colonizing you?

>>73112589
It's worse than them just colonizing us, actually. Not only (((we))) invited them in, but now we are paying them to stay and outbreed us.

>>73112482
>be Nappy
>see Spain going full civil war
>advisors tell you you're popular anyway
>take it

He just wanted to put spanish autism down

File: 2000px-Arms_of_Joseph_Bonaparte_as_King_of_Spain.svg.png (823KB, 2000x2189px) Image search: [Google]

823KB, 2000x2189px

>>73112482
Reminder that Godoy was an opportunistic fuck that was ready to backstab us at the first chance.

Reminder that Ferdinand was a retard, but that he willingly abdicated in exchange for money.

Reminder the old king Charles literally told Napoléon to pick a new king.

Reminder that this "invasion" was just a police action to secure the throne for the now rightful king of Spain, Joseph Bonaparte, because the Spaniards were chimping out.

Reminder that you would have been way better off under the enlightened despotism of the Bonaparte than under the shitshows that were the 19th century Spanish Bourbons.

Reminder that in the end you just traded a French dynasty for another.

Because Napoleon backed by jews.

>>73110321
>falling this much for anglo propaganda

>>73113135
spanniard btfo

Napoleon didn't fuck with people who controlled the world's media.

>>73110321
Napoleon has liberated Europe from feudal laws and fought against anglos.
Hitler is just a Krupp's bitch promoting german rule over everything

>>73114955
Both sides were.

File: frenchies didnu nuffin wrongo.jpg (25KB, 460x276px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 460x276px

>>73110321
>spanish civil war
>invade spain
>spanish people revolt against frenchies
>napoleon killed all of them
napoleon didnu nuffin wrongu

>>73110321
>napoleon
>a hero

He was yet another in a long line of manlet European dictators who got BTFO.

File: 1325065675038.png (168KB, 407x379px) Image search: [Google]

168KB, 407x379px

>Napoleon

- Tried to liberate Europe from oligarch groups
- Tried to civilize and unify a continent
- Wrote laws and a civil code which basically defined modern Western law and is considered one of the pillars of the modern definition of "Western world"
- Tried to unite the European people under one banner
- So on and on
- Brought the ideals of the French Revolution to the territories he controlled

>Hitler

- Following the old Germanic tradition, destroyed Europe
- Killed millions of Jews, Slavs and Germans because of his retarded autism
- Literally thanks to him being nationalistic or patriotic is frowned upon today
- Because of that Europe is going to shit, because you can't defend your country without someone calling you a Nazi (literally destroying Europe from the grave)
- Because of his action the State of Israel was born, bringing war and instability to the Islamic world and middle east, the cause of most of today's problems (was it so hard to just offer them Madagascar?)
- The study of human genetic diversity and human populations was halted because of him
- Eugenics was literally killed for ever because of the Nazis
- Basically all of the world problems and mostly Europe's can be tracked to Hitler and the Nazis

>>73110321
Napoleon was considered the antichrist in the 19th century, he was only rehabilitated in the 20th.

Napoleon liberated Jews from the ghetto. Hitler took their money. And the people today who determine what is history, are Jews

>>73118041
>Napoleon was considered the antichrist in the 19th century
By the Russian nutjob.

UK was literally a global jewry's pawn. Who the fuck financed them if not Rockefellers and Rothschilds? lmao, the City of London.

Anglos and Germans are the biggest goys of the Jews.

>>73110542
And he was also a drug addict with the third stage of Neurosyphilis who fucked his niece (causing her kill herself), and he later killed his dog with cyanide before killing himself, yes.

>Napoleon a hero
But he is not. No one, except europeans, considers him a hero. For the rest of the world he is Hitler-tier.

>>73110321
Both are bad but some of the actions that Hitler did are so deplorable that it made Napoleon look like a saint in comparison and the legacy that Napoleon left behind is far more positive than Hitlers.

Also another reason is because history is written by the victors and the losers are viewed as "villains" or "savages" regardless if the victors are any more ethical than the villain

Adolf von Hitler did nothing wrong

>>73118301
Usually you try to make the losers cool after you beat them. Take English romanticism of Scotland after before Bonnie Prince Charlie, Indians in US after 1890s, etc. Jews are just congenitally incapable of forgiveness

>>73110364
>Napoleon followed the rules of war
>Napoleon was noble and smart
>Napoleon didnt massacred civs by millions
Mmmm

>>73117930
>Because of his action the State of Israel was born, bringing war and instability to the Islamic world and middle east, the cause of most of today's problems
How cute, it thinks Pisslam hasn't been at war with the West for 1400 years.

>>73118558
Making up a country of what they hate the most in the middle of their territory didn't help, senpaitaichi

>>73112454
Second Empire only caused troubles.
The French kingdom has always been better

>>73117681
See here >>73113135

Stop listening to Anglo propaganda.

I'd have to say the holocaust was Hitler's fault and it always will be.

non-meme answer? we still live in a post-ww2 world where hitler is the unofficial secular satan of the anglo-american interpretation of history. once the last veteran dies and the war stops being a concrete factor in decision making and politics he'll just be one failed leader among a dozen more and his real lasting impact on history will be determined. Just like with napoleon who was portrayed as the anti-christ by his enemies but who was also unarguably one of the most brilliant military leaders in history. hitler will definitely not be remembered as a brilliant military strategist but maybe he'll be remembered in the far future as a brilliant propagandist, who knows. we'll have to wait for unbiased historians.

File: Szwoleżer-Lansjer.jpg (72KB, 663x885px) Image search: [Google]

72KB, 663x885px

>>73110321
GOD BLESS THE EMPEROR

>>73113135
Holy shit, I don't like Spain at all but your extreme narcissism and cognitive dissonance actually made me feel sorry for them for about a second.

About 50% of the points you tried to make are just wrong.

>>73110321
Because Napoleon spread liberty, equality, fraternity while Hitler just spread racism, totalitarianism, militarism