[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

question /his/ dilemma

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 79
Thread images: 18

File: DCIM2694.jpg (68KB, 394x501px) Image search: [Google]
DCIM2694.jpg
68KB, 394x501px
If my fathers grandfather was a Berber from Algier, but since 3 generations we are living in Germany and his son and grandson only had children with European women. Am I considered European?
>>
>>479687

Well, since Hermione is now a negress, I suppose so.
>>
>>479693
the Harry Potter one?
>>
depends... if you have a german name, speak german at home, watch german tv, eat german food and stopped being muslim then yes you're european

otherwise you will always stay a foreigner
>>
No, you are a symbol of the humiliation and degradation of European women by taking up brown cock under the influence of American popular culture, and would be lined up and shot by a returning National Socialist political movement into power.

Luckly for you, that will never happen.
>>
>>479696

Yep. I damned near fell off my chair when I saw that.
>>
>>479687
Yes. A European sand nigger.
>>
>>479710
>if you have a german name, speak german at home, watch german tv, eat german food and stopped being muslim then yes you're european

so only if I denounce my heritage completely and hide or lie about it? although I myself, nor anyone can change it, and it will always be in the records who my father and grandfather were.

>>479713
so although all of my maternal ancestry, or autosomal genetic heritage is european, you do not consider me european because my grand-grandfather was a Berber from Algier.
>>
File: aaa.jpg (10KB, 266x189px) Image search: [Google]
aaa.jpg
10KB, 266x189px
>>479721
POST SOURCE NIGAAAA

>noooo
>>
>>479687

Yes. To be a European, you must be conversant with Europe's culture. Race has nothing to do with it.
>>
File: o.jpg (10KB, 231x244px) Image search: [Google]
o.jpg
10KB, 231x244px
>>479732
>Race has nothing to do with it.
I also dip into choco sometimes
>>
>>479732
>you must be conversant with Europe's culture

Doesn't mean that he has to lie about his heritage, change his name, and denounce islam ffs.
>>
>>479730
>so although all of my maternal ancestry, or autosomal genetic heritage is european, you do not consider me european because my grand-grandfather was a Berber from Algier.

Exactly, and particularly since you seen to hold this berber ancestry to higher regard and follow his culture instead, you are not a European but a symbol of the conquest of Europe by foreign elements.

Actually, this is a very common phenomenom. When the Indo-Europeans invaded Europe, they mixed with local women, of course, so after a few generation almost all the genetic heritage was local, but they still spoke Indo-European languages, they still worshipped Indo-European gods, so they were still Indo-European, the ancestry of the maternal line doesn't really matter in the end because the propagation of culture go through the male line.
>>
>>479687

You wanted to post this on /int/
>>
>>479687
Yes. obviously.

>but muh /pol/ shit
no one cares faggot, go watch your c.uck porn alone.

>but muh heritage american shit
Americans have a terrible grasp on all issues regarding ethnicity.
>>
>>479710

it doesn't have anything to hide your heritage, itls about living like other europeans

it's ok yo be a proud algerian but then you can't claim being european too

wanna be german ? live like a german

I'm french, not german, but if I'd went to live to germany I'd give german names to my kids, and try to learn german culture myself.

I'm sick of the multiculti bullshit. You're either a foreigner (which is not a bad thing) or you try to become like your new countrymen.

You can't claim being european if your name is Abdul Mohammed, you watch arab tv 24/7, you don't eat pork and drink alcohol and speak arab at home. It's ok to live like that, but you're not european.

If you're not happy, go back to where you came from.
>>
>>479745
and get /pol/ crap??

/history/ is the only board one can discuss such questions without retards bantering, and thats because burgers have no history.
>>
File: Zinedine-Zidane-014.jpg (1MB, 2560x1536px) Image search: [Google]
Zinedine-Zidane-014.jpg
1MB, 2560x1536px
>>479687
No man you ain't European, you are a Berber. You can either hide it, deny it, lie that you ain't and pose as a German, but one shit that you can't do is to change it.

You are a Berber the only choice you have is to accept it or not.

>and in my book those who accept what they are, are always more respected than those that pretend what they aren't
>>
>>479799
>You are a Berber the only choice you have is to accept it or not.

OP here. You are right, thanks anon.
>>
>>479799
No you fucking faggot. One of his great-grandparents who he has never met came from a place he has probably never been.

If he lives in germany, speaks german, knows only germans, has only german family, etc etc etc.

He's a fucking german.


Americans man, I swear to god.

>but muh 1/6,000,000% berber blood
nobody gives a shit.
>>
File: kompromiss-gesundheitspolitik.jpg (63KB, 860x455px) Image search: [Google]
kompromiss-gesundheitspolitik.jpg
63KB, 860x455px
>>479860
>meltin'pot multiculturalist bullshit
you are the acting as a burger m8

the guy's a berber, certainly not a German, same as this guy's a chink.
>>
File: family photo32.jpg (61KB, 634x408px) Image search: [Google]
family photo32.jpg
61KB, 634x408px
>>479860
>I won't spit on you, I am not that kind a man.
>>
>>479860
This guy is right.
>>
File: anons.jpg (90KB, 640x478px) Image search: [Google]
anons.jpg
90KB, 640x478px
>>479878
>>479860

when did they gave you niggers internetconnection?
>>
>>479687

IF YOU LIVE IN THE EUROPEAN CONTINENT, YOU ARE EUROPEAN; "EUROPEAN" IS A DEMONYM.
>>
>>479731
There's some stage play in Britain about the Harry Potter characters as 50-something adults, and Hermione is being played by a black woman
>>
File: 8_Vols_teaching_8.jpg (2MB, 2592x1944px) Image search: [Google]
8_Vols_teaching_8.jpg
2MB, 2592x1944px
>>479878
>>479860

Remember kids, when migrating to Europe, if you and your children want to be considered European, you have to have sex exclusively with white European women.

>fucking sick
>>
File: annolied.jpg (1MB, 677x4595px) Image search: [Google]
annolied.jpg
1MB, 677x4595px
>>479860
He lives in Germany, he speaks Germany, he knows only Germans (does he?) and has only German family, but he isn't German, he will never be German.

That's the history board, you should know such things from history. Conquering races settle between subjugated populations, but aren't totally assimilated. Germans themselves were like this in the Greco-Roman world in Late Antiquity, and the Arabs in the Muslim world, Turks in Turko-Persian civilization, they act like dominant ethnicities, even if Timur lived in the Persianate world, spoke Persian, employed mostly Persians and had Persian wives in his harems, he was not Persian, he was a member of the Turco-Mongol ruling class.

Germany as an independent nation was conquered by the Allies in 1945, and the victorious powers brought foreign auxiliaries to consolidate their rule. This guy is just a descendant of one suxh auxiliary, a man the U.S. pressured the Germans to let him enter the country and there the first thing he did was impregnate a naive German women ridden with guilt for Hitler and Nazism.

The German spirit is absent of such a man, he is the son of Germany's defeat, the offspring of it's conquest.
>>
>>479876
If you're an American you probably have a black great grandparent so by your own logic you are the nigger.

>>479870
If you think someone who's never been to North Africa, has probably never heard a form of amazigh being spoken, has 7/8 german great-grandparents and has lived in germany all his life is somehow a berber, then you must be an American. It's like saying chuck lindstrom from Minnesota is a proud gaelic Irishman. fucking retarded.

Anon probably decided to check his ancestry and found this berber lad. big deal, it's just some dead guy.

>melting pot
>multiculturalist
they're the exact opposite of each other.

besides germany is so rekt after world war 2 that I doubt there is a single german wihout some slavs, anglos or latins in their family tree. By that logic there are no germans.
>>
>>479928
>besides germany is so rekt after world war 2 that I doubt there is a single german wihout some slavs, anglos or latins in their family tree. By that logic there are no germans.

slavs, anglos, latins, all european.
OP asked about being european, not german.

Europe ain't Clapistan, and please don't ever compare it with that mongrelised piece of crap.
>>
>>479887
>>479920
>>479921
t. butthurt american half castes

We don't have to be insecure about our ethnicity in Europe because we have a culture.

>>>/pol/
>>
>>479940
>We don't have to be insecure about our ethnicity in Europe because we have a culture.

We do, the Europeans. You half-breed mongrelised africans have shit. Accept what you are niggers, it will at least give you some dignity.
>>
>>479687
Well the guy in that pic looks Semitic as hell, blond-hair aside.
>>
>>479687
tell them you descend from vikings
>>
Well you're only 1/8 berber and berbers are still Caucasian, so yeah you're not a pure German, but then again nobody is "pure". But you're still have different ancestry than the average ethnic German.
The only way to know is if you posted your face.
>>
You can probably pass off as a German, right? My grandfathers father is a gypsy, rest is a mix of Swedish/Saami and I mostly pass off as Swedish. I still don't look like the stereotypical swede and I lack pronouncing cheekbones and I have a massive Jewish nose but yeah.
>>
>>480368
>The only way to know is if you posted your face.
Whats his face has to do with it?

It's not about passing, he asks is he considered, thus will his children be considered European. I saw Europeans, mostly Brits that look like Armenians, still everybody considers them Europeans.
>>
>>480389
>still everybody considers them Europeans.
still everybody considers them Brits.
>>
>>479687
You are an European citizen (if you have the passport of an European state), same as every American is the citizen of the USA, but you are not a native European.
>>
>>480636

How is he not a native german when only his father's grandfather is berber?
>>
>>480636
Citizen yes, Native? Nah.
>>
File: families-households-18-638.jpg (80KB, 638x479px) Image search: [Google]
families-households-18-638.jpg
80KB, 638x479px
>>480961
>How is he not a native german when only his father's grandfather is berber?
>How the fuck does anyone what ethnicity one has

By your patrilineal ancestry dumbwit.
>>
This is a retarded argument. I'm a fourth generation immigrant from Germany in the US, both of my great grandparents' on my mother and father's sides came from Bremen just after the great war. I've never stepped foot in Germany, nor do I speak the language or know family or anyone from the old world because my grandparents specifically refused to inform my parents about family ties or teach them the language so they could better integrate in the US. According to people in this thread though, I'd be German rather than American, unless there's some mystical difference between the requirements to be an American and to be a German.

Maybe we should define the exact definition of what it means to be a cultural citizen of a country first?
>>
>>481049
>burgerism is a disease
You are an ethnic German, but an American citizen FFS, is that so hard to comprehend.
>>
>>481017
>By your patrilineal ancestry dumbwit.
why not by matrilineal ?
>>
Real question is, why do you care?
>>
>>479731
http://waltonian.com/2015/12/j-k-rowling-loves-black-hermione-casting-in-new-play/
>>
If we were to flip the script and say that he had a great-grandfather that was German, but in the past three generations he and his family have been living in Algier and have only procreated with Berbers. Is he still considered German?

If you say he isn't European in the original context and also say he isn't European in this one, care to explain why?
>>
>>479687
This is Isabelle Adjani, a half-german half-algerian berber girl.
If she isn't european then most of europe isn't.
>>
Ethnicity is meaningless. I don't know why you autists circlejerk about haplogroups and shit. Just because my great x7 grandfather was an Ottoman rug salesman that moved to Brunei, would not mean that I were Turkish.
>>
>>481049

>his ancestors fled to Clapistan and wanted to become burgers by completely integrating

Ahaha jesus fuck i fell out of my seat
>>
>>483508
this.
People and poltards try to establish the pureness of someone blood while humans history is the result of what burgers call "race mixing".
If you say this guy is not german cuz he had a Berber great grandfather, then what's your opinion on SIcilians? Are they european or not?
you fuckers.
and also, OP, do you live it as a problem? do you really think that not having 'pure german blood' is REALLY a problem for you?
who cares?!
>>
>>479687
Bane?
>>
>>479687
Weren't the original Berbers from Scandinavia?
>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berbers#Origins
>DNA analysis has found commonalities between Berber populations and those of the Sami people of Scandinavia showing a link dating from around 9,000 years ago.
>>
>>483718
More likely that the Saami people somehow originated in Africa since they came to Scandinavia fairly late compared to the original inhabitants. And trough Finland and not Germany.
>>
>>483736
No apparently there was a migration south around 10,000BC
>>
>>483697
Except Sicilians are still something like 98% pure Italian. The whole 'moors raped them now they're black meme' is entirely false.
>>
>>479687
>"Hey guys I'm 7/8th German, am I really European?"

The idea of genetic "purity" is a silly conceit dreamed up by people who either don't know much about science or know just enough to obsess over things that don't actually matter.
>>
first of all berbers don't originate in NA, meaning they're not indigenous to NA.

This berberist movement is just used politically to dissaociate from Arabs.

>Hurr we're not Arabs, we're Berber see, we're not Arabs I swear, those Arabs invade NA and turn my people muslim hurr
>>
>>483801

I dont get what the hell are you trying to imply.
>>
File: Onofrio_Barone.jpg (17KB, 241x300px) Image search: [Google]
Onofrio_Barone.jpg
17KB, 241x300px
>>483756
Sicily is not black, is the original melting pot.
There are people with Scandivanian and African heritage who mixed in the last ten centuries, like Tunisia or Palestine or a lot of other Mediterranean areas.
There's still today Arab looking people and viking looking people.
When sicilians arrived in America, they weren't considered white.
and also, they were not "fucked by turks", Muslim dominance in Sicily was one of the best time for the ISland, economically and scientifically.
To come back on topic, we have way more berber/african heritage than OP but we don't question ourself with "pure blood" fantasies. we are not poltards
>>
>>479908
god forbid that a darkie plays make-believe
>>
File: sicilian23andme.jpg (22KB, 424x241px) Image search: [Google]
sicilian23andme.jpg
22KB, 424x241px
>>483949
Lol. Have you ever been to Italy or Sicily?

I went through both a couple of years ago, I could not tell the difference between people from the mainland of Italy or the people in Sicily. There is a varied range of skin tones in both places, people who are almost Arab looking, to people who could pass as Swiss. Most have at least a slight tan.

>pic related, a Sicilian 23andme result....
>>
>>479687
I've never heard anyone from Sweden calling him/herself an European. We call eachother whatever nation our biological parents are from. For example a gamiban male and swedish female would have an gambian-swedish kid and if it was a boy who later had another kid with swedish female it would still be a gambian-swedish kid since it wouldn't look swedish yet.
>>
>>483987
I was born and raised in Sicily my mate. my knowledge doesn't limit to a trip of some days.
what you ignore is the enormous migration from southern italy to northern italy. the majority of people you see in Rome, Florence, Bologna, Turin or Milan are migrants or sons of migrants from SIcily, Sardinia and Southern Italy.
Of course, Sicilian look like europeans, like Isabelle Adjani who is half Berber or Zinedine Zidane. But a lot of sicilians with beard could be easily mistaken for ISIS troops.
What I was trying to say is that race purity doesn't exist. Mediterranean countries are heavily mixed. In SIcily there are still arabic surnames.
As a Sicilian, my point of view on race is the opposite of an American: there are no rigid boundaries between "white" and "black".
a little story from WWII to better explain myself: when Tunisian people saw for the first time American troops they asked themselves: "why they are pale white or dark black? why they didn't mix and became brown, like we did?"
this is of course popular thinking, but I think it brings a great truth: American fetishize race and skin colour
>>
>>479687
>American notions of ethnicity

Just stop, literally We Wuz Kingz tier.

Just because someone has a berber great-grandparent doesn't make them a berber.
>>
>>484045
finally someone said it!
also >>483768 is good
>>
>>483749
That doesn't make sense since there didn't lived any Sami people in Scandinavia by that time.
>>
>>484016
>American fetishize race and skin colour

The whole world notices skin colour and ethnicity. Studies have shown that people recognise race before they even recognize gender. It's most probably due to our tribal origins as a species, to recognize the differences between groups.

>when Tunisian people saw for the first time American troops they asked themselves: "why they are pale white or dark black? why they didn't mix and became brown, like we did?"

The Tunisian people have always been brown, save for a few smaller migrations of Europeans....

But yes, genetic studies from Sicily actually show that the Moor admixture has had virtually no effect on the genetics of the people there. 2% difference isn't going make them look any different to mainland Italians. Racism in general is probably never going to disappear, it's an innate quality of humans.
>>
>>479687
I think you should be more exact with your question. Are you asking whether you are "genetically European" or something?
Because in other terms I don't see a way in which you WOULDN'T be an European. Born in Germany, I assume you speak the language, have citizenship, lived there your life so far and been influenced by your German environment every waking moment and so on.

And if you're asking about genetics I find your question rather silly and just a matter of defining and agreeing on what is considered "enough" of certain genetic material to be classified as an "European". It doesn't have any more meaning to it.
>>
>>479687
Yes, berbers are pretty close to europeans to start with and you're 7/8ths german so you're quite obviously white.
>>
>>484271
In tunisia you can find "black" looking people and red haired people, while the average Tunisian isn't that different from the average Sicilian; for centuries up until the '50s there were constant exchange, which continues still today.
What I am trying to say is that Mediterranean people are so close to each other.
>genetic studies from Sicily actually show that the Moor admixture has had virtually no effect on the genetics of the people there.

I'm genuinely interested in those genetic studies. But while we have 2% 'moor' ancestry, northern italians claim Celtic heritage. Moreover, Muslim domination of Sicily was mainly from berber north african tribes, Fatimides, with little Arab/Turk/Black presence, a loto of the settlers were Greek converts. So there wasn't a great difference in "race" between the colonizers and the colonized. After them, Normans came to birng even more genetic diversity.
I agree with the fact that racism will never disappear. But in the USA it is very vehement because you have a very recent history of pure hate. 50 years ago black people couldn't vote in the US. Black grandfathers today couldn't vote in their 20s. It will take centuires to adjust
W.E.B. Dubois said that Sicily was the "original melting pot" and Sicilians were "at half road" between blacks and whites
>>
>>479687
Fuck the haters, if you live in Europe, speak an European language, consider yourself an European and are aligned with her values, live and work for the benefit of Europe, you are as much of a son of Europe as anyone. Even if your skin is pitch black.
>>
>>479921
>He speaks Germany

You are a bloody idiot, man. What the fuck is German then? Everyone everywhere was a migrant at one point.
>>
>>479860
He doesn't sound like he considers himself a German. If he did, he wouldn't even have to fucking ask.

I'm German and I can tell you, without a mile-long explanation, that he's NOT German and that's that.

Yes, maybe some kind of "modern", "multiculti", mixed whatever kind of German with a German passport, but not a regular German. At least not if he has to ask. And especially not if he's a muslim.
>>
As long as there is any doubt in your or anyone elses mind, you're not a true member. Self-identification is meaningless, your surroundings must consider you an insider for it to actually be the case. And lying to yourselves doesn't work either, because we all know what REALLY is the case.
>>
>>484344
Here you go:
>http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2985948/

>The genetic contribution of Greek chromosomes to the Sicilian gene pool is estimated to be about 37% whereas the contribution of North African populations is estimated to be around 6%

So 6%, not 2%. But 6% isn't really going to make a big difference in their appearance either...
>>
File: image.jpg (79KB, 520x365px) Image search: [Google]
image.jpg
79KB, 520x365px
>>479687
mischlings passed as germans according to the old rule

although you were barred from certain privileges like joing the SS
>>
>>486778
thank you very much my friend. for things like this, /his/ is like internet pre 2003, I really appreciate.
talking about the article, if you mix 37% greek and 6% North African=43% with another 6% middle eastern and the 50% european, you have a perfect EuroMediterranean.
This for what concern genetics. But OP was asking if he can consider himself German.
National Identity is something only YOU choose. This year sadly passed away Benedict Anderson, the inventor of the expression "Imagined Community", referring exactly to National Identity.
YOU choose if feeling German or Berber.
The abstract of the article my friend posted says:
>The general heterogeneous composition of haplogroups in our Sicilian data is similar to the patterns observed in other major islands of the Mediterranean, reflecting the complex histories of settlements in Sicily.

>Heterogeneous

This means you can choose if feeling one thing or another. That doesn't mean you "are" one thing or another.
Thread posts: 79
Thread images: 18


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.