[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

Celts

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 108
Thread images: 25

File: celts.jpg (2MB, 3050x2000px) Image search: [Google]
celts.jpg
2MB, 3050x2000px
Why are Celts so irrelevant?
They never contributed to anything. Celtic languages are dead, not even Irish speak their own language anymore.

They got all Germanised.
>>
>control majority of western europe
>do nothing with it
>get germanised
>>
Poor ability to confederate. Similar scenario to the Native Americans, really.
>>
>>3327241
Celts were probably a culture band rather than a race or even a united people per se.
The connections drawn between the insular and Continental Celts are very weak and specious.
>>
>>3327241
Dude, the people who contributed the most to the development of the world, the British, French, Spanish and, are all essentially Celts. They just changed culturally.
>>
>>3327339
Those Celts were essentially the Pre IE people, and they just changed culturally.
>>
neanderthal cuck genes from armenia
>>
>>3327339
British are Anglo-Saxon.
>>
>>3327357
Not genetically, not much. Before the advent of Anglo-Colonialism, most colonialism resulted from a small number of founders creating a colony consisting of mostly native members, resulting in very little admixture. A modern Englishman is very little different from a Welshman
>>
>>3327364
So Anglo-Saxons rule over the Celts? Like I said, Celts are irrelevant.
>>
>>3327241
At school They were those barbarians Who for genocided by them, never got why we had to study them and Not my ancestors
>>
>>3327386
Yee, but now the English are irrelevant too.
>>
>>3327241
Ugly, naked, They got memed Into fame by The thousands of autistic white we wuzzers obsessed with them, fucking annoying
>>
>>3327339
The Spanish were still half PRE IE ( TURDETANI, IBERIANS, AQUITANI)
>>
Infighting, eg against the romans, rather than fighting on a united front there was just stupid bullshit

Fuck these retards for being so useless
>>
>>3327346
>Those Celts were essentially the Pre IE people,
Literally dumbest post ever

The Celts are the IE that replaced the Natives, the Slavs(aside from the Poles, Belarussians Russians) and Germnics are the Pre IE

>>3327435
You're literally R1b DF-27, Iberians were I2a and G2a
>>
>>3327241
Didn't they make chain mail or something?
>>
>>3327685
>Didn't they make chain mail or something?
nah, they stole it from the etruscans
>>
I'm wondering now
Are Sardinians and Corsicans celtic people too?
We know for sure that Nuragic were pre-indoeuropean
Are Celtic people pre-indo mixed with indo-euripeans?
>>
>>3327898
Celts were Indieuropean so no, Sardinians traded with The Iberians, especially those in The South west coast where They probably established a small community at Huelva, the other people They had direct relationship with were The Villanovians, the precursors of The Etruscans, They established an emporium in The coastal city of Populonia and probably one at Vulci too, They also had a trading relationship with Cretans and Cypriots but those were more sporadic
>>
>>3327587
Celts are I.E. you retard
>>
>>3327959
Oh yeah I forgot about The Sicels, They had a direct relationship with them too especially those in The Aeolian island of Lipari
>>
>>3327357
Celts with some anglo-saxon blood.
>>
>>3327395
200 nuclear warheads disagree.
>>
French are franks
Most relevant brits are anglos
Spain kind of counts but they're weird mongoloids(t.spainard) so im not sure if they coubts
>>
File: 34613036445_11e6205501_o.jpg (3MB, 3398x4856px) Image search: [Google]
34613036445_11e6205501_o.jpg
3MB, 3398x4856px
Are the Celts the most consistently fashionable people in the world?
>>
>>3328134
>Celts
>some modern day person

LOL...

Might as well say Gucci is Roman
>>
>>3328131
I'm a gaul.
>>
>>3328137
[thinking emoji]
>>
>>3327964
Reread my post, i said :

>The Celts are the IE that replaced the Natives
>>
>>3328179
Not in Iberia or Turkey
>>
>>3328165
If Scotland is celtic then so is half of Europe
>>
>>3328193
This. Scotts, Welsh, and Irish are just English-speaking LARPers.
>>
>>3328196
What about the 2 million or so people who speak Celtic languages?
>>
File: blue eyes UK.jpg (52KB, 634x632px) Image search: [Google]
blue eyes UK.jpg
52KB, 634x632px
tell me about britons, why are they so swarthy
>>
Is it true that Galicia was originally celtic?
>>
>>3328229
40-50% blue eyed is well above the world average. And British skin is notoriously pallid and pale. So I'm not sure what you're talking about. We do have enormous amounts of rather swarthy immigrants, though.
>>
>>3328240
You now know that North Italians are 40% blue eyed on average
>>
>>3328222
They are the real Celts, but they don't inhabit the majority of this territory: >>3328165
>>
>>3328229
Seems a bit low desu. Most English are blue eyed and brown haired with pale skin.
>>
>>3328134
>>3328165
>>3328196
>>3328257
scotfag here
the idea that after so long and so many kingdom collapses and language changes not to mention the huge number of people who have mixed with us Romans ,angles ,Saxons ,vikings and English but through all this we are all essentially the same Celtic people from 450BC is frankly ridiculous
>>
>>3328373
>the huge number of people who have mixed with us Romans ,angles ,Saxons ,vikings and English but through all this we are all essentially the same Celtic people from 450BC is frankly ridiculous
This is the truth though. Settled agrarian populations just don't change all that much. There'll be some admixture along the points of contact but yes, Scots are essentially the same people as they were 2000 years ago, as are the Irish, English, Egyptians, Italians, etc.
>>
>>3328373
>porridge wog doesn't understand genetics
who would have guessed
>>
>>3328185
>Not in Iberia or Turkey
Not in Turkey but they did in Iberia.
>>
>>3328402
>>3328407
yeah from a genetic perspective we can trace are routes but culturally linguistically religiously were completely divorced
>>
>>3328373
Or that modern perceptions of Celtic culture haven't been deliberately corrupted by people like Walter Scot as a reaction to Anglicization.
>>
File: 5mnYzMf.png (688KB, 1600x847px) Image search: [Google]
5mnYzMf.png
688KB, 1600x847px
>>3328402
>>3328407
>Scots are essentially the same people as they were 2000

actually they had a much darker complexion you can see this evidence of Norse and Germanic migration of the British isles through the distribution of blonde hair blue eyes
>>
>>3328757
>Anglo
>56% blond

Delusional Anglos
>>
>>3328791

"Light", not blond. All those light browns count as "light".
>>
>>3328803

Only to make shitty maps.
>>
>>3328757
unsourced map
>>
>>3328497
Not really, considering the celtic core Hallstat area is pink or even light pink in your area and the dark red area is Basque I would say it's not a goo proxy for celtic blood
>>
>>3328841
Basques have less R1b than Western French, Irish, and Welsh

They're just our rape babies

>considering the celtic core Hallstat area

Hallstat is a meme

Proto-Celts start with Bell-Beakers who were all R1b-P312
>>
File: BellBeakerNodes.jpg (214KB, 1121x794px) Image search: [Google]
BellBeakerNodes.jpg
214KB, 1121x794px
>>3328860
>Proto-Celts start with Bell-Beakers who were all R1b-P312

Yeah sure thing
>>
>>3328860
>our
?
>Hallstat is a meme
congratulations, you're oficially fucking retarded.
Hallstat is a source for R1b-U106. Germanic branch of R1b.
>>
File: Celt.png (612KB, 908x664px) Image search: [Google]
Celt.png
612KB, 908x664px
>>3328877
>Claim that Celts start with Hallstat
>Proceed to claim Hallstat was Germanic

WE
>>
>>3328912
>he thinks people segregated themselves according to haplogroups
You're dumber than I thought. You should stick to /int/, the audience there is uneducated.
>>
>>3328757
This. British and Irish people are part of the mediterranean race.
>>
>>3329088
Forgot to post pic.
>>
File: R1b MATER RACE.png (599KB, 1408x3200px) Image search: [Google]
R1b MATER RACE.png
599KB, 1408x3200px
>>3328967
>So uneducated that you claim that Hallstat was Germanic and U106
>So uneducated that you claim that U106 is Germanic
>So uneducated that you are not even aware that Bell Beakers were all R1b-P312 aka Continental Celts

I repeat Basques are our Rape Babies, actual Iberians were I2 and G2
>>
File: 1147400.jpg (70KB, 512x384px) Image search: [Google]
1147400.jpg
70KB, 512x384px
>>3328134
>Invent trousers
>stop wearing trousers when everyone else adopts them
Celts are just hipsters
>>3327241
Well, pretty much the entire Roman panoply was Celtic in origin.
I suppose one of their chief contributions to history also partly caused their demise.
>>
>>3327241

That sweet boar staff...
>>
>>3327241
I like how this retarded picture is mixing Urfield, la Tiene, Hallstat all in a big "Celtic" pot
>>
>>3327299
lol wtf
>>
Celts were plenty relevant during the Iron Age. There's even an argument to be made that Irish monks helped preserve the works of the Classical world during the Dark Ages.
>>
>>3329463
Irish monks did more than that, they were at the center of basically every major theological debate in Europe and founded a lot of their monasteries. The "preserving classical knowledge" thing is a bit of a meme, at the time they were much more renowned for doing their own thing, often out of step with the Catholic Church at large. The Carolingian nobility chimped out at one stage because basically all the King's closest advisors were Irish. This sort of stuff continued until around the 12th century.

An interesting example is the Synod of Whitby, a Northumbrian debate about the Easter computus. On one side, you had churchmen from Ireland, on the other side, you had churchmen educated in Irish institutions who conducted the debate in Irish, and presiding over it you had a King who was converted by Irish churchmen, ruling over a country introduced to Christianity by the Irish. Basically the only figure involved in the debate who had no connection to the Irish was the King's wife, who arguably started the whole thing because she wouldn't conform to the Irish Easter Computus.
>>
>>3329518
WE WUZ KAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAANGZ
>>
>>3329521
What did you mean by this? I'm German
>>
>>3327587
>Literally dumbest post ever
Ok.
>Slavs(aside from the Poles, Belarussians Russians) and Germnics are the Pre IE
You just topped his post in stupidity my friend.
>>
File: manuelburque01.jpg (138KB, 713x975px) Image search: [Google]
manuelburque01.jpg
138KB, 713x975px
>>3328497
>Iberia
I wouldn't say the whole Iberia but primarily in northern Spain and Portugal.
Galicians (Spain) are still mostly Celtic.
>>
>>3327241
They made/invented chainmail...
>>
We, even we, was KAZANGZ

N shit.
>>
File: PCA.jpg (304KB, 1024x997px) Image search: [Google]
PCA.jpg
304KB, 1024x997px
>>3329555
>Iberians are celtic

lol
>>
>>3327364
Apart from the bestial lust for sheepish cunts of course, which the Welshmen takes literally, and the Englishmen figuratively.
>>
>>3329575
>I said Galicians, not all North Spaniards
>Spanish_North on the chart is clustered very close to France and just south of Ireland, with small genetic distance anyway
Learn to read and to interpret your own data fucktard.
>>
>>3329575
Galicians are Celtic. Look it up.

Idiot
>>
>>3328229

Brits/"British" islanders = darker hair, lighter skin

Scandis/continental germsnics (except for some dutch who are pale)= lighter hair, blue eyes more common, but swarthy skin

In early america, Swedes and Germans were distinguished from anglos, Scots and Irish from their swarthy golden tanned complexions
>>
>>3329627
>>3329626
t. angry gallegos
>>
>>3329627

Yeah, no they're not. 2,000 years ago, perhaps, but exactly zero remains of their Celtic culture, language, or even genes.
>>
File: IMG_3801.jpg (291KB, 600x900px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_3801.jpg
291KB, 600x900px
>>3327364
>>3327386
>>3327997
What are you niggers talking about. The Anglo-Saxon takeover of Britain wasn’t like the Norman invasion. It was complete replacement of the natives. The Celts fled to what we now call the Celtic fringe, as shown here>>3328165
>>
>>3328165
>orkney
>celtic
I think you mean "Norwegian"
>>
>>3327357
British is a collective term.
As far as genetics go,

Scots are 50% Irish, 40% Pict, and 10% Norse and Anglo

Irish are 95 % Irish , and 5% Norse and Norman

English are 30% Germanic and 70% Celtic

Welsh unknown, but heavily Celtic.
>>
>>3331071
>Le saxon massacre meme
Nigger stop getting your history from that shitpile King Arthur movie.
>>
>>3331071
This is incorrect LMAO. Some Celtic tribes were pushed into the western edges of Britain, the rest stayed and adopted Saxon culture and language. I can't believe people are still so uneducated to believe the saxons killed everyone. They didn't. The majority of Anglos are still genetically ''Celtic/Iberian whatever'' just Germanic in culture and language.
>>
>>3327299
Wait, the Picts were not Celts? Also, are modern southern Germans more Celtic (as in Germanized Celts), or Scandinavian-derived Germanic, in ancestry?
>>
File: 49AMtGC.jpg (831KB, 2000x1198px) Image search: [Google]
49AMtGC.jpg
831KB, 2000x1198px
>>3327299
>>3327241
ah yes, the "germanic" "people"
>>
File: reallymakesmethink.gif (505KB, 1080x1080px) Image search: [Google]
reallymakesmethink.gif
505KB, 1080x1080px
>>3331193
>attractive people vs not attractive people

hmmmm
>>
>>3331255
not the same phenotype
>>
>>3331260
Half of the above are fucking painted. Paintings don't have phenotypes.
>>
>>3331279
oh noe my germanic heroes were insulted :(
>>
File: 1469327109945.jpg (351KB, 1473x1990px) Image search: [Google]
1469327109945.jpg
351KB, 1473x1990px
>>3327241
Shame those bitchin ass hats got lost to time, they're fucking tits.
>>
File: 1279577015570.jpg (45KB, 384x288px) Image search: [Google]
1279577015570.jpg
45KB, 384x288px
>>3331369
>jewel encrusted shield

>go on strike at me!
>im so wealthy i can afford to lose them
>you cant dent my wealth nor my life!
>>
>>3328097
Even the North Koreans have nukes now, who cares?
>>
>>3328608
Not really. The Celts who were around in 450BC developed into the Celts around in 950 AD, and modern Scotland developed, primarily, from those peoples.
>>
Celts liked to suck fat germanic cock
>>
File: 1467492752324.jpg (413KB, 800x777px) Image search: [Google]
1467492752324.jpg
413KB, 800x777px
>>3332804
your missing the Angle invasion and colonization leading to the use of old english in the central belt which forced the votadini Celts to migrate to wales. Also the picts getting btfo by Gaels and Scotii which changes the language from Brittonic to Gaelic in the highlands
so again not really linguistically as nobody speaks a form of welsh here , not really culturally we dont leave offerings to gods we cant remember in bogs
if you want to focus purely on genetics then yes we are continuation of these and many other peoples but by that logic Modern Turkish people are a continuation of the ancient Greeks
>>
File: 1492368020175.png (260KB, 1180x987px) Image search: [Google]
1492368020175.png
260KB, 1180x987px
>>3327587

>being this retarded

They didn't replace anyone, you fucking morons. Let alone the Slavs and Germanics who weren't anywhere near

People really need to get rid of this meme that migrations from the Iron Age onwards actually radically changed demography when in most cases it was very minor and most conquered peoples adopted the culture. Serbs don't look anything like Russians despite both being Slavs, because the vast majority of their ancestors were Slavified, not exterminated or whatever.
>>
>>3334357

*who werent anywhere near the Celts when they expanded
>>
>>3334297
>not really culturally we dont leave offerings to gods we cant remember in bogs
the people living in Scotland Christianised pretty quickly senpai
>>
>>3327328
Hi dan
>>
File: Yamnaya R1b.jpg (122KB, 544x791px) Image search: [Google]
Yamnaya R1b.jpg
122KB, 544x791px
>>3334357
>Post Autosomal DNA
>On a thread about ancestry

Retard confirmed

Pic related is Indo-European DNA compare it with >>3329107

>because the vast majority of their ancestors were Slavified, not exterminated or whatever.
This is what i said
>>
>>3335638
lineages of R1b from Yamna have nothing to do with Western Europeans
>>
>>3327733
Source?
>>
>>3327241
What were other groups of people living at the same time as the Celts?
>>
>>3328402
>modern scots are essentially the same people as 2,000 years ago
>actual scots only migrated to northern britain in the 5th century
>the same
>>
>>3327587
>aside from the Poles, Belarussians Russians
What about Czechs, Slovaks, Slovenians, Croats?
>>
>>3337376
Culture changes, religion changes, ruling class changes, genetics generally don't, at least not in the old world
>>
File: anglo-saxon ancestry.png (24KB, 1115x151px) Image search: [Google]
anglo-saxon ancestry.png
24KB, 1115x151px
>>3331071
>The Anglo-Saxon takeover of Britain wasn’t like the Norman invasion. It was complete replacement of the natives
Not even close to being true.
Thread posts: 108
Thread images: 25


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.