[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

west european aristocracy all germanic?

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 148
Thread images: 14

So I herd an interesting theory in the other thread before le autistic French ruined it.
It said that all western European aristocracy and nobles stem from Germanic origin.
Like during migration age, Germanic tribes conquered everything that was left of the west roman empire and made themselves at home.
Lombards took Italy, Visigoths took Spain, Franks took France (and Belgium and the Netherlands and Alemanni took what is today southern Germany/Switzerland.
All those societies where tribal, early feudal and Germanic, and so all the noble families where of Germanic origin.
Due to class laws, clear distinction between Germanics and Romans, hugely favoring the formers and constant intermarriage the Germanics (now culturally adapted to their new homes) made themselves the ruling class, and this system kept on going up to the French revolution.
Is this true? Did Germanics really take over all of western Europe?
>>
>>3051660
Eastern Europe too.
>>
File: 640px-Saint_Remy_baptise_Clovis.jpg (68KB, 640x351px) Image search: [Google]
640px-Saint_Remy_baptise_Clovis.jpg
68KB, 640x351px
>>3051691
Not so sure, there is plenty of Polish, Sorbiana and Silesian noble houses who seem to be of Slavic origin. The Russian Rurik dynasty might have some Germanic in them.
The Frankish empire on the other hand had only nobles of Germanic origin as far as I know.
>>
Patrilineally, it is most probable, excepting of course Hungarian and Slavic aristocracy intermarrying with Germans in HRE.

Matrilineally it is most doubtful.
>>
>>3051703
Hungary/Bohemia - Habsburg (Germanic)
Romania - Hohenzollern (Germanic)
Greece - Glücksburg (Germanic)
Russia - Holstein-Gottorp-Romanov (Germanic)

They slowly weaseled their way onto almost every throne in Europe during the 19th century.
>>
>>3051706
Yes, I guess there is a lot of cucking done in over 1000 years. but can we say for the first 2-300 years it was pretty obvious that nobility was of Germanic breeding stock?
>>
>>3051727
You are missing the argument, 19th century politics are not what I meant. All those countries have a domestic nobility class that is not of Germanic origin. Germans becoming king there trough marriage in the 19th century doesn't really change that fact.
>>
>>3051706
So kind alike the Normans took over England and still have most of the nobles titles. German tribes took over western Europe and their families prevailed.
>>
>>3051660
Well, the Tudors were Welsh.
But most nobles and royalty were Germanic.
>>
>>3051731

Actually it is much easier to trace the noble houses from the 10th century onwards, than it is in let's say 500-800 ad.

There is quite simply not enough information about the origins of these noble houses, which were certainly part of the military class and elite, but not yet powerful feudal holders. Who knows what kind of intermarriages went on during the middle and late migration periods.

Hell, if I remember correctly there is a roman senator somewhere in Charlemagne's ancestry.
>>
File: Verdun_Treaty_843.svg.png (325KB, 800x706px) Image search: [Google]
Verdun_Treaty_843.svg.png
325KB, 800x706px
>>3051753
Can't remember Wales or even Britain being part of the Frankish empire and hence part of this question.
But pic related sure only had germanic nobles left.
>>
>>3051769
Before William, Britain was ruled by Anglo-Saxons (Germanic) or Danes (Germanic too).
>>
>>3051783
ok, point taken.
>>
The Bernadotte dynasty is Frenchies taking over the throne of Sweden. Thats some payback.
>>
>>3051809
>Bernadotte could have worked with Napoleon, ensured French victory and possibly gotten Finland back in the process, but instead he threw it all away.
>>
>>3051850
>Bernadottes still rule Sweden to this day
>it is good to be king
>Nappy is dead
>>
>>3051859
>rule
Pretty strong words for the weakest monarchy in the world. At least the Japanese Emperor is a religious head. Is it really worth reigning if you do not rule? Pretty sure the Bonapartes would have preferred to abdicate rather than that.
>>
File: tour_img-539145-70.jpg (102KB, 960x640px) Image search: [Google]
tour_img-539145-70.jpg
102KB, 960x640px
>>3051888
nice trips Adolf.
Also, the Swedish royal family must be so sad to be so powerless, I sure hope their little holiday cottage makes them feel happy a bit.
>>
>>3051908
Yeah it's interesting because the first Bernadotte exercised a lot of his authority and was pretty absolutist until more pressure was put on him.

>Adolf
But why
>>
>>3051933
Maybe he was just smart, like Napoleon is a sinking ship, I am king of Sweden and if I play this right all my offspring will live in wealth and style for the centuries to come.
>>
>>3051660
The vast majority of european nobility is nowhere near old enough to be able to claim roots from postroman germanic settlers, so no.
>>
>>3051964
European high nobility of the early medieval certainly was. Most of them can trace their roots back to Frankish times.
>>
>>3051960
Napoleon wasn't a sinking ship at the time though. French supremacy was at its height and Sweden was in conflict with Russia. No one predicted Napoleon's defeat and the thought at the time was that France was invincible and total victory for her was inevitable.
>>
>>3051985
Bernadotte became king of Sweden in 1818, long after Napoleon and France have been finally defeated.
>>
>>3051973
>high nobility of the early medieval
Most of the high nobility of the early medieval period didn't survive beyond the 12th century tho, so it's kind of a moot point.
Most european noble lineages start being somewhat reliable around the 12th century, by which time it would be absolutely impossible to establish the ethnic origin of new nobility, especially considering the merchantile origin of urban aristocracy and the mercenary origin of country lords.
>>
>>3052032
>Most of the high nobility of the early medieval period didn't survive beyond the 12th century tho, so it's kind of a moot point.
Read the OP again, will you? We are talking about end of migration age and early medieval who laid the foudnations for a germanic noble class.

Feel free to bring examples of familie if you have some in mind.
>>
>>3052020
He was high prince and regent as early as 1810 though.
>>
>>3052042
>laid the foudnations for a germanic noble class.
Kinda my point. Those guys died off by the 12th century, so how can they be said of having laid the foundations of anything? The european ruling nobility of the early middle ages was undoubtedly germanic, but they weren't the ancestors of even just the late middle ages nobility so what foundations did they lay exactly?

>Feel free to bring examples of familie
Off the top of my head, the unruochings were high nobles who didn't even made it to the turn of the millennium. It's kinda silly to ask for examples because obviously given the numbers we're talking about you could name a hundred names that died out and a hundred that survived and it still wouldn't be in any way meaningful.
>>
>>3052090
Look, for example Capétiens and Robertiens both where originally of Frankish stock, and they became ruling house of Franc fro a bloody long time.
So yes, bring an example of what families died off in the 12 century and why they did matter or just quit your argument.
>>
>>3052090
>Off the top of my head, the unruochings were high nobles who didn't even made it to the turn of the millennium. It's kinda silly to ask for examples because obviously given the numbers we're talking about you could name a hundred names that died out and a hundred that survived and it still wouldn't be in any way meaningful.
So lets concentrate on those that survuved, and ruled for example around 1500.
And what a surprise, you can trance most of Europe back to the Franks or other Germanics.
>>
>>3051660
>you get your ethnicity onl by your father
99% of Nobles soon or later married someone from country they ruled. I have never seen anyone claimng that Slavs ruled Sweden only because one of their kings was of house Mecklenburg.
>>
>>3052144
Yes, they married the daughters of their noble neighbors, aka another Frankish girl. Nobles marry mostly inside their own class, you know.
>>
>>3052156
>all nobles in Europe were Franks
>>
>>3052290
Or Lombards, or Burgundi, or Alemanni, or Visigoth. So that makes them all Germanics.
>just in case you didn't read the op
>>
>>3052313
Sweden and Northern Germany and with its Slavic nobles sounds quite western to me.
>>
>>3052427
Seriously, why don't you try to read the thread? Are you stoned or just plain dumb?
>yes it has already been discussed ITT
>no it is not the question
>>
>>3051765

I guess you'd have to look at old medieval ancestry records and see if they at one point claimed that wodin was their ancestor.
>>
>>3052517
The Germanic conquerers did change to the Christian faith fairly early.
>>
>>3052538
>Contemporary historian Ralph of Diceto traced his family's lineage through Matilda of Scotland to the Anglo-Saxon kings of England and Alfred the Great, and from there linked them to Noah and Woden. According to Angevin legend, there was even infernal blood in the family.[9]


That is about Richard the lionheart
>>
>>3052549
???
I take it your post is completely unrelated to the discussion?
>>
>>3052549

Too stupid to read or follow the chain of replies I see?
>>
>>3052595
Sorry mate, but you lost it, long time ago I'd assume.
Thanks anyway for your valuable and informative contribution to this thread.
>>
>>3052648

Yeah you're dumb
>>
>>3052156
This, it was a closed system, marrying a peseant girl wasn't exactly common or sanctioned,
>>
>>3051660
At one point in time this might have been true, but then people assimilate over the centuries. So even if the basic breeding stock of the European noble class was of germanic origin they lost all cultural ties to anything Germanic pretty fast.
>>
>>3052691

Did they?
>>
>>3052756
Not him, but they do. Look at Nicholas II for example, he was Orthodox and fully Russian culturally yet genetically he was mostly German.
>>
>>3052760
Yes or take the Normans, full fledged pagan Norse warriors, after a generation they all spoke French and where good catholics.
>>
>>3051660
Don't know about Germanic but they were degenerates that needed something like the French Revolution or 1917 October Revolution. If all these proto-globalists were offed in Britain and Germany earlier as well as France and Russia, the world would be a better place.
>>
>>3051908
All of them are pretty worthless. Once Elizabeth dies, the British monarchy will become nothing more than a Hollywood celebrity show 'Keeping up with the Windsors' or something.
>>
>>3052760
> Grand Duke Sergei Alexandrovich Romanov (the younger brother and uncle, respectively, of Russian Emperors Alexander III and Nicholas II) served as the Governor of Moscow from 1891–1905. His homosexual relationships were widely famous in Moscow

His brother, meanwhile, was a typical German degenerate. Lenin did nothing wrong.
>>
>>3051660
This is retarded, most of the german dominions over Southern Europe and Eastern Europe were short-lived. Only the royalty was of german (mongrel) blood due to, well, simply being related to every other king in Europe and the western world really. Even the Ottoman sultan was partly related to the European kings.
>>
>>3053758
Pretty much the proto-globalists.
>>
>>3053763
Well, it was their autistic way to gain legitimacy and power.

Regardless, this says nothing about the blood of the lower nobility and high class. They were most of the time still locals. Or families settled centuries earlier.
>>
>>3051660
Whenever a civilization took over another the latter usually wouldn't be destroyed, instead it would be slowly integrated into the fold. This works both ways, believe it or not, the conquerors enforce laws, social norms, culture and what have you on the conquered, but they also learn from the conquered enough to become entirely different.

This usually happens when lots of really different ethnic groups share the same spot for a long time, their cultures unite into a brand new one - all the roman, Breton, Frankish etc people of Francia eventually became French. All the Berber, Visigoth etc people of Al-Andalus eventually became Spanish. Notice how both forgot their germanic Influence and became latin, mainly because the bible wasn't translated and latin was the only written language those people used. So no matter who rules it, the people of the country would eventually meld into the same pot.

With the aristocracy you're mostly right. The aristocrats in western Europe tried to stay in power over the peasants by making it very hard for them to climb the social ladder. They did this not because they valued germanic blood over whateverelse blood, but because they wanted to be a clear gap between noble and peasant. That said there were lots and lots of rulers in Western Europe that didn't claim any Germanic ancestry. Some anon mentioned the Tudors in England, but there are also all the Italian families in the merchant republics like Genoa, Venice, Pisa, there were Greek rulers in southern Italy before Normans came, there were lots of Italian counts and dukes that didn't pretend to be Lombard(Matilda of Tuscany comes to mind.) Italy ceased to be ruled by germanics long before the French revolution.
>>
>>3051660
I did some reading today out of boredom and even fucking Spain has nearly no Germanic influence over them.
>>
>>3053856
They have worse though. They have the Bourbons.
>>
>>3053864
Yeah, but Bourbons are technically a Spanish family. And they're just the national pets like all other kings.
>>
>>3053867
Both them and the UK's monarchy should be abolished. Monarchy was bad back when it was full of degenerates having fag orgies, now its just promoting this cosmopolitan Hollywood-enforced celebrity culture bullshit. Get rid of it.
>>
File: Anthropology.png (1MB, 2358x1708px) Image search: [Google]
Anthropology.png
1MB, 2358x1708px
>>3051660
>Franks took France


Nope

French took Germany tho
>>
>>3053892
OUI
>>
File: FRENCH'D.png (310KB, 481x686px) Image search: [Google]
FRENCH'D.png
310KB, 481x686px
>>3053897
HARE
>>
>>3051727
>>3051706
>>3051660
>Romania ruled by germ dynasties: Hohenzollern,Habsburg
>Bulgaria ruled by germ dynasties Battenberg, Saxe-Coburg, Holstein-Gottorp-Romanov..
>Yugoslavia ruled by germ dynasties: Wittelsbach, Luxemburg, Capetian, Habsburg..
>Poland ruled by germ dynasties: Wettin, Vasa, Piast, Capetian, Habsburg
>Russia (Ukraine, Belarus) ruled by germ dynasties: Rurikid dynasty, Holstein-Gottorp-Romanov
>Czechoslovakia ruled by germ dynasties: Luxemburg, Habsburg..

>Spain Vandals/Visogoths
>The monarchy and ruling elite in Spain derives from the Visigothic Kingdom
>France ruled by descendants of Franks/Normans
>UK ruled by Anglos/Saxons
>Italy Lombards, Nomans, Ostrogoths Frankish Empire by Charlemagne,
>Poland Piast dynasty derived from several noble lines of Germanic Holy Roman Empire
>Russia, Bulgaria ruled by German tsars (Rurik dynasty + Holstein-Gottorp-Romanov Dynasty)
>most of Europe ruled by Hapsburgs
>>
>>3051660 >>3053963

the Germaniacs continue with their 2000+year old expansion and genocide spree.
They bursted from the Nordic peninsula down to modern Germany and started genociding Slavs to the east and Celts to the West.
The Germans officially lost the lands they took from Slavs (Magna Germania), but they gained lands they took from Celts (Britain).
Though eastern Europe was still ruled by German dynasties and Mennonites, the serf/slave population was Slav.

France and Spain was under German rule, but the Germans adopted the Latin languages that replaced Celtic.
Even recently Russia was ruled by German Tsars and aristocracy, so was Romania and much of Eastern Europe.

germaniacs are in the same tier as mongols and mohamedians.
these 3 nations account for 95% of global genocide, destruction, and continued totalitarian extremism.

Osterreich is Eastern Empire
Visterreich should be the name of Germany, France, England
the germans ruled eastern europe (german tsars/aristocrats over russia, poland, bulgaria, romania, czechoslovakia, magna germania) for 2k years
germans ruled over western europe (franks, saxons, vandals)
all the while genociding slavs in the east and celts in the west


The former "German" lands became German by what we call in German "Deutsche Ostkolonisation " (German east
>>
>>3053963
Monarchy is fucking terrible. Proto-globalism.
>>
>>3053967
>Germanic princess Catherine the Great was appalled by German husband antagonistically low opinion of Russians and his desire to germanize the Slavic country.
>Catherine the Great continued Peter the Great's policy of germanization
>introduced Franko-Germanic dress to his court and requiring courtiers, state officials, and the military to shave their beards and adopt germanic clothing styles.
>policy that Germanic customs were superior to Russian traditions
>commanded all of his courtiers and officials to cut off their long beards—causing his Boyars, who were very fond of their beards, great upset[16]—and wear germanic clothing.
>before Peter the great, ballet and other germanic culture/arts in Russia was nonexistent
>Pushkin reformed "inferior" Russian language by introducing Franco-German words and traits

major goal of Peter's reform was reducing the influence of the Boyars, Russia's elite nobility, who stressed Slavic supremacy and opposed germanic influence

Peter saw slavs as backwards and obstacles standing in the way of germanization. He specifically targeted the boyars with numerous taxes and obligatory services, including a tax on beards.

Another Peter decree in 1713 established Landrats (from the German word for "national council"). The new Russian provinces were modeled on the Swedish system of provinces,

Peter's anti-Slav/Boyar reforms culminated in 1722 with the creation of the Table of Ranks. A new generation of technocrats soon supplanted the Boyar class and dominated the civil service in Russia.
>>
>>3053969
Peter's germanization monopolized certain strategic industries, such as salt, vodka, oak, and tar. Peter also taxed many Slavic-Russian cultural customs (such as bathing, fishing, beekeeping, and wearing beards)

Peter changed the date of the celebration of the Slavic new year from 1 September to germanic 1 January. In the year 7207 of the old Russian calendar, Peter proclaimed that the Julian Calendar was in effect and the year was 1700.

Peter's reign deepened the subjugation of slav serfs to the will of mainly tatar-germanic landowners.

Peter firmly enforced class divisions which continued to oppress the slavic majority
>>
>>3053968
"Privilege of German", the Germans/Mennonites were granted additional rights (freedom from war-and civil-service for all time, no swearing of oaths in court, the right to carry on a business or trade, and more), while native slavs lived as serfs with no rights except to be farmhands and servants to their masters.

Native Slavs hated the unjust German "privileges" and economic domination and found them to be a foreign body that owned the native serfs, ie Makhno and his revolt against the Germanic elites
>>
>>3053969
>>3053975
>>3053981
How were these fags allowed to exist for so long? Why did no one do them in before based Lenin and Stalin?
>>
>>3053963
Spain's noble surnames are Visigoth but they're not ethnically Germanic.
>>
>>3053986
most of europe was under Germanic ruling class for almost 2000 years
same story throughout most of europe, including eastern europe:
Makhno revolted against the Germanic ruling elite:
>At the age of 11 Makhno began working as an ox drover on the Janzen estate in Silberfeld. Here he began to develop a hatred for the German ruling classes. In his memoirs he writes: "At this time I began to experience anger, envy and even hatred towards the landowner [Janzen] and especially towards his children - those young slackers who often strolled past me sleek and healthy, well-dressed, well-groomed and scented; while I was filthy, dressed in rags, barefoot, and reeked of manure from cleaning the calves' barn."[17] Makhno also worked at the Mennonite owned Kroeger plant in Gulyai-Polye.

>Throughout the civil war, Mahkno and his troops raided many German and Mennonite colonies and estates in the Katerynoslav Oblast. The larger rural landholdings of Mennonites were prominent targets due to their wealth and proximity to Gulyai-Polye.[18] The Schönfeld colony, located adjacent to the Huliaipole area, was unique in that it consisted predominantly of Mennonite estate settlements across an expansive area. Mennonite colonies were targeted by Makhno because, as owners of prosperous farms and estates, they were considered kulaks - wealthy farmers that exploited the labour of the surrounding, mostly Ukrainian, peasantry. Ukrainians were traditionally hired by wealthy Mennonites as house servants and farmhands
literally Germans ruled over eastern Europe
they were the aristocracy, the tsars, the landowners, the factory owners
the natives were the oppressed slaves/serfs
Ethnic Germans and Mennonites themselves, having been stripped of their wealth and property during the revolution. Some Mennonites accompanied punitive detachments against the peasantry, which greatly contributed to the growing bitterness between Germans/Mennonites and Ukrainians.
>>
>>3054013
Nestor Makhno's anarchist army generally targeted Germans/Mennonites because they were thought of as "Kulaks" and an entity generally more advanced and wealthy than the surrounding Ukrainian peasants. The Mennonites Germanic background also served to inflame negative sentiment during the period of revolution. Makhno himself had served as a slave on a Mennonite estate in childhood and harbored negative feelings based on treatment and abuse he received by the Germans while employed there. Hundreds of Mennonites were murdered, robbed, imprisoned and raped during this period, and villages including (and around) Chortitza, Zagradovka and Nikolaipol were damaged and destroyed
>>
>>3053986
>Ostkolonisation aka germanic reconquista and genocide of slavs
>Ostsiedlung German eastward expansion
>Volga Germans, Transylvanian (Siebenbürgen) Saxons, Transylvanian Landler, Zipser Germans
>Galician Germans, Crimea Germans, Sudeten Germans, Carpathian Germans, Forest Walddeutsche, Gottschee
>Banat Swabians, Sathmar Swabians, Bessarabia Germans, Bukovina Germans, Regat Germans
>Ethnic conflicts erupted between the newly arrived settlers and local populations, sometimes bloody, and expulsions of native populations are also known.[3] In several areas subject to the Ostsiedlung, the existing population was later discriminated against and pushed away from administration.[4][5]

>In 983, the Polabian Slavs in the March of the Billungs and the Northern March stretching from the Elbe River to the Baltic shore succeeded in a rebellion against the germanic rulers


>Klaus Iohannis (Transylvanian Saxon), the current President of Romania

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Transylvanian_Saxons#Privileged_class
>>
File: SO CALLED Eastern Franks.png (607KB, 1232x2084px) Image search: [Google]
SO CALLED Eastern Franks.png
607KB, 1232x2084px
>>3051660
>This is what g*rmcuck actuaklly believe

Delusional nigger
>>
>>3053826
>>3051660
>>3053963

Italy/albania was ruled by germanic House of Savoy

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Umberto_II_of_Italy
>>
I have this theory that autism is a German disease that the rest of humanity has unfortunately inherited due to not keeping them isolated in their frozen hellhole north of Italy.
>>
>>3054063
germanics have taken over the world. The Germanic mind is considered the normal healthy mind. Anyone who does not conform to Germanic way of thought is treated as abnormal and in need of correction. Look at all the pain they have caused. Non-Germanics have had to change their culture and society in order to match Germanics level of selfish interest. Those who do not conform are considered irrelevant and worthy of death and colonization.

It is abhorrent that one should force his mindset onto another. Aboriginal Australians do not want to act like "the white man", they have been robbed of their land and way of life just like the countless other peoples whom the Germanics have conquered. When ancient Romans and Greeks invaded lands they would take care of the native populations, building services and roads but they would be mostly left untouched as long as they paid taxes. When Alexander conquered he built schools and library's and the native peoples loved him for it.

We are so ingrained with Germanic perspective that we don't even realize it.

My question is, how did we reach the modern age of colonialism where Germanics have not only taken away from natives their land, but also their souls? It is evil, pure evil.
>>
>>3054063
Germanic are extremely bloodthirsty savage cruel people. Outwardly they're all smiles and politeness but when you get to know them they're vicious like lions or wolves.

Look at all the misery they have caused worldwide. Wars, colonialism, diseases. Being such a small amount of people they have killed so many more people than they have produced. They're also sexual deviants yet don't use sex to create children. They are a nasty race of devils who have no love for anything except their own individual selves. They don't even like other Germanics or their family members. Everything is competition to them. The Germanics biology is one of seeking out imperishable fame to achieve wealth and sexual partners by any means necessary. And Germanics love it! They take tremendous pride in their ability to kill and destroy, they obsess over violence all day everyday. To the Germanic, families tearing themselves apart and living lives filled with harsh competitiveness is the foundation of their deranged brand of normalcy.

And this way of thinking which Germanics claim is normal has been pushed onto the entire world and everyone cannot succeed in capitalist life without adopting the fierce brutality of the Germanic.

When blacks, Asians, South Americans and other native populations say "I hate white people" they should be saying "I hate Germanics"


they're also mechanistic and ideologically shallow. All their philosophy revolves around how the individual needs to comport himself in society, something everyone else can figure out for themselves. They're ALL little Eichmanns.
>>
>>3054066
> When ancient Romans and Greeks invaded lands they would take care of the native populations, building services and roads but they would be mostly left untouched as long as they paid taxes. When Alexander conquered he built schools and library's and the native peoples loved him for it.

You forgot the part where the Romans executed all the males of fighting age in the conquered population. The Romans had already gotten the ball rolling on mass serfdom of the coloni, they just weren't strong enough to collect on the system with the tribes across the Rhine and Danube waiting for their chance to take over.
>>
>>3053963
>Poland Piast dynasty derived from several noble lines of Germanic Holy Roman Empire
why would you lie on the internet?
>>
>>3054121
Prestiż dynastii na arenie międzynarodowej podniosło małżeństwo Mieszka II Lamberta, syna i następcy Bolesława Chrobrego, z Rychezą, po kądzieli wnuczką cesarza Ottona II.

Mieszko I of Poland also submitted to Otto II's overlordship.[7] Henry II, however, was not so fortunate: Otto II imprisoned him under the custody of the Bishop of Utrecht
>>
>>3054133
>matrilineally
this way everyone is related to everyone else
>>
>>3054145
>Mieszko I of Poland also submitted to Otto II's overlordship.[7] Henry II, however, was not so fortunate: Otto II imprisoned him under the custody of the Bishop of Utrecht

poles submitted to german ballz
>>
>>3054145
http://www.genealogiagenetyczna.com/2017/04/znamy-pierwsze-wyniki-dna-piastow.html

>Wygląda na to, że Piastowie należeli do R1b. Dr hab. Tomasz Kozłowski, antropolog z UMK w Toruniu, ujawnił niedawno, że zbadane szczątki księcia mazowieckiego Janusza III (1502-1526) wskazują jednoznacznie na haplogrupę R1b i że nie było możliwości zanieczyszczenia próbki
>>
A lot of the mainland Europeans intermarried with Gaelic Irish noble families who were exiled from Ireland. Spain, France, Austria etc.
>>
>>3054151
>Błędem jest automatyczne utożsamianie R1a wyłącznie ze Słowianami, a R1b wyłącznie z Germanami lub Normanami.
>>
>>3054148
I know that >H>R>E is a meme, but Holy Roman Emperor was the most powerful monarch in Europe in late 10th and 11th century.
>>
>>3054157
It's too early to tell, but it's possible they were Germanics.
>>
File: euphoricfrench.jpg (845KB, 2300x1300px) Image search: [Google]
euphoricfrench.jpg
845KB, 2300x1300px
>>3054063
>I have this theory that autism is a German disease
So you finally accept your germanic heritage then?
>>
>>3054157
nie, oni niemieckie

Piast belonged to R1b. PhD, Ivan Kozlovsky, an anthropologist from the University of Nicolaus Copernicus, showed recently that explored the remains of the Mazovian Prince Janusz III (1502-1526) indicate clearly on haplogroup R1b
>>
ITT butthurt non-Germanics whining about us being better for all of history.
Get over it.
Just because us Germanics are the best doesn't mean every Germanic is better than every non-Germanic, just most of the time.
>>
>>3054163
>haplogroup
>tell tale sign of people that know shit about history and shit about genetics.
>>
>>3054148
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German%E2%80%93Polish_War_(1002%E2%80%9318)

>As a result, in 1015 Henry, supported by his pagan Liutician allies, launched another armed expedition against him. He attempted to cross into Greater Poland but was stopped by Bolesław's troops at Krosno on the Oder River. In 1017 Henry renewed his campaign, while Yaroslav attacked Poland from the eastern side. The emperor's troops besieged Niemcza in Silesia, however, with the help of outside reinforcements the city held out and Henry was eventually forced to retreat.

>Holy
Pagan allies.
>Roman
lol
>Emperor
One city kicked his ass.
>>
>>3054161
That's not him, he's far less articulate and more vulgar in his insults
>>
>>3054166
Kyrgyz people are R1a z93, they are poles
>>
>>3054163
>shitty google translate to polish
>using memegroups of some shitty prince from 16th c. to prove the whole dynasty is somehow germanic
>>
>>3054164
Germans do not feel pride of themselves, quit LARPing
>>
>>3054177

German Americans do
>>
>>3054164
>In July 1002, Bolesław proceeded to a council with King Henry at the Kaiserpfalz of Merseburg in Saxony to deliberate on the enfeoffment of Meissen. As his claims were rejected, he left the royal court with disappointment. Moreover, an attempt was made on Boleslaw's life, which he escaped only with the help of Duke Bernard of Saxony, the Nordgau margrave Henry of Schweinfurt and several friendly German nobles. While it is not known for sure if the attack had been ordered by Henry and the contemporary chronicler Thietmar of Merseburg denied any complicity, Bolesław believed this was the case. In any case Henry did neither protect him, nor did he punish the assailants.
Because all G*erms are backstabbing bastards.

>mfw Henry II was canonized
>>
>>3054182

>advanced tactics
>bad
>>
>Frederick's brother, Prince Henry, spent the winter of 1770–71 as a representative of the Prussian court at Saint Petersburg. As Austria had annexed 13 towns in the Hungarian Szepes region in 1769 (violating the Treaty of Lubowla), Catherine II of Russia and her advisor General Ivan Chernyshyov suggested to Henry that Prussia claim some Polish land, such as Ermland.

>After Henry informed him of the proposal, Frederick suggested a partition of the Polish borderlands by Austria, Prussia, and Russia, with the largest share going to the party most weakened by the recent changes in balance of power, Austria. Thus Frederick attempted to encourage Russia to direct its expansion towards weak and non-functional Poland instead of the Ottomans.
Is there a nation more evil than Germans?
>>
>>3054193

Kurwa! We wuz victims and shit
>>
>>3054193
slavs do not exist today. we are all germanized or mongolized or both
>>
File: shock.gif (1MB, 450x338px) Image search: [Google]
shock.gif
1MB, 450x338px
>read the OP, lolno
>read the thread, fuck, this might be true
>mfw nobility and feudalism was just a trick to keep the germanics in power
>>
>>3054223
European kings were all mongrels, it's fucking retarded to say they were more germanic than greek or slav or latin, except maybe for the really late monarchs of the imperial age who were assigned by international committee.
>>
>>3054231
I am not talking kings you brainlet, I talk the noble class per see. The class that formed with the germanic conquests during the migration age.
>>
>>3054223
In Europe feudalism was very much the result of traditional Germanic power structures and the absence of some sort of civil servant/lawyer group like say the Romans had.

Feudalism is slave loyalty to a particular master. It still exists in almost any business environment (like when a boss builds his 'team'), but nowadays it's usually frowned upon and is called nepotism or cronyism or slavism.


>>3054231
Fuck off you germanic Imperialistic cunt.

"I feel it my duty to tell the Germans for once what they have on their conscience. Every great crime against culture for the last four centuries lies on them. "
—t. Nietzsche
>>
>>3054242

Nietzsche was a traitor and a cuck
>>
>>3054239
That's even more retarded, the noble class most of the time wasn't even that mixed.
>>
>>3054242
So Feudalism in Europe was a germanic institution, and the ruling class of feudalism was, at least in the beginning, a largely germanic class?
>>
>>3054223
Germanics always ruled the Europe in one way or the other, but when you meet the regular Germanics and get to know how they live and what they're into, you keep wondering how the fuck is that so. I find them all really simple and dull even though nice people. Compared to Scandis and Romance nations and their cultures Germanic people are very boring.
>>
>>3054247
>the noble class most of the time wasn't even that mixed
Yes, they where pure germanics, gallo-roman untermenschen need not apply
>>
>>3054252
>Compared to Scandis
Scandis are germanic, you dumb fuck.
>>
>>3054252
>germanics != Germans
>>
File: 1437940317513s.jpg (3KB, 125x125px) Image search: [Google]
1437940317513s.jpg
3KB, 125x125px
>>3054253
Despite of what you might be lead to believe by pop-culture, Europe is more than just the UK, France and Germany.
>>
>>3054158
the greco roman stuff became window dressing after the germanics took over...after all the holy roman empire wasnt holy or roman


Germanics are like the Mongols--barbardians who conquered classical civilization and ended up being assimilated by it. Greco-Roman culture is the mother culture of Europe.


Claiming germanics to be the mother culture is like saying jurchen, mongols or manchus are the mother culture of east asia.

Germans are to Rome as Arabs are to Persia.
>>
>>3054258
>>3054256
>>3054245
>>3054247
Germany would be like
>I can go into Roman Empire - shits Europe on many occasions, ruining idea of western Roman Empire
>I can go into new religions - shits up Europe for centuries
>I can go into Unification - shits up Europe and world
>I can go into far right and nationalism - shits up Euroe and world, ruining right wing and nationalism for rest
>I can go into multicultularism, tolerance and international cooperation - shits up Europe and world too
>>
>>3054267
You need to understand that Germans suffer from a huge inferiority complex.

>no wars won
>ass-ravaged in 2 world wars
>cucked by the Jews for several centuries
>never had an empire of their own
>Germany was never an unified country
>a lot of Germany's scientists and artists were Jewish
>not very attractive, clean or healthy people
>>
>>3054267
>>3054269
Reminder that if it wasn't for Hitler's autism, Mussolini wouldn't have been discredited as a leader and Italy would probably be way more relevant of a country today.
>>
>>3054269
germans are inherently evil but luckly for the rest of europe they're not very intelligent and are incapable of any kind of thought that isn't pragmatic and present-focus, which causes their usual bloodthirsthy rapacious campaigns on europe for world domination to be doomed to fail every single time since war is more than killing and violent urges.
>>
>>3054289
I'd argue they're the opposite of pragmatic. There was only one German (Bismarck) who actually wanted to reasonably talk with the rest of Europe and not just go on an autistic rampage.
>>
>>3054267
>>3054269
Are you just one guy that's been sitting here all night shitposting?

Because I gotta commend it if so, it's pretty impressive. You must be Australian.
>>
>>3053963
Germans should leave rightful Slavic clay in East-German and let Sorbs live in peace.

We don't want to live together with Germans and Germanized Slavs (these are the worst people, you as an Austrian aka Germanized Slav probably understand me).
1000 years and these fucking Krauts always manages to destroy our home even more
>>
>>3054306

Sorbs are invaders from the east
>>
>>3054294
The problem with krauts is that they are too autistic for diplomacy or political games, but they make great scat pr0n.
>>
>>3054310
The Kraut. He knows nothing but chaos. The Kraut cannot create; he can only destroy.
>>
>>3054308
just divide them into 20 ish states and stoke hatred between them, get some meme linguists to claim dialects of German are their own languages.
Base the hatred on religious us vs them lines drawn by the 30 years war.
Fund Bavaria and a severely reduced Prussia to fight each other.
Fund the Sorbs and other such non German ethnicities to break away from the German states.
Bam, no more unified German threat.
Germany was ripe for Balkanization.
>>
>>3054313

You're mentally ill. Sorbs should go home to Ukraine if they don't like Germans.
Most however love German prosperity and would never move to an undeveloped country.
>>
>>3054267
>>3054269
Dear retard, we are talking about Germanics around 500 AD. We are not talking about Germoney and muh Hitler. Now go suck some /pol/ dick!
>>
>>3054313
Especially since the cultures of "unified" Germany were very split up. Prussia had a militarist culture, unthinkable for you to be a high-up person in Prussia if you didn't serve in the military. Bavarians were libertines, Hannoverians were MUH DIVINE RIGHT MUH ABSOLUTE KINGZ, Austrians were MUH MULTICULTI EMPIRE and so on.
>>
>>3054320
But call him a germ and you will be astonished at how he recoils, how injured he is, how he suddenly shrinks back: “I’ve been found out.”
>>
>>3054317
lands became German by what we call in German "Deutsche Ostkolonisation " (German east colonization). It never was German. It always was a mix of Slavs, Germanized Slavs

Why have germanic people always seeked to conquer, assimilate, or genocide slavs throughout history?
>Danish and German invasion of Polabia
>Teutonic invasion of Russia
>Germanic domination of Velikomoravia
>Flemish crusade against the Bulgarian Kingdom
>Anglosaxon rivalry against Russia
>Numerous Germanic propaganda literature portraying slavs as a genetically inferior.
>Generalplan Ost
>>
>>3054334

Eastern Germany was traditional Germanic land since time immemorial.
>>
>>3054334
>Frankish kings initiated numerous, yet not always successful, military campaigns to settle eastern slavic lands
>campaigns against Slavs included Wendish Crusade against the Polabian Slavs (or "Wends") of what is now northern and eastern Germany; Livonian Crusade against BaltoSlavs, Latgallians, Selonians

>Armed conflict between the Baltic Finns, Balts, Slavs against their Saxon and Danish intruders to the north and south had been common for several centuries before the crusade.

>The germanic crusaders attacked Pomeranians and other Slavs, despite these people having already been successfully Christianized.

>The Teutonic Order's attempts to conquer Orthodox Russia
>>
>>3054334
>Why have germanic people always seeked to conquer, assimilate, or genocide slavs throughout history
Because back in the day the French would've whooped them so they had to expand tot the east like John of Luxembourg
>>
>>3054343
>>3054334
>>3054351
After the Northern Crusades against Balto-Slavs, the Germanics quickly came to control all the administrations of government, politics, economics, education and culture of these areas for over 700 years until 1918, despite remaining a minority ethnic group.


In contrast to the Germanic rulers, the ethnic majority, the native Estonians, Latvians, Slavs had restricted rights and privileges and resided mostly in rural areas as serfs, tradesmen, or as servants in urban homes. This was in keeping with the social scheme of things in Imperial Russia, and lasted well into the 19th century, when emancipation from serfdom brought the native peoples new political rights and freedoms that freed the natives from their germanic oppressors.
>>
>>3054357
>In contrast to the Germanic rulers, the ethnic majority, the native Estonians, Latvians, Slavs had restricted rights and privileges and resided mostly in rural areas as serfs, tradesmen, or as servants in urban homes.
Sounds exactly like what happened in France then.
>>
>>3054434
Sounds like another you're still butthurt about us raping your women and burning your sacred tree

Why are you trying so hard to LARP as French btw ?
>>
File: franksfag.jpg (421KB, 1374x994px) Image search: [Google]
franksfag.jpg
421KB, 1374x994px
>>3054678
Oh look, it is him!
>and he is triggered again
>>
>>3054692
kinda pathetic when even on a anonymous Tibetan woodcarving board you are easily spotted for your sheer autism.
>>
File: German genetic history.png (489KB, 1768x1278px) Image search: [Google]
German genetic history.png
489KB, 1768x1278px
>>3054692
>>3054697
I'm the only guy on /his/ that post actual sources so it is easy to "spot" me

Anyway, why are you so butthurt against French ? Verden ? Bouvines ? Narpoleonic ? ? WW1 ?
>>
>>3054434
Salic law indeed does make gallo-romans second class citizens compared to free Franks. However this happened in many early medieval societies, early germanic laws always did distinguish between free Germanics and locals, usually discriminating the locals.
>>
>>3054726
Again I'd like to ask you to trip- or namefag. This way it would be much easier to hide your bullshit and normal people can get on with their discussion. Nobody takes your shit serious anyways, see here >>3054161
>>
File: French Rape baby.jpg (3MB, 4896x4592px) Image search: [Google]
French Rape baby.jpg
3MB, 4896x4592px
>>3054739
I recognize you too m8

You're the hysterical guy that said "even your countrymen tell you to fuck off" and started to chimp out.

Why are you violent ? is this because you are insecure ?
>>
>>3054727
Salic law, the same law that discriminates against non Franks was in use for inheritance up to the late medieval. A good example how long the feudal institutions brought by the Germancis lasted in European culture.
I would go as far to say the entirety of European high nobility was of germanic origin, but the feudal institutions that shaped Europe for a long time where of germanic origin.
>>
>>3053967
>eastern Europe ruled by Mennonites
What the hell are you talking about you literal nigger
t. East Euro
>>
>>3054844
>>3054727
>>3054434


Sounds exactly like >>3053981
>>
>>3053892
>>3053919
>Franks (((who were actually Pannonian))) spoke Germanic because they were so (((nice))) to the peoples they conquered.

At least stay in my thread and don't annoy others, Frenchfag
Thread posts: 148
Thread images: 14


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.