Was communism ever actually reached?

>>2753298
catalonia

Yes. Not it's final stage though. "Final stage" communism is oxymoronic though because people will never throw off all their identities in favor of a worldwide classless society.

>>2753298
Nope
Every attempt to achieve it only end in disaster, its not even worth it

It was reached by hunter-gatherers before civilisation corrupted human nature.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_Territory

>>2753298
Does it matter?

File: yung lean marx.jpg (48KB, 720x720px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 720x720px

>>2753298
No, of course not
Well, unless you count primitive communism
/thread

File: lycklig pepe.png (29KB, 310x326px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 310x326px

>The state will "wither away"

>>2753333
Not true, they owned capital and exploited workers with it.

>>2753346
Well yeah, are you saying that finding an ideal model of society isn't important?

File: owo.jpg (1MB, 1628x1707px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1628x1707px

>>2753298
OwO what's this?

not in excess of dunbar's number

>>2753639
I recognize that bulge

>>2753639
Communism

>>2753836
She does look like she's never been tried...

>>2753958
>she

File: cccp.jpg (13KB, 275x183px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 275x183px

>>2753639
>>2753980
It's a puffy vulva, virgins.

Tried in the sense that folks really tried to work towards it
never tried in the sense that it was never reached
"never tried" is a meme fuelled by a few naive children just getting into politics taking the thing at face value, and thus saying in all seriousness "oh yeah, it's never been tried, which is why we need to try it!"

>>2754020
You are just trying to get rid of some unwanted guilt. Its a boy.

>>2754063

it hasn't though

>>2754120
Hasn't what?

>>2753342
How is this communism?

>>2754128

It has not been tried.

>>2753298
No, certainly not. Communism refers to a specific type of society that is not really possible in coexistence with capitalism -- a society in which the production of goods is divorced from market processes. The commodity form is gone.

Capitalism, as a system built entirely upon growth, cannot abide resources being produced independent of market forces. As long as capitalism is the prevailing mode of production, practiced by the world's most powerful and developed countries, communism isn't tenable.

>>2754171
It cannot be "tried", communism is something that is built.
One can try to build a building, but one cannot try a building before it is built.

File: 3VwaF4F.jpg (72KB, 500x746px) Image search: [Google]

72KB, 500x746px

why do you burgers love talking about shitty people? I always 2 to 3 threads like this, why can't you all accept that the fucking communism is a fucking failure,


when will you stop flooding this already shithole with your defined bullshits, stop,

SHOVE THIS IN your pathetic asses,
Communism is a failure, it NEVER WORKed, and it NEVER WILL, sheesh you're much worst than the feminist,

File: 3327517.jpg (451KB, 1440x2160px) Image search: [Google]

451KB, 1440x2160px

>>2754255
> Communism is a failure

File: 6tIfTTL.jpg (16KB, 288x206px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 288x206px

>>2754267

bro who is that,

>>2753298
Never reached? No. There are definitely still states.
Never tried? It's definitely been tried. The reason people say "it's not real communism" is because they're essentially moving the goalposts. Someone tries their own interpretation of Marxism, it fails horribly, everyone else says "well they were just interpreting Marx's ideals wrong" and claims that own interpretation would totally work if implemented, guys.

>>2754267
this better a boy

>>2753298
no, and it begs the question of whether it can be achieved or it was a flawed concept from the very beginning

>>2754267

please tell me there's a sauce and that doesn't have dick

>>2753312
Sounds like Evangelion-tier unachievable coolness.

>>2754255
This does not appear to be a real book
how exactly do you want me to shove it in my ass

>>2754624
Use your imagination queer, I'm sure you'll come up with something. You lot are champs at figuring out new ways to sodomize yourselves after all.

>>2754638
You're the one giving the order, why not use yours? Give me at least a conceptual framework for how I may stick it in my ass.

>>2753639
The means of production.

>>2754696
kek

>>2754679
Just keep trying forever until it happens faggot, just like with communism.

>>2754696
The means of reproduction, I think you mean

>>2754135
That's literally what communism is supposed to be.

>>2755113
i don't see where it's become a classless society with common property, but perhaps i just need to learn more about it

>>2754301
best ive got anon

vk dottt com/wall-88487361_225503

sry vk links must be blacklisted or something

>>2754559
(((SEELE)))

>>2754301
https://www.instagram.com/squirrel___girl/

>>2754696
Ha!