[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

Is Christianity a European religion?

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 142
Thread images: 25

Is Christianity a European religion?
>>
Christianity as we know it evolved in Europe, yes. Indo-European polytheism was no more indigenous to this continent than Abrahamic monotheism was so Varg's argument in this is shit.
>>
>>1947781
It's a Jewish religion.
>>
>>1947781
Where is Jesus from? What is now Palestine

Where is the Bible set? The Middle East

No. Just no.
>>
>>1947781
>>1947817

its a western religion
>>
let's see

>Jesus was a Jewish troublemaker
>Paul was a Jew
>The Disciples were a Jewish gang
>claim Jesus fulfilled Jewish prophecies
>is literally a scapegoat, a Jewish concept

European Christianity dressed it up in Pagan ornaments
but at its core it's a Jewish faith
>>
>>1948192

so what, jews have lived in europe for millenia and developed rabbinic judaism there
>>
>>1947799
>Christianity as we know it evolved in Europe

Why do you ignore 1. Where it originated, and 2. the several hundred years or so where the great 'christian debates' were not in Europe but profoundly affected it even to its modern dressage.
>>
>>1947781
>Varg: Everyone important wuz white. Da middle east wuz white.
>Christianity is a middle eastern religion.
>Christianity = White
So does Islam btw.
>>
It's a Universal Religion.
>>
>>1948220
The Levand and Mesopotamia were not always populated by Arabs and Semites, retard
the Sumerians and other peoples at the time were caucasians (not 'nordic' though)
same thing with Anatolia
it used to be filled with Greeks and levantine peoples
but not it's filled with turks
>>
>>1948220
We was kings though, and the Middle East was white. North Africa and large parts of the Levant were white.
>>
>>1947781
Europe wasn't a proper concept at the time Christianity came about.
Dont tell barg bigernes that though
>>
>>1948235
I was going by Varg's stupid logic.

Apparently every civilization from China to Europe was founded by white cunts. So Christfaggotry and Jizzlam is white.
>>
It's a religion with a jewish source material that transformed into what it is today by adapting its practices to pagan european traditions, easing its way into adoption by european polytheists.
>>
>>1948221
This is the only correct answer. Unlike Judaism, both Christianity and Islam repudiate ethnic or tribal concerns.
>>
>>1947781
No.
>>
>>1947781
No, it's a world religion. A message for humanity
>>
>>1948348
yes
it's the forerunner to universalism and egalitarianism
>>
>>1947781
It's a universal religion
>>
>>1948220
>>1948270
When/where did Varg claimed that west asian civilization was made by whites?

>>1948235
>semites not caucasian
hmmm
>>
>>1948235
>turkish = turkic
Modern turkish people are just Greeks and levantine peoples who started using the language of their step overlords aka the original turkics
>>
File: 5577.jpg (151KB, 960x720px)
5577.jpg
151KB, 960x720px
>>1947781
1. Europeans freely accepted the true religion that follows Christ. Someone is going to post about "muh crusades", but the truth remains that even after those, Europeans could have raised their kids and descendants as pagans. Christianity was chosen and paganism was abandoned as impractical and false.
2. Christianity has been around in Europe longer than any pagans movements.
3. Christianity has molded our cultures and countries into what they are today. It's given us an edge on the world as most scientific movements and academics were funded by the Roman Catholic Church. Most universities were paid for the Church, as well. The entire continent was brought out of dark ages of living in mud huts, thanks to Christianity.

So yes, Christianity is a European with the origins of our Lord being in the Levant. Anyone who says otherwise is most likely just a LARPer. Also, for most westerners here, I can almost guarantee that everyone posting here was baptized and raised in a Christian church and a lot probably are still active in their churches.
>>
>>1948375
semites are from africa
>>
>>1948192
>European Christianity dressed it up in Pagan ornaments
That claim is r/atheism tier. Mind backing it up?
>>
>>1948389
sure
literally every celebration in European Christianity is based on a pagan festival. Christmas, Easter, in particular
catholicism is like 80% paganism
>>
>>1948385
>brought out of dark ages of living in mud huts
Nice meme.
Dark ages should only refer to an age if we have scant records of it. The way you're using it is stupid.
>>
>>1948385
>2. Christianity has been around in Europe longer than any pagans movements.
Up for question since Christianity has changed a whole fucking lot since the Roman times.
>>
>>1948385
>Europeans freely accepted the true religion that follows Christ. S
>Freely

le happy Frank face
>>
>>1948192
>but at its core it's a Jewish faith
It really isn't. Christianity even at core is pagan as fuck.

If you tried telling the ancient Israelites that about trinities and the great human sacrifice for our sins they would kill you stone dead.
>>
>>1948387
>semites are from africa
The language, yes. The people, mostly west Asian. Reminder that Phoenician and Akkadian is semitic language.
>>
Its like asking is Buddhism a Chinese religion. For all intents and purposes it may as well be.
>>
>>1947781
No, neither is neo-paganism considering it's practiced by American autists
>>
>>1947781

The most important parts of the New Testament were written by Greeks. So yes.
>>
File: 9629962[1].png (41KB, 248x242px) Image search: [Google]
9629962[1].png
41KB, 248x242px
>>1948385
>Europeans freely accepted the true religion that follows Christ.
Christianity was imposed on Europe ISIS-style.
>>
This is not a simple matter. Catholicism and Orthodoxy as they developed historically are in fact European religions which only use Semitic mythology for coloring/background. However, Semitic slave-moralistic tendencies are inherent in it and can awaken and come to the fore given the right circumstances.

The New Faith Movement attempted to purge the Indo-European, Aryan aspects of Christianity from its Judaic substratum, but it didn't have time to accomplish it.

One way to accomplish this would be, following Goethe's lead, to denounce the OT in toto and have Homer and Greek philosophy be our "OT".

Therefore Protestantism and all forms of sola scriptura hermeneutics should be avoided.

PS: Marcion dindu nothing wrong.
>>
>>1948449
>The New Faith Movement attempted to purge the Indo-European, Aryan aspects of Christianity from its Judaic substratum, but it didn't have time to accomplish it.
I should say purge the Judaic elements from its Aryan superstratum.
>>
>>1948445
So freely chosen?
ISIS practices jizya on Christians and Jews, so free choices there
and they treat their yazidi slaves very well so it's a free choice there
>>
Seeing that many wish to continue following the Christian religion (due to various emotional and cultural ties), new Marcionite and Gnosticizing interpretations of Christianity are in order.
>>
>>1948441
>were written by Greeks
Paul- Jew
Mark- Jew
Matthew- Jew
John - self-hating Jew
Peter- Jew
James - Jew
Jude - Jew
Luke - goy

Literally only two of them were written by Greeks. And by that I mean one Greek.
>>
>>1948453
This post probably isn't ironic. /his/ is by far the most smug, contrarian board on this site. It outdoes /mu/. No wonder so many cunts here love Stirner so much. Fuck you. What an absolutely horrendous post.
>>
>>1948400
>pagan festival. Christmas, Easter, in particular

Claims with no basis in truth. Just because old pagan traditions coincided with the same dates of Christmas or Easter doesn't mean one was derived from the other. We celebrate those dates as the birth and resurrection of Christ, pagans celebrated those dates for whole other reasons.

Are there any parts of those holidays you think are derived from paganism?

>>1948403
Ironically the only reason we know anything about paganism is thanks to the Church and monks that kept record of them. Most scientific advancements produced back then were thanks to the Church and even today a lot of notable scientists are funded by the Church or are Christian.

>>1948423
You ignore the second point I made, where they could have easily gone back to their pagan ways and passed it onto their descendants. Faith is something personal that can't be forced upon you.

>>1948419
The same church and belief system is still around, Roman Catholicism.

>>1948445
Not really. Churches were built and crosses were put up, but what you believed was up to you. Nobody forced you to attend mass (and most people attended church only a few times a year). Europeans that practiced the faith then and practice it today do freely.
>>
>>1948465
>Ironically the only reason we know anything about paganism is thanks to the Church and monks that kept record of them. Most scientific advancements produced back then were thanks to the Church and even today a lot of notable scientists are funded by the Church or are Christian.
I never denied this. I was simply attacking the notion that paganism was just mud huts and barbarians, with Christianity bringing glorious civilisation to them.

Plenty of people still lived in mud huts even after becoming Christian.
>>
>>1948457

The gospels weren't actually written by the apostles that they were ascribed to, and neither were the epistles, with the exception of those written by Paul - who was THE self-hating Jew, btw.
>>
>>1948465
> Faith is something personal that can't be forced upon you.
This is retarded.

Faith is absolutely something that can be forced on you, especially over multiple generations. They could not have easily gone back to their pagan ways because very often that would mean death, especially on the count that apostasy was usually a crime.
>>
>>1948470
Paul was a self-hating Jew. But John was the self-hating Jew king.
>>
>>1948482

But John didn't write anything. At least, if he did write anything, it didn't show up in the New Testament.
>>
>>1948470
>The gospels weren't actually written by the apostles that they were ascribed to, and neither were the epistles
Sources on that?
>>
>>1948492

As far as I know, every single bible scholar (who isn't a Christian fundamentalist) agrees with that statement. At least, I've never come across one that would disagree with it.
>>
File: perun.jpg (86KB, 725x450px) Image search: [Google]
perun.jpg
86KB, 725x450px
>>1948480
>very often that would mean death, especially on the count that apostasy was usually a crime.
This is retarded. Medieval Catholics killing for apostasy is just a meme that Muslim apologists use to justify the actions of ISIS. It almost never happened and nobody cared if you were pagan, for the most part. I mean, there were STILL pagans in my part of the country almost 500 years after my country converted to Christianity. They were praising to their gods right alongside Catholics who prayed to our God before battles.

I hope you realize that "the Church" for most people consisted of the village priest. Nobody was forced to go to church and most people just tended to their livestock, farms or businesses.
>>
>>1948465
>We celebrate those dates as the birth and resurrection of Christ, pagans celebrated those dates for whole other reasons.

Because christ was born at the winter solstice under a world tree and three siberian shamans gifted him fly agaric mushrooms after arriving on flying reindeer?
Because on easter, he was resurrected out of an egg delivered by a hare ?

>You ignore the second point I made, where they could have easily gone back to their pagan ways and passed it onto their descendants. Faith is something personal that can't be forced upon you.

Yeah, "convert or die" was never used by any christians at all
There was also no torture or burning "devil worshippers" at the stake
It was totally possible to not attend church and denounce the bible without any consequences in medieval europe

All of missionary work was just nice old monks going door to door, bringing bread and wine and preaching love until all of europe was united in neighbourly friendship.
>>
>>1948508
>his is retarded. Medieval Catholics killing for apostasy is just a meme that Muslim apologists use to justify the actions of ISIS.

>i-it didn't happen

Pathetic, I was hoping you might have a real argument.
>>
>>1948517
>Pathetic, I was hoping you might have a real argument.

Did you read all of it? ->

>there were STILL pagans in my part of the country almost 500 years after my country converted to Christianity. They were praising to their gods right alongside Catholics who prayed to our God before battles.

Reality: nobody cared about the pagans and that they practiced their beliefs. Despite modern critics painting lies about the Church, the truth is that pagans were still around and dominated many European countries centuries after Christianity was introduced.
>>
>>1947781
It came from Egypt - cult of God of Death (Asiris).
>>
>>1948465
>truth is not an argument
Kys
>>
>>1948522
>Did you read all of it? ->
Yes, it was barely a paragraph long of course I read all of it.

>Reality: nobody cared about the pagans and that they practiced their beliefs.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saxon_Wars
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massacre_of_Verden

>the truth is that pagans were still around and dominated many European countries centuries after Christianity was introduced.
1. They're the exception and not the rule
2. I hope you realize that this totally undermines your earlier point that Europeans freely choose Christianity because it's true and abandoned paganism
>, Europeans could have raised their kids and descendants as pagans. Christianity was chosen and paganism was abandoned as impractical and false.
>>
>>1948465
>The same church and belief system is still around, Roman Catholicism.
Argument invalid.

There's literally bajillions of Christian divisions nowadays that to say "Christcucks remained the same." Is completely laughable.

In addition to say that the Roman Catholic Church is the same as those little communal cults of the first christians is also fucking laughable.
>>
>>1948531
>christianity is pagan because i said so!!
>kys
I ask you for more specific arguments, perhaps similarities in the celebrations that I can debunk for you.

Typical atheist strawman arguments.
>>
>>1947822
>Western religion
>Invented in Palestine
>Codified in Turkey
>>
>>1948544
Your religion is a syncretistic clusterfuck. Deal with it.
>>
>>1948544
why do christians paint eggs at easter?
why is it called easter?
who is ostara?
>>
File: _46639665_stake_gettycr_466.jpg (62KB, 466x270px) Image search: [Google]
_46639665_stake_gettycr_466.jpg
62KB, 466x270px
>>1948465
>what you believed was up to you
>>
>>1947781
Kind of but not really
>>
File: st-peter.jpg (47KB, 348x447px)
st-peter.jpg
47KB, 348x447px
>>1948532
>I hope you realize that this totally undermines your earlier point that Europeans freely choose Christianity because it's true and abandoned paganism
>>, Europeans could have raised their kids and descendants as pagans. Christianity was chosen and paganism was abandoned as impractical and false.
Not really. I never said it happened overnight, it was a gradual process. It took centuries for missionaries to be successful in spreading it to all corners of Europe. :)

>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Saxon_Wars
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massacre_of_Verden

I can post wikipedia links to Pagan raids on Christian villages and monasteries, as well. These are isolated incidents and the general population didn't really care about pagans.

>>1948553
Still can't formulate an argument?

>>1948536
Those little groups are called protestants for a reason, they diverged from the truth.

>Roman Catholic Church is the same as those little communal cults of the first christians is also fucking laughable

Roman Catholicism was founded by Peter (the most important of the original 12 disciples of Christ) on the orders of Christ.
>>
File: Absalon.jpg (115KB, 1024x914px)
Absalon.jpg
115KB, 1024x914px
>>1948423
>>1948445
Danes adopted Christianity sorta freely, it was seen as politically advantageous. I still find it hilarious that there is a less than 100 year timeskip between the last large Danish viking raid to the first Danish crusades. Christianity changed almost nothing, just a change of targets from Christian to pagan. One guy fucking killed a pagan god.
>>
>>1947781
The Roman sect is European.
>>
File: Haha.jpg (20KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]
Haha.jpg
20KB, 480x360px
>>1948572
>Still can't formulate an argument?
Nigger I played this game 1000 times. It's like trying to convince a fanatic commie that Marxian economics doesn't work.

I'm over trying to convince fanatic zelots. I figured it's just better point and laugh at them, while their religion (Marxian or Christian) fades into obscurity.
>>
>>1948192
>posts irrelevant bullshit when the Church was Roman and European vast majority and people convered to the Church not to some irrelevant middle easterners.

The cross symbolized God's sacrifice for us

Now to end it with a tune, DEUS VULT.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=isxvXITTLLY

also Christianity isn't homogenous, Spanish Catholicism is different to Swedish Catholicism etc...
>>
>>1948572
>I can post wikipedia links to Pagan raids on Christian villages and monasteries, as well.
The thing is I'm not defending Paganism as a religion of peace. I fully acknowledge that pagans were often very brutal people. I just think you ought to admit that very often Christianity was spread ISIS style.

>These are isolated incidents and the general population didn't really care about pagans.
Ah, but you see Christian forced conversions and general religious violence were not isolated incidents. As a matter of fact they were quite a regular occurrence.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_persecution_of_paganism_under_Theodosius_I
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roman_Inquisition
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goa_Inquisition
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Portuguese_Inquisition
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_Inquisition

>It took centuries for missionaries to be successful in spreading it to all corners of Europe. :)
And sometimes those missionaries carried swords.
>>
>>1948584
Lots of European nations accepted Christianity freely. It's just also true that many of them didn't.
>>
File: 1470083718694.jpg (41KB, 450x327px) Image search: [Google]
1470083718694.jpg
41KB, 450x327px
Christianity is destined to become a lower-class mestizo, indio, nigger and shitskin religion in the next few years, as Europeans and Anglo whites --the only people that matter and made Christianity anything to begin with--, are increasingly abandoning the Church, seeing it as the treasonous, cancerous entity that it really is.
>>
>>1948560
You need to realize that none of those things are accepted by the Church. Ostara is a pagan goddess of fertility and just because they fall on the same seasons of the year =/= that we are celebrating her. The first mention of Easter eggs started appearing in the 1600s (long after the conversion of Europe and by this time most of Europe was Christian) and they symbolized the resurrection of Christ.
>>
File: wyd2005.jpg (18KB, 380x273px) Image search: [Google]
wyd2005.jpg
18KB, 380x273px
>>1948587
>I'm over trying to convince fanatic zelots. I figured it's just better point and laugh at them

I think it's because you can't defend your points.

I've been in this thread for over an hour, I'm open to hearing your arguments.
>>
File: catholic.jpg (713KB, 1150x2896px)
catholic.jpg
713KB, 1150x2896px
What happened in the past doesn't matter. If Europe ever was Christian, and Christian European, it doesn't matter anyway, because whites don't believe in Christianity anymore and Christianity openly advocates for open borders white genocide.

If Christianity is to survive, it will not be white.
If white people are to survive, they will not be Christian.

The two are mutually exclusive.
>>
>>1948608
and Christianity* European
open borders and* white genocide

I should say.
>>
File: 20040921b_2.gif (35KB, 440x448px)
20040921b_2.gif
35KB, 440x448px
>>1948608
>because whites don't believe in Christianity anymore
False. Pic related is the weekly church attendance, for any holiday add 30%+ church attendance to the current one for every country.
>>
>>1948618
Yes, whites don't believe in Christianity anymore.

Dagos and slavshits do however.
>>
Christianity has been thoroughly Hellenized and latinized. Little of it is Jewish. I'd argue it's in many way more European than European paganisms which are closer from Indian Vedism than Christianity is from Judaism.
>>
>>1948618
>make the pic small so people won't notice the dark green is actually only 30%+
Clever
>>
>>1948620
Republic of Ireland/GDP per capita
50,503.42 USD (2013)
>>
>>1948626
Hinduism is based though.
>>
>>1948628
Qatar GDP per capita
132,870

They must be so white with that GDP per capita.
>>
File: german_citizens.jpg (168KB, 880x543px) Image search: [Google]
german_citizens.jpg
168KB, 880x543px
>>1948620
Which countries do you consider "white", exactly? Waiting for your answer so I can post some statistics, Mr. Abdul. :^)
>>
>>1948634
not white but based as fuck.
>>
>>1948627
If you can find a bigger pic, I'd appreciate it so I can use it in the future!

Like I said, holiday attendance adds another 30%+ to each of those.
>>
>>1948637
Estonia
Latvia
Finland

These for example.
>>
>>1948643
The point wasn't that the pic is too small. The point is that 30%+ is actually quite pathetic if it's the highest bracket of church attendance.

>Like I said, holiday attendance adds another 30%+ to each of those.
Do you have a source for this?
>>
File: 1478783046583.jpg (70KB, 570x560px) Image search: [Google]
1478783046583.jpg
70KB, 570x560px
>>1948644
>Estonia
>Latvia
>Finland

>white
Most of their populations are of Mongolian or Asian ancestry.
>>
File: Katya-Lischina-6.jpg (80KB, 338x600px) Image search: [Google]
Katya-Lischina-6.jpg
80KB, 338x600px
>>1948650
Mongols are white.

Praise Tengri.
>>
>>1948650
More Germanic than Anglos though.
>>
>>1948647
>The point is that 30%+ is actually quite pathetic if it's the highest bracket of church attendance, but it varies between countries. My diocese for example enjoys a comfy 70% weekly attendance.

I never denied that church attendance is on the decline, but the attendance of those that show up once a month is higher.

Also, you'll have trouble finding any Arab Islamic countries with higher mosque attendances. You can find higher mosque attendance, but you'll have to dip into Africa or Asia (the church attendance there is also higher there, often 80%+).

>Do you have a source for this?
Do you want any specific countries?
>>
>>1947781
>yes, YHWH is the great god of Europe! Yeshua is a European!
Simple truth is, it is not European. It was a non-European religion adopted by Europeans, sometimes under pain of death. It has attached itself to European identity, but this is recent in human history.
>>
jewish
>>
>>1948681
>Also, you'll have trouble finding any Arab Islamic countries with higher mosque attendances.
I would hazard that to your average Muslim Islam isn't taken much more seriously than Christianity in the west so this isn't surprising.

>Do you want any specific countries?
If you can find statistics concerning say three of any of those countries on that map that would be fine.
>>
Yahweh akbar!

Christianity is a European religion!

Behead all those who oppose Yeshua ben Yoseph!
>>
>>1948465
>Ironically the only reason we know anything about paganism is thanks to the Church and monks that kept record of them
We'd know a lot more if the pagans weren't killed or converted desu senpai

>Not really. Churches were built and crosses were put up, but what you believed was up to you
Saxon Wars didn't happen, Baltic Crusade didn't happen, Wendish Crusade didn't happen?
>>
>>1948687
>>1948697
here come the pagans or infidels.
>>
File: 1478700918362.png (317KB, 1356x1360px) Image search: [Google]
1478700918362.png
317KB, 1356x1360px
We have a new god now, one that doesn't ask us to accept other races and open our borders to low-iq hostile savages.

One that actually gives us victories for a change.

Praise.
>>
>>1948572
A pagan raid never wanted conversion.
A Christian crusade does.
>>
>>1948711
Witnessed.
>>
>>1948704
>waaaah catholics tell me if I am a filthy degenerate I go to hell and like there should be no authority for behaviors1 fucking kike on a stick

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vdhF4O54YjU
>>
>>1948704
So the Semites are here to stay, you mean?
>>
>Almost 25% of christcucks are from sub-saharan Africa
>European numbers keep decreasing

Top kek
>>
>>1948722
>semites
semites are in the middle east unless you pagan hedonists let them in because they offered you some coin.
>>
File: 1451944447953.jpg (649KB, 800x1360px) Image search: [Google]
1451944447953.jpg
649KB, 800x1360px
>>1948726
The semite is in your brain.
>>
>>1948726
I'm just trying to show how low the level of dialogue is.
I made a post about Abrahamic religion origin, he just started doos vult role-playing.

Don't pretend there was anything more profound in his statement than mine.
>>
>>1948725
It has to do with the rapidly increasing world population and the fact that Europe is stagnant in that area.
>>
File: 1470764820329.jpg (10KB, 250x227px)
1470764820329.jpg
10KB, 250x227px
>>1948725
Like I said here >>1948608
Argue all you want about the past, Christianity is to become a de facto non-white religion in the near future, and the Christian hierarchy, foreseeing this, has already turned against its former host, eager to jump on a new host, like a tick or a flea.
>>
>>1948729

this is so good
>>
>>1948729
The problem with paganism is that, to most people, it feels so alien and parochial compared to universalist religions. If people like Varg were aiming to replace Christianity with something more considered, like a nation-specific form of Deism, then there'd be far less room for mockery in such movements.
>>
File: 1451791130580.jpg (1MB, 1200x1800px) Image search: [Google]
1451791130580.jpg
1MB, 1200x1800px
>>1948729
>>
>>1948883
>nation-specific form of Deism
Hm, I like this idea.
>>
>>1947799
Indo-Europeans are indigenous to Europe though.
>>
>>1948389
The Devil is the typical representation of Pan
Angels are depicted as Cupido and Eros
Christmas' day is Mithra's rebirth day
Most tales in the Bible are actually pagan myths rewritten so that people would convert more easily
>>
>>1949003
>Most tales in the Bible are actually pagan myths
Name one.
>>
>>1948618
>"Religious attendance" instead of Christian attendance
>Not having different data sets for different ages and different religions
>>
>>1949016

Genesis is a combination of the Enuma Elish (the creation part), stories from Ugarit (the story about Adam and Eve), and other various stories from around the region (a story about a global flood already appeared in Gilgamesh and the Epic of Atrahasis). Furthermore, several themes in the Bible were very clearly influenced by themes that were already prevalent in the region (the final judgement and parts of creation already appeared in Egypt, a lot of the background of the Gods is from ancient Canaan, the division of good and evil and life as a cosmic battle between them can already be found in Zoroastrianism).

It's not a 1-on-1 copy, but you're very naive if you think that the Bible and everything in it was completely free of outside influence
>>
>>1949003
>Most tales in the Bible are actually pagan myths rewritten so that people would convert more easily
Yeah, while this is generally true, we should differentiate between OT and NT myths.

OT myths (Noah, etc.) come from Mesopotamia. Voegelin even showed that Hebrew (fictional) patriarchical genealogies closely mirror the genealogies of Babylonian (mythical) kings. See his Order and History Vol. I: Israel and Revelation.

They weren't meant for conversion though.

NT myths draw from the Dumuzi cycle, the Odissey, and general mystery religion lore.

The latter is what I think you meant by

>pagan myths rewritten so that people would convert more easily
>>
>>1949045
>They weren't meant for conversion though.
Unless of course you meant conversion of the Hebrews from Canaanite polytheism to Yahwism. In this case, my mistake.
>>
>>1948883
Racial/ethnic and cultural awareness is growing among yuros and yuro diaspora, though. Once universalism becomes unpalatable, where will people go when they want a faith that will help them identify with their heritage?
>>
>>1949042
*drools*
>hurr
*spills saliva*
>hurr
*shits his pans*
>de bible didn't gopy bagan myths
*changes diapers*
>bagan myths copied the bible
*is washed by a nurse*
>de bible is teh word of bog
*is fed by a nurse*
>jag made bedoras!
*shits himself again, triumphantly*
>>
>>1949068
Meant for >>1949016
>>
Dog blezz Isruhl.

America too, but first Isruhl

Grizzdianity is a Yuropian religion!
>>
>>1948650
>Most of their populations are of Mongolian or Asian ancestry
Pure bullshit. If you bring Mongolians into the scale, all Europeans sit in a pretty small cluster. Finns and Sardinians are the most far removed of that cluster, but even so they're both way closer to Anglos than they are any Asian.
>>
>>1948711
Goddamn.
>>
>>1949042
>>1949045
I think that comparisons prove that there is a universal story. This is so easily dismissed as deriving from a indo European common shared mythology. But then you mention how Chinese myth speaks of eight people who survived a flood on a boat, the same number of people on Noah's ark. You use these similarities to prove religions right or wrong or that they "copied" off each other.. You use dates to show that one people came up with an idea first and there is no other explanation for the similarities except direct plagiarism.

How about a theory that God jumbled up the human species language and this resulted in our sharing the same basic stories and ideas but seen differently through English speaking, modern, academic consensus field worshipping perspective? I mean, Abraham himself came from Mesopotamia originally, who is to say that the god he worshipped wasn't well known to all the other mesopotamians?

If we all really do descend from Adam and eve then of course we will have similar stories across different cultures.
>>
>>1949161
>I think that comparisons prove that there is a universal story.

Well naturally, because in these societies and at these times would have had to deal with roughly the same problems, resulting in experiences and reports of those experiences that will probably look very similar.

>How about a theory that God jumbled up the human species language and this resulted in our sharing the same basic stories and ideas but seen differently through English speaking, modern, academic consensus field worshipping perspective?

That would be something that's pretty hard to test.
>>
>>1949055
I honestly expect cynical worship of their own DNA/history before a full-fledged return to paganism, although doubtless more awareness of their national mythologies will develop. Personally, I'd find something like Arthurian mysticism more appealing than Wotan worship.
>>
>>1949204
>resulting in experiences and reports of those experiences that will probably look very similar.
Well no you would have to be pretty dumb to view Odin's self sacrifice on a tree with being pierced in his side by a spear to not be analogous to Jesus Christ's sacrifice. Or the fact there exists in Mesopotamian mythology a tree with a snake at the roots and a Thunderbird at the perch, same as Nordic mythology. Or that Ask and Embla were created from clay/Earth by a triune of god's which is extremely similar to the creation story of Adam and Eve. And to think that the exact amount of people who boarded a boat and survived a flood in both China and Israel is just pure coincidence is ridiculous. And there are world flood myths on every continent.

But to then suggest that all of this and hundreds of other comparisons are simply nothing more than forgeries or inventions to assimilate other cultures beliefs into one religion is not moronic, it is insanity.
>That would be something that's pretty hard to test.
And yet we find that there are language similarities between completely different cultures but are explained away as there having been travel and trade. There's always a convenient excuse for academics, because that's all they do all damn day, is find ways to circumvent a belief in something divine. Just think of all the people who would not have jobs if it was widely accepted that God is real and that was the general consensus. Academic scientists and professors are nothing but charlatans seeking to rip off the public just like so many religions do as well.
>>
>>1949161
It could also be different cultures reflecting historical events in their mythologies.

Like that big as flooding at the end of the last glacial maximum.
>>
>>1947781
At its core? no. It's a belief system born of Judean lower castes. However, through diffusion into Europe, wherein its powerbase was consolidated into Rome and Constantinople, it went through incredibly thorough syncretism - which then occurred repeatedly with the various other peoples it met. Protestantism - in my mind - is the result of Latinate syncretised Christianity conflicting with Germanic syncretised Christianity
>>
>>1949240
I didn't say anything about reconstructionism, famalam.
>>
>>1947781
Christianity is for everybody.
>>
File: 1478641333600.jpg (15KB, 200x213px)
1478641333600.jpg
15KB, 200x213px
>>1948465
>jesus wasnt even the first deity to be 'born" on the solstice, or the only deity at the time of Paul
>"easter" literally comes from the name of the deity Ishtar, and bunnies and eggs are used because they symbolize fertility, which Ishtar represented
>Catholicism, the first major propogator of christianty, simulated a pantheon by canonizing saints and ritualistic prayer to make it more palatable to the pagans of rome and celtic europe

if you deny the pagan influences on Christian traditions you are literally stupid
>>
>>1947822
christianity, just like western civilization, began in the middle east.
>>
>>1948235
Arabs are caucasian
>>
>>1948548
>Turkey
Codified outside of Europe in a geographical sense but not culturally or ethnically.

Turkroaches started moving into Anatolia around 1000 AD.
>>
>>1948544
The Saints are a Christianized pagan pantheon. Godhood in the ancient world was decided similarly to sainthood in the Catholic Church: by eclesiastical authorities. Those same authorities were and are often deified and worshiped themselves. Christians rebranded their form of worship, but the core element, patronage by each figure of a specific concept relevant to the prevailing faith, stayed the same.
>>
>white cucks
>worship brown man
>white men worship brown men
>but brown men dont worship brown men

brown men > white cucks = pagans
>>
>>1952053
>this dude
>retarded
>>
>>1951487
Greeks have had an Asiatic kink in their brain ever since the Alexander's conquest.
>>
>>1948650
At this point, I don't even know what people mean when they say "white people".
Some say you must have light hair and light skin to be white, some bring out the haplogroup maps, some say all europids are white etc.

I think that people should not be classified as white, black and so on because it creates so much confusion and leaves way too much room for interpretation.

>>1947781
>Is Christianity a European religion?
What is an European religion? A religion that was created in Europe? A religion what most Europeans follow?

Anyways, closest answer I can give is that christianity was europeanised over time.
Thread posts: 142
Thread images: 25


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.