[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

who were the picts?

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 67
Thread images: 4

File: 1449655109191.jpg (34KB, 298x550px) Image search: [Google]
1449655109191.jpg
34KB, 298x550px
who were the picts?
>>
>>1919328
British Gauls, right?
>>
>>1919328
Faggots from the looks of it.
>>
>>1919328

French Germans
>>
>>1919334
Get out here before I smack you on the nose with a rolled up newspaper gremlin.
>>
Brythonic Celts
>>
>>1919328
They got cucked by the Scots
>>
>these replies
This is some kind of /b/ or /v/ tier board.
>>
>>1919600
Spanish Mongols
>>
>>1919328

They were badasses that fucked in public and didn't afraid of anything
>>
>>1919328
Finngolian Mexicans, m i rite ?
>>
>>1919328
danish lesbians
>>
>>1919328
Descendants of ancient Finns
>>
>>1919600
It's spelled /int/, like cunt but with an 'i'.
>>
>>1919587
That's like saying Aztecs got cucked by Mexicans. "Scots" as a concept, much less a 'unified' people, didn't exist until relatively modern times.
>>
>>1919600
/his/ had a short golden age of actual intelligent troll-and-meme-free discussion until /pol/ and other barbarians showed up. Such is the way of the world... Trying to maintain standards in a horde of plebs is tough.
>>
File: 1457576631935.jpg (21KB, 391x366px) Image search: [Google]
1457576631935.jpg
21KB, 391x366px
>>1919890
Remember when the mods imposed the high standards listed in the board description? Neither do I.
>>
>>1919890
Barbarians? Are those like french swedes?
>>
>>1919880

No, the King of the Scots, Kenneth McAlpin, invited the Pictish leaders to a meeting to discuss the ongoing problem of Norse raiders. When they got there, he had them all murdered and usurped the Pictish throne.
>>
>>1919919
Frankly, no. I frequent a couple other boards that aren't full of memey shitposting (/his/ is worse, but still light compared to of course /b/ or /pol/), but even there mods don't seem to do shit. I can only assume their legions are filled with barbarian ranks, too. The end is surely nigh.
>>
>>1919328
Original inhabitants of Scotland, they lived in the North-East and raided other tribes like everyone else
Became a pest to the Romans, as did the Irish on the West coast (Scotland is named after an Irish clan iirc)
They were not particularly good sailors or cavalrymen, mostly fighting on foot with minimal armour, and very little cohesion
A reportedly tall people, they we're used as mercenaries by other factions like their neighbours in the west

Merged with the Irish Gaels sometime after Roman contact to form the Kingdom of Alba
They spoke their own language, now extinct, of which i know nothing about
Adopted Christianity, not much else to tell about them
They don't exist in Scotland anymore really, the two main cultures there now are Loyalist British Scots and Nationalist Gaelic Scots.
>>
>>1919933
You're still putting the cart before the horse with an overly-broad asynchronistic definition of 'Scots'. There was no such people called 'the Scots' until the various smaller tribal groups present in what is today 'Scotland' slowly coagulated (willingly or not) into a more-or-less single kingdom in the first place. I.e. that of Alba, and only later renamed 'Scots'. Picts were a component part of this milieu, basically the last holdouts outside the burgeoning 'Scots' ethnic/political umbrella, as they were on the north-eastern fringes. Yer man Ken there didn't conquer anyone, he was just another king/lord who himself had inherited (matrilineally) a last Pictish kingdom.

Picts, Gaels and Britons were separate tribal federations of closely-related Celtic groups. It is our (ultimately Roman-based) naming conventions that confuses the matter and imagines them as somehow much more separate people than they actually were. They likely did not view themselves as very different from their Celtic neighbours, but instead as merely autonomous.

Along with Angles (maybe a few Saxons), they were all the original 'Scots'. A heap of Norse and a dash of other insular (Irish/Manx) Celts were lated added to the soup.

Besides all that, 'Scots' when used alone is typically used to refer to a distinctly ANGLO-SAXON ethno-linguistic group of Scottish people. Scots Gaelic would avoid confusion if you're talking about the unravelled thread.
>>
>>1920016
>They spoke their own language, now extinct, of which i know nothing about

No one really does. They had no writing as far as we know and all that survived of their language was a few names of people and places.
>>
>>1920016
>They spoke their own language, now extinct, of which i know nothing about
When does a dialect become its own language? They almost certainly spoke a Gaelic language, closely related to that of their neighbours. Breton/Welsh/Cornish further south was more divergent, but still partially intelligible.
>>
>>1920102
>most likely spoke a Gaelic language
Unlikely, Gaelic was an Irish language, they're own language was most likely closer to the other Celtic languages of Britain
>>
>>1920083
The Irish Gaelic (linguistic cousins) called them 'Qritani', which would be the Q-Celtic version of the P-Celtic 'Pritani'. Guess where Britain got its name from.
>>
>>1919880
>"Scots" as a concept, much less a 'unified' people, didn't exist

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/D%C3%A1l_Riata
>>
>>1920016
>Original inhabitants of Scotland

extremely unlikely
>>
>>1920134
They we're big guys
>>
>>1920124
English ppl??
>>
>>1920115
You are wrong. I mean it's not like this information is hard to find... The Picts were most certainly a Gaelic people, as everyone else around them (in northern half of Great Britain) was too.

Gaelic (more linguistically-properly called 'Goidelic') is just one *branch* of the Celtic family, not a language itself (albeit the word is used that way as a short form, which is maybe why you're confused). Brythonic is the other branch, which includes Welsh and Cornish (and other extinct dialects). There were also continental branches, but they died out thousands of years ago. Bretagne in France is actually a re-colonization of the mainland from insular Brythonic peoples.

Anyway, Gaelic and Brythonic are/were closely related, much like Spanish or Portuguese or Russian and Ukrainian. There would have been a degree of mutual intelligibility. For the "Picts" and their other close neighbours, they would have understood each other well enough. If you're from Seattle, you can still largely understand a thick Appalachian or Texas English accent.
>>
>>1920166
>implying dialects are the same as accents
Wew
In any case, the language of Scotland today (aside from English) is a dialect of Irish Gaelic. This is because of the Irish colonisation of the west coast. Gaelic did not exist in Britain otherwise as far as i know.
But if you can link any other tribes natives to Britain, which spoke a dialect of Gaelic independent of Ireland, then I will concede
>>
>>1920166
>The Picts were most certainly a Gaelic people, as everyone else around them (in northern half of Great Britain) was too.
do you have anything to back that up?
>>
>>1920131
A rose by any other name would still be as sweet.

Obviously the name came from somewhere, but "Scots" was not a thing as we understand the term today until the 15th century or so. Transfering the term back to centuries before it's time is ridiculous. This is /his/ for chrissake, have some appreciation for proper eras.

>>1920140
Celts are Indo-Europeans, with an 'urheimat' in basically the Austrian Alps (and the surrounding plains running northeast). They exploded and spread everywhere in Europe (and some to the near east) during the Iron Age, including into the British Isles. They are not indigenous to the British Isles, and absorbed/replaced the original inhabitants (i.e. Stone Henge building cultures, etc)
>>
>>1920166
>The Picts were most certainly a Gaelic people, as everyone else around them (in northern half of Great Britain) was too.

No, just no. The Picts were certainly P-Celtic speakers, as was literally everyone in Britain before the arrival of the Scots.

>Gaelic and Brythonic are/were closely related, much like Spanish or Portuguese or Russian and Ukrainian.

You are completely fucking retarded. The similarity would be more like Baltic and Russian, P and Q celtic are not at all mutually intelligible.
>>
>>1919328
probably Brythonic Celts like the other inhabitants of Great Britain, but we cant know for sure since they had no writing.
>>
>>1920205

They did have writing, but it's untranslated. The few words we have of Pictish are unambiguously P-Celtic.
>>
>>1920206
source?
if they're P-Celtic, than that all but settles it, they're brothers to the Welsh, Cornish, Britons, and the like.
>>
>>1920181
>implying I implied that
I did a couple years of linguistics before switching majors, so nigga please.

>>1920188
I think there's confusion about what eras we might be talking about. Without a time machine, we'll never really know.

>>1920202
> P and Q celtic are not at all mutually intelligible.
Prove it. Even modern Irish Gaelic or Welsh, which have had several more centuries to drift, you can see some of the connections. They are different languages to be sure, which is what I said, but not as far divergent as you seem to imagine. "Not at all" intelligible for perhaps some dirt farmer's wife, but anyone sailing around with enough contact on either side of the Irish Sea would have been able to pick out words and phrases to start with.
>>
What's this thing I heard about a language called "Iron Speech" spoken in Ireland?
>>
>>1920257
If it's not intelligible to an Irish farmer who's spoken Irish, and only Irish, his entire life then it's not intelligible
Welsh and Irish are very different languages

I can "pick out" some words and phrases from German and Latin, but i cannot speak either language at all, because they're not mutually intelligible
>>
>>1920285
Most likely an extinct dialect
>>
>>1920285

Cormac's Glossary, from the 9th century, makes brief reference to it and a couple of Irish words stemming from it and that's about all we know about it.
>>
>>1920257
>Prove it.

Saint Columba needed an interpreter to preach to the Picts, despite being a native Irishman.
>>
>>1920285
it was a North Germanic language that took in the Kingdom of the Isles from the Norsemen.

Never had much folks speaking it to begin with, so it didn't have much a chance of staying.
>>
>>1920140
For you
>>
>>1921836
Was getting walled part of your plan?
>>
>>1919331
pretty much
>>
Another race of sheepfuckers who got their ass beat by a race of skirt-wearing sheepfuckers.
>>
They're all rapists
>>
>>1920257
>I think there's confusion about what eras we might be talking about.
How is it even possible to be confused about this? I'm not saying that you're wrong about their language if you have anything to prove it, but if you're talking about the time after Dal Riada had culturally, politically and linguistically annexed them, you're not talking about picts.
>>
>>1922185
Some of them are good people.
>>
File: 1448822158726.jpg (879KB, 2048x1536px) Image search: [Google]
1448822158726.jpg
879KB, 2048x1536px
>>1922343
>>
>>1919328

Sheep fuckers who eventually evolved into clover monkeys and bagpipe niggers.
>>
>>1919328
A bunch of Guy Fieris.
>>
>>1919328
Ancient punks?
>>
>>1924448
>spoke gaelic

Why do all the words of attestably Pictish origin follow the P-Celtic pattern, then? For eg the placename element pet-, found across the Pictish region and cognate with Irish cett- and Welsh pet-
>>
>>1919328
What's with his hair?
>>
>>1925036
He's about to put on a bowling shirt and cram a double cheesburger into his face and call it the best ever, while the cooking staff look on awkwardly.
>>
>>1925353
Celts were more based than I thought
>>
>>1920193

celts were atlantic, that was their uhrmeit
>>
>>1925036
Bleached with lime (the alkali not the fruit)
>>
>everybody here claiming the Picts were P-celtic
>always thought they were Q-celts
>turns out the book I read on this subject was over 100 years old
rip sir Oman, you crazy racist gentleman.
>>
File: 1478230547161.png (99KB, 340x340px) Image search: [Google]
1478230547161.png
99KB, 340x340px
>>1926766
Celtic historical anthropology moves at the speed of light, my man. There's a lot of stuff I learned in during my history degree 5 or 6 years ago that is now considered baloney.
>>
>>1926488
No. Just open a fucking book to find out how wrong you are. Celts were central Europeans. Their Urheimat was in the Austrian Alps and Danube valley (in between proto-Germans and proto-Italics, among others). Before and during the bronze age (in two major waves), they spread into the British Isles, among other places. Over time, they absorbed and replaced earlier stone age inhabitants of the British Isles.
>>
>>1926861
Of course, as Indo-European peoples, depending how autistic and far back you want to consider, even the Austrian Alps are not their origins. But it is where they developed into what we consider distinctly Celt.
>>
>>1922349
we've been here before
Thread posts: 67
Thread images: 4


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.