why did the Jacobites fight at culloden? they would have known that the open field favored cumberland's artillery, what logical reason did they have to fight on the moor?
Being jacobites they probably knew it was only a matter of time before they were beaten by protestant work ethic. Decided to get it over and done with.
>mfw the Jacobites invaded England, only to run back to Scotland when they heard an army was coming
>>1757151
Why didn't you just read the wiki page
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Culloden#Lead_up_to_battle
The Irish captain that Prince Charles had delegated the setting of the order of battle to was a complete fucking idiot. He was a decent administrative supply officer but a horrible tactician. All the other Jacobite captains protested, knowing that they would get slaughtered, but Charles didn't listen to them.
>>1757415
>putting the irish in charge of anything
Jesus Christ dread to think what the state of Britain would be if these heathen lunatics succeeded.
>>1757503
In fairness the Irish contingent with the Jacobites were the only unit who won their engagement on the day, and after it was clear the battle was lost, they held the line while the Scots retreated
>>1757520
>God bless those Irishmen, they can win for any cause but their own.
>>1757503
england would've had freedom of religion..
>Anglos bullying Ireland for being stupid despite Ireland being better off both HDI-wise and GDP per capita wise than the UK
>>1757161
>/his/ in a nutshell