Find a flaw

>>1630500
An eye for an eye leaves two people blind in one eye

>>1630500
Justice can't be simplified to equivalent exchange.

>>1630500
Revenge is not Justice

File: 55421766.jpg (110KB, 800x800px) Image search: [Google]

110KB, 800x800px

>if a man rapes a child, the child should rape him back

>>1630505
?

>>1630500
Nobody gains anything except maybe some soothed hurt feelings. But presumably these are adults and society shouldn't be based around their hurt feelings.

>>1630500
The Law Maker, the nation and the institution the enforced this is dead and extinct for the past 2500 years and their entire culture is just a curiosity for the countless visitors to a museum in a land that used to be populated by savages.

So the obvious flaw, it failed the test of time, like all men and their creations(including all religions) do.

>>1630527
Abrahamic faiths will be here until humanity is extinct

>>1630521
to deter, shouldn't a judicial decision hit harder than the crime?

To err is man.

What if he is a fool who only think his eye has been taken? Or he takes the wrong man's eye in revenge? What stops him from taking two eyes from the man? The cycle of violence continues.

This is why good justice is cathartic. Because it is rare.

>>1630517
>If a man rapes a woman, the woman should rape him back.

>>1630558

or maybe a willing bull for the rapist

>>1630517
>>1630558
The Woman should kill him

>>1630510
Who cares?

>>1630581
>>1630582
No, she should rape him back. Do you not understand justice?

>>1630517
>>1630558
>>1630581
wtf I love justice now!

>>1630538
>Abrahamic faiths will be here until humanity is extinct
the entropic law of the universe will ensure its destruction before mankind. IT will happen in the next 40 decades.