Easter Rising: What If?

>>1201010
Ireland would probably be in a civil war between the the U.K. backed Ulsters and Ireland.

>>1201560

That seems unlikely. Even if the fledgling Irish republic could hold Dublin, even if they could cause enough trouble in the countryside to draw off British forces, how long could they possibly endure? Once WWI was over they'd have the full force of the British army direct their way, not just mercenaries and token forces sent to quell a restless backwater.

Plus, the rising had almost no widespread public support in the beginning. That only came as the British started cracking down and executing the rising's leadership in a heavy-handed fashion, inflaming public sentiment. If Pearse and the rest were holding out in the Post Office, raising hell in the countryside, and brining the country to a halt, they'd receive widespread public scorn, and the blame for the unrest would fall on them in the public eye. Plus, eventually the British would just cut them off from the countryside, strangling their lines of communication and supply.

File: 1459931266213.png (1MB, 2426x1314px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2426x1314px

Easter?

Wasn't the plan to create a big of enough stink that the Brits couldn't kick them out without pulling too many troops from the front, thus forcing the Brits to the negotiating table?