>people that did nothing wrong

>>1130361
>right wrong dichotomy
>relevant to history

>>1130361
>McClellan
You simply mean "people that did nothing" then.

File: file.png (671KB, 840x633px) Image search: [Google]

671KB, 840x633px

>>1130361

>>1131507
Iraq 2003 is pretty unjustifiable fampai. Other than that you're right.

>>1130361

He didn't crush the Army of Northern Virginia at Antietam, despite having nearly 2:1 numerical advantage and knowing Lee's plan.

He could have, and should have, won the war right then and there. That he didn't is definitely doing something wrong.

File: MTE1ODA0OTcxNjk0Nzg2MDYx.jpg (17KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 300x300px

>>1130361

>>1131547
It's bait, but yeah. Also >>1131414 has it right.

File: 1436084682684.jpg (80KB, 500x737px) Image search: [Google]

80KB, 500x737px

>>1131547

>he believes Sears memes

File: 1453078040853.jpg (78KB, 640x533px) Image search: [Google]

78KB, 640x533px

>>1131547

>2:1 numerical advantage

>not knowing the difference between aggregate and PFD/combat arms

File: vladtepes.jpg (169KB, 392x483px) Image search: [Google]

169KB, 392x483px

>>1130361

Surprised no one has posted hitler yet.

File: screencapture-en-wikipedia-org-wiki-Robert_E-_Lee-1459023999498.png (197KB, 1559x1123px) Image search: [Google]

197KB, 1559x1123px

>>1131414
>>1131547
>>1131755
McClellan doesn't deserve his bad reputation. He did better than any other commander of the Army of the Potomac against Lee. The war would have been won a year or two earlier if Lincoln didn't sack him.

Adolf Hitler.

He did nothing wrong, watch "The Greatest Story Never Told".

>>1133859
He was terrible commander tho.

File: 1462430969747.png (141KB, 1000x500px) Image search: [Google]

141KB, 1000x500px

Ian Smith

>>1131541
What are you talking about? He did nothing wrong

>>1134038

He killed Saddam Hussein.

File: otto_liman_von_sanders.jpg (74KB, 620x386px) Image search: [Google]

74KB, 620x386px

Did´t kill the armenians.

File: cs.jpg (493KB, 900x1024px) Image search: [Google]

493KB, 900x1024px

We're the boys who went around McClellanian, went around McClellanian, went around McClellanian! We're the boys who went around McClellanian, bully boys ho, bully boys hey!

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XquoxxcHmdc

>>1136215
>>1136215
Yeah, nah.

>>1136782
you responded to the same picture twice, ya dingus.

>>1136796
double clicked like a tard

>>1133859
>>1134122
Turks leave this board, you cancerous edgelords

>>1133885
You can't be serious... He was an excellent organizer but a shit field commander, of all the commanders of the Army of the Potomac he was the only one to get sacked TWICE. He was arrogant, timid, indecisive, publicly disdainful of his superiors and a bit of a dick.

He COULD have taken Richmond during the Peninsula campaign, he COULD have destroyed Lee at Antietam, instead he bungled both royally. It's a measure of both Lincoln's patience and desperation for some kind of useful leadership that he stayed in command as long as he did and was reinstated after being replaced the first time.

>>1137020
Based

>>1137262
Based

>>1137266
Absolutely based.

>>1137267
Idk about him yet.

>>1131547

>believing Sears memes

I feel sorry for you fampai.

>>1133113
>>1133130

These senpaitachi have it right. McClellan only had roughly a 5:4 manpower advantage at Antietam, and a few thousand of his men were green troops straight from training and basically worthless.

>>1138732

Continuing the Sears meming I see.

He was the best Union general of the war, or at least top 3. He defeated Lee in West Virginia in the start. He organized the overall Union strategy that eventually won the war. He was only fired by Lincoln because Lincoln was a moron when it came to political matters, and because he was a Democrat.

He could have taken Richmond in the Peninsula Campaign if Lincoln didn't hamstring him by removing his forces and giving him retarded orders like "leave your right flank open to connect with the men marching from Fredericksburg that would have been with your army but I pulled out because I was too pussy to leave the direct route to DC undefended - hehe just kidding I'll send them to the Valley to get fucked by Jackson on a wild goose chase!"

McClellan saved the Union in the Antietam campaign. The Antietam campaign was a crushing defeat for Lee. Also, before you bring it up, the Lost Orders had no impact on the campaign except confirming what McClellan already deduced. Note: the marching orders for the next day had already gone out by the time the Lost Order reached McClellan's hands.

Anti-McClellan meming was started by Lincoln and the Republicans to shit on him as a presidential candidate, and it continued after the war with moronic retard authors like Sears who distort facts and numbers to fit their agenda.

Also, McClellan's original plan to bypass the overland route to Richmond and use the James River was completely correct. It utilized the two biggest advantages the Union had: water control and siege warfare. Lincoln was a moron obsessed with open-field battles. Eventually, Grant's overland campaign failed and he switched to McClellan's suggested line of operations, the James River, and this ended up being the winning move. Grant did in 1864 what McClellan wanted to do in 1862 - only difference was Grant had the political capital to do it with Lincoln.

File: antietam18th.png (535KB, 508x788px) Image search: [Google]

535KB, 508x788px

>>1138732

Note also: Grant wanted McClellan to command the Army of the James but Lincoln blocked it.

Lee also called McClellan his most able opponent.

Also, McClellan was outnumbered in the Seven Days battles but executed a brilliant change of base after Lincoln's order to extend his right flank and keep it open became untenable due to Jackson's flank attack.

Even dumbass Stanton realized that McClellan's new position on the James was a more advantageous position, in his own words at the time:
Stanton: "McClellan has moved his whole force across the Chickahominy and rests on the James River, being supported by our gun boats. The position is favorable, and looks more like taking Richmond than any time before.”

Further, you probably don't even know about McClellan's successful post-Antietam campaign that Lincoln pulled the plug on right in the middle.

>>1133378
everything wrong

>>1131652
nothing wrong

>>1138905
>>1138933
>all that revisionist bullshit

Are you related to this incompetent, guy?

>>1140845

Great retort. Facts are facts.