Was this show unironically good or was it just egdy Winx?

>>95353672
Show was meh.
Comic was great

>>95353672
W.I.T.C.H. came first, genius
And the comic book's much better

>>95353717
>W.I.T.C.H. came first, genius
it didn't, though

>>95353672
First season was barely better than Winx.

Second season is legit good.

File: firegirl.png (743KB, 966x461px) Image search: [Google]

743KB, 966x461px

Why does she turn into Coolio every time she transforms?

>>95353672
I thought Winx was garbage Witch, also comics were great, never watched a single episode of the show

>>95353672
Winx was plagiarizing, unimaginative garbage with awful design and animation, cardboard characters who were defined by having a single interest which was also their name, cardboard villains, and boring, retarded plots that were literally cobbled together from plagiarized stories and cliches. They took the shittiest, laziest magical girl template and somehow managed to execute it in the worst way possible, all to exploit little girls for their parents' hard earned money with shitty merchandise.

WITCH was quality Western take on the magical girl genre that adopted some basic ideas and developed them in positive ways. In doing so it surpassed the vast majority of the interchangeable cookie-cutter bullshit from Japan. It had character development, it had ongoing plotlines, it had actual changing dynamics within the group, secondary characters were actual characters, villains had motivations, plots that made sense and spanned multiple episodes, and they were threatening, the antagonism between the girls and the villains was developed in them acting to frustrate the villain in an organized manner. And the romance and drama weren't too dumb or too boring. So yes, it was unironically good as far as little girls' cartoons go.

>>95353750
Yes it did, numbnuts.
The W.I.T.C.H. comic first appeared in 2001.
Winx Club first aired 2004.

>written by a female
Objectively shit.

File: anonbtfo.png (7KB, 656x155px)

7KB, 656x155px

>>95354937
LITERALLY FUCKING WRONG LMAO

File: image.jpg (254KB, 864x1945px)

254KB, 864x1945px

>>95355038

Fucking idiot.

Despicable.

>>95353672
Comic is based. Irma is best girl

>>95355038
The tv show came after winx but the comic came eariler.

File: 1504302561141.png (58KB, 441x302px)

58KB, 441x302px

>>95355218
>the town bike
>best girl

>>95355416
Yeah, insult Irma. See what happened last time.

>>95355416
>the town bike
>not Cornelia

How many of you have been on /co/ long enough to remember that guy who was obessessed with this?
"Wyatt Creed" was his tripcode

>>95355572
>ima shoot water on your face
so intimidating

>>95355416
>>95355572
>>95355605
Don't argue. They're all whores except for Elyon who is actually pure.

>>95355634
I've heard of him and was around when he made a brief comeback.

>>95355662
Don't kid yourself anon. Elyon is the most depraved of all.

>>95355662
Hay Lin is the purest little puffball ever rendered in comic form

>>95355639
Cuba and Florida (and a bunch of caribbean islands) says otherwise.

>>95354215
cause she black

Hay Lin best gril

>>95353672
>Winx VS W.I.T.C.H debates have existed since before /co/ was a thing
what in the absolute fuck
http://www.toonzone.net/forums/threads/w-i-t-c-h-vs-winx-club-the-battle-truly-begins.3775701/

File: WITCH_7839.jpg (43KB, 348x488px)

43KB, 348x488px

>>95353672
So I've never watched this, but from promo pics I've seen 3 of the 5 girls look hot as fuck - the redhead in particular may well be the hottest waifu I've ever seen, which is saying something considering I normally HATE short hair on girls.

Question is, are they actually that hot in the show itself? Because that's often not the case.

>>95356223
The nigger is hotter cause she doesnt look like Coolio all the time and the asian has a pretty charming personality

the opening should suffice if you need to see them in motion
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fdkPQQ62-Rg

>>95356223
They are actually much hotter. The magical costume design is probably one of the weakest points. They look much better in their civilian clothes, and both their clothes and hair styles change as the comic and subsequently the show also had a fashion element to it. Which you can also see in each girl having a different magic costume design, forming a collection all together, rather than the lazy color-coded single design shit Japs do, but the color pallet and most of the designs are still weak in my opinion.

File: It_Begins_(2).jpg (47KB, 564x423px)

47KB, 564x423px

Irma best girl

>there's good Italian comics.
>there's good French comics.
>there's no German comics at all.

What's up, Germany?

>>95357652
Too busy planning WWIII

>>95355038
Kill yourself , faggot

And may your mother get raped to death

>>95354937
The Winx cartoon came out after the W.I.T.C.H comic, but Winx had been in development since 1999, before W.I.T.C.H.

>>95356148
Be probably had them on /b/

File: german autism.jpg (72KB, 850x400px)

72KB, 850x400px

>>95357652
German's can't do anything without ruining it.

File: werner[1].jpg (15KB, 419x291px)

15KB, 419x291px

>>95357652

There is Werner

>>95357747
>But they are Germans. So they will end by ruining our idea.

I love how these gigantic figures of history sound like shitposters on /int/.

>>95357729
Interesting

>>95353672
Isn't Winx the Slut version of W.I.T.C.H.?

>>95358071
I think at one point winx reached the point they could not make the outfits any more revealing so each new outfit became more covering instead.

>>95353672
Winx got a little bit dark a couple of times.
Whoever survives gets to graduate comes to mind.

>>95356223
>>95356316
>>95356771
Guys' taste in looks is so varied, said no one ever.

File: IcyDisenchantix.jpg (78KB, 768x576px)

78KB, 768x576px

>>95358156
Yeah, pretty sure the Trix's Disenchantix outfits were that point.

>>95360633
Oh. So THAT'S why people watched this shit. For the girls in slutty outfits. I labeled it as shit and gave up on it pretty early on, so I never saw all the sluttier get-ups.

>>95353672
The show had cool monster designs

File: 54651641616184616.gif (2MB, 400x304px)

2MB, 400x304px

>Season 2 introduces a hot lich who wants to bring her magical girl team back though necromancy and other evil methods

>>95358071
>>95358156
>>95360633
>>95360735
The W.I.T.C.H. girls are far more attractive, though. So that makes no sense.

>>95361011
Winx changed costumes every season or so so we got to see a lot of variety.

>>95361824
Costumes don't make girls attractive.

>>95356316
>>95356771
Don't they get aged up by the costumes? At least that's what I've read.

>>95362951
Yep. Iirc they even use it to sneak into a party, and Caleb is suprised to find out that Cornelia is younger than the thought (despite being willing to date Elyon later on...)