DC Rebirth

>>94822863
>Batgirl
its ok
>Batgirl & the Birds of Prey
ok
>Detective Comics
only good for clayface
>Action Comics
wavers between meh and good
>All-Star Batman
pretty good
>Batwoman
ok
>Batman Beyond
good
>Supergirl
ok
>Superwoman
ok now
>Trinity
ok
>Suicide Squad
eh
>Harley Quinn
ok

the only rebirth books I dislike are titans and deathstroke

Action started off bad, but it has picked up.

>>94823149
From what issue?

>>94822863
I like Action more than Superman desu.

>>94823194
after the initial doomsday arc just abouts. You could even start with the arc where Lex and Supes have to go to space because they think Lex will become mega hitler.

>>94823074
Superwoman is okay now? Waht.

>>94825313
yeah there is a new writer.... its still not good but its not fucking terrible anymore

the breif Atomic Skull bits are great

>>94822863
>Batgirl
Garbage
>B&BOP
Garbage
>Detective
7.5/10. Spoiler spoils it.
>Action
8/10. Some of the stuff with Borg Superman and Zod feels improvised, but it's entertaining enough
>Supergirl
5/10. Nothing special, drags in the beginning but levels out to be strictly inoffensively boring. Cute blonde girl doing super stuff.
>Trinity
6/10 pre-Superman Reborn; 8/10 post-Superman Reborn. Had to get past all that "Bruce doesn't trust Clark" bs. Good substitute for Justice League Rebirth, also pretty hype if you enjoy the magic side of the DCverse.
>Suicide Squad
I might get flack for this, but 8/10. It had great humor in the beginning (like the graphic designer running joke) and decent plot so far. It has some hiccups, and Rick Flag is the single most boring character since Steve Trevor, but the hope of seeing Amanda Waller finally lose is keeping me hanging on.

>>94825305

Actual I thought the trail of Superior Superman was very predictable and tedious. It was a lot of noise and drama that didn't change anything.

I mean it was an improvement to what they did to Lex in the first arc of Superwoman, but it was a wasted opportunity. Lex didn't really anything about Clark in those six or so issues that Paul Cornell didn't handle better in one issue of The Black Ring.

>>94822863
I don't read some of these. Not sure why all the hatred on this site for Batwoman other than it seems to be a reflexive Bennett issue not at all based on the actual stories or issues. People just complaining to complain.

I'm not fond of Batman Beyond. The Justice League Beyond book was somewhat interesting and I think the concept works better that way than just being another Bat book.

Supergirl could be better.- they could have done so much more with the Phantom Zone arc for example, and Emerald Empress was just wasted for those appearances.

Trinity I agree with this >>94825519.

>>94822863
>Batgirl
Boring.
>Batgirl & the Birds of Prey
Somehow even more boring.
>Detective Comics
I really don't give a damn about any of the characters in this one.
>Action Comics
Fun stuff for the most part, on par with Superman imo.
>Supergirl
Awful. There so much synergy, Kara is treated like she's pretty much perfect, the art is awful, Orlando's writing is choppy and his pacing is so off it's not even funny. I'm also mad that the LoSH hints are contained in this book right now because they do not deserve that.
>Trinity
Boring, long drawn out arcs that probably read much better in trades. But the art had been nice so far.

>>94822863
>Trinity
Not really that bad, I'm actually enjoying the current series.

I would put Nightwing in this list because the book is so boring with hardly any interesting idea.

>>94826439
*current arc

>>94826439
>>94826447
I read Nightwing's latest issue but somehow I can't remember what's going on in there. Is it just me or it's just forgettable?

>>94822863
>Batgirl
Bad, the containment book.
>Batgirl & the Birds of Prey
Actually pretty fun. But having a black guy as Oracle is fucking stupid. They literally already have a black woman that's also a cripple. At least use her so the all girl thing sticks.
>Detective Comics
Great book unless you're a Batgod fag. Easily the best Bat book of Rebirth.
>Action Comics
Really fun action kek series
>All-Star Batman
Boring as fuck
>Batwoman
It's fine. Still need more time to form a definitive opinion.
>Batman Beyond
I've actually been really loving this series.
>Supergirl
Boring and tedious as fuck. First arc was way too long, the art didn't fit. It really does seem like the only characters Orlando can write are Middy and Lobo.
>Superwoman
Boooooooooooring. First arc was way too long and way too fucking wordy. Superwoman should not be the most wordy DC book.
>Trinity
I've been liking it quite a bit.
>Suicide Squad
Mindless fun.
>Harley Quinn
Apart from the Dini backups it's just pretty boring.

>>94823074
>the only rebirth books I dislike are titans and deathstroke
You have weird as fuck taste.

>Above average tier
Action Comics
>Recently improved tier
Superwoman
Blue Beetle
>Okay tier
Detective Comics
Batman Beyond
>Boring tier
All-Star Batman
Batwoman
Supergirl
Trinity
>Shit tier
Batgirl
Batgirl & the Birds of Prey
Suicide Squad
>Only good for back-ups tier
Harley Quinn

>>94822863
Rebirth was a mistake.

>>94825519
>also pretty hype if you enjoy the magic side
Fuck you this is garbage made to appeal to vanilla cape readers.

>>94826478
It's. I wanted to give Nightwing a chance with Rebirth, but I haven't been impressed at all.

>>94823074
I forgot about Titans. It definitely deserves to be in the list.

I'm a couple issues behind on Batman Beyond, but I enjoyed the first arc.

Birds of Prey I started and dropped after too issues. Not bad, just okay.

>>94822863
>Action Comics
Feels like a universe-spanning event. Very good (most of the time)

>All-Star Batman
You'll love it if you liked Snyder's New 52 Batman.

>Detective Comics
>Supergirl
>Superwoman
I've heard good things about all of these.

>>94822863
>Batgirl
First arc was average but it's been shit ever since
>B+BoP
Shit
>Detective Comics
Average with clayface and cass being the highlight and spoiler being the low point
>Action Comics
Fun but I still think it should be a book that follows Lex
>All-Star
Two face was great haven't read anything else
>Batwoman
Bad, no wear near as good as her new52 run

Haven't read the rest

>>94825519
>I might get flack for this
Never. I made this thread so I can see the different opinions going on. Nothing worse than the /co/ hivemind, brotha. Rock on

>>94826533
>I've actually been really loving this series.
Wanna elaborate?

>>94828146
It's been a nicely paced fun story with a couple of cool twists.

>>94828532
How does it compare to the DC You post-Future's End Batman Beyond?

>>94828557
Not him, but it's a lot better, since it doesn't focus on the destroyed world aspect.
It's still a continuation of it by Jurgens though. New shitty suit, twist at the end of the first arc and Ra's successor shit are pretty stupid still make it just an okay book.
I hope that it will get a new team.

>>94828721
Hmm thanks for the info, friendo

>>94822863
Meh
Bad
Better than Batman
Great
Haven't read it yet
Okay-ish
Between meh and good
Haven't read it
Is it still being released?
Comfy
Don't care
Fuck Harley

>>94822863
>Batgirl
Boring
>Batgirl & the Birds of Prey
Even more boring
>Detective Comics
Alright. Unlike birds of prey the teammates interactions are nice.
>Action Comics
Really Good. Although I think I like it alot because of how shitty the n52 action comics was so by comparison the rebirth stories are amazing.
>Batman Beyond
Alright
>Supergirl
nothing special. Boring but not as boring as batgirl. Art is really shitty though.
>Superwoman
alright
>Trinity
boring but not as bad as supergirl or batgirl. Redhood's trinity is better.
>Suicide Squad
ok. Zodd was interesting.
>Harley Quinn
shit

Haven't read allstar batman and batwoman

>>94822863
>>Batgirl
Never bothered to read

>>Batgirl & the Birds of Prey
Never bothered to read

>>Detective Comics
Nice so far, most of the times i prefer it to the Batman's book

>>Action Comics
Nice so far, most of the times i prefer it to the Superman's book

>>All-Star Batman
Dropped after 3 issues

>>Batwoman
Never got past the first two issues, but it was fine, i think i'll catch up

>>Batman Beyond
Not going to read

>>Supergirl
Curious but never bothered enough to read

>>Superwoman
Sometimes boring, not on my must read list

>>Trinity
Dropped for a while, cause too many Batman and Superman comics, but i'm catching up now, pretty good

>>Suicide Squad
Fine

>>Harley Quinn
I always forget she has a book, i guess that says a lot

>>94822863
>>Batgirl
Meh
>>Batgirl & the Birds of Prey
All over the place
>>Detective Comics
Some arcs are good, some are borderline bad, Clayface is aces
>>Action Comics
It's jurgens so I imagine it's mediocre
>>All-Star Batman
Meh
>>Batwoman
Okay wtih good art
>>Batman Beyond
Can't decide what it wants to be
>>Supergirl
First arc was terrible, don't look at it anymore
>>Superwoman
First arc was terrible, don't look at it anymore
>>Trinity
All over the place
>>Suicide Squad
terriible
>>Harley Quinn
terrible

Can people rating books add a short blurb of what's going on right now? I've been culling my pull list so I have room for some more interesting sounding ones.

>>94832366
Good idea

>>94832366
>I've been culling my pull list so I have room for some more interesting sounding ones.
Look at a different publisher.

From Rebirth, I've only read Superman, Batman, Wonder Woman, Justice League, Green Lanterns, Hal Jordan and the Green Lantern Corps, Flash, and Green Arrow. I read Action Comics too but dropped it after the first arc. What title should I check out next, /co/?

>>94834501
New Super-Man and Red Hood are the only DC books worth reading

>>94822863
You forgot Justice League and Blue Beetle.

>>94835633
What's your opinion on 'em, chief?

>>94835104
Red hood fans are the worst. Because the believe shit like this.

>>94835659
Blue Beetle sucks Justice League is fun
>>94835979
Damianfags and Dickfags are just sad and jealous

>>94835104
What's the appeal of New Superman? I've not read any of it, but seeing the character in other comics gives me a sour interpretation. He seems like a quippy Marvel hero, and not in a good way.

>Batgirl
4/10
>Batgirl & the Birds of Prey
5/10 - Better than batgirl
>Detective Comics
6/10
>Action Comics
7/10 (but right now suck, writing and art)
>All-Star Batman
6/10
>Batwoman
read only the first issue and dropped it, so no idea.
>Batman Beyond
same as batwoman
>Supergirl
4/10 a great disappointment
>Superwoman
3/10 worse than supergirl
>Trinity
4/10 I was hype for it when it started but is sucked
>Suicide Squad
6/10 some times is not bad, sometimes is not good
>Harley Quinn
never give it a chance so no idea

>>94826342
> I'm also mad that the LoSH hints are contained in this book right now because they do not deserve that.
I know that feel bro.

>>94836065
>Damianfags and Dickfags are just sad and jealous
jesus christ talk about pathetic. anon was right red hood fans are the worst.

>>94822863
>Put the whole new Marvel Family on the promo poster
>Still no sign of a Shazam/Captain Marvel book

Granted i'd rather wait for a good book than have a bad one immediately, but the complete radio silence is getting annoying.