5 Stars

>>93978893
It's a good comic... the only bad thing is Jane :P

>>93979006
so the whole comic is bad

>>93978893

Tumblr can bridage star ratings all they want, it still won't get them any more sales.

so what's Gwenpool's rating

>>93979006
No the Titana scene & the Asgardians turning against Odin after several million years for no other reason then patriarchy=bad is cancer.
>>93979030
No the art is great, the villains are all decent to good. The Fem Thor design is great.

>>93978893

Anon, go in detail to why the comic is lame.

File: FeministSister.jpg (683KB, 1988x3056px) Image search: [Google]

683KB, 1988x3056px

>>93979111

>the villains are all decent to good.

So good that they surrender just because the hero is such a brave feminist.

>>93979261
Five star writing. Fucking video games have better writing.

>>93978893
The people who would buy it are already predisposed to giving it 5 stars. Why does anyone care? It's like asking people who enjoy taking massive dildos in the ass how they feel about the King Kong Super Dong. You better believe that they're going to give it a 5/5.

>>93978893
I got a trade through Secret Santa last year, and it ain't that bad. Art is GOAT, Fem!Thor is hawt, and the stories are entertaining. If you can get past "SMASH THE PATRIARCHY" it's not so bad.

>>93980432
Exactly this. The confirmation bias was there from the beginning. The same way it is here.

>>93980432
OP is not bright enough to realize that.

>>93978893
> caring about online reviews

found the idiot

>>93979111
There's not defending the Titana scene, but the Asgardians turned against Odin because they realized Asgard was better off without him as the ruler of Asgard and they were mostly right especially since he threw a huge hissy fit that left his wife susceptible to being assassinated and he's a warmongering asshole who can't realize the fact that his brother Cul is a a terrible person to have as your right hand man because "MUH BLOOD FAMILY"

Seriously this book is actually really fucking good and people who can't get past Jane Foster as Thor are seriously missing out on a really fun and well written amazingly drawn book.

File: IMG_9733.jpg (25KB, 343x343px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 343x343px

>>93978893
When will we have another war so we can hunt down feminists and white knight faggots like dobson and use their heads as trophies and put their fingers onto necklaces?

>>93980937
>The All-Father
>Wrong
>(also a shitlord)
No I think I've heard enough to condemn this book already thanks

File: 29651176-Cartoon-Illustration-of-Funny-Tasmanian-Devil-Marsupial-Animal-Stock-Vector.jpg (143KB, 1300x815px) Image search: [Google]

143KB, 1300x815px

>>93979261
>>93979111
For fucks sake you guys really can't get over literally two pages in a series with dozens of issues at this point. Insecure faggots.

>Ghostbusters gets like 80%
>Every MCU movie breaks 90%+
>TFA best thing ever
>Every SJW comic best thing ever

Welcome to the world of dishonest critical review. These people exist in a bubble and push whatever they're expected to.

>>93980959
>The tripfag thinks he's better than other people

how quaint
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YgHNtzxO0y8

>>93980968
Without Odin as the All-Father they were able to establish the Council of the Nine Realms and get a fuck ton more done, it went from a Monarchy to an Oligarchy and worked out for the better and he threw a pissy fit over the fact that he's now been established as ruler past his use.

>>93980996
> in a series with dozens of issues at this point

Literally no one has bought or read those so how can we talk about them?

>>93981007
>>Every MCU movie breaks 90%+

I want Snyderfags to leave
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y_erAn0Y6Io

>>93981031
I've read them and they're pretty good for the most part.

>>93981031
Tons of people have read them, /co/ is just too autistic and insecure to openly talk about a good comic that has a good female protag that proves what insecure whiny little shits they're being.

>>93981019
What important issues is the council addressing that Odin has neglected for the last centuries? Legalizing gay marriage in Asgard?

File: Unbelievable_Gwenpool_Vol_1_3_Textless.jpg (617KB, 1264x1920px) Image search: [Google]

617KB, 1264x1920px

>>93981055
We have Gwenpool threads everyday.

>>93981066
Mending relations between the realms and getting past his bias for certain realms.

>Legalizing gay marriage in Asgard?

Christ you sound like an insecure little faggot. Who the fuck hurt you? How many women rejected you that you feel this insecure that a comic would trigger you this badly?

>>93981083
One sadsack avatarfagging and spamming the board on the same level as the pedoposters on /tv/ doesn't really count

>>93981104
(you)

>>93981114
Well boo fucking hoo princess, get over yourself.

>>93981104
You're the only one who is being insecure about the fact that most people don't ilke this shitty comic that you happen to like and then starts insulting people and projecting random shit onto them as your explanation why they don't like said comic.

>>93981142
I don't think he even likes the comic.

>>93981055
Defend this page. >>93979261

File: hitman004.jpg (42KB, 290x382px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 290x382px

>>93981104
>Christ you sound like an insecure little faggot. Who the fuck hurt you? How many women rejected you that you feel this insecure that a comic would trigger you this badly?

Imagine being this guy for just one day let alone his whole lifetime.

>>93978893
Nah its a pretty good series, i would give it a 4/5 though because while its a fun ride it has really only hit its stride in the past year. Plus the few cringe choices toward the beginning.

>>93981174
It one page three years ago that was part of a cold open that has no bearing even on the story it appears in.

Basically its so unimportant that the only reason anyone even remembers it is for threads like thi.

File: 1500085653114.jpg (575KB, 1200x1542px) Image search: [Google]

575KB, 1200x1542px

>>93979261

>>93980937
>Seriously this book is actually really fucking good and people who can't get past Jane Foster as Thor are seriously missing out on a really fun and well written amazingly drawn book.

Let's not get ahead of ourselves. It's average at best saved by the artwork.

>>93978893
Yet, theyre going to kill her. What does it tell us?

>one bad page keeps getting posted from a full run
that says more about how good the run is than how bad it is

>>93982314
It mostly says that barely anyone read it.

>>93982359
except all the people who clearly do buy it and read it...? the numbers are literally out there for you to see

>>93982419
Marvel numbers are bunk, but that's not the point.
Saying "nobody read it" isn't fucking literal. It means the sales didn't meet expectations. It's a business. They changes Thor into a woman because they wanted more numbers. That didn't work so they'll try something else.

Insecure much? lmaoooooo

File: DAIm5Z7VoAAz8c5.jpg (74KB, 949x678px) Image search: [Google]

74KB, 949x678px

>>93978893
Yeah well it doesn't sell like a five star comic

>>93983066
It's almost like the majority of men are afraid of female characters, when really they should enjoy stories that are well written, beautiful and easy to wank off to.

>>93983086
Its almost as if the writing is shit, tripfag.

>>93983094
Nah, the writing is mostly fine

>>93983094
Are you implying people always flock to great writing?

>>93983086
How dare men not enjoy stories they SHOULD enjoy! How dare they!

>>93978893
Why is it bad? Just because it's a woman protagonist as Thor? Grow up, bitch.

File: 1497469133181.jpg (173KB, 1436x1080px) Image search: [Google]

173KB, 1436x1080px

>>93983217

>>93978893
>five stars!
>still we are selling this for half the price
>please, buy it
>someone gotta buy it

>>93983248
Well, if you put it like this, yeah, the very premise of a female Thor is stupid as shit because Thor is not a title but a name. It'd be like a guy taking over the mantel of Miss Marvel and starts calling himself Kamala.

>>93983258
It's half price because it's in a Comixology sale for best-selling collections. Do you do any research before you post?

It's not /co/ likes comics of similar quality.

>>93983111
Im implying the comic is garbage

>>93983086
Maybe people don't want to read a Thor comic that doesn't have Thor in it.

Didn't work in the nineties and it's not working now.

>>93983321
Accept it originally did work like that with Thor being the hero name of Donald Blake. And There have been times when other wielders were also called Thor. but I doubt you even know three things about Thor

>>93983334
>Do you do any research before you post?
Thats asking way to much of a average /co/ fag

>>93983334
>Do you do any research before you post?
not on tumblr, apparently

>>93983425
no need to imply, its blatantly obvious to everyone that it is, indeed, TRASH
but hey, its five stars trash! gotta pay 4 bucks for it RIGHT NOW!

>>93983425
Must suck to not realize you have shit taste, I suspect it an "Emperors New Clothes" sort of feeling

>>93983448
>Accept

That's gonna haunt me

>>93983468
You speak like you're from a different site.

>>93980937
>>93981019
So how is turning Odin, the guy that made a magical deal to gain great wisdom and who sacrificed himself to seal off some kinda apocalyptic evil TWICE, into a huge baby bitching about not being the absolute monarch of everything and doing things solely because fuck you, considered good writing?

>>93983471
Oh wow, the dude reading a comic about Whor is judging MY taste.

>>93982603
>>93983086
I see you are trying to become /co/'s very own Virt.
Godspeed.

>>93978893
Its 3 stars... 4 at its best, but only if you ignoe some bullshit. 5 star? No way it is without lowering the bar.

>>93979168
He can't because he didn't read it and just wants to cry feminism. I didn't read it either, I just like watching and fueling arguments. And just for the record, the last comic I read was Beauty last week.

File: 1500316189148.jpg (446KB, 843x1034px) Image search: [Google]

446KB, 843x1034px

>>93983648

>>93983556
and you like you re from a different reality

>>93980937
Sorry, senpai. Not gonna read it today. Not gonna read it tomorrow. No amount of your shilling is going to get me to do it. Just be happy with the .0001 you're making from Disney per post and leave it at that.

>>93984123
I sometimes wonder if I sounded as retarded as you. If I did, I'm sorry /co/.

>>93984180
you ahve been sounding much more retarded this whole thread.
not sure why, if you are getting paid to sell a shit sjw comic, if you are a sjw moron who never read a comic, if you are just a troll...
endless possibilities

>>93980937
Let Big Bang Theory have Sheldon make a nigger joke, without making a big deal out of it, and see how long the normies would continue to back the biggest show on TV.

One major misstep can and should make something "good" now "shit". I fully believe that.

I happen to disagree with Rooney on Whor if you aren't blindly REEing about it two years on like the rest of us.

But anyone bitching about Rooney being a tripfag is laughably new.

>>93979006
The whole shit is about Jane

>>93984481
nobody gives a shit about namefags on 4chan, this aint tumblr, you not famous for posting here
also
(you)

>>93982448
>Marvel numbers are bunk
>they don't count when I want them not to count
lmao

>>93978893
>my dudes

Oh, it's you. You are an insufferable shithead after all.

Always figured you were.

>>93984641
What? Sales figures are units sold to comic shops, not what the people are actually buying. Marvel has recently been notorious for sending way more than stores order to inflate their sales numbers.

>>93978893
Wait, Odin is a warmonger now? What did I miss?

>>93984628
>Thinks he tells me something I don't know
>calls it a namefag
>Acts like REEing about tripfags makes him cool
>Gives a (you) as if my comment was bait

Seriously though, did you start posting here yesterday?

>>93978893
Nah, only Marvel. And it's a good fucking riddance.

>>93984836
(you)

>>93984757
>notorious for sending way more to shops
>yeah lets just keep losing money printing out this stuff that no one buys
so now its a conspiracy huh? theres just nooooo way ANYONE AT ALL is buying this comic, nope.

Marvel is actually doing much more poorly than DC. Even though they make more per unit and ship out more.

>b-but they just have more this month, next month DC will beat them
that people say every month lmao

>>93980937

So what you're saying is, they character-assassinated Odin in order to justify the plot of the book? Sounds like pure trash.

>>93984877
it's almost as if marvel has an agenda and a source of income other than their comics

>>93984912
He's just shitposting. Stop.

>>93984877
marvel threats to black list shops who don't order their stuff, calling them racist and misogynist.
ask your retailer

>>93979261
I can write better than this hamfisted trash

>We're not about to fight some no-name wearing Thor's helmet. I'll give you one chance to stay the hell out of our way, unless you want to take His place.
>I am Thor in all but name
>I'm willing to bet you'll go down much easier than the Asguardian
>Thine wager begets that of a fool

File: squirrel_girl_kevin_biegel_inset.jpg (58KB, 768x433px) Image search: [Google]

58KB, 768x433px

>>93978893
Marvel is fuckin DONE!! look at that ART OMG.and the story is worst.
>https://twitter.com/DiversityAndCmx?lang=en
>https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCrlzSqLSGj8GIOeT5jrQsJA

Check Links For more info

File: 1500319220459.png (8KB, 259x194px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 259x194px

>>93984897
actually, this whole thread
I pity you marvel fags, don't drag DC on your shit

This shitposting is boring. What's a good guide to give a mate for Thor?

>Thor: The Mighty Avenger / Thor: First Thunder
>Walt Simonson Thor
>Romita JR Thor
>JMS Thor
>Beta: Godhunter
>Fraction Thor
>Gillen JIM
>Aaron Thor

>>93984836
Where have you been all my life?

>>93985050
(you)

File: 1497243125396.jpg (25KB, 320x304px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 320x304px

>>93985069

>>93985112(You)
(you)

>>93984767
Nothing worth reading.

>>93981722
Cool. I was looking for this pic.

>>93985050
Defending BvS for a year and a half. Before that likely touching myself.

>>93981174
No writer gets a pass. Especially when they bend over backwards to please SJW. The compromised the integrity of their work to shovel shit into the readers mouth. You don't see people giving Bendis a pass because some of his Spider-Man stories are absolute garbage. And we're not going to give this guy a pass because he showed us exactly what his priorities were.

>>93981174
Sorry, meant to respond to
>>93981643

>>93985648
Are you me?

>>93984911
Sound like your average cape comic...

>>93982419
Then, either none came on /co/ or it's so average no other page stick out.

Aaron/Dautermann Thor > Aaron/Ribic Thor

>>93983086
>enjoy stories that are well written
It's written by Aaron, the guy who's praised for the God Butcher even though it became mediocre past the middle of the story.

I have my doubt about well written.

>>93986388
How can you be taken seriously once you've confessed that you liked BvS?

>>93986388
No, but I've been in threads making the same points for a while now lol.

>>93988085
>How can you be taken seriously once you've confessed that you liked BvS?
Thats some nice Original recipe shitposting you got there anon. Anything extra crispy for those of us with taste?

File: edgy.png (167KB, 338x425px) Image search: [Google]

167KB, 338x425px

Yeah this never ever happens in the opposite direction.

>>93981722

Any more of these?

>>93979261
Has there ever been another scene so bad that an entire comics run was permanently tarnished by it?

>>93989989
"A Y chromosome."

>>93978893
Manipulated ratings. I'm just amazed she was still allowed to be white.

>>93990061
If you're refering to what I'm thinking about, that was an entire issue, not one scene.

>>93988692
Added to my wishlist :^)

>>93990067
You haven't heard of the new Muslim Asgardian? Hoo boy.

File: Thisiswhathappenswhenyouhiretumblr.jpg (74KB, 600x555px) Image search: [Google]

74KB, 600x555px

>>93989989

I was about to mention the Wonder Woman mansplaining thing but that entire run was a Mary-Sue/SJW disaster all around. I wonder if the Storytime of Pain has ever shared it here.
My favorite:

>Wonder Woman goes to Gotham City, beats Batman villains, spares female Batman villains because feminist solidarity and basically does everything better than Batman.

>>93989989
Mockingbird's. I don't have the pages, but the comic was at least decent before it

>>93988567
>taste
It's not even about taste.
If you give me a charred cake to eat, don't talk about the taste police when I say it's shit.

>>93990820
>Take three hours to come up with a garbage response.

I asked for Extra Crispy not soggy wedges you fucking faggot.

>>93990157
>Muslim Asgardian

wat?

>>93979261
You know what triggers me worst?

How blatantly out of character this is for titania

>>93992694
Shhh dont say that. Some Aarons defender will be along to say "you never cared about her before so what does it matter"

>>93979006
If she hooks up with Jane, all is forgiven.

It's got a fem moment here or there


But you know actually reading Aaron's Thor run would surprise many of you.

That's giving the fact that you guys actually read what you are bitching about past a page or assorted screenshots

>>93992758
>you didn't like it so you didn't read it

I have a faggot in the Batman ST thread telling me the same thing. And I have three copies of almost every issue.

Funny how assumptions work.

>>93992736
I love arrons old work any one who defends this shit is no true fan.

>>93988692
Remind me why this is bad again.

File: Thor Name.png (2MB, 750x1024px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 750x1024px

>>93979261
Here's the page that Aaran uses to justify why she is called Thor but the real Thor can't use his first name.

>>93980996
>>93981055
>furfags got shit taste
No wonder you fags spend all your money on tweening comissions