What was the fourth flavor?

>>93386757
I always it was New York Cheesecake or something

Butterscotch.

>>93386757
The power of friendship.

>>93386771
>NY Cheesecake

That sounds good.

peepee poopoo

Some sweet pecan butterscotch caramel flavor, perhaps.

>>93386757
lemon

>>93386757
According to numbuh zero, it's close to blurpleberry

File: Blurpleberry_Supreme_Profile_-_KND.jpg (72KB, 628x470px) Image search: [Google]

72KB, 628x470px

>>93386855
I literally couldn't comprehend something like this being edible when I was younger

File: ringpops.jpg (97KB, 500x289px) Image search: [Google]

97KB, 500x289px

>>93386885
I just thought it was something like these

>>93386845
fuck you

>>93386816
It is good

Gooseberry

Lucuma

>>93386757
Lemon or banana.

>>93386757
Salted caramel.

>>93386757
Honey.

Nogatongamegalosomanjarchafafrinilofo

>>93386757
Probably banana. A specific ingredient that mimics authentic banana flavoring really was lost to history after huungry bugs drove the plant it grew on to extinction. That's why most banana flavoring tastes like shit, and that's probably what they were referencing. Plus, it's yellow.

>>93387210
Artificial banana flavor is godly how dare you.

>>93387261
Artificial banana flavor is literally the worst flavor on everything they stick it on and always has been.

IT'S MANGO YOU FUCKS

MANGO FLAVOR IS BEST FLAVOR

File: 1497859435979.jpg (10KB, 236x213px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 236x213px

>>93387295
>mango ice cream

Real talk if we're talking about fundamental flavors of ice cream, you have vanilla, chocolate in some form including chocolate chip or mint chocolate, fruit (usually strawberry) and then probably cookie dough.

>>93387352
IT'S GLORIOUS AND I WILL HEAR NO ILL TOWARDS IT

>>93387352
>not liking mango
What kind of monster are you?

>>93387285
That's a weird way to say Green Apple, anon>>93387295

>>93387737
Youd have to be the biggest faggot on the face of the earth to not like Sour Green Apple

>>93386757
caramel

>>93387210
artificial banana flavor is actually much closer to the extinct banana than it is to current cultivars.

>>93386757
Lemon

>>93387210
>>93387261
>>93387285
>>93387737
>>93387940
Artificial strawberry. It literally tastes NOTHING like strawberries.

File: 1491683221634.png (204KB, 356x276px) Image search: [Google]

204KB, 356x276px

>>93388127

>>93386757
Yellow.

>>93388163
It is very sweet though, and has a warm flavor. It is everything I want from strawberry candy.
And yet I hate strawberry Icecream. None of the sweetness, none of the warmth.

>>93386757
Roach.

>>93386757
Coffee.
It was coffee flavored ice cream.

Semen

It SHOULD have been Orange Creamsicle.

Why can't I find any fucking Orance Creamsicle Breyer's anymore did they stop making it?

>>93387352
Best ice cream I ever had was mango. It's one of those things that sounds awful on paper, but actually works.

>>93388326
>It's one of those things that sounds awful on paper
How is fruit + cream ever bad?

>>93386855
This is the canonical answer... I always thought blurpleberry was like blue raspberry or something. Wouldn't exactly fit the yellow color though

>>93386757
It was coffee flavored aka the best flavor of ice cream
However is considered taboo to kids because they associate the flavor with adulthood so it is pretty much the forbidden fruit of ice cream

>>93386885
it's rock candy anon....have you never had a Jolly Rancher?

>>93386757
I always goddamn hated the flavor of strawberry. It's heresy that it's the third flavor. Clearly the third-flavor is chocolate chip mint.

How can every single one of you be this wrong?

Its fucking butterscotch.

>>93389181
that's 2 flavors you idiot

>>93389034
Coffee is an okay flavor personally,but this one makes the most sense

>>93386757
Jimmies.

The Delightful Kids from Down the Lane didn't just commit the cardinal sin of "putting something on good ice cream", they corrupted a good flavor with a diluted farce. It was like squirting a dollop of off-brand chocolate sauce into a pint of chocolate Haagen-Dazs.

>>93389381
But wouldn't sprinkles-flavored ice cream just taste chalky and sweet?

>all these people not saying Salted Caramel

File: 32642193442_91f09d5a4d_z.jpg (73KB, 524x640px) Image search: [Google]

73KB, 524x640px

>>93389525
Dummy.

File: BA3EA347-C538-4768-8081-DAC8998A8FB8-7009-0000053B0EDAC374.png (700KB, 910x915px) Image search: [Google]

700KB, 910x915px

Vanilla > Strawberry > Chocolate >>>>>> Neopolitan

File: 1457124040486-2.jpg (40KB, 691x480px) Image search: [Google]

40KB, 691x480px

>>93389596
Blue Moon conquers all of them. Deal with it.

>>93386757
Grand Berry

File: 1488897800370.jpg (192KB, 864x860px) Image search: [Google]

192KB, 864x860px

>>93386757

>>93386757
Victory

>>93387210
yeah I'm pretty sure it's Banana too, although Pineapple is also a possibility

>>93386757
Butterscotch

>>93389962
Butter up your anus

>>93386757
I always thought it was whatever your favorite flavor was. Like ambrosia from Percy Jackson.

>>93388266
holy fuck, and people say there is no such thing as bad taste.

File: tumblr_inline_nxmi4aiabE1qhy6fn_500.gif (1MB, 400x166px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 400x166px

Like pussy, my son

Chirimoya alegre

>>93386757
marmalade

Lemon. Best ice cream.

I think sprinkles are okay on icecream.
Why was it so terrible when they added it?

Durian

>>93391110
because you're not supposed to put ANYTHING on good ice cream. that would include shit like chocolate or whipped cream. the problem wasn't the specifically the sprinkles, it was that they were arrogant enough to try to improve upon perfection

maracuya

>>93386757
It's Vanilla.
Someone just had a wee :^)

>>93388285
I always thought it was Coffee flavor when I was little. Mostly because coffee was my favorite flavor back then and the color reminded me of it.

>>93386757
based on the color either cheesecake, butterscotch, lemon or banana

lucuma.

>>93386757
A fruity sherbet of some kind. Like the pinnacle of berry-sherbet flavoring

It's also supposed to be very close to familiarity

If i remember right, Numbah 5 had instant recognition and was just about say what it tasted 'just like' before the show ended

It's corn

>>93386757
Where was this from again?

>>93392107
fucking die

>>93386757
It was blurpleberry

>>93389611
This. All other flavors are imitating something better, blue moon is pure.

>>93386757
Mango

>>93386757
piss

>>93386757
Loli pee

>>93390579
I'd eat it.

File: huhbird.jpg (41KB, 960x600px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 960x600px

am I the only person browsing past this picture and coulda sworn it was some heft dark skinned woman in a dress and stockings bending over?

File: Golden-Berries.jpg (27KB, 637x422px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 637x422px

>>93386757
Goldenberry. It's similar to bluepleberry, and is gold in color.

>>93386885
Remember people, share your candy. Candy taken in greed will ALWAYS taste sour.

>>93393082
I think you might need some help man

>>93386777
This.

File: 1474861494546.jpg (57KB, 438x445px) Image search: [Google]

57KB, 438x445px

Honeycomb.

The BEST flavor.

>>93389596
It really is amazing how much more shit Neopolitan is compared to every other flavor.

>>93392264
>>93390579
>Fish flavored ice cream
This shit sounds like something a mexican came up with.

I always thought it was maple syrup. inb4 >leaf

File: crying_1.gif (500KB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]

500KB, 500x281px

>>93393827
>Visit Ireland
>Have a brief moment of sobriety
>Go to ice cream parlor
>Order Honeycome Fizzbombs
>Cry silently for the next 3 months after returning because they will never understand
>No one will ever understand

>>93386757
it's the genie from aladdin

>>93386885
I wanted to get a taste of that thing so fucking badly when I was a kid

Cunt.

Lemon

>All these pleb favors

It was either sea-salt caramel or mango, although based on the colorization I'm leaning towards mango.

>>93386757
I always thought it was mango.

>>93386757
Probably whatever this was:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=opNQ0lJv7tQ

File: 1378177686128.gif (1008KB, 400x229px) Image search: [Google]

1008KB, 400x229px

>>93388061
The Gros Michel is not extinct...

>>93391236
>because you're not supposed to put ANYTHING on good ice cream. that would include shit like chocolate or whipped cream. the problem wasn't the specifically the sprinkles, it was that they were arrogant enough to try to improve upon perfection
well that and Sprinkles are incredibly low tier among Ice Cream toppings

File: stickybeard.jpg (233KB, 1024x768px) Image search: [Google]

233KB, 1024x768px

>>93386757
Skunky Scout candy

>>93386777
Trips confirmed

>>93393840
lol virgin

>>93386757
piss

File: 1463286005218.jpg (83KB, 480x679px) Image search: [Google]

83KB, 480x679px

>>93387352
BACK! BACK!
BACK TO HELL YOU GO DEMON!

File: aye.jpg (263KB, 860x558px) Image search: [Google]

263KB, 860x558px

>>93386757
Bitch
Nigga

Apple Cider flavor created from the finest selection of Golden Apples in the entire world.

Yeup, like melted gold.

File: Honeycomb.jpg (12KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 480x360px

>>93397352

>>93397593
Haha dude that was really fucking funny how you replied to every post in the thread with a jojo reference.

>>93397939
Jesus, what a faggot.

>>93386816
>That sounds good.

As someone who mostly buys Ben & Jerry's Strawberry Cheaskake flavor, I can attest to that a NY Cheesecake flavor ice cream would be godly.

>>93386757
De nanche

>>93387210
I like this theory the most so far, thanks anon.

>>93386757
Iranian ice cream. It's yellow and taste like flowers

>>93389547
I actually saw some fried twinkies in the frozen section at kroger, the other day. This fucking country, man.

File: three.jpg (162KB, 1280x960px) Image search: [Google]

162KB, 1280x960px

Just going to throw this out there why it's 100% this flavor.

What goes into an icecream Sunday?
VANILLA icecream
STRAWBERRY icecream and occasionally just the fruit
CHOCOLATE icecream and syrup

and... walnuts

>>93387210

It's not actually extinct!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gros_Michel_banana#Continued_use

It came close, but it's still out there and gradually making a commercial comeback. I'm pretty curious to try one at some point in my life. I don't live too far from Seattle. I should make a day of it.

File: ButterScotch's Wat Reaction.png (97KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

97KB, 1920x1080px

>>93386777

>>93387617
Mango flavored hookah will ruin mango for you forever dont do it

>>93400180
The only mango ice cream I've ever had was the kind with actual mango bits in it.

>>93389181
Sweetie.

Do you know what's in the fucking flavor you suggested.

COULD IT BE FUCKING CHOCOLATE?!