How would you rate Genndy as a writer for cartoons?

>>92649709
10/10.

Even if he makes mistakes, more often than not just with clever ideas he elevates the medium, he is always doing something that feels interesting and different without being really too weird for normies

>>92649709
He's a better storyboarder and director than a writer.

>>92649709
9/10

>>92649771
>10/10 (perfect)
>makes mistakes

>>92649771
1/10

>>92649709
Eh, a 6 or 7.

>>92650096
>>10/10 (perfect)
>>makes mistakes

everybody makes mistakes so you can't takes way from him points for something that every single animator suffers from.

>>92649709
8/10

7/10.
He's more of a style over substance kind of guy but god damn does he have style. His talent is from getting very basic idea's and somehow elevating them to something interesting and almost feel fresh, even when in reality their not.

That said we've never really seen him write something truly substantial, even Samurai Jack season finale, while decent, had an awkward pace that felt more like he was just trying the get the whole show over with as quickly as possible.

>>92649709
When he's doing good work it's absolutely fantastic

>>92649709
Pretty damn bad, don't listen to these fuckers. Samurai Jack only worked because it was episodic and the priority entertainment was the animation, visuals, tone, and fight scenes/choreography. The problems were obvious with Season 5's story arc format.

>>92649709
George Lucas/10