Redesign Thread

>>89790834
Shit
>>89790874
meh
>>89790888
groovy
>>89790906
shit
>>89790907
but is it art?
>>89790926
shit
>>89790945
shit
>>89790993
neat
>>89791045
ok
>>89791103
nice
>>89791128
shit
>>89791160
nothing special
>>89791193
meh
>>89791204
pretty good
>>89791206
passable
>>89791248
ok
>>89791316
gay

>>89791349
>OP's
>Shit
You're shit

>>89791349
No one cares, faggot.

>>89791103
NEEDS LESS CLOTHING

>>89791379
Your taste a shit.
>>89791385
You cared enough to respond.

So are these Spidey redesigns meant for Peter or some other Spidey?

>>89791371
>top right
kek

>>89791390
Starro?

>>89791527
>let me put as many sketch lines all over my drawing
>it's "stylish"
Disgusting.

>>89791349
Shit
>>89791349
Shit
>>89791349
Shit
>>89791349
Shit
>>89791349
Shit
>>89791349
Nothing special
>>89791349
Shit
>>89791349
Meh
>>89791349
Shit
>>89791349
Shit
>>89791349
Shit
>>89791349
Shit
>>89791349
Gay

File: 1484565701701.jpg (359KB, 896x1001px) Image search: [Google]

359KB, 896x1001px

>>89790834

>>89791553
huh, looks a bit like Michel Fiffe's style

>>89791572
Butthurt.

>>89791493
Could be pretty good with some red, at least the eyes.

>>89791645
My ass feels quite nice actually

>>89791667
Sure it does.

File: black_manta_by_comicfiction-d5jbhk0.jpg (81KB, 900x600px) Image search: [Google]

81KB, 900x600px

>>89791667
Can i feel it?

File: Spidey.jpg (398KB, 900x704px) Image search: [Google]

398KB, 900x704px

I think this looks better, it's more intimidating.

>>89791726
That looks even worse. Now he's got eyebrows.

>>89791349
>>89791572
When will you faggots stop posting like this

File: 1407533812812.jpg (84KB, 600x825px) Image search: [Google]

84KB, 600x825px

purple gloves make every batman design better

>>89791651
His face in the middle looks like a parent who's just discovered their son has made a mess of his study.

>>89791756
When will you faggots stop posting like this

>>89791748
I thought it looked like he had a spoopy mouth.

>>89791764
Is, is that supposed to be Darth Vader?

>>89791784
So now he looks like a muppet.

File: 1440165793456.jpg (266KB, 500x707px) Image search: [Google]

266KB, 500x707px

>/fit/ mode

>>89791806
>Implying Muppets aren't scary

>>89790834
i dont think the white works on him.

>>89791826
Prove to me that they are.

>>89791797
seems like it

>>89791857
>ring face-guard
lmao, is this faggot for real

File: Muppet.jpg (27KB, 149x162px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 149x162px

>>89791849

>>89791884
Holy shit, just... wow

File: 1444796731681.png (1MB, 1600x1172px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1600x1172px

sanic

File: 0e0ef5faba59944ca3d64a0047d350e6.jpg (21KB, 225x225px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 225x225px

>>89791857
kek

>>89791896
why are his eyes in his mouth?

>>89791921
>why are his eyes in his mouth?

Because he's a spooky, spoopy spidey.

>>89791955
I remember now, the most venomous spiders wear ascots.

>>89791977
They're also the fiercest killers in the insect kingdom.

Most of these designs suck anus hole.

>>89791997
Their mortal enemies are goblins.

File: Ghost Rider, Bullseye, Kingpin, Mandarin.jpg (338KB, 1535x500px) Image search: [Google]

338KB, 1535x500px

>>89792012
most redesigns do

>>89792012
Post your own if you're so great then.

>>89792087
Sword and board Casey Jones. Pretty shit desu

>>89792075
>hurr you can't criticize thing unless you are master at thing
Faggot.

>>89792120
I'm talking about the designs you like, dumbass. Post them if your taste is so superior.

>>89792157
I don't have any saved, knobgobbler.

>>89792193
Then look them up, cocksucker.

>>89792214
I'm looking them up in this thread. Fudgepacker.

>>89792124

This redesign seems really effeminate compared to original Galactus. Doesn't feel nearly as godlike or powerful.

>>89792238
Then quit your bitching since people here are doing your job for you, shit-for-brains.

>>89792328
The visor makes no fucking sense.

>>89792355
I can comment on any design I like without having to answer to you, fuckboy. That's what these threads are for. And if my opinions make you so ass ravaged then you should leave.

File: 3657984-7692422161-cloud.jpg (102KB, 600x1280px) Image search: [Google]

102KB, 600x1280px

>>89792349
This to your liking?

>>89790907
MediEvil?

>>89792422
Looks like a gay transformer.

>>89792328
>>89792377
He looks like he has a vagina for a face.

>>89792562
That's just a budget Deadpool with horns.

>>89792195
I love this! A sci-fi super spacesuit, that's awesome.

>>89791913
Sonic Skyline is a pretty good set of redesigns

>>89791857
MORTAL KOMBAT!!!

File: darkdevil_0.jpg (19KB, 196x300px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 196x300px

>>89792562
Uglier Darkdevil

>>89792815
Nice skirt wonderboy

99.9% of Superman and Spider-Man redesigns are shit
Fact

>>89790888
I think this could work as an Scarlet Spider suit with a bit more of red?

>>89792815
>>89792844
>>89792870
>>89792898
>>89792934
These suck so hard.

File: raven_and_starfire_redesign_rough_sketches_by_noflutter-d8lclru[1].jpg (151KB, 800x679px) Image search: [Google]

151KB, 800x679px

>>89790834

>>89792528
if he just had some storage thing on him for his fear toxin then it would be gucci

File: 6.jpg (202KB, 822x1200px) Image search: [Google]

202KB, 822x1200px

Wonder Luchadora

>>89793037
Looks like a Batman pastiche you'd see at Image.

File: 1474669786281.jpg (70KB, 774x1032px) Image search: [Google]

70KB, 774x1032px

I could see this being a teen version of shocker for the new MCU films

File: 1482113943243.jpg (90KB, 1200x643px) Image search: [Google]

90KB, 1200x643px

>>89793076
I still think its cool
>ywn see this deisgn in a series of older Dick and Older Bruce crime fighting in an even more darker future

>>89793102
More like the Shitter.

File: 1482112695490.jpg (54KB, 1000x1414px) Image search: [Google]

54KB, 1000x1414px

>>89793102
>Tyking everything in sight
MCU was a mistake

File: mysterio_color_06a.jpg (104KB, 1000x1600px) Image search: [Google]

104KB, 1000x1600px

>>89793113

>>89793147
Some please help this poor man find his neck. He can't even move.

>>89793147
>tyking everything
name a single thing that was tyked or was peter never in school

File: 1481549939804.jpg (330KB, 2000x1359px) Image search: [Google]

330KB, 2000x1359px

>>89793158

>>89791451
Thats some cool shit

File: 1435965817474.jpg (101KB, 755x1057px) Image search: [Google]

101KB, 755x1057px

>Justice League from Deep Space

>>89790926
eyes are interesting
>>89790945
low tier
>>89790993
why does manta have openings?
>>89791128
ed-209
>>89791194
neato
>>89791204
neato
>>89791248
meh
>>89791285
could work
>>89791316
disgusting
>>89791371
whats the fucking point?
>>89791390
shit
>>89791427
neat concept i guess
>>89791451
too tacticool, but i like the visor
>>89791493
literally whats the point?
>>89791527
what the fuck is suppose to be coming out of him?
>>89791553
wow thats fucking terrible.
>>89791576
Not godlike enough
>>89791615
pretty okay
>>89791703
interesting idea with the fin
>>89791757
good shit
>>89791782
alright
>>89791857
good lord no
>>89791931
Klaw is cool, rest sucks
>>89791962
Doctor Spectrum is fucking cool
>>89791996
Blizzard is cool, rest suck
>>89792053
Mandarin's dragon coat is neat, ghost rider is too
>>89792162
good
>>89792195
jesus christ wtf
>>89792218
lol
>>89792254
meh
>>89792266
alright
>>89792328
retarded visor
>>89792528
With the hat looks pretty cool
>>89792786
so the sash is just going over her titty?
>>89792815
oh jesus no
>>89792844
gross
>>89792870
wtf why?
>>89792898
terrible
>>89792934
fucker was too lazy to put in a logo?
>>89793021
pretty cool
>>89793037
eh
>>89793070
the cape is eh
>>89793102
literally every shocker redesign.
>>89793113
isnt this from shattered dimensions?
>>89793147
meh
>>89793150
dunno why Boon didnt go with this one
>>89793158
neato

File: Flash design3 copy.png (1MB, 3200x5376px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 3200x5376px

I posted a Flash design of mine in an earlier redesign thread and I thought I'd share this modification of it. In the Get-Down Netflix series, Grandmaster Flash wears a red and white tracksuit and I thought it'd be neat to apply that to the Flash himself.
I figure it'd be for Wally since he's wearing red and white right now.

>>89793325
Superman is literally from Deep Space already

>>89793446
Is he going to the local gay bar?

>>89793446
Is the faggoty intrusive watermark part of the costume?

>>89793431
deeper space

>>89793528
a bit spiky for my taste but I like the general idea and the halo

File: Saint-Laurent-Paris-black-leather-double-breasted-biker-jacket-3.jpg (161KB, 952x1030px) Image search: [Google]

161KB, 952x1030px

>>89792608
Double breasted jacket GR needs to be made great again

Robbie is cool and all but I hate that the head looks like a fucking mask from bleach.

Not a fan

>>89793113
>>89793158
>>89793208
With all the fucking Spider-man movies out there, how the fuck have Mysterio never been used as a villain?

>>89791434
That would've been better imo.

>>89793649
Yeah, right? He even worked for films.

>>89793671
I know right? He actually looks like a dragon
Larsen's design is more like, I don't know, the Savage Kraken or Finhead or something, not a dragon

>>89790907
Artist?

>>89790834
the motherfucker who drew this doesn't seem to care how webshooters work.

>>89792870
That would be a badass Zod.

>>89794008
making the penguin look exactly like a penguin kinda misses the point

>>89794117
Well, he likes penguins, doesn't he?

>>89790993
Hideous

>>89793446
I know it's a hood, but it looks like hair so I'm calling this guy Nathanos Explosion.

>>89790945
I'm a major sucker for digits, but the colour scheme isn't doing it for me
The hourglass over the face implies the black widow a little too much

It'd be good for an Assassin style Spider-man
Or maybe Kaine or something

>>89794180
>not wizard looking
Literally where's the point

>>89794251
I like it but it kinda just seems like a regular BB design

>>89793954
Toucan Man!

>>89794251
Would be neat without the armored parts and the old goggles.

>>89794479
the tattoos kinda look trashy/basic but I do like the idea of a inked up wanda

>>89794682
Needs more skulls.

>>89794666
Pretty retarded, Satan.

>>89793649
Because there's only been five Spider-Man movies and he has at least a dozen highly recognized villains in addition to Mysterio.

File: catwoman_and_nightwing_by_sketchmasterskillz-d4oyk3o.jpg (53KB, 600x590px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 600x590px

>>89794746
its a joke, moron

>>89794858
I thought jokes were supposed to be funny.

>>89793680
It looks like he has a pizza behind his head in the thumbnail.

>>89792608
Vertigo's Ghost Rider

>>89795210
THE AMBIGUOUSLY GAY DUO

>>89794888
I thought faggots were supposed to be shot in a nightclub

>>89791764

That's pretty boss.

>>89797047
I thought mommy didn't let you post in 4chan.

>>89792113
Better than his old look.

>>89791493
>generic tacticcol

Get fucked

>>89792724
Wiggy.

>>89794888
It's making fun of the original concept art. It went to great lengths to show how much more practical and effective some fancy biker leathers are over a state of the art supersuit.

>>89791493
I love tacticool designs, but this doesn't look anything like Manta. Looks more like concept art for an NPC in a shooter game.

>>89793649
because you work your way up to Mysterio, you don't just start with him.

>>89797411
also not particularly tacticool for a guy who fights underwater.

>>89797453
Name 10 good Mysterio stories

>>89797422
the thing i don't get about green lantern is, you have to make the bullets fire out of the gun using your own imagination, so why not just imagine bullets in mid flight instead?

>>89797523
He's a super hero, not a character from a Touhou game.

>>89797603
All of these designs with retarded visors/eye pieces can go fuck themselves.

>>89790834
What's the functionality of the scarf? Was he just chilly that day? Also fingertip webs are retarded

>>89794180
>Old Snake

>>89791349
it's a "anon thinks his opinion matters" episode

>>89798406
Giving an opinion on what I think is shit isn't equivalent to thinking it matters to anyone but myself, tard.

There is one absolute to any redesign thread, and that is any Superman or Spider Man redesign will instantly be labeled shit. Suffice to say I don't blame them for saying so; both are iconic designs that are adored for their simplicity.

File: 1493324-pan06uio.jpg (106KB, 640x1440px) Image search: [Google]

106KB, 640x1440px

>>89794682

Cant top this look.

>>89798406
>its an "anon gets mad because someone didn't like something he liked episode"

>>89798479
My only problem with Animal Man there is the colors. Too much orange and you're venturing into Aquaman territory what with the "A". Which I know his original look was sporting orange but personally I think this would look a whole lot better sticking with just blue/white. Other than that I think its good

>>89798610
Is that Captain Pause Button?

>>89793401
I dig it anon, try putting a circle around the the lightning bolt to make a pop a little better

File: Katana redesign.jpg (101KB, 600x777px) Image search: [Google]

101KB, 600x777px

This heres Katana, shes here to mow the lawn

File: 1480234516760.jpg (54KB, 824x772px) Image search: [Google]

54KB, 824x772px

>>89798923

File: 1480230640093.jpg (34KB, 500x750px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 500x750px

>>89798954

>>89799065
that looks terrible

File: 1484557001676.png (2MB, 1272x1958px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1272x1958px

>>89799046

>>89799065
Wow, that is spectacularly shitty.

File: 1480232895386.jpg (291KB, 1600x1498px) Image search: [Google]

291KB, 1600x1498px

>>89799101
This is the rest of
>>89799102

>>89799102
Admittedly, I never thought giving Cable wings would be a good idea, but it's certainly novel.

>>89799065
What the fuck is going on here? Nothing about this says X Men or Cyclops for that matter. For starters it seems like the artist completely forgot that his visor is basically the key thing to his costume and here its an afterthought.

>>89799183
I don't even know what the point of the cowl or the Batman ears is. And don't even get me started on the horse's ass.

File: 1471812901301.jpg (341KB, 1600x1091px) Image search: [Google]

341KB, 1600x1091px

>>89799166

File: 1471765994997.jpg (76KB, 615x950px) Image search: [Google]

76KB, 615x950px

>>89799289

>>89799289
kinda like this one

File: 1471759989209.jpg (350KB, 683x1000px) Image search: [Google]

350KB, 683x1000px

>>89799322

>>89799322
>>89799355
are these from an actual comic run?

>>89799252
Its busy, off color palette, and overall dogshit. Its like he binged watched some anime or something before drawing it
>>89799318
And holy fuck apparently this artist just has overall shit taste when it comes to redesigns
>Exposed skin
>Top heavy
>Gauntlets look cumbersome
>A loincloth?
>A FUCKING DIAPER
The ONLY credit I'll give the artist is the sickly feeling

>>89799387
No, but the second one is clearly evocative of the Jim Lee design.

>>89793037
Seems like an Incredibles hero

>>89791615
Looks like Diana and Starfire's lovechild.

File: iceman_redesign__by_comicbookguy54321-d7kabos.jpg (147KB, 1024x1448px) Image search: [Google]

147KB, 1024x1448px

>Bobby...

>>89799446
That freeze looks too exposed. Maybe if the suit had legs and sleeves, the outside suit look is fine.
He looks like he's barely able to stand up on his own let alone lug around the chest piece and gauntlets.

>>89799530
Well.....it certainly gay enough

>>89799530
>>89799632
hes missin a choker for that extra faggy look

>>89799652

Snek

>>89793685
>Spiderman movie with Mysterio
>Starts with Andrew Garfield/ASM doing Spidey stuff (audience is confused)
>"Cut!"
>Spidey Andrew takes off his mask and walks off set as it's revealed to be a movie filming, introducing us to Mysterio
Might be neat

>>89791996
What have they done to Namor?

>>89790834
Fingerwebs are dumb, but I like the rest.

>>89800549
There are simple designs, and just plain unfinished. Logan there looks like he could to morph into Harvey Birdman

>>89798610
Cap didn't use a gun I thought

>>89800763
Cap has no problem whatsoever using a firearm. The shield has just proven more useful at this point

>>89793037
That'd actually be perfect for Earth-3 Dick.

I'm curious for opinions on superhero costume designs, and designs that are in comics that are not superhero-related.

I know the norm for superheroes is to draw their outfit as if it is skin-tight, like they are nude and just painted over to show off musculature. But would it bother you if there was a noticeable change in such a detail? For example, if the linework allowed for more subtle details, like seams, more padding, more girth, less showing of the abs, more colors/fabric/textures, etc. I guess what I'm saying is: is there a line to where tacticool is acceptable, or would most of /co/ just stick with the usual bold contours?

Also, let's say there's a design in a comic you like that's not superhero-related, but the design would look like it's painted on as if it were. Would that bother anyone personally? Is it just a sort of taboo that stays in the cape world?

>>89795210
Iron Wing? Night Fist?

>>89800903
>I know the norm for superheroes is to draw their outfit as if it is skin-tight, like they are nude and just painted over to show off musculature
It's a retarded norm made up because artists used to be lazy. Yes, I'm talking about the likes of Neal Adams and George Perez when I say this, wonderful artists otherwise but goddamn were they lazy with their superhero drawings. At least Jack Kirby didn't draw them like they were naked.

File: tumblr_m57epqiAnJ1qc9wc7.jpg (109KB, 494x750px) Image search: [Google]

109KB, 494x750px

This thread is too boring, let's liven things up a little!

>The Premise - I wanted to make an X-Men reboot that plays to the strength of the concepts, namely growing up as a teenager, dealing with those who are different and how to deal with those who hate you. The primary change in my setting is that the mutations have a clear sci-fi foundation rather than just being random superpowers. Mutants being “the next stage in human evolution” was biologically dubious in the 60s, and now it’s just corny. Additionally, I think the X-Men premise only really makes sense in a setting without other superheroes. With that in mind, here’s my pitch…

>THE SETTING
>Thousands of years ago, godlike alien beings known as Celestials came to Earth to secretly experiment on the human race. Their goal was to use homo sapiens as a genetic template to revive long-dead civilizations and species throughout the universe. However, their initial tests proved inconclusive, and the project was abandoned. What was unknown at the time was that the original “program” developed by the Celestials had spread and embedded itself onto the DNA of countless human beings and continued to be passed down through the generations, dormant.

>The story begins in the near future, where in the past few years this “x-gene” begins to activate, creating outrageous mutations and causing a general panic in society. While no one is sure what is causing the mutations, it’s clear that the power in human society may quickly shift if something isn’t done. Most mutants go into hiding or destroy themselves when they are unable to control what is happening to them. A few, however, are taken in by a handful of more knowledgable mutants like Charles Xavier.

File: tumblr_m57fbcdit31qc9wc7.jpg (99KB, 494x750px) Image search: [Google]

99KB, 494x750px

He literally says his Colossus should be "Eurotrash"

File: tumblr_m57ikwdLSt1qc9wc7.jpg (80KB, 494x750px) Image search: [Google]

80KB, 494x750px

Funnily enough, he doesn't comment on why the Sentinels look like Inspector goddamn Gadget

>>89800549

Make the whites yellow on Cyke and at least give him a belt and it could work.

Wolvie just looks like the artist gave up.

File: tumblr_m57nuq59ce1qc9wc7.jpg (81KB, 494x750px) Image search: [Google]

81KB, 494x750px

>m-muh waifu doesn't get any deforming mutations tho!!!

>>89801048
*gay eurotrash
Gotta force that in there too buddy

File: tumblr_m57q7pBQlV1qc9wc7.jpg (92KB, 494x750px) Image search: [Google]

92KB, 494x750px

Apparently Colossus wants to be Superman

>>89790834
Why the anime scarf?

File: tumblr_m580zoev7n1qc9wc7.jpg (90KB, 494x750px) Image search: [Google]

90KB, 494x750px

He pretty much just gave up on Beast and Toad

File: tumblr_m58109GtKK1qc9wc7.jpg (94KB, 494x750px) Image search: [Google]

94KB, 494x750px

He hand is supposed to be Juggernaut's btw, he's openly ripping off Shadow of the Colossus here

>>89801144
He's big in Japan. Like that one song.

File: justiceleague.jpg (638KB, 1200x1229px) Image search: [Google]

638KB, 1200x1229px

And just for shits and giggles let's post his DC redesigns too

File: doom.jpg (237KB, 900x664px) Image search: [Google]

237KB, 900x664px

The old lady is supposed to be Parasite. Yeah
And yes, that is the Huntress

>>89799065
>Genji is with you

File: batfamily.jpg (418KB, 1277x1000px) Image search: [Google]

418KB, 1277x1000px

And finally his Bat-family designs, which are actually semi-decent compared to the rest

>>89801201
>Cyborg
Ugh, I hate Diaz's dapper/steampunk bullshit aesthetic.

>>89801063

Magneto and Xavier are both reasonable, but not exactly inspired. I enjoy the Inspector Gadget Sentinel, but it kind of suggests a lighter story tone which I don't think he's going for.

>>89801084

I kind of get what he's going for with Nightcrawler, but I really don't like where it ends up. Logan is pretty whatever, I don't like the way his arm hair's drawn. Emma Frost is being overly literal.

>>89801103

I actually like Rogue's design, but she's an odd pick for giving bestial features. Storm is too clearly designed around that specific hairstyle, and it isn't even actually interesting once you look at it. I think defaulting to face-lines is lazy, but I like the costume and I think the talon hands are a kind of neat idea. Kitty Pride is a complete non-design because muh waifu.

>>89801128

Overly literal cyclops, boo. I like Colossus' appearance as a human, but god dammit that leotard is awful. I can forgive the face lines on Archangel because that's deliberately tying him in to Apocalypse's design, but it's pretty yawn-inducing on the whole.

>>89801153

These are all complete non-designs, what the hell. You didn't even try on Beast and Toad!

>>89801128
>>89801103
>>89801063
>>89801048
fucking shit
kurt wa almost decent tho

>>89801669
You do know Emma can turn into diamond right?

>>89801171
>>89801201
>>89801231
I think Apocalypse, Wonder Woman, and (I think that's Livewire?) are actually decent. Not for any cohesive comic series' but as stand alone redesigns.

Actually, looking at them again Apocalypse doesn't make any sense for what he's supposed to be and Livewire's the only one I still agree with because she looks like an actual comic book character.
The rest have no effort put in whatsoever.

>>89791493
Streamline the bodysuit a bit, give him his standard glowing red eyes and you got yourself a nice Black Manta for Aquaman or for Metal Gear Solid.

>>89791962
Doc Spectrum looks pretty cool.

File: image.png (234KB, 777x992px) Image search: [Google]

234KB, 777x992px

>>89791204
I actually really like this

>>89795210
>>89800906
Deadman

File: steampunk static.jpg (252KB, 850x1100px) Image search: [Google]

252KB, 850x1100px

Normally not too fond of steampunk designs, but this one is shockingly nice.

>>89791726
He looks like candleja

>>89794858
If I wanted a joke I'd ask for your one rep max

>>89803802

No, dumbass. He doesn't come when you START saying 'Candlejack'. He o

>>89803802
You ruined the joke. First of all, you've gotta say the fill name. Second, who would enter your comment? I doubt Candlejack would be nice eno

>>89791316
>giving cyborg hair
When will people learn that this is a shit idea?

Why are there never original Iron Man designs? Is it because he changes outfits so often already anyway?