why?

One of them isn't an edgy palette swap of a pre-existing character.

>>89370396
Funnily enough those character traits aren't very endearing when applied to a mickey-mouse looking cartoon hedgehog.

>>89370396
if you cant understand the difference then theres no helping you

File: Wolverine_Vol_1_1.jpg (65KB, 400x617px) Image search: [Google]

65KB, 400x617px

>>89370396
>>both cant smile
u wot m8

>>89370396
>Shadow
>most hated sonic character
There are literally dozens of characters in Sonic that people hate more than Shadow.

>>89370396
Shadow does have memories though and it was revealed in literally his second game appearance that the SA2 shadow died and the current iteration is a duplicate

>>89370396
Most hated Sonic character? Shadow is the second most popular character behind Sonic himself.
Sonic fans hate Shadow the Hedgehog THE GAME, not the character.

>>89370551
That would be Dakken.

>>89371077
And you see how popular he turned out to be.

>>89372242
Let's hope that turd stays flushed.

>>89371040
>Shadow does have memories though and it was revealed in literally his second game appearance that the SA2 shadow died and the current iteration is a duplicate
2nd part is false. Wait long enough in the final boss of Shadow and it's revealed that Shadow never actually died and it's been the real one all along
>>89370396
>Shadow
>Most hated
Reminder that Shadow wasn't supposed to be in Boom originally and he only got in due to sheer fan demand

Because one of them fits into their universe a hell of a lot better than the other