So how you prefer Red Sonja? With or without the Oath of Chastity?

I don't really give a shit, it's all about the writing. I can see why it has its storytelling merits but I also see why some people find it outdated. I just don't like how Simone writes her.

>>88567069
Yes Simone's eternally horny Sonja, was a bit too much. Especially when she wanted to fuck every loser that she met in her path.

With the oath, but not so retarded.

When Red Sonja only fucks the guys that can best her in sword play, i see her as a baddass and confident woman that live and die for her skills with the blade. She places all of herself on her skill.

When Red Sonja fucks everyone and constantly pay for orgies when she has a bit of cold coins, i see her as an insecure and depressed woman that base her entire worth on her looks and that desperately fucks always her issues in an attempt to gain a regain a bit of self-worth, security and affection.

Sluts and manwhores are depressing people.

>>88567255
How about a middle ground? It doesn't have to be so extreme.

>>88566984
Without
I think its dumb for a hero to lose her skills if she sucks some dick

>>88567526

It didn't wok like that. She had to be bested to have sex.

>>88567255
>Sluts and manwhores

Wouldn't Conan fit this description anyway?

File: 24.jpg (529KB, 1041x1600px) Image search: [Google]

529KB, 1041x1600px

>>88567255
I remember the paid orgies part. I still cringe when i look at this page.

>>88567637

Conan IS a depressed guy. He constantly feel a "great melancholy" even when partying hard.

>>88567743
I think that probably has more to do with all of the brutality and bloodshed he's seen/taken part in, as well as the overall grimness of his world.

>>88567800

Nah. He's usually in his element when he's in the middle of the carnage using his instincts or when he's with a rare friend in the wildness just chatting. What gets him depressed are big cities and the times he's feeling utterly lonely. So he go, drink, party, fuck, but that never helps. Afterwards he feels even shittier.

>>88567865
i still don't know if I would attribute that specifically to sex.

>>88566984
With.

Every story I've read where she didn't have it (admittedly, not a lot), she made a big fucking deal about how she could fuck anyone and everyone she wanted. It's like writers want to write a more sexed up version of Conan.

>>88567255
>When Red Sonja fucks everyone and constantly pay for orgies when she has a bit of cold coins, i see her as an insecure and depressed woman that base her entire worth on her looks and that desperately fucks always her issues in an attempt to gain a regain a bit of self-worth, security and affection.
OR MAYBE SHE JUST LIKES FUCKING SEX!

>>88567638
This

>>88566984
we had this discuss acouple of weeks ago.
turboslut red sonja>chaste monk red sonja but not by alot.
ultimately it comes down to the arc and while I am williing to give this red sonja a little rope im not confident.

>>88566984
so they fuck?

>>88570112
Nope the cook rejected her, because Sonja's stink.

>>88569283
Ah, a sane comment!

>>88567069
This. They both have their merits in my opinion.

>>88567637
Conan is a textbook example of great rages and joy followed by massive melancholies and depression.

>>88566984
WITH.

>>88566984
With is the whole point. Without is gay.

>>88566984
>last panel
>COCK GOES IN HERE

"She may only have sex with someone who defeats her" doesn't mean she HAS to have sex with that person if she doesn't want to. It's still entirely up to her.

>>88566984
That face in the last panel is about the biggest turn off ever.

Besides, riding a horse for 4 days would probably make you sore as hell.

>>88573423
From memory, she was always a bit loose with the oath. One guy, albeit a demigod of sorts, disarmed her by surprise, and she took that as an excuse to fuck him because he "beat" her.

File: red_sonja_by_mmcdart-d6lqp3k.jpg (200KB, 1024x1263px)

200KB, 1024x1263px

>>88566984
Obviously with her oath active, I need my waifu pure, pure.

>>88566984
That fucking face though

>>88574141
That means defeat in various cultures so it makes sense.

>>88566984
With. It's not really a vow of chastity, though. When Scathach offered her aid to Red Sonja, she warned her that this would set her down a road of bloodshed and violence. She would never cuddle with her lover tenderly on quiet nights. She would never feel new life growing inside her. She would never cradle a babe in her arms and nurse it from her breasts. Instead she would wade through bodies and blood her entire life, as an avatar of death instead of life.

This is what her vengeance would cost her. And she chose it anyway, because she's Red Fucking Sonja.

(Simone's Sonja is fine, but it's a bit telling that she though the shitty part of Sonja's oath was the "no sex" bit and never even noticed it also meant "no motherhood".)