Who is the most popular Robin?

>>88466585
Dick or Jason is the most popular and Tim or Damian is the least popular.

Who even asked for this story?

>>88466585
Among the casuals, Jason is the most popular with Dick behind him.

Among hardcore comic readers, Dick is the most popular with Jason behind him.

Can't tell who is the least popular popular between Tim and Damian.

Tim>Dick>Jason>Damien>Stephanie

>>88466669
I doubt that among hardcore comic readers Jason is more popular than Tim. No way.

>>88466669
>casuals
>giving 2 shits about Red Hood as Robin

Dick

Duke

>>88466721
>>88466743
People seemed to like Jason in the Arkham game and Dick and Tim were clearly the worst of the batfamily in the entire series.

>>88466749
He's not Robin.
>>88466776
Game is game but I replied about comics part.

>>88466721
He is. A lot of fans warmed up to him in the recent years while Tim lost fans.

>>88466833
Ah while Timfags have been destroyed and are alcoholics by now.

Dick for the most hardcore comic readers, Damian for the new ones.

>>88467340
>Damian for the new ones
They absolutely loath him. Dick fans are the ones who like Damian and they are old fans.

>>88466585
>porn war
what?

>>88466669
>Can't tell who is the least popular popular between Tim and Damian
Tim I think because supersons is making people slowly warm up to Damian.

>>88467474
War on who has the most porn made of them.

File: Super-Sons-by-Jim-Lee-DC-Comics-Rebirth-Jon-Kent-Superboy-and-Damian-Wayne-Robin.jpg (227KB, 928x1200px) Image search: [Google]

227KB, 928x1200px

Post best Robin

>>88466585
>Most popular
Dick

>Least Popular
Tim

>>88467553
None of them was the best Robin.

They all had good moments and bad moments that made them interesting and different from each other.

The true challenge though, is who can grow beyond being a robin? Dick and Jason did it, but I'm not sure if Tim and Damian can.

File: robinpornwar.jpg (392KB, 1408x552px) Image search: [Google]

392KB, 1408x552px

>>88467523

>>88466721
i've always preferred jason over tim. more interesting story overall. bruce is portrayed as a more loving and nurturing individual when jason was robin.

>>88467701
this tbqh senpai

>>88466669
This the correct answer.

>>88468114
Batman was great with Jason.

>>88468114
>>88468222
I'm really curious about this.

Was Batman really different with Jason? I assumed that Jason was one he liked the least.

>>88468291
Bruce was great before Starlin took over and DC made batman darker overall

>>88468291
It wasn't so much he was different with Jason, it was Bruce was a good individual until the mid-late 80s.
Starlin took over and he did NOT like Robin. Had Dick still been Robin, Starlin would've written the two of them poorly too.

Most flashbacks now pretty much have Bruce treating Dick and Jason like he does in more modern times. i.e. like shit

>>88468393
Except for some of Lobdell's flashbacks, with is nice, but woo boy some of those Dick flashbacks.
That entire annual by Tomasi and Nightwing YO were were a doozy.

>>88468291
>I assumed that Jason was one he liked the least
Why woud you even assume this? Batman mourned him for years and his death hit him as hard as his parents'.

Just read the 80s Batman stories and you will get your answer.

>>88468291
I feel like he cared about Jason more than most fans(and writers)gave him credit for.Batman started to become darker after Jason died.

>>88468291
yeah Bruce loved Jason like a son and comes off as more happy and centered individual as a result.

>>88467710
Tim's the least to grow right now, having adopted th Red ROBIN persona, while Damian has constantly been portrayed as growing up to be trenchcoat Batman.

>>88468291
>Bruce treated Jason better than everybody else
>Jason still whines like a little bitch and thinks Bruce hates him

sounds about right
at least bruce smacks dick around more than anybody else so dick has a reason to be salty as fuck

>>88468469
>Red ROBIN
It's still pseudo-Robin.

File: 568a0f9d-9015-40ca-a645-c2c915f643fc.jpg (99KB, 273x455px) Image search: [Google]

99KB, 273x455px

>>88468291
Bruce treated Jason better than any Robin.

>>88468568
That's why I said Tim was least likely to grow beyond Robin.

I mean, look at them.

Dick - Nightwing
Jason - Red Hood
Tim - Red Robin
Damian - Batman (in certain stories)

>>88468602
YOU WEREN'T THERE WHEN IT MATTERED
FUCK YOU BRUCE!
There, I've summed all Lobdell's stories.

>>88468393
>Most flashbacks now pretty much have Bruce treating Dick and Jason like he does in more modern times. i.e. like shit
Nah, not with Jason.

Tomasi was the only writer who had Batman treating Jason badly.

>>88468643
Everyone was Batman in certain stories. Most of the times it's Dick. I don't think Jason had any story where he's Batman, though.

>>88468930
Battle for the Cowl, but it was pretty shitty.

File: Countdown30-12jasonbats-1.jpg (33KB, 249x492px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 249x492px

>>88468930
>I don't think Jason had any story where he's Batman, though
He does in countdown and Gotham was actually clean and a developed city under his protection.

File: Battle_For_The_Cowl.jpg (2MB, 2560x1979px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 2560x1979px

>>88469026
Yeah, yeah. I've meant more like some alternate future where he's Batman. I've never read BftC, though. Only saw pic related where even Two-Face has outfit.

>>88469054
>Countdown
Well, you know why I skipped that, too.

File: NOT AGAIN.png (139KB, 245x302px) Image search: [Google]

139KB, 245x302px

>>88469054
>Countdown

>>88469054
>He does in countdown and Gotham was actually clean and a developed city under his protection
It's seems pretty interesting. I guess I will give Countdown a shot.

>>88469143
I've seen people complain about his current helmet but anything is better than this.

>>88469198
What's wrong with his helmet in Rebirth?

>>88466585
Man, Duke looked so much better in the Jacket than the current Yellow Batboy get up.

File: shitty helmet.png (57KB, 139x182px) Image search: [Google]

57KB, 139x182px

>>88469198
that's fanart

but yes the small comical frown at the bottom is better than the last helmet

>>88469054
Was Countdown the series with Jason, Donna and Kyle as a team? I have seen some good panels with them and it got me curious about it.

>>88469268
Yes

and no it's not good. It's awful.
So awful DC themselves told people to ignore it.

>>88469268
Yep and their part was the most enjoyable in the whole book.

Read Countdown: The Search for Ray Palmer which was focused only on them.

>>88468291
Batman loves Jason the most.

File: Countdown.jpg (94KB, 500x342px) Image search: [Google]

94KB, 500x342px

>>88469385
Second that.

Countdown worth the read only because of their team up.

>>88468930
The reason I made that exception for Damian is because right now, he's just a kid, while all the other robins are already young adults. I pulled from material where Damian already was an adult and in those, he's Batman.

But even if I weren't to pull from those, he's already run around as a miniature trenchcoat Batman and at one point had the alter ego of Redbird.

>>88468291
He's actually like him the best which is why he let him do whatever he wants.

>>88466721

Tim has about 6 fans that shitpost in every thread about him. By far the worst Robin. I laughed so hard when he died.

>>88466585
>that jason design

Why must Lee Bermejo create such majesty, which is never used by anyone else?