DC Rebirth in Review – Best to Worst

>>88270442
That's a much closer spread than I would have expected. Does a book as shit as Justice League usually end up up there in the 6.7s?
Also, M&A isn't Rebirth.

>>88270442
Harley quinn should be at the bottom 2bh

>>88270442
In my opinion, Deathstroke (9.0), Batman (8.5) (which i enjoy) and suicide squad (8.3) are rated lower than they should be while Wonder Woman (7.8, since it just started to pick up) and Harley (7) are higher than they should be.

>>88270967
For comparison, Marvel's lowest book is Ghost Rider (5.1) and Squadron Supreme (6.1). Their highest book is Vision (9.3, which is an all-time high for a series)

>>88272304
>Ghost Rider (5.1)
>Squadron Supreme (6.1)
Oh, fuck off. Those are two of Marvel's decent books.

>>88270442
> The Flash that high

literally the most overrated book of Rebirth.

File: 1406950428758.png (556KB, 763x992px) Image search: [Google]

556KB, 763x992px

>>88270442
>red hood that high
FUCK OFF
every dialogue is cringy
every issue is about boo hoo batman won't pay any attention to me WAAH WAAH

Fucking shit taste I swear.

File: aquatic fellow.jpg (148KB, 800x1200px) Image search: [Google]

148KB, 800x1200px

where's aquaman?

>>88272304
>>88272304
Holy shit, your taste is so bad, how can you rank Squirrel Girl and Hellcat higher than Squadron Supreme and Ghost Rider? But then, you gave Harley Quinn a 8.0 so I guess that explains things.

>>88272685
http://comicbookroundup.com/comic-books/reviews/dc-comics/aquaman-(2016)

7.7

>>88270442
Flash and Teen Titans definitely shouldn't be that high.

Does Rebirth One Shots mean the original DC Universe Rebirth? If so that's obviously the best.

>>88272883
You're an idiot.

>>88274273
Least I'm an idiot with taste.

>>88270442
>Cyborg that low
Oh fuck you it's definitely better than Superwoman
>Green Lanterns that low also fuck you
>Harley Quinn that high
Are these people high or something?

>>88272463
>>88272883
You two are real geniuses, aren't you? He said they're RANKED like that in Comic Book Roundup, they're not his personal rating, dumbasses.

>>88272600
Anon, you have the shit taste. That book is fun.

>>88274329
No, man, I'm saying "fuck you" to the reviewers. I don't know OP's taste and I don't really care.

That's retarded

>>88274329
He actually said Comic Book Review

I figured it was Comic Book Roundup though

>>88272600
It's the same as it was before. Except for some reason /co/ are now sucking it's dick instead of going
>Lobdell

>>88270442
>new super-man that low
New Supes has been the best thing to come out of Rebirth, yet it gets so little recognition from /co/ or any comic book sites (besides "wow so progressive").
Of course, Rebirth didn't actually change anything besides bringing back a few dead characters, so of course nobody gives a shit about the books that don't involve Batman or Superman.

File: 1437359256273.jpg (14KB, 220x220px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 220x220px

>>88272600
>>88274551
>Can't handle the fact that Red Hood finally got a good series

>>88274740
Fuck you nigger, I've always liked RHatO and RH/A. It just shits me that everyone's sucking it's dick cause it's under the Rebirth banner. Same with Venditti's GL. It's the exact same book as it was pre-relaunch.

>>88274979

No they're really not. Green Lantern was a mess and Red Hood was only for characterfags.

File: 1405464921767.png (372KB, 646x756px) Image search: [Google]

372KB, 646x756px

>>88274979
>It's the exact same book as it was pre-relaunch.
No it isn't. RHaTO used to be the Jason show where all the important character interactions happened off panel. This one is taking it's time to set up and has meaningful character interactions rather than bland Jason cock sucking

>>88274408
>done by someone who probably doesn't read comics?
They did read comics you know?

>>88275252
Might want to ditch the anime image, mate. This is /co/.

>>88274979
no they're not. They're liking it because of the new artist and how Artemis and Bizarro provide a more interesting entertaining dynamic that when Jason stole Dick's friends.

>>88275904
>liking it because of the new artist
I'm guilty of that.
But you're right on dynamic part.

I just wish there would be encounter of them dark trinity meeting with Titans in the future. Where jason and co got misunderstood for doing the bad things and got beaten up by titans

>>88275904
>new artist
It's the same guy that was on the last book

>>88270442

Aquaman too low (best Rebirth title with Supes imo)
Trinity too high (it's just nothing special)
Deathstroke too high (convoluted mess with flashes of brilliance that will only be readable as a collected trade)
Batman too high (do I really need to explain)
Titans right were it should be

And I just realized I probably need to pick up WW and Flash books once they release the trades

>>88272600
BIZARRO AM WORST VILLAIN

>>88276120
He only did the last issue you dunce

>>88276120
He was on two issues I think, but the different colorist is definitely helpful. Gandini is great.

>>88272600
>every dialogue is cringy
It's Lobdell. At least they're restraining him enough for it to be enjoyable.

>every issue is about boo hoo batman won't pay any attention to me
I don't think he's been mentioned since the 2nd issue or so. Plus it's Jason Todd, Daddy issues are a pretty big part of his character.

File: Eobard freakout.jpg (274KB, 898x1346px) Image search: [Google]

274KB, 898x1346px

>>88272506
I fucking love Flash, and I agree.

Who the fuck rated this?

Batman is WAY too high. Both DC and A-S B.
Teen Titans should be a bit lower
New Superman should be higher, same with Aquaman.
Batman Beyond should be on the bottom.

>>88272685
>>88273014

Aquaman is literally top 3 right now, after Red Hood and Hal Jordan.

Also not sure how Teen Titans can be so low after the first issue, I haven't read #2 yet but I'm willing to bet it's just asshurt jonboy fans

>>88277059
it's average ratings based on aggregated scores for each issue

>>88277247
>Also not sure how Teen Titans can be so low after the first issue, I haven't read #2 yet but I'm willing to bet it's just asshurt jonboy fans
issue 1 has an 8.5 and 2 has a 7.8, that's still pretty good

taking comic book 'review' scores into account
people who judge the issues on silly things like dialogue, whether the story picked up momentum in a multi-part arc (really comic book critics should judge a book by arcs and not by issue - comics often deal with the whole of things), off-brand characterization (although staticity in comics is supposed to be bad i'm pretty sure - characters should change and grow overtime), etc.

I read TCJ for comics criticism because they actually get into discussions about art, art theory, thematic depth in comics, etc.

people who review cape comics have no idea how to properly critique comics. its just 'muh bad dialogue' or 'bad because it doesn't have proper anatomy' even though art doesn't strictly depend on realism, especially in a fucking superhero genre

>>88277247
How does a 7.7 middle of the list translate to "top three"?

>>88270442
>green lanterns that low

What a load of shit

>>88277790
It looks like that's his own personal ranking.

>>88270442
Green Lanterns should be much higher, Harley Quinn much lower, though I agree with Justice League being dead last, that shit is terrible. Detective Comics is top 10 but I don't think it deserves to be number one on the list. I'd probably pick Superman as my favorite book of the list. Aquaman should be up there with the 8s too.

post yr own top 10s
1. Deathstroke
2. Green Arrow
3. Midnighter and Apollo
4. New Super-Man
5. Sixpack and Dogwelder - Hard Travelin Heroz
6. Detective Comics
7. All-Star Batman
8. Superwoman
9. Suicide Squad
10. Superman

>>88270442
Detective Comics and Red Hood ranking higher than Batman and Nightwing?
Deathstroke not being the highest ranked title in the lineup?
New Super-Man at 7.9

Clearly people have no taste.

>>88277790

>what are personal preferences

>>88270442
Titans is the best book

File: RVD dunno lol.png (149KB, 450x385px) Image search: [Google]

149KB, 450x385px

>Oliver Queen framed as criminal
>"it's okay you got Green Arrow left"
>Green Arrow framed as criminal

Is this really a top three book?

File: 20161118_214936.png (2MB, 1439x1357px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1439x1357px

Where the fuck is Aquaman? The book has some of the best pacing of all the rebirth books.

>>88278785
>>88278935
Abnett pls go

File: 1417523015572.jpg (109KB, 1003x1024px) Image search: [Google]

109KB, 1003x1024px

>>88278984

>>88278930
Lotta Innocent Dickgirl Fans

File: IMG_2329.jpg (92KB, 756x1134px) Image search: [Google]

92KB, 756x1134px

>>88270442
Hyped about Superman

>>88280106
Same. I'm glad the book can focus on Clark now that Jon is in Supersons even though I enjoyed him.

>>88270442
It's so funny. My two favorite comics - Tec and Wondygal - are the top, but my third, Birds of Prey, is almost the bottom. Ah, well. :)

>>88277721
How should people review comics on a monthly/semi-monthly basis, other than that? The comics are written and released as single floppies for consumption, and reviews should reflect that. Otherwise, you're just arguing that people should write reviews every three to six months, depending on the release rate.

>>88272883
>your

>>88274740
>finally
kys
casual

>>88278935
see >>88273014

>>88280602
Your an awful troll anon

>>88280624
>Your vs. you're
Not what I was going at.
The anon was calling out somebody's taste, when they were just reposting CBR's shit taste.

>>88278091
Deathstroke
Midnighter/Apollo
New Super-man
Sixpack/Dogwelder
Hal & Pals

File: Screen-Shot-2016-10-24-at-14.11.41.png (1MB, 1078x516px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1078x516px

>>88278091
no particular order, and I just really like this cover

Superman
Hal Jordan and the Green Lads
Aquaman
Green Lanterns
Green Arrow
New-Superman
Nightwing
RHATO
Detective
Deathstroke

Honorable mention to Young Animal books since I dunno if they count

>>88280842
>Honorable mention to Young Animal books since I dunno if they count

They're listed under Vertigo, just for added confusion.

>>88270442
>8.1 - Red Hood and the Outlaws
It deserves even higher than this because this book is literally my favorite.

>>88270442
>7.8 - Batman
>7.8 - Nightwing
>7.8 - Suicide Squad
>7.7 - Action Comics
>7.7 - Supergirl
>7.6 - DC Rebirth one-shots
>7.6 - Titans
>7.5 - Batgirl
My faith in critics has restored.

Though, these books deserves even lower ranking than this.

Yang is a genius yet doesn't have the best book?
hmmm
also Trinity is boring is balls but pretty

>>88274979
this
Lobdell has always been fun while Venditti is still shitty

>>88287997
New Super-man is fun, but isn't one of Yang's best work.