Batfamily Rebirth Books

Great tier:
Batman
All Star Batman

Good tier:
Detective Comics

Meh Tier:
Nightwing


Shit tier:
Batgirl


I don't read tier:
RHatO
Batgirl and the Birds of Prey

>>85408630
Official rankings
>RHatO
>Nightwing
>Detective comics
>All star
>Batman
>Both Batgirl books

>>85408630
Objectively correct opinions

Batman - great
Nightwing - good
Detective Comics - good
Batgirl - good
Batgirl and the Birds of Prey - kinda good
All-Star Batman - kinda stupid, but will probably get better
Red Hood and the Outlaws - mediocre, but will probably get worse

Batgirl was better than expected but still not really for me. I like 'young hero finding themselves' stuff but I can't get into Babs as Batgirl since I group her with the older characters mentally.

Bird of Prey's art was distracting in the bad sense and the writing didn't really do anything special. Might find its footing though, but I probably won't bother to see if it does.

Nightwing is just ok but I like where it's going.

Batman is alright but it hasn't done much for me. #4 was better than the previous issues, felt more King-like.

Didn't read the others.

RHaTO is only quasi-Batfamily, since it's not directly in the Bat-office (aka edited by Mark Doyle or one of his people).

>>85408630
Enjoying Red Hood the most.

Still hopefull about Batman.

The rest are meh.

>>85409140
>tfw RHatO isn't in Batcrossovers because he's in Super-office
>tfw Super-office won't crossover it with Superbooks because he's ex-Robin and fuck Batman, we don't like him

>>85409414
Huh? Rhato was in every batcrossovers so far.

>>85409414
he's in the same editorial as Titans, Deathstroke, and (probably) Teen Titans

>>85409473
He is not in superman office anymore? And have the same editor as Deathstroke and Titans? Interesting.

>>85408630

>Great tier
Nightwing
Batman

>Good tier
Detective comics

>Meh tier
RHatO
Batgirl

>Shit tier
BoP

>Avoid like plague tier
All Star Batman

>>85408630
All of them are mediocre, although Batgirl shined for a couple of pages.

Haven't read ASB.

>>85409538
>And have the same editor as Deathstroke and Titans? Interesting.

Pretty sure this was always the case, it's just that those books were also under Superman editorial. Probably even calling that group the "Superman" editorial group was a misnomer from the start, it was basically just another JL group.

>>85409860
But now, Berganza is editing just the Super books, and those others are under Alex Antone, who somehow has managed to scrub 50% of the Lobdell-ness out of Red Hood

>>85409941
I think Berganza still has the lantern books too, or at least he has Simon and Jessica's.

File: newrebirthlist.jpg (3MB, 1200x4773px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 1200x4773px

>>85409538
Yep. Going through this list so far, we can safely say:

>Bat-office (aka Doyle books)
Batman
'Tec
Wonder Woman
Nightwing
Harley Quinn
Batgirl
Batgirl and the Birds of Prey
All-Star Batman
(Gotham Academy Second Semester -- technically not a rebirth book, but it's highly unlikely it'll move out of the Bat-office, regardless)

>Super-office (aka Berganza books)
Action Comics
Superman
New Super-Man
Superwoman
Supergirl (technically unconfirmed, but 99% likelihood)
Green Lanterns
Hal Jordan and the Green Lantern Corps

>Titans office (Alex Antone and/or Brittany Holzherr usually edit them)
Titans
Deathstroke
Red Hood and the Outlaws
Teen Titans (confirmed by Andy Khouri on Twitter, IIRC)

>Justice League office (Brian Cunningham, Andy Khouri, and Harvey Richards)
Aquaman
The Flash
Green Arrow
Justice League
Suicide Squad

>odd one out
Hellblazer (edited by Jessica Chen and Kristy Quinn)

>unknown/unconfirmed
Cyborg (likely in the Justice League office)
Trinity (likely in JL office)
Blue Beetle (no idea, to be honest; maybe edited by the Hellblazer people??)
Batman Beyond (it's currently in the same office as Earth-2 Society, which Injustice is in as well.)

>>85410181
GLs is under Cotton.

>>85410181
>Hellblazer (edited by Jessica Chen and Kristy Quinn)

Chen is usually digital stuff right? That is pretty weird.

I would guess JL office for Blue Beetle but it could be with the Titans stuff too. Or whoever was editing JL3K/1 I guess to keep Giffen happy?

>>85410297
and Cotton is under Berganza

>>85410297
Berganza is still credited as the group editor on both Green Lantern books, though.

>>85410181
Why Red Hood isn't in the bat office in the first place?

>>85410554
They don't want nothing to have with Lobdell, or Red hood too.

>>85410554
Makes sense to me that it's not there. More non-Bats than Bats even if Jason is the selling point and it gets tie-ins occasionally.

>>85410554
Lobdell was probably friendly with Berganza

>>85410621
Considering that Red Hood was in every Batman event. I don't think so.

>>85410628
But Wonder Woman is in the bat office and she's not a bat character?

>>85410791
Because Rucka wanted Doyle as the Head editor.

>>85410791
>>85410889
Yeah that one's not a content thing.

>>85410554
Lobdell and Berganza moved both Teen Titans and the original RHaTO out of the "Bat-office" fairly early into the New52.

And from then on, it's just stuck. Inter-office crossovers still happened, but it was apparently easier for Lobdell to work with Berganza and for Berganza to have more shit to edit. Go figure.

>>85411047
Was this when Lobdell was put on Superman?

>>85408630
They're all mediocre but Batman and Nightwing could possibly get better.

/co/ rebirth when?

>>85411797
Yep!

Forgot about that, but yeah, that seems to be what moved the books under the same office.