XKCD VS CYANIDE AND HAPPINESS

Cyanide and Happiness has given me more chuckles

C&H is far more amusing and less psuedo-intellectual

>>80742674
xkcd is the reddit of comics

I forgot to put money into that C&H Kickstarter.

>>80743111
C&H is the funnyjunk of comics

>>80742674
console war threads are a bannable offense

>>80742674

Best XKCD can be really witty, topical and hilarious, not to mention thought provoking (especially if we are counting the educational stuff).

Best C&H is fucking hilarious, but at a basic, kind of immature level. It's different, but I would take a godly XKCD over an equivalent C&H any day.

However, at its worst, XKCD is preachy, faggy, circlejerky shit. Unfunny and standing on a soapbox. At C&H's worst, it's just a missed joke; unfunny but nothing lost.

So, maybe across the board C&H is better, but XKCD is more ambitious and its best is really good.

>>80742674
c&h basically has three jokes-- either there's wordplay involving the literal interpretation of something, or where a character otherwise elaborates on a seemingly innocuous phrase to be something subversive (often zooming out to show that they meant something entirely other than what was expected), or a generic joke setup gets replaced with a punchline that's horribly dark. I almost never laugh at it.

>>80742674
Let them kill each other, then celebrate.

>>80742674
Cyanide and Happiness has a larger number of funny strips just its sheer massive output.
XKCD has better highs and also clearly has far more effort put into it but suffers massively from the cringey relationship strips.
Both of them are mostly pretty bad.

I stopped reading both a longass time ago

File: 1457287638532.jpg (112KB, 772x817px) Image search: [Google]

112KB, 772x817px

Fedora vs Edge?
I'll take edge every time.

>>80742674
>Look at my opinion and how superior I am, I am so great I shit fedoras holy fuck look at me did I tell you I went to college and everyone I know also went to college? Oh yeah college, college, college, sure is fun being smarter than 90% of the population
vs
>/b/ of comics

File: circlejerkcartoon.gif (42KB, 750x200px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 750x200px

i only like comics that align with my beliefs

File: nv5iajpwTt1s2d73n.jpg (44KB, 540x269px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 540x269px

>>80744183
I prefer this one. Much more succinct

I am mostly unfamiliar with both. Could someone post some examples of the best and possibly worst of either?

File: GUD COMIX.png (38KB, 590x595px)

38KB, 590x595px

>>80744205

File: Prove it.png (63KB, 697x287px)

63KB, 697x287px

C&H obviously.

>>80742674
SMBC

>>80744205

God damn I will always love this one.

C&H is really funny... if you're emotionally 13-year-old. Not that xkcd is all that great either, but it's certainly better than C&H.

>>80744205
>>80744859

Yeah it's actually really fucking succinct and clever, it's a classic.

File: caught.png (101KB, 450x2255px) Image search: [Google]

101KB, 450x2255px

SOCIAL COMMENTARY

It's hard to choose which turd I'd rather eat, OP.

>>80745687

I like that you can clearly see he was wearing a seatbelt the first time and not the second.

File: what_xkcd_means.png (109KB, 350x891px)

109KB, 350x891px

>>80742674

I pick the one who's not an edgelord.

>>80745975
so c&h then

xkcd is more consistently preachy and condescending, but C&H is worse when it does decide to get preachy. Tough call.

i stopped reading C&H when Matt left

File: EvenTexturePaper.png (37KB, 730x290px)

37KB, 730x290px

>>80743538

XKCD by far, I'm into humor not offered on a plate, if you have to so to speak earn the punchline it feels more rewarding. Bonus points for What-if

>>80742674
I don't care for XKCD's style of argument sometimes.

>>80743111
XKCD is the Aalewis of comics

MEGAAAN

MEGAN I LOVE YOU

MEGAN?

MEGAAAAANN

>>80742674
Cyanide and Happiness for sure

>>80742674
Which Cyanide and Happiness?

I always love "Depressing Comic Week"

>>80742674
Can I still enjoy xkcd's "What if?"s if I choose the C&H side?

SMBC.

File: bhyxpanuf.png (35KB, 730x290px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 730x290px

C&H tries too hard to be stupid.
XKCD tries too hard to be intellectual.

They're both garbage but C&H wins by a mile because of the random comic generator.

>>80748357
No one here should know who that is.

>>80744205
>Looks like you have some growing up to do
Lost it

File: implying.png (41KB, 730x290px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 730x290px

>>80751571

>>80745687
PBF is the clear winner.

File: 1425066359521.png (57KB, 730x290px)

57KB, 730x290px

>>80753245

>>80745687
PBF wins every time

>>80751571
>>80753245
These are fucking golden.

dude math lmao

>>80742674
Are there any comedy webcomics that aren't complete shit?

>>80757006
Nedroid.

>>80742674
XKCD has better highs but worse lows.

Cyanide and Happiness is pretty consistently a 'hehe' comic.

XKCD either provokes genuinely interesting thought or is very witty, or it's Randall seeing what new unplumbed depths he can explore in his own ass trying to sound deep/quirky.

>>80757052
Boring hipster shit

>>80757073
Says the anonymous hipster on boringhipst.er

>>80757006
"manly guys doing manly things"
"it hurts!"

>>80757192
>manly guys doing manly things

no

>>80748357
http://i.imgur.com/hoTK1Mv.png

>>80742674
Cyanide and happiness for me hands down I don't read much of the comics but I love the Cartoons. Also I think sometimes XKCD can be too preachy.

File: 1401570981643.jpg (127KB, 946x472px) Image search: [Google]

127KB, 946x472px

>>80744205