Is soup a food or a drink?

both

>>8018262
Is boba a drink or a soup?

>>8018276
>is this tea-based beverage a drink or a soup?

Tea-based. So, drink.

>>8018270
how does your body know what to send through your penis and what to send through your butt when you eat soup

>>8018279
Luck?

is V8 a soup or drink?

>>8018289
The answer to this question will have some serious implications.

V8 is a liquid vegetable thing, which could (in theory) be served hot. So if it is a soup, then that means that soups are also drinks. If it's a drink, then that means there is a soup-ness factor which V8 does not possess.

>>8018279
Your body extracts everything. The proteins, minerals, sugars, water. When you piss it's waste water from your bodys functions and shit is hyper-decomposed matter. You piss out liquid from steaks and chocolate.

I was about to say the difference is if it's hot or not, but then there's cucumber soup, which is cold.

>>8018262
Soups a food. A simple way to think about it, where is it on a menu in a restaurant? It's definitely not in the beverage section, and usually in a subsection of main dishes.
>>8018279
all the water goes to pee, and the lumpy parts go to the other side, duh.

>>8018297
Tomatoes are fruits not vegetables.

>>8018315
>make fruit salad
>put tomatoes in it
>everyone complains

no

>>8018315
>tfw the V stands for vegetable

Even so, it has other veggies mixed into it.

But now that you mention that, because tomato soup is a thing, and tomatoes are fruit, does that mean that you can have soups from other fruits?

Is apple juice a soup?

>>8018278
But you have to chew it so food.

>>8018321
I swallow boba whole and so should u

>>8018321
So then are things that aren't chewed drinks?

Is tomato soup with stewed tomatoes a food, but without is a drink?

File: rec_blueberrysoup_large1.jpg (25KB, 340x340px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 340x340px

>>8018319
Yes fruit soups are a real thing
I have an old cookbook with some recipes check out blueberry soup

File: WHOA.jpg (2KB, 125x89px) Image search: [Google]

2KB, 125x89px

>>8018334

Jesus Christ.

The captcha I got on my last one said select all the food, and guess what was there.

Just fucking guess what was there.

>>8018324
it's simple, ice is food (it's solid) and water is a drink (it's liquid) and if you put ice in water you have soup which is food + drink

this leads me to believe there are undiscovered food types with gas and plasma

>>8018342
>ice is food

lol

>solid + liquid = soup

So is turkey(solid) with gravy(liquid) a soup?

>>8018341
my last captcha said select all the drink. only cappuccinos were there. is coffee a soup?

File: 20160823_082015.jpg (2MB, 1640x1970px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1640x1970px

>>8018334
I can post the recipes

>>8018350
>fruit
>soup
>in drink glasses

this is not ok

>>8018342
So is tomato soup a beverage

is gazpacho a drink or a sauce?

K so I just asked my little brother for ideas randomly, and he says that if you can add crackers or croutons to it, and it still tastes good, then it's a soup.

Thoughts?

>>8018361
is peach cobbler a stew? is cheesecake a soup?

>>8018359
it is a cold vegetable compound

>>8018362
WHOA WHOA WHOA

Who said anything about stews?

Soup doesn't make me any less thirsty, so it's not a drink

>>8018369
Beer makes you more thirsty, so is it an anti-drink?

I think we can all agree that this is a in fact a chicago pizza

soup is hot and savory gazpacho is cold and savory. juice is only juice if it's been filtered. however tomato soup is a drink and a soup but more complex soups with piece of whatever in them are not.

File: giphy.gif (1MB, 245x182px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 245x182px

>>8018368

Speaking of Stews...

>>8018262
It's a type of casserole.

What the fuck happened to them after the 1980's?

>>8018376
So, OJ with pulp is soup?

>>8018262
Soup is soup

The dictionary definition of soup is "a liquid food made by boiling or simmering meat, fish, or vegetables with various added ingredients."
Obviously it's a food as the dictionary definition says so.
Now, by "drink," you really mean "beverage"
The dictionary definition of beverage is: "any potable liquid, especially one other than water, as tea, coffee, beer, or milk"

Therefore, as soup is defined as a "liquid food," and a beverage is defined as "any potable liquid," soup is both a food and a beverage (drink)

>>8018373
It's a drug.

>>8018345
Oh, young Anon. You've discovered one of the many technicalities of the culinary world!

You see, a combinations of solids and liquids can only be considered a soup when the volume of liquid is greater than than the volume of solid matter to the degree that the solid matter can be suspended within the liquid.

Liquids sharing a plate with solids in a lower volume fall under the classification of sauces.

>>8018262
Its a form of tea

>>8018279
You don't pee excess water, you mostly pee the shit that comes out of your kidneys

>>8018279
really makes u think

>>8018321
Are aloe drinks food? Is gelatin with no calories food?

>>8018361
It's salad a soup?

>>8019058
Gello is soup

>>8019237
You don't need to chew aloe drinks.

Gelatin with no calories wouldn't be food, but it would be edible. Zero calorie gelatin does not exist.

>>8018397
Nice

What people on this board constantly fail to realize is that foods aren't categorized exclusively by their ingredients and contents, but the contexts in which they exist in. Because of this, soup is a food. Under some specific contexts it can be a beverage like a Bovril tea.

If I put water in a bowl and eat it with a spoon is it a soup or a drink?

>>8018405
no oj with pulp is a gazpacho

>>8018262
Soup is neither good nor drink.
It is soup.

>>8019237
you dont have to chew it so no. Similarly ice cream is a drink unless its rocky road.

>>8020512
>soup is not good
come on over anon, I'll make you some good soup.

File: 1467096570742.png (348KB, 600x456px)

348KB, 600x456px

>>8018279
what

>>8020847
I meant food but I'll take you up on that offer.

>>8018262

Did you crumble some crackers over it?

>>8018342
It was funnier when I misread it as ice is a food (it's a salad).

If it has no nutritional value it is not a food.

>>8018373
It's a beverage.

>>8021325
>If it has no nutritional value it is not a food.

i'm pretty sure water has the most nutritional value of anything since you'll die in a few days without it

File: 1354938265391.jpg (121KB, 408x408px) Image search: [Google]

121KB, 408x408px

>>8021378
>water
>nutrients
Water has nothing. It's 0 calories, 0 vitamins, 0 anything but 2 hydrogens and an oxygen.

>>8021427
If you take distilled water maybe or just approach it scientifically, in reality there are minerals which differ greatly from region to region or brand
Not saying you are wrong, of course you pointed out a retard