Can we all agree that the division bell was the best pink floyd album?

File: 41MW804MPJL.jpg (30KB, 301x300px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 301x300px

>the best pink floyd album

both crap.

I liked that song with mr speak and spell

>>727113999
I honestly like Obscured by Clouds. It's not my favorite, but I think it should get more attention.

>>727113772
they're all pretty shit grandpa

>>727113772
Pink Floyd fucking sucks


Grow up faggot

File: IMG_8186.jpg (55KB, 500x700px) Image search: [Google]

55KB, 500x700px

>>727113772
>>no Roger Waters
>>pleb tier Floyd.

File: medium_total_recall.jpg (13KB, 300x282px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 300x282px

>>727113772
NO. GOD NO. NO. NO. NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

#DeathGrips amirite?

piper at the gates of dawn is their best

>>727114475
If by pleb you mean main driving force of the band with lots of great solo stuff and being cool af

>>727113772
the wall
>thread

I love meddle, mostly because of echoes

>>727114530
I like that one too. I don't think it's their best, but it's good. Better than the next few.

>>727113772
no.

>>727114584
In all honesty, I agree.

>>727114584
agreed.

>>727114401
Now post what music you like so we can make fun of you for your shitty taste.

>>727114475

this

>>727114616
strangers passing in the street...

>>727114616

listening right now

>>727114584
the band is not just the wall

File: IMG_8189.jpg (66KB, 666x1000px) Image search: [Google]

66KB, 666x1000px

>>727114574
Who? This fatass?

>>727114584

yes, and dsotm plus the songs: echoes, atom heart mother, a saucerful of secrets.

>>727114616
Fearless is the best song of that record homie

Echos is pretty good though.

We can both agree the meddle is the best

>>727115124
that's right man

File: IMG_8190.jpg (25KB, 220x219px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 220x219px

Might not be "the best" by whatever fruity measure, but Final Cut is, by far, my favorite.

>>727115063
david gilmore is shit

a momentary lapse in reason is right.

>>727113772
Its the least "floyd" of them all.
still pretty good

>>727114318
steven hawking?

File: FC.jpg (263KB, 835x740px) Image search: [Google]

263KB, 835x740px

>>727114616
i have a copy of the original master recording of meddle.

>>727115627
oh man, I'd love to have that, how long do you own it?

Ummagumma, best Floyd of them all!

For me its

Meddle
Animals
Wish you were here/Dark side of the moon

Unrelated
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nIpyMi6R3nw

>>727115918
the narrow way... OH BOI

>>727115868
bought it some time back in the 90s. i have the wall, too. along with Rush, Moving Pictures.

>>727115918

<3

File: fav al.jpg (239KB, 1300x1300px) Image search: [Google]

239KB, 1300x1300px

thoughts?

File: IMG_3220.png (88KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

88KB, 300x300px

Let's all be gentlemen about this and agree that no record is more pink floyd then wish you were here

>>727116248

Mah nigga

>>727116341

meh, apart from titletrak the other songs are crap

>>727116410
shine on you crazy diamond was pretty good

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bJ0sfE6oe4s&ab_channel=ScottSpeer

>>727115349
You're literally the only person I've ever heard say that, Like every other PF fan I know hates the final cut because it's "too depressing" or some shit.

>>727113772
maybe post waters

meddle, animals, wish you were here
in no particular order

>>727116410
Have a cigar is great statement about the music industry that still stands true today

>>727116482

yes, both parts, but other songs are terrible. WYWH (song) is pathetic

>>727114616
You gentlemen have fine taste in floyd, indubitably. I need nth say morr.

>>727115349
I need to grab that. It's the one album I haven't listened to a bunch

>>727116517
I can't agree with him, but also don't hate the album, I can't hate floyd

>>727114515
bitch

>>727116410
never listened to it while tripping?
dedicated to syd barrett

>>727116410

Shine on you crazy diamond and have a cigar are fucking rad

File: IMG_8191.jpg (111KB, 500x495px) Image search: [Google]

111KB, 500x495px

>>727116341
That & Animals. Really I think of them as two sides of the same body of thought.

But yeah. Not sure if either are "best" but certainly the "most Floyd."

>>727116801

never did drugs lol

File: 1489627018034.jpg (55KB, 625x468px) Image search: [Google]

55KB, 625x468px

>>727113772

Dude? Seriously?

File: images (13).jpg (26KB, 384x384px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 384x384px

>pink floyd

File: IMG_8193.png (363KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

363KB, 500x500px

>>727116517
Dippy fake bitches like this say that. They were my generation's version of the fake gamer girl.

>>727116615
You speak truth much like the farm animal chews grain. Truth nonetheless. I like you.

File: u suck.jpg (442KB, 758x692px) Image search: [Google]

442KB, 758x692px

>>727116959

>>727113772
I love these threads that talk about music

>>727113772


Best ones are animals and wish you were here, then dark side of the moon, then meddle, then the wall, then the division bell, then obscured by clouds

File: IMG_2979.gif (2MB, 320x240px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 320x240px

>>727116959

>has never done drugs
>>>in a pink floyd thread

That's like being a nun with an opinion on inflatable dildos

>>727117107
>caring what fucking phase a female is invested in.
>fucking wut

>>727117377

wat? I like music ant that's all

>>727113999
Trips of truth.

>>727117569
but...drugs and floyd tho...

File: IMG_0224.jpg (2MB, 2376x3168px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 2376x3168px

suck it /b/itches

have the same stuff on vinyl, but they're at my parents' house. vinyl sounds much better

Favorite floyd video?

Love pompeii. For later floyd thhere is pulse live at earls court. Of course the wall.

Also love the Bike music video of them all being high doing what the fuck in Hyde park.

>>727113772


TOP 10

1. Wish you where here
2. Animals
3. Dark side of the moon
4. The Wall
5.Meddle
6. The Division Bell
7. Atom Heart Mother
8. The Final Cut
9. The Piper at the Gates of Dawn
10. Ummagumma

Animals used to be my favorite but I've really started to appreciate the wall the more I listen.

File: IMG_3221.jpg (60KB, 732x383px) Image search: [Google]

60KB, 732x383px

>>727117569

You see you'd better start listening to this>>727117712
man

That man knows what is up

One of these days, I'm going to cut you into little pieces.

>>727118182
It's hard to even compare post meddle with pre meddle. It's so different. I personally put Animals above wish you were here though, but it's really close.

>>727118165
>>727118165
>Love pompeii

Literally listening to echoes when I saw this thread. The Live at Pompeii version is possibly one of my favorite songs. Shame youtube took it down, couldn't find a torrent.

>>727113772
this is fucking bait right?

the best is househoud objects

careful with that axe, eugene

File: Capture.jpg (182KB, 1715x957px) Image search: [Google]

182KB, 1715x957px

>>727118083
Nice collection man, here's mine

>>727118556
Yea. I don't think anybody actually thinks that.

>>727118548
fuck that, the same happened to me, wtf universe

>>727118460

yeah, both animals and WYWH are my favorites, shine on you crazy diamond is my favorite song, both parts

>>727118548
Plus that one off of Seamus with a real dog was pretty rad

Did anybody else watch the David Gilmore On an Island concert where David Bowie did Comfortably Numb?

>>727118692
nice. i have original vinyl from the 70s. my dad collected this stuff

>>727118845
I love Seamus

>>727118548
Yup, the cinematography was superb and the setting of an ancient amphitheater works on multiple levels with a song like echoes.

live at pompeii. careful with that axe, eugene.

BEST
SONG
EVER

>>727118284

Joints have no effect on me :-/ i tried some times
also, LSD would be the way to go, and only for the first album.

>>727118858
That copy of the Wall and a momentary lapse of reason are both originals from my pops as well.

Rest I've picked at various stores. That copy of Meddle is a japanese release, no idea how it ended up in my hands. Refuse to buy the newer re-releases, they are way to overpriced

>>727119129
I have to listen to them sober. A little weed maybe, but I feel like I'm missing out if I'm impaired.

>>727118845
Also loved when they are being interviewed and mostly ignore the interviewer while requesting oysters 20 times and pie without crust.

They seemed to have so much fun together. Before turning into money grubbing old people.

>>727119231
if you're a true collector, you must have
>Peter Frampton
>Frampton Comes Alive

Rubber soul is the best pink floyd album.

>>727115627
that's the mobile fidelity sound labs remaster, jackass

>>727119411
Not a huge fan of that album or peter frampton lol

Don't think I could call myself a collector, I just enjoy digging through the bins at a couple stores around me

>>727119724
4chan isn't a place for such hostility

>>727119724
yeah? and? i have it.

>>727113999
You wot m8?

>>727119399
That's why I loved meddle and live at Pompeii so much. You could tell they all enjoyed the music. Kinda lost on the later albums (though they were still good)

>>727118931
Same. Named my doggo after that song.

>>727120060
Yea. It got sad after Dark Side of the Moon

>>727116517
That's probably cause it was supposed to oroginally be an afterthought of the Wall. It was orogonally gonna be like the broken pieces, of the wall that is. I think some of the songs on final cut were in the wall movie.

>>727120189
That's fantastic. I really want a dog just to do that.

File: Dark_Side_of_the_Moon.png (22KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

22KB, 300x300px

>>727113772
Dark Side of the Moon, no contest

>>727116248
Personal favorite.

No band will ever release five albums in a row that come close to Meddle, Dark Side, Wish You Were Here, Animals, and the Wall.

It's impossible.

>>727120232
Sorry I meant originally

>>727118083
The Wall by Waters is his most self-indulgent piece of shit he ever did.

Roger Waters plus Hires Guns

>>727120353
What about Imagine Dragons? Chekmate

>>727120314
a buddy and i used to DJ parties

we had fucking awesome equipment

when we played Welcome to the Machine, we could set off car alarms

>all pink floyd albums are on the same level
>supreme
>that includes unreleased material such as Household Items

>>727120232
I've generally felt final cut was a Roger waters solo album played by pink floyd.

>>727120570
>I meant Household Objects

>>727120462
kek. you snowflakes are easily triggered by insignificant stuff.

>>727120603
Yea. I've thought the same thing. The division bell is also basically David Gilmour's first solo album also.

>>727120211
Agreed. For me, at least, Meddle was the turning point from early Floyd to commercial Floyd, where they really found their rock sound but lost a lot of the magic of the older albums.

Not to say I don't like the later albums, they still kick ass, but not as good.

>>727120603
Which is funny. Roger centric album is way too dramatic and lyrical without good music and David centric album is the opposite. They made their best music when they were all on the same page of course, its just cool to see how shitty it gets as they fell apart.

>>727120547
Sounds dope man

>>727115349
Wow, going to have to give that a listen. Been 10 years, at least. A Momentary Lapse of Reason is my favorite, not the best per se, but it came out when I was 16.

>>727120819
He had a few before division Bell. A self titled one and another called about face. They're... Ok.

>>727118846
Yes sir and it was fantastic. PF really did shone with their live performances

it's my favorite

>>727120757
Revisiting the interred corpse of a great album 20 years on strikes me as pointless

File: DSC00570a.jpg (2MB, 3000x1611px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 3000x1611px

Saw Floyd in 1986 without Roger. Saw Roger do the Wall 3 or 4 times, each time was EPIC (God damn image size limit)

>>727121210
as if anyone gives a shit about your opinion.

reply again.

>>727121210
Exactly this. The rest of the band moves on to new projects and here he still is, still jabbering on about his greatest work. We get it bro, you Wall

>>727121031
Momentary Laps if Resin came out more then 1 yr ago, faggot newfag

>>727121152
I'm glad to see someone else enjoyed that as much as me. David Gilmour is a fantastic saxophone player.

>>727116871
Animals was the best, in my opinion. Meddle was a close second.

>>727114382
Millenial fag detected

I've been trying to figure out the context in which Money belongs on Dark Side of the Moon, but really can't. It seems like the odd one out on the album, both lyrically and musically.

It's a great song, don't get me wrong, but for me it really wrecks the flow of the album

>>727114530
Piper is Syd Barrett, and a back up band, it maybe their start but its totally unrecognizable to compared to Meddle or Atom Heart Mother.

>>727113772
Madcap laughs

>>727121421
>Momentary Laps if Resin
>Laps
>if
>Resin

>>727116248
>>727116341
Yes now we are talking

File: piper at the gates of dawn album cover.jpg (26KB, 316x315px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 316x315px

>>727121559
I'm here literally just to say that Piper is their best.
Undeniably.

>>727121691
I think that was the Weird Al version

>>727121556
You know the prwmise of dark side is the things that make people go and, right? Like the great gig in the sky (death) and money (money). It fits. Money is also the start of the B side of the album on vinyl, so it made sense for it to be a more vibrant single type song

>>727121691
That's is rite faggot new fag get ur faxes straight. Ur a 17 bitch.

>>727121556
Have always thought that. Money is a great tune. Dark Side of the Moon is fantastic album. But just don't go together.

>>727121410
His visiting war monuments and performing on NetFlix just struck me as someone unwilling to make new stuff, even if it may bomb.
>>727121370
back it up with your worthless opinion.

File: rickwright408x271.jpg (15KB, 408x271px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 408x271px

Favorite album? Nothing really mattered to me after we lost Mr. Weight, shine on.
Listen as tribute
https://youtu.be/5Rnn2cV9NHA

>>727121993
see? reply again.

>>727121903
**things that make people go mad

Pink floyd? More like
>Stink void

>>727121903
I see your point on the first half. But your second statment about it being more vibrant single type song is what bugs me about it.

It seems to be shoehorned in there just to have a single on the album. The rest of the tracks seem to be about death and insanity, or some combination of the two, and then wham money out of nowhere.

>>727122297
We're not talking about yo mamas pussy bro

>>727113772
Yes.

Having heard all their albums I can honestly say that the wall and dark side of the moon are the only albums I can play beginning to end without getting burnt out.

>>727122406
You're right. We're talking about your mom's

File: 20170327_214900.png (1MB, 1080x806px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1080x806px

My Floyd vinyl.

>>727122611
Damn son you got me hickory smoke roasted. You bent me over. I will never recover. Off yourself, your taste in music is absolute shite

>>727116248
WELCOME MY SON

>>727122654
Reaaaaaaaaly need to get animals. Nice collection

>>727117569
Live a little anon! Take some lsd and throw on dark side of the moon and get lost in it

>>727113772
relics

>>727122654
Get their first two albums you commie

>>727122654
Nice!

>>727118669
Yes... Meddle is my favorite. You've got Echoes for the newer fans and the rest for the older fans. It is their best album.

Went to the Us and Them tour this year at citi field and that shit was wild. My dad went to see the wall at shea a while back and has me mad jelly

>>727117377
If I remember correctly, Pink Floyd pretty much went straight edge after Syd Barrett got fucked up on drugs. I didn't do drugs til after I listened to pink floyd, and when I did do drugs, I actually began listening to other psychedelic and neopsychedelic jawns. Pink floyd is better than drugs

>>727113772
lol good troll

File: 0e9.jpg (27KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 600x600px

>>727113772
>not the wall

>>727114616
yeah meddle is awesome.

Also I liked A Final Cut for raw feeling.

>>727115349
I agree.
I posted here:
>>727124021

>>727123384

Their early stuff doesn't do it for me like the post Barrett stuff. I enjoy it and listen to it, but I don't care to get them on vinyl.

>>727120603
Roger Waters didn't want to do The Wall as much as he wanted A Final Cut. That's why it's so heavy with his influence.

>>727117377
Echoes.

For the longest time I thought the meddle art work was like a dinosaur or something, until I realized the whole thing made and ear opened up.

>>727123714
Yep. It's always been a common misconception that they were a drug band. After Syd lost his shit, they weren't at all.

>>727124121
LISTEN TO THEM AGAIN
AND AGAIN
AND AGAIN
UNTIL YOU LOVE IT

File: Front.jpg (520KB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

520KB, 900x900px

Speak of the devil. Not sure if anyone still uses newsgroups, but I saw there were a bunch of Floyd live bootlegs posted to dk.binaer.musik today.

As a side note, I have always thought Gilmour was a better blues player than slow hand. His phrasing was so much better IMHO...

File: original.gif (630KB, 340x256px) Image search: [Google]

630KB, 340x256px

>>727116871
>>727121459

>>727116248
>>727116341
their best

Animals is overrated Water-era hipster bait
It's good, but certainly not their best, or even close.

>>727114887
by chance two different glances meet

>>727113772
Close but no

>>727124780
He is the master of bending notes

>>727113772
It actually is my favorite, all memes aside. Got to see Gilmour in LA last year and it was fucking amazing. Coming Back to Life might be my favorite Floyd song, possibly beating out Time, Wot's Uh The Deal, and Fat Old Sun.

File: Roger-Waters.jpg (356KB, 2048x1536px) Image search: [Google]

356KB, 2048x1536px

>>727115349
The Final Cut might be my favorite too. Always struck by a wave of feels at the beginning of the sax solo in "The Gunner's Dream".

>>727118182
1 WYWH
2 Animals
3 Piper at the Gates of Dawm
4 Meddle (practically tied with 3)
5 DSOTM
6 The Wall
7 Division Bell
8 Atom Heart Mother
9 Momentary Lapse (fuck you I liked it)
10 Ummagumma

Get your hands off my desert

No.

Piper at the Gates of Dawn is definitely their best, followed by Dark Side of the Moon

File: what's the deal.jpg (27KB, 319x282px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 319x282px

>>727118182
>>727126372
>Animals this high
>Not having Piper at #1

>>727115349
Fuck all that, we've got to get on with the show

>>727116248
this is the album that got me into PF, even more than DSOTM

>>727116871
having to scroll this far for Animals. damn do you guys even like floyd?

>>727113772
No.

It's one of their worst, and I like Pink Floyd.

>>727126372
Why did you abbreviate Wish You Were Here to WYWH yet type out all of Piper at the Gates of Dawn? This post just looks weird.

>>727115349
I agree. Never met someone with the same opinion.

File: Pink-Floyd-pink-floyd-2122592-1024-768.jpg (198KB, 1024x768px) Image search: [Google]

198KB, 1024x768px

>>727115087
>>727114616
>>727118548
>>727118994
>>727123528
>>727124242

I love the beginning and ending of echoes but I skip past the middle section. It just sounds like a Halloween haunted house CD to me.

am i bad person.

*Meddle
Fixed that for you.

>>727116341
Love shine on you crazy diamond but strangely didn't care for many others on that album

>>727124242
Yes this!!

>>727127723
Yes. Halloween house CD music is the fucking best.

>>727119129
Probably not inhaling or getting fake/really bunk weed. Weed doesn't just not work for people lol. But lsd is simply fantastic and id recommend it over weed any day

>>727118367
hey fuckin nigger i was going to say that

they have way better albums then the wall and dark side and i hate that is all people know of them like do not get me wrong they are both good albums but they are not their best ones and animal is my favorite and wish were here

>>727127723
Haha ill skip through it if i have guests over or something because i dont want them to think im weird, but normally ill let it run through the middle part. I like the ominous noises and love the build back into the second part of the song. Super atmospheric