So now that the dust has settled, what went wrong?

Split them up when they were at their hottest because they're fucking obsessed with splitting teams up.

They were able to cover for each other's weaknesses as a group. Said weaknesses were exposed when they went their separate ways.

>>2817732
Said weaknesses couldn't still been covered for as singles guys with. Y'know, competent writing.

>>2817726
They should've never broken up the shield, they could win the wwe title and still be in the stable, evolution did it and authority did it too.

>>2817726
forgot that it literally took two entire guys to cover for roman sucking, then took away the guys

Nothing. These piss ratings are all part I'd the plan. Gotta have downa to have ups. When The Shield reunites the struggle will be validated. wrestling will be saved and become mainstream again.

>>2817763
Evolution broke up when Randy and Batista started winning the world championship.
Authority was full of old guys who didn't to fight over the championship.

WWE needs a 3-man tag championship if it wants to keep stables.

>>2817781
Broken Hardys > SAnitY > WWE Bullet Club > Shield reuniting. They are so badly booked, I doubt they'll be saving wrestling together.

Towards the end they acted like Dean wasn't the leader all along and that it was either roman or there was no leader.

They made Dean a face and he's been a face ever since despite the guy being a natural heel.

Seth had an amazing heel run and had so much promise but his injury and horrible "face" turn have completely killed him.

Roman is the corporation's guy, the WWE's hottest period was during a time where the whole point of their main guy was being anti-establishment and telling the corporation to fuck off. When people see how obviously he's the corporation's guy and how he has completely mediocre to bad mic skills and average wrestling skills people don't buy into him, people want to boo him yet they refuse to turn him heel.

>>2817726
Nothing? They were an awesome team, started to become stale, and broke up in the way that was least expected. It was written perfectly.

>Roman Reigns. Pushed him to the fucking moon when They should have just waited one more Year. He should have swapped roles with Bryan at WM 31, having a solid IC title reign proving himself and winning the big one in Dallas. Instead of making him a Silent Badass Batista/Lesnar hybrid they tried making him a shitty Cena clone. They constantly keep putting him in positons to fail and piss off the fans when he could have easily been the guy if they let him be him instead of the vision vince has. He always delivers in ring, but his booking is dogshit and they won't turn him when they can print money with him as the top heel. Obviously the chosen one so fans instantly resent him. Not his fault, but still should argue with vince to change it up a little. Should be a modern Lesnar 2003, but isn't.

>Seth Rollins
The guy who turned, At the time the best worker in the company. Everything was going perfect until He won the actual title. He went to a guy who could go toe to toe with Brock and Cena, to not being able to beat anyone at all without cheating. Literally lost almost every non title match completely killing his credibility. Being a chickenshit heel is lame as fuck and lazy in todays era. Accidentally almost killed Cena and Ended Stings Career. Jon Stewart. Knee Injury makes him Miss WM 32 when he should have been defending the title. Everyone wants to Cheer him and they had a perfect opritunity to do a double turn with Him and Roman and make Rollins the Top babyface but they Stuck to the status quo. Than he and balor had to wrestle for the Fruitrollup where he injured him. Had to turn babyface as an emergency, but they shot a hot angle with HHH but than ignored it for a couple months killing any heat it had. Reason for turning wasn't satisfying as a viewer, basically the bully got fucked over and is now going after another one instead of realizing and saying “Hey I was a dick, I'll fight for good” or some shit. Was stuck against another chickenshit in KO (what the fuck was that reign) and was demoted to Romans Little Buddy. Has no vclear character at his point as its an awkard combination of a metalhead, x-man and I don't know what else to say. Finally they were gonna start the HHH feud, but he got Hurt AGAIN, making the whole build awkward. Has a decent match with HHH, but goes into a feud with Joe in which they were afraid to put either man over so it was sort of a waste of time. Now is stuck in a feud with Brayetty. Obviously not winning the Title anytime soon, so they are just wasting time with him. He really should have been top face when he came back last year but they really nutured and fucked him over characterwise and in the ring. Should have been a HBK/Hart level guy but his booking really hurt him.

>Dean Ambrose
Super Fucking Hot with the crowd after the Initial Split, Rollins Feud started well but he just kept losing and was shoved into a lackluster feud with Brayetty that killed a bunch of momentum and was shoved in a midcard title match at WM. His mini feud with Rollins again was good and the post MiTB promo was awesome. Then he was relegated to Romans little buddy duty for the next few months when he was obviously more over (rewatch the final 2 of the 2016 Royal Rumble, they should have pulled the trigger then). The prospect of a Brock Lesnar vs Dean Ambrose hardcore match was cool on paper but was fucking dogshit irl because Brock was Lazy as fuck and buried him when it should have been an Attitude Era style Brawl with blood and maybe even a massive stage bump.Le Wacky Dean started here in the feud with Jericho and it took away the sense of Danger and Grit he had in his shield days that was unique to him. Winning the Money in the Bank and Cashing it in on Rollins was a great Move and getting Clean Pins over Roman and Seth cemented him as the top guy for a really brief time. The feud with Ziggler was like Part 1 of a trilogy that was going to be told but was cut short so it made it very Underwhelming and Austin put him on blast on the podcast when He's a private guy. It was AJ Styles time and he needed the title, so they took it off him after 3 months. The Feud with AJ and Dean really made SD Live special until Ellsworth became the major Focus making it Shit Vince Comedy instead of a Modern Flair vs Funk feud it should have been. The Miz feud started strong involving Rene, but the story was transferred over to Cena, so Dean was Stuck Midcarding with Baron Corbin. When he was drafted to Raw, it was clear they only will keep him as an Uppermidcard guy to get pops and eventually try He should be full on Moxley mode holding Rene hostage and setting people on fire and shit, being deranged and actually insane instead of spraying hot dog shit and fighting bears.

They pushed the wrong guys. Dean should have been top face, Rollins top heel, and Reigns a mid carder.

>>2817906
>>2817918
>this sperg out
Trip on NEETbombz

they split them up when they just destroyed evolution and were white hot

might have been the most retarded bullshit ive ever seen. then when they split them up, they had no long term story. just a shitty feud with jasethy and deanetty and then a presumed one off with jasethy and roman since roman was going to main event wm31 with brock anyway. literally why did they split them up then. makes 0 sense