Keep in mind this is WWE only. Based on some shitty point system from November 10, 2008 Wrestling Observer Newsletter.
1. Bruno Sammatino
2. Hulk Hogan
3. Bob Backlund
4. Argentina Rocca
5. Triple H
6. Undertaker
7. Steve Austin
8. The Rock
9. Pedro Morales
10. Shawn Michaels
11. Superstar Bill Graham
12. Miguel Perez
13. Bret Hart
14. Buddy Rogers
15. Randy Savage
16. John Cena
17. Kurt Angle
18. Mick Foley
19. Andre the Giant
20. Dr. Jerry Graham
(TIE) Johnny Valentine
22. Roddy Piper
23. Ivan Koloff
24. Ultimate Warrior
(TIE) Randy Orton
(TIE) Batista
27. Greg Valentine
(TIE) Yokozuna
(TIE) Sgt. Slaughter
30. Kevin Nash aka Diesel
(TIE) Kane
(TIE) George Steele
(TIE) Chris Jericho
34. Ric Flair
(TIE) Big Show
(TIE) Stan Hansen
(TIE) Gorilla Monsoon
(TIE) Ken Patera
39. Fred Blassie
(TIE) Bob Orton
(TIE) Brock Lesnar
42. Eddie Graham
(TIE) Killer Kowalski
(TIE) Toru Tanaka
(TIE) Don Muraco
(TIE) Davey Boy Smith aka British Bulldog
(TIE) Edge
(TIE) Chris Benoit
49. Larry Zbyszko
(TIE) Paul Orndorff
(TIE) Iron Shiek
(TIE) Nikolai Volkoff
(TIE) Waldo Von Erich
(TIE) Booker T
>>2817213
> Diesel that low
Wew
>>2817219
Considering he was only there 3 years, I'd say pretty good.