Is he now seen as a joke since he broke the star rating scale TWICE?

>>2762343
He doesn't give a shit about his star rating.

No, but he's basically making fun of his retarded followers who think his rating scale is the holy grail of wrestling. He never took his ratings very seriously, it was just a quick note on the match.

Declaring Asuka the 2nd and possibly single best worker in the company was when he became a joke

>>2762348
This.

yup hes system is a joke now

imagine some major movie critic gave a movie he liked six stars?

He would be blacklisted by the movie critic profession

>>2762348
As far a women are concerned, he's not wrong. Although I can't stand how she's booked with the no-selling unstoppable monster bullshit, she's the only women who moves like a traditional wrestler in the ring. You can see this with Charlotte and Ember Moom to an extent as well.

his fans are retards with zero self awareness so no

Who cares? This rating shit is just Meltz getting everybody interested and talking about his favourite wrestling promotion, and creating some business for himself. Get worked marks.

>>2762343
He officially jumped the shark when he gave the first Omega/Okada match 6 stars.

Fucking weeb's been following gook wrestling all his life and can't understand a word of Japanese. SAD!

>>2762343
He should have given the first one 5.25 stars or something as a gesture. The fact that the second match between them was supposedly better, and it was 1.25 stars above every other great match, is silly.

>>2762343
He's scared for his career because he knows the Trooth Bombz revolution is happening across the internet.

>>2762343
BASED BIG DICK DAVE WORKING THE SMARKS

>>2762400
>He should have given the first one 5.25 stars or something as a gesture.
He used to give a "5+" to really great matches.

>>2762406
cringe

>>2762343

Yep he exposed himself hard. No one takes him seriously anymore.

>>2762343
Y'know we are gonna have to wait and see how it turns out y'know. He might not be a joke Monday, plans change y'know