John Cena
> In Ring - 3
> Mic Skills - 5
> Charisma - 5
> Durability - 4
> Overall - 17/20
Rules: Only use these attributes, 1 to 5 and no shit posting, only answers that make sense. 5 is great, 4 is very good, 3 is solid, 2 is lacking, 1 is bad and 0 is non-existent.
>>2663047
Oh and no .5s. Only whole numbers, fucking hate when people do that, might as well be out of 10 when you do that.
Kenny Omega
> In Ring - 6
> Mic Skills - 6
> Charisma - 6
> Durability - 6
> Overall - 24/20
If Cena is a 5/5 in charisma then Rock is what? 6?
Failed scale.
>no shitposting
kek
Pentagon Jr
>in ring - 4
>mic skills - 4
>charisma - 5
>durability - 5
18/20
Durability?
>>2663057
Also a 5, genius.
>>2663057
Both are 5s. Faces of the company that sold merch out their ass.
>>2663047
Roman Reigns
>in ring - 3
>mic skills - 2
>charisma - 2
>durability - 3
>overall - 10/20
>>2663060
Yeah, basically if injury prone or Don't wrestle often then it will be lower. Taker's durability has dropped in recent years, but still charismatic.
Also building off of Pentagon post, he is definitely a 5 after that fucking car wreck of a match with Vamp.
>>2663060
Saying that Cena equals Rock in charisma is ridiculous.
That's why .5s are there. Otherwise Cena gets a 4.
>>2663063
I would be fair to Roman, give him and Seth a 4 for durability for being injured once each and taking hard matches in the Shield. Ambrose is a 5 for having the most matched fought last year.
> In Ring - 2
> Mic Skills - 2
> Charisma - 3
> Durability - 4
> Overall - 11/20
>>2663068
Doesn't mean they're equal, it just happens to be the limit. Also, get off The Rock's dick.
Tye Dillinger
> In-ring - 3
> Mic Skills - 2
> Charisma - 4
> Durability - 3
> Overall - 12/20
He has the potential to improve and dur. is at 3 because I don't feel like he's been in any drag out brawls yet.
Dean Ambrose
>in ring - 4
>mic skills - 5
>charisma - 5
>durability - 5
>overall - 19/20
Is Ambrose the goat?
BLANDY BORETON
0
0
0
0
OVERALL: NOT A SINGLE DIME DRAWN
>>2663063
>>mic skills - 2
>>charisma - 2
Way too generous. He gets 1 each.
> In-ring - 3 (4 before Owen)
> Mic Skills - 4
> Charisma - 5
> Durability - 4
> Overall - 16-17/20
Durability fairly high because he took that pile driver that could have paralysed him and wrestled for years after.
>>2663090
he had his best matches in 2001
so he should be a 4 on in ring
and if Austin isn't 5/5 mic skills no one is
>>2663093
His mic skills are very good but he does have a sort of single tone. Which I wouldn't have any other way, but he doesn't dribble passionate gold like Rock or Cena.
>>2663090
>mic skills - 4
Austin completely redesigned the way people cut a promo. He's a 5 any day of the week
>4 before Owen
He was also a 5 in the ring. Austin was a GOAT in ring before his neck
Ric Flair
>in ring - 5
>mic skills - 5
>charisma - 5
>durability - 5
>overall - 20/20
AJ Styles
> In-ring - 5
> Mic Skills - 4
> Charisma - 4 (Arguably 5)
> Durability - 5
> Overall - 18/20
Only gave him a 4 for charisma because he's not as much of a household name as some others. But damn if he isn't the best wrestler in the world.
>>2663108
You're being a bit to generous to AJ here. For mic and charisma I'd give 3s.
>>2663108
Forgot the pic of Based-J.
>>2663112
Did you not hear that pop he got at his debut?
>>2663114
And what in the fuck does that have to do with anything? I'm not denying he's popular, but he isn't very charismatic and is average at best on the mic
>>2663104
I love Naitch too, but his in-ring is a 3. I'm sorry but his silly prat falling would never fly today and It's not like he's a tech like Bret. Everything else is a solid 5 though.
>>2663090
>> Mic Skills - 4
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X6c1PidMS7Y
25+
>>2663123
Are people really this triggered that I said Stone Cold' s mic skills are very good?
>Goldberg
In Ring 3
Mic skills 3
Charisma 4
Durability 4
Total 14/20
In ring - 2/5
Mic - 3/5
Charisma - 4/5
Durability -3/5
Total - 12/20
>>2663164
Honestly yeah. 5 Charisma in WCW though.
>>2663047
Bray Wyatt
> In Ring - 2
> Mic Skills - 4
> Charisma - 4
> Durability - 3
> Overall - 13/20
>>2663068
>>2663077
I'd say 03/04 Cena is a 5 and Super Cena is a 4, since he appeals to the kiddie demographic. At least Rock appeals to all demographics.
What's this? An honest discussion on /asp /?
Bret "The Hitman" Hart
> In-ring - 5
> Mic Skills - 2 (3 when heel)
> Charisma - 4 (5 in Canada)
> Durability - 3
> Overall 14/20 with a peak of 16
Chris Jericho
>In-ring- 5
>Mic Skills - 5
>Charisma - 5
>Durability - 3
This may be being a homer but Jericho was the ideal wrestler during his prime. He could work with the best cut segments with no problem.
He's taking time off and allowed to come back when he wants so durability gets cut
18/20
discuss if you wish
Hey Dean
>in ring - 5
>mic skills - 0
>charisma - 2
>durability - 5
>overall - 12/20
>>2663200
Personally I would give him a 5 for durdurability. He often brags about never getting injured.
>>2663207
i'll give him this, his in ring skills are growing.
they need to work on his mic skills, he could become a top heel worked right
>>2663184
>> Durability - 3
Huh?
>>2663200
>>In-ring- 5
Has there ever been a more overrated in-ring guy? I think he mainly gets the rub from who he came up with so people just think he's great in the ring.
Jeff Hardy
> In Ring - 2
> Mic Skills - 2
> Charisma - 4
> Durability - 5
> Overall - 13/20
In-ring: 5
Mic: 5
Charisma: 5
Durability: 5
>>2663212
He had to retire because of something in WCW, I think he had years left if it wasn't for that.
>>2663218
So you ignore the first 20 years of his career where he probably worked more matches than anyone in the US without getting hurt and only take one break?
>in ring - 3.5
>mic skills - 4
>charisma - 4
>durability - 5
>overall - 16.5/20
>>2663090
>mic skills 4
>in-ring - 5
>mic skills - 3 or 4
>charisma - 5
>durability - 3
> In Ring - 5
> Mic Skills - 3
> Charisma - 4
> Durability - 5
> Overall - 17/20
>>2663232
>> Durability - 5
How? He didn't work a full-time schedule after his comeback, had a near 4 year hiatus, lost his smile, was suspended. He had a long career, but he was constantly taking time off. I think he only had like one full year as a singles guy in his entire career.
> In-ring - 4 (taking a point for being unsafe with Austin)
> Mic Skills - 3
> Charisma - 4
> Durability - 0
>>2663239
Okay just kidding about dur., It's a 4 or 5 really. Overall - 16.
>>2663238
You're right, he is probably 3 or 4
>>2663238
Kevin Nash had a joke that Shawn was like a teacher in that he always found a way to take summers off.
>in ring - 5
>mic skills - 5
>charisma - 5
>durability - 5
>overall - 20/20
>>2663232
>> Durability - 5
????????????????
James Elsworth
> In-ring - 0
> Mic Skills - 1
> Charisma - 2 (Debutted with 3)
> Durability - 4 (Strowman has destroyed him a couple times)
> Overall - 7/20
Hogan
In ring: 3
Mic skills: 4
Charisma: 6
Durability: 5
18/20
>>2663248
> 6
Fuck off Meltzer. But feel free to move that one to the mic skills column.
Dolph Ziggler
>In-ring - 4
>Mic skills - 3
>Charisma - 2
>Durability - 5
>Overall - 14/20
>>2663298
I'd give Dolph a 4 at his peak winning the WHC.
>>2663218
18+
>>2663047
Boreman Lames
> In Ring - 0
> Mic Skills - -2
> Charisma - -3
> Durability - 0
>Overall - -5/20
>>2663307
Roman reigns is a solid in ring perfomer
>>2663047
Super Cena (From an 18+ perspective)
> In ring - 2
> Mic Skills - 5
> Charisma - 2 (Does very little for adults, a 4 maybe a 5 for kiddies)
> Durability - 4
> Overall - 13/20
>>2663089
It's that sticky wicket of his writing vs. his talent. Which is really dragging him down? It's hard not to lean towards his writing.
>>2663047
>durability
Great thread OP.
>>2663246
>In-ring - 0
That superkick is honestly worth a point.
>>2663303
i did that based on right now but peak ziggler would have a 4 charisma so hed be a 16 yeah
he probably is a 3 rn anyway
>>2663047
Let me fix that for you.
>John Cena
>In Ring - 5
>Mic Skills - 5
>Charisma - 5
>Durability - 5
>Overall - 20/20
>>2663047
> In Ring - 4
> Mic Skills - 0
> Charisma - 4
> Durability - 5
> Overall - 13/20
Eddie
>In Ring - 5
>Mic Skills - 3
>Charisma - 5
>Durability - 5
>Overall - 18/20
>>2663216
> In Ring - 2
he is at least a 4
>>2663047
Brock Fucking Lesnar
>In Ring - 5
>Mic Skills - 2
>Charisma - 4
>Durability - 5
>Overall - 16/20
Brock Fucking Lesnar + Paul Heyman
>In Ring - 5
>Mic Skills - 5
>Charisma - 5
>Durability - 5
>Overall - 20/20
Hulk Hogan
>In Ring - 2
>Mic Skills - 5
>Charisma - 5
>Durability - 5
>Overall - 17/20
>>2663077
Shame, he used to be a 4 for in-ring. Some thought he was the next HBK. Why has he been so terrible since his injury?
>>2663759
He's a flippy fuck with a bunch of kicks who is now fighting on one leg... you do the goddamned math!
>>2663056
Kys
>>2663087
>In ring - 2
>Mic Skills - 3
>Charisma - 2
>Durability - 5
>Overall - 12/20
>>2663056
GOATOAT
>In ring - 5
>Mic Skills - 3
>Charisma - 4
>Durability - 5
>Overall - 17/20
>>2663767
REAL RATINGS THAT IS FAKE RATINGS
>In ring - 4
>Mic Skills -5
>Charisma - 5
>Durablity - 5
Overall - 18/20
Cesaro
>In Ring - 5(100,000,000 if the fact that he's a 6'5" midget who can swing galaxies is considered)
>Mic Skills - 3
>Charisma - 5
>Durability - 4
>Overall - 17/20
Because May 19th
>In Ring - 3
>Mic Skills - 3-4
>Charisma - 4
>Durability - 5
Overall - 15-16/20
Kane is cool
>>2663047
>Those stats.
>Thought it was out of ten at first
>It isn't
Well now it just makes no sense OP.
>>2663047
Jericho
> In Ring - 4
> Mic Skills - 5
> Charisma - 5
> Durability - 5
> Overall - 19/20
>>2663104
>In ring 5
>Mic skills 5
3 at best on both counts man.
>>2663200
>Durability 3
>Never been injured
????
>>2663776
No, that's only "true" for 2015 WWE onwards, and it's "true" because it gets over with the die-hard fans, nobody else cares
Hogan
>In Ring: 2
>Mic Skills: 4
>Charisma: 5
>Durability: 4
>Overall: 15/20, brother
>>2663090
t.smark
The-dogs-are-in-the-enclosed-pool-area yourself
>>2663778
Your math: 0/10
Stone cold is the only 20/20
In ring: 2
Mic: 5
Charisma: 4
Durability: 2
13/20
Zack Ryder
>In Ring - 2
>Mic Skills - 3
>Charisma - 3
>Durability - 2
>Overall - 10/20
durability is such a random thing to rate
I can think of another more important attribute that begins with a D
>In Ring - 33 1/3rd
>Mic Skills - 25
>Charisma - 75
>Durability - 66 2/3rds
>Overall - 141 2/3rds/20
>>2664239
diet?
>>2664239
Dancing? Dexterity? Depth? Desireability? Destrucity?
>>2663056
BTFO NJPW Mark
>In-ring - 3
>Mic skills - 5 (Possibly 4, unsure)
>Charisma - 4
>Durability - 3
>Overall - 15/20
Seems reasonable
>>2663056
And without the Tokyo Dome passive buff?
>>2663784
Cesaro is an easy 1 or 2 for mic skills
3 or 4 for charisma
>>2664218
I honestly never saw the appeal of Punk on the mic
>I'm gonna break your faaaace
>>2664341
>mic skills 5
Hi Kevin!
>>2664341
In the softest, dullest voice
>am gonna bring aboot change
>that's gonna be my title
>nobody can ever beat me
He's a 3 on the mic, he can't improvise for shit.
Miz
>In Ring - 2
>Mic Skills - 5
>Charisma - 5
>Durability - 5
>Overall - 17/20
You can not argue with this
>>2664426
Mic 4 and charisma 4
He's had one really good promo his entire career and the majority of his career was awful for both mic and charisma
>>2663949
Not the guy you replied to, but durability doesn't mean just staying healthy. It means doing it day in and day out healthy. Jericho often leaves to go play rock star or one of his many other ventures.
And I say this as a huge Jericho mark.
>>2663047
Scott Steiner
>In Ring - 4
>Mic Skills - 12
>Charisma - 100
>durability - 4
>Overall - 120
>>2663047
The Brian Kendrick
> In Ring - 4
> Mic Skills - 4
> Charisma - 4
> Durability - 5
> Overall - 17/20
>>2664450
I'd give him a 5 for durability considering he's wrestled pretty much non stop for decades and got his chest cut open to fix a severely damaged trachea, then continued to wrestle like nothing happened.
>>2663734
>Durability - 5
>Eddie Guerrero
Cactus Jack
> In Ring - 3
> Mic Skills - 3
> Charisma - 5
> Durability - 6
> Overall - 17/20
> In Ring - 4
> Mic Skills - 3
> Charisma - 2
> Durability - 4
>Overall - 13/20
Just bring back El Generico, the hat is literally the worst gimmick
>>2663056
>No shitposting
>>2663214
In ECW and WCW he was a much smoother worker. But yes he is overrated in ring. His character is what makes him stand out.
Scott Hall
>In Ring - 3
>Mic Skills - 4
>Charisma - 5
>Durability - 3
>Overall - 15
Kevin Nash
>In Ring - 1
>Mic Skills - 5
>Charisma - 5
>Durability - 1
>Overall - 12
>>2665270
Kevin Nash
> In Ring - -5
> Mic Skills - 2
> Charisma - 2
> Durability - 0 (can't go a day without tearing his quads)
> Overall -1/20
Literally not far off from Boreman Lames
>In Ring- 5
>Mic Skills- 3(Catchphrases count for Charisma not mic skills)
>Charisma- 5
>Durability- 5
>Overall-19/20
Prove me wrong
>>2665260
Nah he was better in the WWF/WWE. He said in one of his books that Pat Patterson had to teach him how to work from scratch.
Scott Steiner
> In Ring - 0
> Mic Skills - 20
> Charisma - 0
> Durability - 0
> Overall - 20/20
>>2665304
>in-ring skills-0
>when https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LN6A4FjdQ7k exists
>>2665291
Well, 5+3+5+5 is 18, for starters.
>>2665304
Underage fag never watched a Steiner match prior to 1998.
>>2663231
>mic skills : 5 when working heel in montreal.
Much as HBK hated working heel against hogan it was the promo of his career
>>2665203
>Zayn keeps losing, slowly goes more and more el generico, starts changing his gimmick for the given match.
He's looking to become the next Cactus Love Kind
>>2663056
thank god he wears pants now
>>2663047
>In Ring- 3
>Mic Skills- 3
>Charisma- 5
>Durability- 5
>>2669415
I would say his matches with Shawn, Triple H and Punk at WrestleMania making the main events looking bad has earned him at least a 4.
>>2663216
>charismatic enigma
>4
> In Ring - 3
> Mic Skills - 1
> Charisma - 0
> Durability - 4
> Overall - 8/20
>In Ring - 1
>Mic Skills - 4
>Charisma - 3
>Durability - 2
>Overall - 10
I actually enjoyed him for a while, but once the novelty of the same lines he throws out every time he's in the ring wears off you realize he needs to step up his game or else he'll bring Cass down with him.
>>2669465
>charisma
>0
lol
In Ring - 3
Mic Skills - 3 (1 in 2015)
Charisma - 3
Durability - 4
Overall - 13/20
>>2664235
Honestly find him pretty entertaining in ring, easily a 3. Dudes glass cannon though
>>2665197
>Durability - 6
>Retired from full time competition at 34
No.
>>2663061
Rock sold merch to everyone. Cena sold to dumb kids who can't recognize...which apparently includes you.
Cena is no higher than a 3 in every category besides durability, which isn't important since he makes wrestling look more fake and staged than anyone.
>>2663164
Goldberg
Mic Skills - 1
Durability - 2
Fixed that for ya, youngster
>>2663047
Cena is 0 in everything but durability, fucking pgbaby
>>2669465
Forget how he talks on the mic
His look alone is at least a 3 in Charisma
>>2670118
>Look literally ripped from tacticool edgy tean.
Put a trench coat on him and he'll look like a guy who shot up his school.
ROLL 3 D6 IN ORDER
REEEEEEEEEEEEE
>>2663047
Cena is a 4 in the ring and definitely a 5 for durability, storyline wise or in real life.
King Kong Bundy, the big fat fuck who crushes people
>In Ring - 3
>Mic Skills - 3
>Charisma - 1
>Durability - 4
>Overall - 11/20
Based House Sized French Man
Andre the Giant
>In Ring - 3(1 past 1980)
>Mic Skills - 2
>Charisma - 10
>Durability - 2
>Overall - 17/20
His charisma is double the max because he was the biggest draw in history, and the only reason Mania 3 sold out.
>>2663970
Hogan is a 5 on the mic, brother.