ITT: Returns that would cause the roof to unglue

>>2512394

>Is given a serial killer gimmick

Vincelaughing.img

eddie
>I LIED ESSAY

>>2512394
He would have KILLED it. He would have made the place go MENTAL.

>>2512407
You know, for the first ever Janetty, he's been given a FUCK load of chances in WWE even as recently as 2009

>>2512394
well a zombie gimmick would be over as hell

>>2512434
didn't work for the undercarder

>>2512394
Paige and Del Rio

>>2512470
>tripneet still in shambles about his picture getting leaked

>>2512470
THE HERO OF KVATCH!

>>2512470
Somebody use his picture in that app that /b/ is using to turn into a girl.

File: Paige 32.jpg (113KB, 642x722px) Image search: [Google]

113KB, 642x722px

>>2512394

Punk returning in Chicago would still get a bigger pop tbf.

>>2512434
ECW on scifi already tried that

>>2512470
I've seen it a lot, but this is photoshopped right? Please tell me it is

In order
>Punk in chicago
>Taker 3-4 years from now
>AJ Lee
>Paige

cant think of any more

Hardy's would have been a bigger noise if the arena was closed

>>2512694
Paige would get a big reaction but nowhere near the level of the others you listed. Not even close

File: image.jpg (33KB, 390x362px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 390x362px

I think Bobby Lashley would get a decent pop.

He's one of the only people that I can think of that I haven't seen mentioned in the thread.

>>2512720
i used to call him he chocolate bar lmao

>Punk, esp in Chicago
>Taker down the road
>Jessie and Festus, who then join The Club. Make it a running gag that Festus and Luke are never seen together
>Cornette
>Lashley
>Jimmy Wang Yang
>Chavo Guerrero
>Carlito
>John Morrison

File: IMG_4713.jpg (12KB, 267x277px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 267x277px

>>2512394

>>2512723

Bit racist innit

File: 1484701942559s.jpg (2KB, 125x100px) Image search: [Google]

2KB, 125x100px

>>2512410

People watching wrestling were born after his shit