Wrestlers with a 5 Star Match are allowed to be in this thread.

Daily reminder that star ratings for matches started with a joke suggestion by Cornette, and haven't become anything but a joke since then.

According to Dave Meltzer? He gave one to Phil, he's disqualified.

File: jeff-hardy.jpg (24KB, 310x383px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 310x383px

How about wrestlers with multiple 5 star matches

>>1564141
There are no 5 star matches and if you think there are, you are a Meltzerfag who is instantly discredited.

File: HE'S FAT!.jpg (146KB, 512x318px) Image search: [Google]

146KB, 512x318px

>>1564143
>>1564146
Fat ass detected.

>>1564147
>being that fat that you call other people fat so you don't feel fat

>>1564145
He has no 5 Star Match.
>>1564148
Getting this worked.

File: based sasha!.gif (2MB, 540x300px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 540x300px

>>1564141
Hi

>>1564167
She will actually get a 5 star match eventually. You all know it's true

File: Steve Austin.jpg (13KB, 301x266px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 301x266px

>>1564167
>>1564169
You wish.
>>1564171
I don't think Goldberg has a 5 star match.

>>1564172
vs ddp
vs scott steiner

>>1564175
not according to le Meltz's meme rankings

>>1564171
this
5stars when he kicked brets head off

>>1564172
She's got multiple 4 stars for a fucking c brand, she'll 100% get 5 after a wrestlemania because meltz has never had sex

File: Rey.jpg (39KB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]

39KB, 500x281px

>>1564178
This, although honestly wrestlers with match of the years should also be included in this thread.

>>1564183
That's because she had weeks to practice it beforehand on NXMeme. She's been getting exposed as a shitter hard on the main roster.

>>1564144
Phil was an excellent worker and very rarely had a bad match.

>>1564178
>>1564189
<lemeltz

>>1564208
>Phil
>excellent worker

HAHAHAHA
literally one of the sloppiest '''''wrestlers''''' ever

he almost fucking killed cena and botches in every match

>>1564144
He gave two to Phil. Punk/Samoa Joe II in 2005 and Punk/Cena at MitB 2011.

I disagree with Meltzer on many counts, but no one that watches those matches can disagree that they're phenomenal. Joe more for the wrestling itself and Cena more for the angle and stakes.

File: samoa-joe-to-wwe.jpg (16KB, 588x333px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 588x333px

>>1564208
>>1564214
I heard Joe got a 5 Star from Phil as well as from AJ Styles.

>>1564218
Joe has 3. Punk, Styles/Christopher Daniels, and Kobashi.

File: Kenta-Kobashi1.jpg (33KB, 420x618px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 420x618px

>>1564218
Samoa Joe's 5 star matches are Joe vs Phil 2, AJ/Daniels/Joe and vs GOATbashi (which is the indie shitter version of Rocky vs Hulkster where the crowd elevates the match)

>>1564224
I recently watched the Kobashi match and wasn't that big a fan of it. The match vs Chris Daniels and Styles was great, though. All three of those matches he did with Punk are great, too.

>>1564224
It's kind of safe to say the crowd elevated Punk/Cena too. It was a hell of a storyline and a great setup, the match was good if not great, but the Chicago crowd was insane that night.

File: goldust-wwe-free-wallpaper.jpg (4MB, 2390x3003px) Image search: [Google]

4MB, 2390x3003px

Sup fags

File: eddie.jpg (43KB, 600x674px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 600x674px

>>1564230

File: nancyb6.jpg (37KB, 410x542px) Image search: [Google]

37KB, 410x542px

>>1564229
It's Kobashi in front of an audience that has spent their childhood or young adult years watching traded tapes from the mystical land of All Japan do his chops in person against one of the hottest stars in American wrestling at the time without any meme chants ruining it. Come on

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xNi02SHEXvg

>>1564243
True.

Ricky Steamboat (several)
Ric Flair (several)
Scott Steiner
Goldust (as Dustin Rhodes)
Bret Hart (too many)
Steve Austin (too many)
Tiger Mask
CM Punk
Samoa Joe
AJ Styles
Shinsuke Nakamura
Razor Ramon
Shawn Michaels
Stan Hansen
Misawa
Kobashi
Christopher Daniels
John Cena
Arn Anderson
Owen Hart
Sting
Rick Rude
Jushin Thunder Liger
Big Van Vader
Brian Pillman
Lex Luger
Dusty Rhodes
The Road Warriors
Barry Windham

>ric flair has fucking 8
Did le Meltz fall for the Flair meme?

File: Hiroshi_Tanahashi.jpg (2MB, 3648x2736px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 3648x2736px

gook version of BMJ is pretty based

four five star matches i think

>>1564251
He has 6 actually

File: Superstar-Category_Superstar_562x408_undertaker.png (221KB, 562x408px) Image search: [Google]

221KB, 562x408px

>>1564243
A lot of the matches before smarks became vocal were legit 5 Star Matches.

File: FireShot Capture 29 - Top Rated Wrestling Matche_ - http___www.profightdb.com_top-rated-matches.html.png (227KB, 1244x1791px) Image search: [Google]

227KB, 1244x1791px

Here's every "Dave Meltzer 5 star match"

>>1564161
THE AJ COMMUNITY?

>>1564258
Why does Dave have such a massive hardon for Japanese wrestling

File: 1464987827952.jpg (103KB, 785x782px) Image search: [Google]

103KB, 785x782px

>>1564258
>Paul has 0 (zero) five stars from le meltz but Scotty and The Juice do
really makes you think

>>1564274
That would imply Trips has ever had a match worth 5 stars

>>1564258
How is Goldberg vs Steiner not a 5 star match? Meltzer seriously had a hate boner for wcw and I will never respect what he has to say

>>1564281
the Russo shit at the end

File: 12.jpg (23KB, 266x355px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 266x355px

>>1564274
Steiner was an A+ player while Haitch was B+ player.
>>1564281
WCW had some 5 star matches when it was in the NWA.

File: Rick_Rude.11.jpg (131KB, 1284x722px) Image search: [Google]

131KB, 1284x722px

>>1564141
>tfw You'll never get so another 5 star match of his

>>1564167
she got a 5 star head

>>1564250
Le meltz invented the flair meme, how he got 8 for wrestling the same match for 30 years is what makes his ratings do laughable

His flairboner and gookboner is legendary

>>1564214
>the angle and stakes

This is why Melzers opinion should be discarded
He gives Punk v Cena 5 stars because of story yet gives Hogan v Andre negative 4 when yhe the "angle and stakes" was bigger than ever.

If two jobbers wrestled the same match ad Punk and Cena no one wouls call it 5 star

In fact if Cena had gone over no one would call it 5 star

>>1565095
>If zero draws wrestled in a 5 star match it wouldn't be five star.
>If all the circumstances of a good math were taken away it wouldn't have been a good match

Wow any other brilliant and ground breaking observation? Something like if they tried to push naked mideon as the face of the Attitude era it wouldn't have gone as far with as with Stone Cold?

Those were some pretty pathetic mental gymnastics just for the end result of I don't like Phil so I'm not happy he has a five star match.

>>1564169
Nigga only 5 star match this bitch winning is the Kentucky Darby.

unless the botch wing of the hospital gets the C-show once smackdown gets cancelled for being shitter than sasha's skank-ass weave.

File: Final_DELETE_THIS.gif (2MB, 540x300px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 540x300px

>>1564145
DELET THIS