Is he a good man?

>fails as a protector
>fails as a procreator
>fails as a lover
>doesn't even try to build or discover anything of value
>but kills lots of people
No.

>>159431500
>fails as a lover

he dick'd Caska down so hard that it was one of her most defining moments in her dream-scape.

>>159431364
>literally all the tragedy and horror would have been avoided if he'd just put his dick in Griffith's ass

No. Nor is he bad. He is Human

>>159431364
The only bad thing he did was killing the prince and donovan

>>159431364
Compared to anyone else in berserk he is a saint.

>>159431364
Considering he was raped as a boy and then all his dreams and goals came to a destructive end and he survived only by sheer force of a lifetime of fighting opponents far stronger than him...

And is now spending the rest of his life watching his past be consumed as his entire world is consumed with it by his best friend who betrayed his everything and everyone...

Well, no, he's reacting pretty appropriately if you consider his murder spree of all things trying to murder him.